High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11024/2016dismissed

Laxmi Narain Yadav v. Union Of India & ORS.

2016-09-05Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary8 pages

Gurbax Singh 2016.10.17 16:25

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT

CHANDIGARH CWP No.11024 of 2016 Date of decision: 05.09.2016 Laxmi Narain Yadav ......Petitioner Vs.

Union of India and others .....Respondents CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AJAY KUMAR MITTAL HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAMENDRA JAIN Present: Mr.Puneet Jindal, Senior Advocate (Free Legal Aid counsel) with Mr. Jaivir Singh Chandel, Advocate alongwith the petitioner in person.

Ajay Kumar Mittal,J.

!!" #! ! $ % ! &" !

'!( $!!) *$+&!

,-&"!

&" !

!$ !'(!

! .

! / / ( "$!

!"& $!&'

(! ("

( ( ! !! '!" & ! !!0!!

1"!2"!

!"!3!!!*123- !"

"! .6 ! ! 2

!!7 8!!"..6$ 2$!( / 123$ 9 $0! !

( !" 4 5 45 !" '!" !

: !($ '! ! ! ''$ 123 *;<-$ 9 ..6 = ! 1"! 2"!

!"!$ >!! 9" '' *!- 123 *;<-$9 ( !

..6$%!!! !

! !" 0!!

!!7 ?! !"&>" ;@9 !(!

! ! 4 5 5 4 ..

(

...$ % ! ! ' 1"! 2"!

!"!$ >!! 1"! 2"!

!"! 9'!$ !!

! &" ''$ 123 *;<-$ 9 (

! & !

!& &!

! 7!! 2 ! $ % /$ !! !&"' ! !! ! !! !" ''A ! ! ! ! ( ! $ % ! ''$ 123 *@B-$ '!&! ( ! / / $ %4 4 5 5 4 ..

!" 44 545.

& &!

!7!!(! 6 $ % ! ! !

/ &(! !! !

! !

!&"''& &!

!7!! 2! 6 $%&!

"'!

" ! ! 1"! 2"!

!"!$ !!

! ''$ 123 *;<-$ 9 (! $%6 ! ' &!

! 7!! ! 6 $ !

0! !

" 44 545. !! !

! & !!! !

$1"!2"!

!"!$!!

! =="!!=!$9 3'

! ' 4

( ! 4

$ % . A" 4

! .4

$% $ !

'&" '! !

( !/ 4

$%!! (! 5( 0!!

& !

2 !

$ !

''! ">'&!! 2 !

!! &!

#!! !! 4 5 $4 ..

( ! ..

$% !

$1"!2"!

!"!! .

$ % / '' !

>!! *@!- *@- )!!;$9 =( !

'' !

>!!$9 ( = ! / 4

$ % !

$ ! ''$ 123 *?B-!!!! .

$%4

!!2''!

$% $ ! !@ !

( 3( *3- ! !$ ! !

*- @ $ .

! =$ = "$ &'

!' ! !( " !" ' &' !'

*% - !" !" ( !

! (

!!'!"!?#"

#"$ !

!!!!

"($ !

!! ( !

!!(&' ! / / *% 6- !! ?#"

!"!"'!

" '(!

' ( ''!

( !

/ /$ % . !!

! !"(!! /*% -2 ! /$ %

$ !

! !" ' !!

!! !"!"!( C!=!

3! =(! 4.

'!!! @ '! $ 4 ( ! = / 4

' @!A!?%9 >'&! A" / 4

!! '! ! !

'' !

>!!$ @ @($ ' %9

! ! ! =! ! & "'! ! ' !

(

! 4.

'' !

$ @ ) $9 '!!! !

'' !

>!! @ @( ' %$ 9

! ! !&(! =!

! !

( " "@! !&A !(! !& " &=!(! &""'2 & !'! = &=&""' ( ! &" & ''$ 123 *;<-$ 9 ! !

' &" 8 ''$ 123$ ( ! 6 2 !

. $%/ $!''*2D B-123 9 ' ! ( & ;C& ;@>!!'!123( (! (& !!6 $% / ! '' *2 ! 3 - 123$ 9 ! / $ % / 3 9(!

'' !

>!!$ 9 9( ( ! = '( ! $%//!! $ ! !" = " ! "! ! ! ( ! & != ! = ! !

!( & & &" / 4

& 2 ! 6/ $ % / $ !

'' *9>- ' !;@>!!'!$123'( ! '!!

! & '! !! 6 $%/4& '> ! 2 ! . $ % / $ ! ''2 ! 123*;<-9 '! ! !

' ! & %! &" '$ ! ! 6 A ( &" $ !!

/ !

2! 4$% $!'! ! &"!!

!! ' !!

!!!3 . '!( &!

$ .64 2 ! $ % $ &!

' ! &" ; !&" / ! ! $ !(' '! ! ' ! $ % !&"&!

$ !! & !& ( !" '!!

( !

(

!!' !& !

" &"&!

! ! !5!''(!

! / /&"

B 4/ ;@

/ !A &"&!

( !/6

?((! !

' 4!! !

! !" !

'! ! / / !

!!& "5 5A !! ! !' ! !

! '!!!& ?(& $ ! !& !& !" &!!

!' '! !

%!'(!

! '! !! ' ! &"

&(!E5 +/! !!&!'!;!! ! & '( ' ( &" ! / / ; ! ! B & !&!'!';!

% ! ( ! 4 *%/-$!&!

! &" &! !!

!! ' ! !! (!! ! / /$ & !' ! & A &" !'! 123 ( ! // ! ! (" ' 6/ *% /- ! ! ! ! ! ! ! #" $ ! ! ( = ! &" ' !=!

" !(

'9 >'&!!!

! !! ' ! &'

!' ! & &(!!&'( '(

!( '!!

" ! !( &" ! 6/ & B!& 9 '& 4!&! &" '!>($B$! ! ! ' '(!

! / / (" !!!B 4/ ;@

/ !' ( ! /6

@( !

&" ! ! ! !

' 4 ; B!

&!!

A !! !'!!!& ( &(!$B ' '>!

F! ! & !& ! &"&!

!! A

6 ! :$ ' !( & ! &" !!

! '! ! # "$ '$!'&"' (Ajay Kumar Mittal) Judge September 05, 2016 (Ramendra Jain) 'gs'

Judge != ! 0 !&