Aryan Raj v. Chandigarh Administration And Others





   
     

  !"#$!%&'&"()*+,+   



 ! 
"# $"#% 

# "&  &'#  ) -.

/+ /
    -.

+ /
/ 

. & ( & )*% +#,- +.

 .&'# &#  * $")$+#,- + .&'# / *0 +#,-  . "''1 - 
&

2#

.

 33333 / 

.0+


2


 4"

&  ''1

 . 5%'

 .% .

$ -

-'

&. "5* 26#

5%'

 &*$"

 . & $ # # " ''1

 & #& &'&#. 




 / 4"

&  ''1

 . %'1# " ''1 -  & &'# 2

 

4"''1

&117#&'#.# "''1 -

%'1## & &'#  2  %## %% . '

8  -#


  2 4" '

 *11 -"11$# " 5  9:

&; 11 $-<*

 & &'=




# ?

?+ &&*# > " @,%  ">

 ;&

 . ; *1 =

&+ -  /+
"# $"  : "& '&&# "

&
1&&

"5% 

- >+

A.% "

1;&

. ' -"1 $+&-* $/ %8&* . 1.2

%8&:"& 1&'

- ' , *&&' &, & "

1# 1,1+

"# 1&.7"

-"",>$ , "

&0 # 5#&5* /7

"7

'

:1&"&

-> .% ##"& '

- ' *%>. 5"

&#-%'

&+&# 1#

" 0 #  5*  /  

 -

 &'-  . "

-"

,%  ' &# #
.

+",>-11-

,15# &5*

4"&'#

11$*&# '1%-*& B  . '"& -116% 11 -"11$# & &  4" %-1 * . " & # -*& & = '1%  B    . = ,$ . &"  C=B=D  4" 1 $

 -

  ". & '&& $ . 

" -1&&  E* ,1 5% 

-$ F#> " # . ">! ,&

7

" %*%.

9%8& -&.
6 4/29%8&+-1-*1

>&  . .

, &*>- & # >

9 $$$  %8&   -& .
6 4/29%8&+ '

*#4& -%' $>- =7 $#

/ -%'&



$ 1..*& &",>&-

#. & # -*&+  -"  # & . ''1 #  + 

$+ @'"

-& # -*1'

* 4" -*& "&  #*

. .* & ; *116% 11 -"11$# & &  1 $ >1 1 & . 

$ # ''1 #  + &*>- "% '#*- $  -

.% "-%'  * "

"6&" &.

'*&* -*& *-"& && *# "'-

-1&*>- '&- >#.B  -*&+>* 5%'

#.% "& *#. "&*>- & ? 4" '

 ''1 # . " .%

# -*& 1$7

" -&& #-*% & # "

& ''1

 7& --'

# 4".

+ " .

1# " '&  7

 '

 -"11$ $ -  ', & . " '&'- *& &&*# > " &'#

11$ , F    .*-

 . & & > 7 '"& -11 -"11$# # 11-"11$#& &#>, .'

*#4& . 11-"11$#& &1&.* "'"&>%#. -&

 .  '- 1 0# -%' $ 5' " .

1# .

*1 #

 ,1,  % "# . &&&& $ .

&& . 

*11-"11$#& 7"

1''1 $.=B=-*& # . "', .'

*#4&  A # 1#7

& % "&>.

1#>"1..
"# $" #% 

 # " &'#

11$+ 7" % >

. "'& '

"&>>- 4" '

& &*>%

" &

'*1

& - # " '&'- *& 7 $ '',# .% " > ! ,&

 >. -1*& ". '&'- *&4"*&+ "& # "1 $

-#

&"#>1 #

  #7.

#*-& #

> "5' ".

1##8'

, 7 "& ', &# ".+ .- &-11#.  .

 &&*-.

-.%

+  %# -

7&

&&*#&, $& .

 "# .

# 1 >  7& $  "

% 8 ' " '

*# 4&   4" &*1 # # ?

. "'

*#4& &5* 26-#+ --# 7"

-"+

&-*#/?/9%8&#7&#-1# . 1# ;&*'' "-&.

+1#-*&1.

"&'1-#1 -*'&-

&/ #/ " $"

&. &&7

"=

&-

 " .

.# &C "- D  *#$%  # #  

 '&&# >  = ,  0-" . " =1"

:

$"
*   
  A2/ .

1# & 1(2"3 4($5&

&("5 45"674 4&'

 4!58 653 65$&( 9'+ !34& !%4("3"7&%3 (&:!5'& ;- "& > 1 # *'  &*'' $*%   % 11 -"11$# '& &   ' 7

"  -"#*1#
& 6 -"#*1#4 >'&# "*&+% %*%./29%8&&"*1# > "E* % .-1 "'

*#4&   -

& /  # / " - +  '#*-# >17 . #.-( C*+ !'!5: &"( &( 4&74!5 !$6% &"(3 &(' & 6 &"(')  11@,%

&."

$"#*-

# ""

$" #*-

& - , $  # .% " @,%  &"11 &,   1&& " .

, ' -  & & . '&& 7

>-"%8#

&

2  4"'&&7

">-"%8#

&&"11>$ , *''$15

..

,&.#%

& ."

$"#*-

D 5555555 C*+  !'!5: &"()   , '''  @,% &"11 ''  , @,%  & >1 &"% +   1&& " .*'- 1*%>.,-- "-#& $

 -" $*' . '& & %  > .

11# 7

" '&& 7

>-"%8 #

& . 7"

-"+  ' -  -" &"11 > &,# . '&& 7

" >-"%8 #

& *# -1*&& + > # - #  ' -  . '&& 7

" >-"%8

&*#-1*&&##+%1(G >1 #&&#17, H >#.#"#." $H - 1-%  #

-1*# $ ->1 '1&+ 1'& -*#+#7.

&%+- #

-8, -

%&#%*&-*1#& '"H # *

&%+ *1 #

+ &'- - 1

#% 1 11&&H  %*1

'1 #

& .% %$&  '&& *# -1*&& # -1*# $#.

>1 #&& "'& #

.-"#

&( , ## " &,

 '%

 &"11 > --#-7

"&*-" *-

&& &&*#> "'''  @,% .%

%

%( , ## .* " " '''  @,% -&*1

 7

"
"

.
%%   
%% +& "-&%>+%+", $$# ' . 78 - # *   @,%  & >1 &"% + > 

 # &*>-  &*-" -#

&+ . + & % > &'-  &*-" 

& 5%'

  @,% & >1 &"% .% "', &. &&-

  " -*

,--- > 11# *' #*   , 1>

 .  &*

>1 '& 7

>-"%8 #

  .   " &*..

-   &&+ &*-" ,-- &"11 > - # .7# " &*--# $ -*

  # . "&*--# $-*

1&&*

>1'&

">-"%8#

& , 1>1+

%.

& >.

11#>

-"$%$ ".

,- $ &#17" " & '& 7

" #

 , 1>1 . " '&  + %'1 &"11 .

11 *' " ,-- > ''  .  '&+ " "'&7

"#

( , ## . " *.,-- & >1 &"%

&&*-" $ ,- $.'&- >%'1#+ ,-- &%> -"$#%$ ".

,- $ &7

' '',1. "''' @,%  / 4" '''  @,%  %+ > 

+ ', #.&*-"15

.*''$1

.%'1% '&&7

">-"%8#

+&

8&.

D 4".

& $*% .1#-*&1.



"%*& >> .*-

. 1, 1>1& &> 7'"& -11 -"11$#& &#% 116 *11-"11$#& &B

&'*'&+&""&'1-#1 -*'&-

&/ #/ "- '#*-#" >, -

/ "- +', #&. 1&& " 29&,

.'&&7

">-"%8#

7

"*''$ 15

..

,&.#%

&."

$"#*-

 -

 / " - + ', #& .   1&& " 9 &,

,-- 11@,% & >1 &"% &#.* "', #&.9 &,

 . '&& 7

" #

 . >1 #&&+ #.&& # 1-% #

 -;

''& "$*% .1#-*&1

&>&#*'', .9&,

1. "&&*.. $.%

*111 ##

%*1

'1#

&:7,+ .- &

*

', "'& -&+7*>1 --'

&*>% .

1# -*&1 .

'



? ; *116% 11-"11$#& &-''11.#  .

$#''1 # -". "&# &"&& 1 :# ">% "& "&# &+ "$*% 1#-*&1.

-*1#",>5% #&,

" 1 &  , 1>1 .  &  &*.. $ .% *16% 1

7*1##' ,& &7

"'"& -1#

&.%''1 . "&%+7"

-"7*1#>#  1 "  & &&&7

&&*$"

>$ ,&%'.-> "- &  $"

E*1

#& % 11*&. "%+>* 11'&&7

%*& >  #E*11#>.

->$ , -1&&. &>1#'&& "5'&. "-1&& / 4"5 $*% 8'

, 7 "1

.

*116% 11 -"11$# &  "6&" &"*1# > 5%'

.% 8 $ '

*# 4&   ;.   11+ " '

*# 4&  > 8+ %*%'&&%8&&"*1#>#*-# /29& "-&.
6 4 &>-*& *116% 11-"11$#& & 1& E*11 #' ,# & 
6 4 & .   % # . & '*'& 1 - "& > '1-# *' " -& . (2"3 4($5& '6<5 + . # &$*% 1&#&,& >- #;

%>  " =B= -*& "& &'- -11 > -.

# . &

" #

&  )'

 , 7 "  1

&+ " 1 $

-#

& ", > '&- >#  4" &% ", > '&- ># > 5' ".

1##7 '&

# - "* "

#'

# .. %#.%8 $#% & *-"%

&>& 1.

 5' & & "
* & 1-8 " 5'

&  '

 "*'  4"

A '&- '

 . /29 %8& & " % %*% E* # . -1 '

*# 4& + 1& -  > # > *& . " &% &  11 -# # &. "=B=-*&&*...%#

# ">

 # E*11   .* " --&&  "& > $ 
6 4 -# # &+>* &#& % '&&7

"#

> '1-# # &#, $4"

&7& "&

*

"-&.(2"3 4($5& '6<5 # "*&+ "= , 0-". "=1"

:

$"
* "1#  '&& 7

" #

 &"*1# >  #   ' 7

"
6 4 -# # &  ; " & # -&+
6 4 -# # & "# > $ ,  9 15

"% %*%%8&E* #.#% &$ 29 15

''17

"#

 B " .%

# &&+ 7 ",  '

+ >* &% && &7

'

 2  - "7,+   1& & $"

" .-  

*116% 11-"11$#'&&",- 1

&+7"

-"  " '"& -11-"11$#'&&4"&*>- 5' &7*1#

"*&+>711#, &# 5%  ".&

.-

$-*&7"

-" & " &'- - #& . &*-" '&&   4" % 1& 5% 

-& "*%>.& "# .

$#''1  7

", 7 --%%#

$&*-"& &         / 

.

      *+,+   %#' $" " "&'8 $6&# I&6 " "' >1  I&6