High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12632/2014allowed

Harpal Singh v. Managing Director State Warehousing Corporation & ORS

2019-01-22Mr. Justice Arun Monga6 pages

!"# #$%&%'( )

! "

#### $

& ' " " ( '

& '

)$ )* $++, % - " . )$ /))0 '&1 . $) /))23 5$)61

" 7' '- )$ )* $++, ' 1 8 . $ 1' & 7' 5"5' " ' '" $* )2 $++* % 9& '

" '/:

)2 5$6 % &1 '& ' 1 /,;

&- ' ' &1 < ):

5/6

5'- "1 " ' "1 '- "& $++$ '" 8 9& '$2 )* /))$3 < " ' 1 &' &-' > " ' < " $$ /))/3 526

" 1 ?,)55:?)5+2) % 1 " & """ ' " 1

@ ' "1 & A "1'

&1 " & &1 < &" < - ( ' "1"1 "

& . )$ /))0 &1 7 " 1

>'& 7 " 1 )$ /))0 $) /))2& 5$)1

'&1. $:

)* /)$23 5$$6

& ( "1<'-'

' 1 '- <1' & "1

" 1 736 0) "&

/))0 ' 1 & ( - " $$ )$ /))?

4 5,6 ' &1 /+ )+ /)$) 3 4 5*6 % < )$ /)$) 4 5?6 &1 "" ' " ' '- ' A ( & 1" 1 *

' 1 &" )* )?

/)$03 5:6 ' 1"" &1 < )* )?

/)$0 ' " &

& 1" 1

"" ( '" ?

C "

&" )$ ):

/)$0 3 4 5+6 '

' "" &1 ' "5

" #$% :

' & "1& '- ( " & > & " ' 1 ' &

- ( 1' "1 "1

" . )$ /))0 $) /))2&1 7 " 1 +

> ' " &1 & ' $++, 1' & 7' 5"5' " '

& - 7' 5 "5' " 37 6 /:

/))0 7 & " &1 7 " "" /:

45$6

"" " &1 """ & " '4" &1 " 1 ' & " % &"&1 ' 4"

D 1

&1 ' 5'-

" " - &1 =

" ' & E " ' ' "1" ' 9& '

' & > & "1' "

E '& A ( &17 " 1 """ B . )$ /))05

# $%#&" &

'! !() *+ !" ,++*

*+ !"

,++*

" #

! '! ! !

,-+

() " ""

" ! "

! $

" !

! "

! *+ $% . $) /))23 <$)6 /0$ 1

'! !

" # "

" *2$2$34 !

$% 5 .

24$+4$,+2- (6

. 722) 8 /9 '! '! !

" " ' 7 !! ' " #

8: ( ) !

* () ,0 ,+2-

/% $/

> &1 &A" (

& $0

' F" ( /:

/))0 7' 7 &

" &1 7 " $2

>& 1 ' '

& & > "1 1 & " " (

" ' 7'

& > &1 1 & < " & ( G ' 1' "1 36 & (

" & & '1&- &

& " & = &1 "- (

1 ' ( '

" '

"' & ( % & A 1& ' H+; "

9 & ' "

) !

7 ;7< !"

;7<