The Post Graduate Institute And ANR v. Central Administrative Tribunal And ANR


 

       


   

    

  

         

 

     

  
     !"#!"$#!"%&'(")"*#+!,&-'."$"/,$#"'0*#!"'0("+#1 "+



 

   



   

 

 

  







 

  



   

"+/,*'"*#+, 3*'0*#!" $0(0*3-//-043#0,*."5,$"#!"

-"3$*"'  "*#$3-  ')0*0+#$3#06"  $0.&*3-  !3*'0(3$!  "*4!  75,$  +!,$# 8$0.&*3-89!36"4!3--"*("'#!",$'"$'3#"' :

:/3++"'.;#!"-"3$*"'

$0.&*3-'0$"4#0*($"+/,*'"*#, #,4,*+0'"$#!"3//,0*#)"*#,53//-043*# 3+ -"$<,**,#0,*3-.3+0+= "

#!"'3#"=!"*#!"-3+#/"$+,*3//,0*#"'3+ 3$"+&-#,5#!"+&.%"4#+"-"4#0,*%,0*"'3+ -"$<3*'344,$'4,*+">&"*#03- ."*"50#+.;=3;,5+"*0,$0#;3*'/$,),#0,*



"+/,*'"*#  ,   !"$"0*  =!,  =3+  #!"  3//-043*#  ."5,$"  #!" -"3$*"'$0.&*3-4,*#"*'"'0*!0+/"#0#0,*#!3#!"=3++"$60*(3+3 3$' "$63*#,*'30-;=3(".3+0+5$,)?

 @@ 0++"$604"+="$"$"(&-3$0A"'


= "

 :

@@:

 !"/"#0#0,*"$+!"$"0*0++&"',#05043#0,*,*? @ @@ 43--0*(5,$3//-043#0,*+#,50--&/?/,+#+,5 -"$<+#!$,&(!)/-,;)"*# B4!3*(" !3*'0(3$!3*'5$,)3),*(+##!"$"(&-3$")/-,;""+,5  =,$<0*( 0* #!"-,="$/,+#+   "+/,*'"*# ,  !"$"0* 3//"3$"' 0* #!"

#;/"=$0#0*(#"+#!"-',*@  @@3*'!0+*3)"=3++!,=*3#$ , 0* #!")"$0#-0+#/$"/3$"'.;#!"/"#0#0,*"$+!"$"0*,*#!".3+0+,5!0++4,$0*( :  ,$'+"$ 0*&#"0*#!"#;/"=$0#0*(#"+# "=3+3+<"'#,3//"3$ ."5,$"#!""-"4#0,* ,))0##""5,$0*#"$60"=,*C  @@?

!"3//-043*# =3++&$/$0+"'#,-"3$*#!3##!"/"$+,*+=!,="$"-,="$0*)"$0#="$"(06"* 3//,0*#)"*#

*  #!"  =$0#  /"#0#0,*  #!"  /"#0#0,*"$+  !"$"0*  +&.)0##"'  #!3# !"$"0*=3+*,#5,&*'+&0#3.-".;#!""-"4#0,* ,))0##""

3+!"=3+3=3$'"'8 0*&+ 8($3'"=0#!#!"$")3$<+E*,,5504""B/"$0"*4" *,4,)/&#"$"B/"$0"*4"  0*&+F

:

"3$*"'  4,&*+"-  3//"3$0*(  5,$  #!"  =$0#  /"#0#0,*"$+  =,&-' +&.)0##!3##!"/"#0#0,*"$+$"%"4#"'#!"43*'0'3#&$",5$"+/,*'"*#, 3+!"

=3+  *,#  5,&*'  +&0#3.-"  .;  #!"  "-"4#0,*  ,))0##""

 #  0+  !0+  5&$#!"$ +&.)0++0,*#!3#+&.%"4#06"+3#0+534#0,*.3+"',*#!",.%"4#06"3*3-;+0+)3'" .;#!""-"4#0,* ,))0##""43**,#."4!3--"*("'."5,$"#!" ,&$#  

   -"3$*"' 4,&*+"- 3//"3$0*( 5,$ $"+/,*'"*# ,  6"!")"*#-;4,*#"*'"'$"5"$$0*(#,#!"4,)/3$3#06">&3-05043#0,*#;/0*( +/""'($3'0*(3*'"B/"$0"*4",5#!"43*'0'3#"+=!,3//"3$"'3-,*(=0#! ."5,$"#!""-"4#0,* ,))0##""#!3##!"+"-"4#0,*!3+.""* )3'"/&$"-;.3+"',*"B#$3*",&+4,*+0'"$3#0,*+3*'*,#,*)"$0#0*#!"

D
/"$5,$)3*4",5#!"$"+/"4#06"43*'0'3#"+

?

!"$"  0+  *,  '0+/&#"  #,  #!"  534#  #!3#  $"+/,*'"*#  ,   =3+ /,+0#0,*"'3#*' /-34".3+"',*#!"#;/0*(+/""'!""B!0.0#"'  6"*3 43*'0'3#".;*3)"3-=3*#0*(!=!,!3'/3++"',*-; 3#$04&-3#0,*=0#!

#;/0*(+/""'53$."-,=#!"#;/0*(+/""',5$"+/,*'"*#, !3'.""* +"-"4#"'

 *"03$ !3*',*0=!,4,&-'*,#."(06"*3*;($3'0*(3#3-- 3*'=3+53$."-,=0*#!"#;/0*(+/""'4,)/3$"'#,$"+/,*'"*#, !3'

3-+,.""*+"-"4#"'



*",5#!"$"3+,*+3++0(*"'5,$$"%"4#0*(#!"43*'0'3#&$",5 .;"-"4#0,* ,))0##""=3+#!3#!"!3'*,4,)/&#"$ "B/"$0"*4"

 *3/"$&+3-,5#!"$"4,$'+="5,&*'#!3# G+3$6""*2&)3$ 3*' 360*'"$0*(!=!,3-+,'0'*,#!36"3*;4,)/&#"$"B/"$0"*4"3*' ="$"53$."-,=0*#;/0*(+/""'4,)/3$"'#,$"+/,*'"*#, ="$"3-+, +"-"4#"'

 

*,&$4,*+0'"$"'60"=#!""-"4#0,* ,))0##""!3'60$#&3--;

/&+!"'  #!"  )"$0#  0*  /"$5,$)3*4"  #,  #!"  .34<($,&*'  =!0-"  50*3-0A0*( +&44"++5&-43*'0'3#"+ #!3+$0(!#-;.""*,.+"$6"'.;-"3$*"'$0.&*3-#!3# #!"$"!3'.""**,530$/-3;0*#!")3##"$,5+"-"4#0,*',*".;#!"/"#0#0,*"$+ !"$"0*

@

"3$*"'4,&*+"-3//"3$0*(5,$$"+/,*'"*#, +&.)0##"'#!3# $"+/,*'"*#  ,   =,&-'  *,#  /$"++  5,$  ),*"#3$;  ."*"50#+  ,&#  ,5  !0+ 3//,0*#)"*#3+ -"$<3*'#!"+&.+">&"*#/$,),#0,*+)3'"<""/0*(0*60"= !0++"*0,$0#;



!"$"5,$"#!",$'"$/3++"'.;-"3$*"' "*#$3-')0*0+#$3#06"

:
$0.&*3- !3*'0(3$!"*4!0+4,*50$)"'

,="6"$0#0+)3'"4-"3$#!3# !"$"0*0+*,#"*#0#-"'#,3*;),*"#3$;."*"50#,&#,5!0+ 3//,0*#)"*#  3+  -"$<  3*'  #!"  +&.+">&"*#  /$,),#0,*+  (06"*  #,  !0) 4,*+0'"$0*(  !0+  +"*0,$0#;

 =,  ),*#!+8  5&$#!"$ #0)"  0+  ($3*#"'  #,  #!" /"#0#0,*"$+!"$"0*#,4,)/-;=0#!#!"'0$"4#0,*+,5#!"-"3$*"'$0.&*3-



!"=$0#/"#0#0,*0+'0+)0++"'=0#!#!"3.,6"'0$"4#0,*+

 ! "     &(&+# !

 "

&-3#0