Chaman Lal v. Financial Commissioner, Punjab And ORS.
!
"
#!$%&'#$( )*
) (#+#,#
-%.%
#$#++%%* ./#01(%
%23%
!"#$% %$ &!"'(
%& ' 2#4-+#*3$#* !(2
' #35(#+#*33
./#0* !(5#
' 36#%(7#2*3$#* !%23
99999 %$ &!)*+
* 0: # #22$# ( 2# 2$3:%* (#:2.$(#%3(%(#!+#%%*#$;%(#*%#::3!(3 !( #$#++%%*<(07(+#(#%0+30#$4
' 2#4-+#*#3$.%!(2%.0+% (#(###!#3% 6;8'*<(#%(%(#!(2 $+%=6;)'%;#;%%(#!%23 8*#+7*.#5:( >6;
)'* 0: ?$%% 2%%%% ! @6;
' #3* (!* ( 2%%%%(#%03%.03 (%%2$%7<(#<#%307( %%%# $ % #3 #3 ( ++%% <* (
#$#++%%(#%#22$#3(#!+3!#$#3*
(!* ( 3 ! +#3 % #7 !##$.% (#% 3#< ( #!(%.(/.3:+#33$3#38
@@ 33 5.
=>!= @
@ *<(07(%.%.3#(%#$ !.#5:(#3(%<#%3$3(!!$(#(7#<% 2%%%%(?! A=%(#(#3 <*(,< 22#.(#%+3!3(#!+3/.3:+#33$3 /.3:+#33$3#3)
@@=(!<:+#&;
B
!" #!! $ %
&
'
(
!
$) '$ * '
(
!
+
! ,! !
! - .( /! !,$ ,!
' *&
.(0(010"(21" /!)!$ ,!
* &
0(312"4((21" .(5(.215" !!
!
!
6 - "
!
#' !
!
, ' 3 6#%(7#2* #3 $.% ! %23 %.0+%(#3.02#%23 8%#%#$;%(#*0.#%# #!#%%!(?$%%%(##3*(!*(%%#.%<.30!# # (+37*!#7*!(2%%4($ #$$3#$<(#<*(.:((%#:+(#<.30#!#$$# ?$%+#3:(+#0#$4(#.(%!(2.2%! #%%%%:(2%%%%!(2#% (!#$.+!$;<(#%0 33#3*+.$(%%!$3(/.3:+#33$3$#3#0
(#(#3(#3$.%!(2#%#3#22#%3 (2#204
(!#$.+!#$;<0:##!#($;< $#03%2. (/#+#0#32#$3$3#%?. ;8A8 %(<%(%#.%!(2#%#:#+#.%#3+#%.:=6; )'* *?$%%!<(#(%%(#* *>6;
)'
(+37*+7 <*!(2%%4$#%2(:.3%!3 5$@!( ./#05$.7!,#3.%$* @"=C$
!
@"=
+7 <* ( #$# ++%% %(.3 (# +#33(+#0#$4#%(+#3<.3%(2.2%*!* (2%%%%!(%23*0:#!#$;%(#*#+7*#%% <.3 0 ! # # 3%2 ( 2# 2$3:% (#: $.+#3!#2#3 %.#7*(3!( #$# ++%%%+3!3 5$(2%%%%!%23 8(#% 042 #$07.!(/.3:+#33$*(%#+$#0 #407%:3.2$%%!#< (2%(#0#07 #4(+37#$$3#$<(#<#%3$#3#0
- ( (#!+3 +3!$#* <(.2(3: ( 3!2#*<2%#3%3%2%3!
*./0&0 )%$ + *1 2/ !"'( / / 23 *4 56 *2
/ / *9