High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRWP/7400/2020allowed

Parminder Kaur Brar v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2020-12-17Mr. Justice Arun Kumar Tyagi24 pages

!"!

#$%&%&

'$ ()'

& *

+ '

!" # $ % & $ ' ( ))))

+ ' ,& *+

, - + " " --(.--/ 0 1 2 " 13

( 3 * 4 "4, "" "

3 $ ' ( 3 2 2 2. $ 5 ( 3 " 3 2 3 + "

$ ' ( " &

"3 "

6-6 2 2 $ ' -- 7% -7%% + " 189+ " 0 3 -7%& 3 "" . $ ' 3 " 0 + " 2 2" -:

7/ -7%' 0 2 3 0 # 2 " -% 7/ -7-% ; 13 2 3 0 0" #& -7%<6-7-7 + " 2 6 $ '

13 1 77% -7-7 " ;

"" "3 2 0 -5 7% -7-7 " 6 $ ' " 1 + 1 77& -7-7 = $ ' 0 $ '

3 3 1 06%< 2 2 0 + 1 7& 7:

-7-7 $ ' 0 " 2 " $ ' + " 6" 7< 7< -7-7 3 0 " " > + 6"2 "" 0 2" " 2 $ ' " " $ 5

+ 2 $ 5 " 2 $ 5 ( + " > 2"" 2 0 $ 5 ( ""2

6&6 " 3 $ ' ( "" ""3 " "

" 0 "

" $ % & ?2 "3 " 3 $ % & + 3 $ ' ( "3 -:

7< -7-7 $ ' " " $ ' ( ( 1 "3 $ ' ( "3 $ ' "

" 3 2 6 $ ' "" "

1 @ 3 -7-7 " " 2 $ ' 2 " "" " "3 $ ' 3 " B + 1 -7-7 3 $ ' " + " " 2

" 2"" 3 "3 $ ' 2 "

" "

" * $ 5, 2 * $ (, + " 1 1" "

2 " " " + 2 " ""

" 0 3 " 2"" " " 2 2

;

( 3 " " " !" "

6'6 = 3 + $ ' 0 " 2 $ ' 2 0 2 $ ' "3 " $ 5 ( " 2" "

+ $ ' 3 " " 2 " $ ' 2 0 " 2 $ ' "3 3 " " ""3 2 3 2 3 " 2 + " "3 " "3 3

/ 1

" 0 " ;#

$ % & " 0 " $ ' (

" :

!" "

" 0 " $ ' 0 + " 2 0 C 0 1 0 + $ ' " 2 " 1

" $ ' 3 1 2 " 06%< $2 $ ' 0 3 " + "3 0 "3 " " 2"" 2" " 3 0 = 3 3 0 0

< 9 0 "

" 3 $ ' ( "" ". 3 ? " 3 3 " 0 > >3 2 3 3 = 3 $ ' 2 " 0 9 0 "

"3 3 $ ' 3 0 2 " 3 " 0 = 3 3 0 0 1

" 0 " " "

! "#$% &

'()*+*('

* "

% , -. /(,-0 123-' 3 $ /

4 4 -0

6(6

1 )' 4 5 $3 %7

D " 0 " $ ' (

3 " 0 " @ 3 -7-7 3 $ ' " + 1 -7-7 3 $ ' " $ '

" ( ?

3 # %<5( * 4 ?# 4,

3 " 2 $ ' "" "

+ = ""3 3 "

?# # ! %:<7 * 4 #! 4, + ? 0 " + " "3 " 2 " 3 $ ' "3 " "

2 + " 1 1" "

2 " " 1 3 " "3 " " 2 2"" " " ( 3 " 1 2"" 2" " $ ' ""2 3 9 0 " $ ' ( "3 3 1

" 0 " $ ' ( " " ?4" 0 & 6

6/6 + +

2 !

& %%

+ = 3 " 3 ?4" 0 ' 6 ,

1# 7 " 3 0 " ""3 2 6 1 3 ?4" 0 !6 0

# ! 2" " 2 ""3 3 " " 2 " 2 3 " + " " 3 "36 3 ?E" 0 .8, 8,( 6 66 1#7 2$

= 3 2" ?2 " CC" " 2 " 2 " " %-

! ? ?# "3 2 " 2 3 ( ?# "

? 4 2"" 4 3 *> "

"3 3, 3 " F "

" ?

2" %& *%, ?# " " 3

6:6 3 2" "" %&*-, ?# " "" "

3 3 "2 "

2"" 2" / #! 2 0

%/ *%, #! "

0 ""

3 2

"3 2 "2 2 2" %/ *-, #! " 2 2"" 2" 0 "" > " 3

2 3

3 > "

2 3 %/ *&, #! "

"" 0 3 $

( ?# "

" " " 3 ( ?# 2 2" " *

- ,9 0 :12$7 312 ! = 3 " " "

6<6 " 2 2 " 2" * ;<,=

( !/ =>?

12# $ , %& $2 2"" " 2 3

2 ""3 + @0 00<@0 13 "1#%/4 = 4 = (* 11 "3%

"1 4=+ 6

0& =

! $ %'

1 4=+ ?

6 0& =

! $: ?4" 0 6

" #$

"% %5

1 (

'&8 #71

1A 4 8

2" ;<,=

( !/ =>?

12# $ %.( 0! >(

#2 $"$ ' 6 ,

1# 7 ?4" 0 2

6%76 " " 3 " >3 2 "

?2 > > 3 2 2 ""3 "3 ""2 "3 "" "3 2" " " " 1 -=

8 "

2( "$ #(' 7 #"2 2 " 3

> 3 0 = " 2 > 2 3 = 3 "

" "" > = 3 1 2 "3 " 3 " "3 " 3 "2 2 3 3 3 2 > " 3 2 2" " 3 = " 2" " 2 " "

""2 " 1 2 " "3 2 "" " G 2 " "2 2

6%%6 "" "3 2 2" " 1 + !

0 0

!1 2 ?4" 0 -=

8 "

2( "$ #(' 7 #"2 " " " 1 ""2

%/ 1 .

"1:?4" 0 6

(

% %:

+ 2" " 3 3 "3 "3 3 " + 2 42"4 2 + " " 2" " 2"" 3 " 2""

$ * 9"3 @ /8+ :217$7, !" ""6 2 1 "

" 2" = 3 " " " = 3 " " ?2 2" " " 3 3 "3 3 "

2 " " "" " "4 2 "3 " * ?3 3 @

6%-6 )6 )6 >-

12=B 8'=

"# - %< 1 + ! 0 0

!1 2?4" 0 6 )*"'

, -

. / + '

+ +

+ (

)

/ /

+ '

% -7 ?4" 0 (,4 0

27 !173 "

3 " 5- ""26 C& 80! 08 . 8 123 +

3 (

! + + /

6%&6

+ +

+ (+ +

% -% 1!( 7""1

/ 0 &

. 0 8

?4" 0 6 C

+ 5

& 5

5 % -- 1 3 ?

0 0"

16" 0" %<:7 1 " " &- 0 1 " " "" 3 ? 0 > " --( 0 1

?4" 0 " 2 = 2 " 2

1 3 2 3 ?4" 0 2 ? 0 3 >3 "3 2" "

6%'6 3" 2" " + 0 3 " 3 2 . 3 3 -& *.( 0! :

!#12

#2 $"$ ?4" 0 6 *2

+ '

(

+ '

(

3 (

+ '

& 7 !

+ (

% -'

1 & 6+ +

1 ""2 " .( 0!

#2 $"$ ?4" 0 " ""26 *

7 +

(

6%56

(

+ 6

+ + + + !

+ 6 &

(

% -5 1

! 5*

#$ 2 3 2

3 + " 2 H 2 C 2 3 2 2 3 H

3 H 0 + 2

3 2 2 2 H 1 "

2 3 H

"" 2 " 2 ?4"

6%(6 0 " > 3 " 2 2 " H 2 "

-( 1 (00 = (! /

"1 " " " 2 8 "

C 2 "3 &I 3 " + " = H

1 ?4" 0 > " 2 " H

3 "3 " 3 + 0 2 "

3 " " 3 2 " 2

1 3 = 3 2

-/ 1 " " 0

1 > 3 ?4" 0 = 2 > " --( 0 1 " " " 3 " " 2 2"

" " " 0 3 1 1 = 0 3 = 3 " = 3 > = 3

6%/6 "3 2"

" " D "3 2" " " 1 2 = " 3 3 = 3 2 " = 3

1 " " > 3 C 0 3 1 0

0 ""3 "3 0 "" 55776(777 '57( "3 2 3 " 3 0 + "

" 2 " 2 0 "" 3 " " "" " 3 2 " " 1 " 2 "3 0 "3 " "

-< + " " 3 > 3 0 + 3 3 " " " 3 0 ""3 " 2 "

3 "

3 " "

" " 0 + " " " 1 "" ""

6%:6 3 " 62. "

3 " " 1 " "C "

3 "

3 " "

" " 1 +

" " 2

2 "

" 8 " 2 "

" 2 3 "

3 0 2 " + " " " "3 3 " " 2 2 + 3 " " " " 3 " ""3 2 2 3

2 + "

" > 3

3 3 2 "3 "

"3 " 2"" $ = 3 " 2 2 " 2 " " 2 $ ' 2 " 0 " " " " 3 + 3 "3 "3 $ ' "3 " 0 + 3 " 3 "

6%<6 3 " " 2""6

+ " " C 0 2"" 3 H" " " "3 0 " " 2 " "

$ " "3 0 " " " 3 " " + ""

" " 0 3 3 2 "

" " 3 0 " " 1 2"" 2 2"" " ""

2"" " !" "

" " 0 2 " " 3 " " 3 " " " 1 2 " 62 "

" 06%< 2 " 2 0 3

" "3 " " " "

&7 1 & 6+ +

2 !

:" 3 " 0 " $ '

( "" -7 7% -7%7 2 ? $2 ;" H 2 "" 2 "3 ""3 "3 +2 2 2"

7< -7%- %7 7< -7%' "3 "" 3

6-76 " " "" " %5 %% -7%'

+ " " 2 D -'

7% -7%5 ""

2 " 2" ;

"" "" -'

7% -7%5 7/ 7& -7%5 + "" " H 2 1 7/ 7& -7%5 H 2 -:

-7%5 -7 %7 -7%5 3 @ " ; " 0 F> 0 3 " 02" 3 " + " 3 2 ""2 3 ;" ? 0 "" 2 2 H D " ?4" 0 ;" ? 0 3 "" 2"

6 1 :

*;)

+ , &+

1 3

+ + 3

(

+ + +

6-%6 & <

7 !

*#;1*;1

7 + &

@ +!

7 ,

<+ !

+ +

(

7& (

+ (

7 % &% 1 $ '

0 ""3 "3 0 0 $ ' 2 " "3 0 "3 " 1 + " 3 " > 3 0 " 2 "

6--6 3 "

3 " "

" " 0 + "3 & 6+ +

2 !

+ & 6+ +

2 !

" 3 " " $ ' ( 2 " 3 " $ ' ( &- 1 2 "3 3 = 3 1 2 2"" 2" " " "

" 0 2 2 2"" =

. 3 " " 3 0 0 2" " && 1 2 2 ""2 2 ""2 6 *, $ ' 0 "

2 " " 7% 7% -7-%G *, $ ' " "3 2 $ ' "" 3 " " 77% -7-% 3 3 G *, $ ' " 3 " "

6-&6 77% -7-% 3 3 $ - ""

3 " " $ ' 3 " " 3 3 G *, 3 " " "" " " " 0G *, " " $ - 3 $ ' ( ".

"" " " 3G *, " " 0

"" "3 " " .

3 " " 0 G *, "" " 3 " . 3 3 3 0

$ ' "" " " 3 3 %777 %77 "" " 3 3 $ ' 0 "" " " 1 $ ' . " 3 &'

?2 "" 3 " 3 2" " 3

6-'6 " " 2 " "3 3

"3 3 3 3 " 1 " " " 2 "" 3 0 3 " 3 " = 3 2" " *

+ ' , %&%&

.3 ! . J ! " J