High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/4679/2017allowed

Rupinder Singh v. Mohinder Singh

2019-03-25Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu4 pages

!"#"$%&%'()*

+,%'-"./%'01 "!%!%'". 2".&+&

1%'-"./%'01 "&,'-"'!

."&"'!

./1+33 .4-2$ !"#.!1","!%!%'".

. 5 6 64-2$ !"#.."&,'-"'! 777 ."&"'!."2%&%',"!%!%'1 &8""'#%3"-+'-"./"$!%' -" # .%9%' 3 .$"-+."4 *4 #. &1.! :

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

&44AB#.9!1"."&,'-"'!B$9,3 %' '!%'!1"9'!1#/",!"98". =%!1 &&+. '$" !1 ! ' -"9 '-4 & %- 9+'! =%33 8" ."!+.'"- 1" $9,3 %' '! -"9 '-"- 1%& 9'"> 8 $< '- !1" ,"!%!%'".4 %' .-". ! -%&$1 .0"1%&3"0 33% 8%3%!>%&&+"- $1"C+"*- !"-) -. =' ' '<4 . '$1 .%-<! 1" 82" $1"C+" = & ,."&"'!"-#."'$ &19"'!8+!!1"& 9"= &-%&1'+."-')4

=%!1 !1" ."9 .<& D

E '&"C+"'!3>4 &! !+!.> 3"0 3 '!%$"- !"-)= &%&&+"-!!1","!%!%'".8+!#'"##"$! '- !1 !3"-!!1"#%3%'0#$9,3 %'!+'-".!1"$!

'!1"8 &%&#!1",."3%9%' .>"2%-"'$"3"-8>!1"."&,'-"'!4 !1" ,"!%!%'". = & &+99'"- ! # $" !.% 3 #. !1" $99%&&%' # ##"'$" ,+'%&1 83"+'-".!1"$!4 '-!1"." #!".4'!%$"# $C+%&%!%'= &&".2"- !1%948+!1",3" -"-'!0+%3!> '-$3 %9"-!.% 3 ' .-". ! ,.2" 1%& $ &"4 !1" ."&,'-"'! B$9,3 %' '! &!",,"-%'!!1"=%!'"&&8F & G '-!"'-"."-1%&-+3>&=.' ##%- 2%! F GA '- 3& ,.2"- !1" .%0%' 3 $1"C+" %' C+"&!%' & F 4

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

9+'!# &))4AB%'3+9,&+9 0 %'&!#+33 '-#%' 3&"!!3"9"'!!!1" $9,3 %' '! %' --%!%' ! &AB 3." -> , %- 8"#." !1" 3" .'"- ,,"33 !" +.!1"9 !!".= & 3&."#".."-! "-% !%' '- '$%3% !%'

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

'$"-"-3>4 /"$!%' # !1" $! ,&!+3 !"& !1 ! "2".> ##"'$" ,+'%&1 83" +'-". !1%& $! %& $9,+'- 83" '- %! %& ="33 &"!!3"- ,.%'$%,3"#3 =!1 !'$"!1""..%'0, .!>1 &9 -"!1", >9"'!#"'!%." 9+'!4 !1"' 8!1 !1" , .!%"& =%!1 !1"%. #."" $'&"'!4 ." "'!%!3"- ! $9,+'-!1"##"'$" '-!1"& 9"%&'9."."&B%'!"0. 1"'@83" /+,."9" +.!%'!1"$ &"#

#$%&%!% #%' ( ) ) * &&

+,-, -. &% % /# !%! 0.+ 1 & 1"3- !1 ! +'-". &+$1 $%.$+9&! '$"&4 !1" , .!%"& &1+3- 8" ,".9%!!"- ! $9,+'-!1"%'-%$ !"-##"'$" '-!1"."3"2 '!, . ?!1"."#." -& &+'-".(B

D? 2%'0."0 .-!!1"& 3+! .>,.2%&%'&#/"$!%' # !1" "0!% 83" '&!.+9"'!& $! ." - =%!1 /"$!%' * # !1" -" # .%9%' 3 .$"-+."4 !1%&

+.!%&#!1",%'%'!1 !%'2%"=#!1"$9,.9%&" ..%2"- !8"!=""'!1", .!%"&4!1","!%!%'".&1+3-8" ,".9%!!"- ! $9,+'- !1" ##"'$" $99%!!"- 8> 1%9 +'-"./"$!%'*?#!1" -"E !%&,.2"-'."$.-!1 !!1", .!%"&1 2"$9,.9%&"-!1" 9 !!". '-!1","!%!%'".B$'2%$!1 & 3." ->9 -"!1""'!%.", >9"'! 1+&4 %! =+3- 8" %' !1" %'!"."&! # 6+&!%$" !1 ! , .!%"& 8" 33="-!$9,+'-!1"##"'$"!"' 83"!1"9!3%2"," $"#+33> '-%' 1 .9'>2"'!1".=%&"4!1"."%&'3"0 3%9,"-%9"'!%'!1%&$ &" '-!1" & 9"%&$2"."-8>!1". !%#3 =3 %--='%'!1"6+-09"'!#'@83" /+,."9" +.!%'

!1 !%!& '2%"=#!1" 82"4 ,,.2 3%&0. '!"-#.$9,+'-%'0!1" ##"'$"+'-"./"$!%'*?#!1"$!

'&"C+"'!3>4!1",."&"'!."2%&%',"!%!%'%& 33="- '-!1" %9,+0'"- 6+-09"'! - !"- # 3" .'"- --%!%' 3 /"&&%'& +-0"4 .%-<!4 =1%3" +,13-%'0 !1" 6+-09"'! # $'2%$!%' & ="33 & .-".#&"'!"'$"- !"-?, &&"-8>3" .'"- 4 ."1"."8> &"! &%-" '-!1","!%!%'".%& $C+%!!"-#!1"$1 .0"#. 9"- 0 %'&!1%9 )*

# 2$%#$%!&% 45% !/ %' 6%!5/ 2$%#$%%&/# *% 6%!5/