High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/557/2006dismissed

Commr. Of Income Tax-I, Chd. v. Usha Saboo

2015-05-15Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari,Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal34 pages

! "

# $ #% !" #

! "

# &''% #% !" $ (

! "

# )*#% !" % +

! "

# !#% !" & (

! "

# - . ! #% !" ' (

! "

# / 0 ! #% !" ( ((

! "

# )*#% !"

1) 213456)-$# 6#-.78) 9 268-$# 6 213456)-$# 69##2:5-$96

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 2 :

) *

+,+ --."

!/ .0!

+ * "+,12 ,.2,!

!/ 3, + * ,1 +,4."

!/ .0!

+ 5555 #-.78) 9 268-$# 6)6 + -, +!

" +/!78 ,9 !3,- !" : -, + !

" !0 !77,,! !0 /!7 8 ;< , !/",- ,,- !

!0 7 !

" " " / ,!%$;$<!0 +/!78/ .=',

/ +7 4 ==%6=& # + 7, > ,!!0 3 +7 , + + > ,!!00/ ,!//! +7

/ ,!+ 0/ 7!

," ,/" ,4 , /!/ "?. 0!

.",! !0 +94 +,/!77!!

" "@ "-7 ?3,0!

/! ,/. +!3 . 0 +0/ ,!&&(!0#AA' $ + / , 6+ , +, + !" , + 9!

779 +29!!- ! !B/1

29!!C "3@!,

9 3 !" " *D +!"!

!B 2!+ /1

"09 ,1!77", /+0 .

+,0, 7, 74 ; !B/1

- ! <+29!!- ! " !B/1

- ! +"%AE" 'AE + !0 + > , 4 /, !0 !B /1

29!! C " / 4 , !9 3 3!- ! ",- +29!!- ! 0,,- ,! 0!

! ,! " 7,7-7 " / ,! $=( " $=F !0 !7,/ .=&'+ ,!3",7,"+29!!- ! 0," " / ,!A +!7,/ .=&'90!

+,,-+!

+ 7

3 ,7 4

" , 7 !0 2+

/+ - " "#A==$ %AAD63 !9 +/!," ,!0!

+!0

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 3 :

++ +"94 +29!!- ! + !B/1

- ! +- ! /! ,"

,/ D- /!

-, 94 + 29!! - ! +

!" /! "" +43 " !!

,! 7!0 AAD6!

!0 %AAD6/!," ,!0!

+- /!

+,/,73 @/ 94 +,- 00,/ " +;<9 3!3"94 +!

" ,9 ,7 -", +, % ? + +" +! -+ + - ","!

9,0 / /!," ,! !3 " ,! /!

, +- . +3 " !9,0 / +7"!

!0 !3 " +- /!

,3,/!

", !" :0 94 @ "-7 +2 7!

+,,! ,3 194 !

,-+ !

0/ 3 + +" + 7! !0 AAD6 !

!0 %AAD6!

,!" !3 " +- D

,/ /!

3,0/ !

+/!

,- +/!/ ,!3+ !" 3, + /

, &.&&.#FAD6 + & + !" 0,"

!0 ,/!7 !0 ,- 00,/ " !" : ,/!7 %.##.A#AD6 +

!" /+-" + !

" 90!

+ !77,,! !0 /!7 8 ;<! ,! - ! ",/ ",- +! + 9@/ 7

+;<",7," ++ ,9 !3"

!" :-, +,!

" ' +3"7,

"! +0!!3,- 9 ,> ,!!0 3)6 G?+ ! + 0/ " /, / 7 / !0 + /. !:9 , @ ,0," , 3 ,

,- 7 !0

AAD6 + /, /, !

/+ -9 8

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 4 : 9/ ,,!!02/ ,!%F. + /, !!0+ /+ -9 8HI ( =&=. ! J29!! +" !9 ," 0 !7 + !

7 !0 ",,"

,,//0!

+7 0/

!0+!, 4"0,/, " /!9!

,! - 3 " , ! 9 3 J29!! " *D +!"!

!B2!+ /1

"09 ,1!77", /+0 .

+,0, 7, 744

" "#=&=. +!

7 !0 ", + /!9!

,! - + ," J29!! " !B/1

- ! ", !- !0!

7" !7!

/!74 ,7, ". 94 + , ", //!

",-4. ! &A='A. !B /1

29!! C " 3 ,/!

" 3+,/+ 9/7 "7" 9,/ ,7, "/!74 " / ,!%$6!0 +!7,/ .=&'+ !B /1

- ! +"'AE+ " +,"29!!- ! , !" +"%AE+ !0 +> , 4/, F !

+4 =FF", "",00 / !9 3

+ !B/1

- ! " +29!!- ! ##A==#. +29!!- ! 0," ,! " / ,!$=("$=F!0 +!7,/ .=&'-,

+ !B/1

- ! 0!

7,7-7 "! ,!!07,!

4+ 6 +!" 90!

+ !74 C3 ! " 3 +, + !74 C3 ! " 94 !

" " " ##A==# @/ + ,! " ", / 29!! - ! ! , %AE + , !B/1

29!! C " + !B /1

- ! !9" 7,"94*D2,,7!

,!74. +

"//! + 29!! - ! 0," " / ,! A;

< !0 !7, / . =&' 90!

+, ,-+ !

, 3+,/+ , ,7 !

4,- +! ,!!0 +!

" +!74C3! "3"

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 5 : = + 779 !0 + 29!! - ! " + !B /1

- !

" +7

, 7!02+

/+- " "#A==$ + !B /1

- ! , 0

, + K /+ : " 779 +29!!- ! 0

, +K :/+!0 779 !0 29!! - ! - " ! .

0 . ,- " ", /+ , + !B/1

- ! +, + + ,-!7, !0 AD6 + + ,/!0 %AAD6 + -- - ,- ('A/ + ,/!0 ++ 3,/ , !0", ,"" ,-+ '!0 +- ,"" , 30 "7 /!", ,! " / !0 + /!

/ + 3! " 9 !0 + %%A.AAAD6> , 4+ !3"94 +29!!- ! + ,,!!0

+2+

/+- " )6

! !

!! "

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 6 :

# ! ! !

! !

! $

# ! ! !

! !

% #

! &

! ' !

(

* "+ ,

- !

/ .

/123441

-6 -

(

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 7 :

230!!3442

! !

8 0

* A + !" /! "" !

!0 + 7 !0 %AAD6 . 7!0 AAD6! -+ !9!

,!"/!," ,!!//!

+ - /!

, " , + 2+

/+ - +4 /! "" +," 7!0 AAD6 + 3! "9!//! !0/,

/, 0!

- ,- + - /!

" + 2+

/+ - " +79,-/, ,

/+ -9 8! @ ,04 + 9, " + > 7 !0 +, /,7 0!

,!7 .

!" 0," ,! !

"//! *DL,+ !/, 3+,/+ " + + =$# 9 16 ! $A$==$ + //!

",-4 /,7" "" / ,! !0 AAD6 !

7!0 %AAD6 + +,- 00,/ .+!3 .",!3"

+7+" !" D3!

" !, 6

!0 + + , " , + 2+

/+ - + ,- 00,/ +" 3!, 6 !0 + ,/!0 %AAD6, 2+

/+ - " 3 ! "!/ 7 4 !!0 AAD6!

%AAD6 + 3 !3 " +- /!

+,- 00,/ !

+@ "-7 +2 7!

" + *"

,-+ !

" !9

, +! / + !0 9 , "

0 !0 7-7 !

7, ,! !0 -/4 " /!7 ,!0!

0 " 0 ,,-0 !7/!7 ,!3

" /, /, ,! 4.+!3 .++" +/, ,,!!0 /!78/ .74/ ,!("#F;,,< " + ,/,.

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 8 :

. 0 " !0!!3 +@ "-7 ?3,"3, +/ ,!#F;,,<!0

,- + 9!

,,! !0 + 2+

/+ - .++" + !B/1

- ! 0 4,- %AAD6 + 3! " + 9 0!!,+ !

1 + / /! ," , + 9!

,,! 3/! "" 90!

+ ,,!3 ,, !94 + !B/1

- ! !4!

!09 " / ,!+,- 00,/ ! +" ! 0/ + 9,0 / ,! ! //! !0 + - /!

+"!

9 9,+"+,/! ,!3 , "90!

" 3 3, ! " 3, + + 7 0

+" + ,/ !0 %AAD63 + ,/!0/++ " +- /!

7 4 0!!3" ! + !B /1

- ! 1,- !

+ 7-7 !9

,0 3 !9!

,!7 +/!," ,!. , / 3+! ,> ,+"!00,/ 3! "- +,-+ 7! + +!

779 +29!!- ! 3/! ""90!

,0/ 3 !!

,!7 # +;<+" !" ,!&&(!0#AA' 3, , / !

7!4!0 +/!74M +3!

/+,/ 8

M + !0 + + /! " !

+ 7 !0 7- ,/!

! 3+" !" 3!

, / !

7!4 !0 + /!74. + /! " !

+ 4 7 !0 7- , /!

!" +","!

+ 48

,7, ! 94 + /+ !0 + + , !B /1

- ! 0

/!/ ""

,/ /!

,/9 !" , !&&(!0#AA' 3. 0!

.+" + 7! %AAD6 + 3 /, "-, +!0 ++ " +,- 00,/

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 9 : +" ,-+ 4

+ 7!

+/, /, ,90!

/, -, $ ,!

/ 4 +, - 0 +!

" + ,9 3+,/+3+ +"?3, 0 +7 % *+ --. "/! ,-!9+0!0 + 97,

"0!!3)6 < + 9,-!9,0 / ,!, +- 9 3 !0

+ + " !0 + - /!

!" D3!

" !!

,!7 !00!

+ !!07 " +/!78/ < + 3 ,0/ ! /!," ,! 49 , / !0 - /!

< +!

" ,

L< 4 . +/!," ,!0!

+- /!

" &&,9 8 " / ,!#F!0 +/

& * + --:. 9! !!, ,! + , !

" ! 1 9,0 / ,! !0 + /!," ,! , " , + 2+

/+- 7 49/ +- "!!

,"0!

7 , !

3 0! "" !

,3. , " ! 1 9,0 / ,!!0 +/!," ,!7 ,!", +- ?+

+ /!," ,! 3 ," , / !0

,/ !7, !

, > ,!!00/ 3+,/+7 / ,4""! +0/ !0/+/

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 10 : ' *2 ,: ,/ ! +@ "-7 !0, ,,!/+!0 !794,-+!

! " #$%&.,3 0! "" /. +*-,--/4!0 @ !

!*,C "3 +"94 +0, 7!02+ ,+-3"!"94- " F + 4. =$F + ," 0, 7 ,-" + 7-,- -/4 " %.($' !0 +/!74 !2+ + 7+

9+ @0!

(.&.AAAD64 - " "A(A==%'. 7, "+ !- " ,> ,+

+, 7-,--/4 ,-+ " !- *D+

72!!, *-,- - " ! '&.A# + !0 + /!74 + ,/ !0 '&D6 + +3

, 7, "+ !"

+8,-

7 ! -+ !+,7 8, / !0/, -, 0!

+7 4 =%F6%=/! ",- + ,/!0/++ +! " 9 1 '&D6 , + ,/ 7 ,!" , + - + /! "" + 7 1 ,/ !0 + + ! + " !0 - 3 %'D6 + ", , ,/3+,/+! -+ !9 1, /!," ,! 0!

" 7,,- + /, -, + ,9 // "

7 :/! ,!3+,/+" 0 /90!

+, ,,!/+ +,0 ,/+-1,-0!

+")6 G/ , ! !

! ! 7

34+" !

, , ! !

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 11 :

: "

;

31<'1# !

! ! !

( ! 5!

= ! !

!! ! !

! , ! !

! !

(

( :+"

(

? : "

! !

31<'1# 0 : "

, ! !

( !

:+"

! @!7

B ! !

(

( !

! !

5! <!

( !

(

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 12 :

C 9

! / , .

! !

B !

( ! .

!: :3D

! .

( !

> ,

! !

( !

! !

;

! !

31<'1#

! ( :+"

* '

# ? , / 0 - 3, + +@ "-7

,/ 3- +

+ ,-!

,!" +/!," ,!9 3 3!

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 13 : 7!

/71!",00 / ,-+ + !1 !

,!7 +/!," ,!, / !0/+!0 +7 ( ?! !, ,/, ! +0 !7"!,- !+ !9/ ,9" !/+

/ ,!7 !9 ,! 4"" !

+ ,"/" +0/ ,/+/+ 8!03+

.7 9 ," ! + 9, !0

!0 + !0

/ ,! " !

7 4! +9,!0 / ,9" !, 94 +"". ,3

+/!

4/! "/ @ ",/ , 0!// /! ,!3! "9 !/ ,9

,0,/, ! 9,-

+7 ! !," 8 F !

" 94 + , ,,! /+ , ,@ + +

9+ @: /.

+- ,",/ 3!", ,/ 74 ++ " +7-,- -/4 + / 90!

+ - /!

" + + ,"" " ", ,/ 3 !,9 ! + " ,"" - , / !0/+!0 +7+- , 7!0

+ - /!

/! ," , && "," !

0!3 !

!0 - ! ++ /+!0 +- /! "+ 9

,"" +!

/+!0 +- /! "+ 9

" 3, +!

" , +9/!0 +!

+- /!

/! "+ 9- " !94 +779 +29!!- ! 3, +!

+ ,-!" +, " + 779 !0 + 29!! - ! /! " + !" +, + 3, +!

- ,- + - /!

3 0!

!4 7,,99 / 4 !!

,! +/!," ,! !3 "/+!0 ,""!0/!

, ,!,9 !/

, !0/+!0 + = /+ !0 + " "- !0 + 2 7 !

, ' "( # )

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 14 : ! "$*#

" 3, + +, 4, ,-0! "

!7 -, ,- + -/4. +

, +" ! " ,

,/ /!

. +2 7!

+")6 EEEEE=

! !

(

, 5!

(

, ! !

! * ' !

# +@ "-7 ,/!7 3 !*+ --: 97,,! #A *2 ,. + ," !@ "-7 +, ,,!/+!0 *"

,-+!

) +!

,**% ! /. +3 --",

",-"

,// ,/,-"0!

3 ",-- /

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 15 :

! /

, - . /!74 7" ** C " --" , ,-- ,/!0", !" / +- 3

3" +

,. +!3 . " , ! - 0!

7, ,! !0 + ,- -/4D",

,9 ,!

-7 + ** C " - " !4/

,7! ,, 7 ,/!," ,!!0 +: // ,- + 67

7, ,! !0 + - /!," ,!

!0. + - - " !

! // !

-- , 0 , 4 ,-D",

,9 ,!

-7 !04 !" / !04!

7 0/

3! " /!7 3, + + ," 0!!" !" / "D!

+ ," !,

, + +"!- " !!

/ /+/!0," ,, 4/ + /, +7! " " +- +,-!00,/

+7 /, 3+,/+3 89+!77,,! /!7 8 /!0, 7" + !

" + ,9 +" #AE !0 /!7 ,!

,9 9

,/ /!

" !9,- ,! " ", / +7! 9 1/, /, "!

,9 8 ,/!7 " / ,! #F;,,<;/< !0 + / " " + "", ,! 8 +> ,!, +: +,-+!

33+ /!7 ,! 3! "

,/ + /, /, !

/, + ,-+!

+" +/!7 ,!3,/!," ,!!0 + 67

7, ,!!0 +,--/4D",

,9 +,- "!, / !0

,/ /!

4,- ! +@ "-7 +2 7!

, +/!0 () .

$$/$*

"0 # +, ,,! /+ +" +!

,!7 # *2 ,! ," ! +@ "-7 +, ,,!/+!0

,-+!

, 1

2 01

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 16 :

3% ! %% ?3, 0 +,@ "-7 +!

43+,

,- !@ "-7 /, "94*+ -- ## + 97,,! +,!

" !!

,!7

!3 " + ,/!0 ++ " ,/!0

,/ /!

7 4 9/ + 2+

/+ - , 0 "," !

9,0 / + 7. ,

@/ "?+ +- 9 3 +

,,",/ + 76 7 /!," ,! 3 , / !0 3! !

!7,. , , ,9 ! 9 9,0 / " " !

,!" 9 3 /+ !0 + ,7 9,0 / ,! ! , 0 !0 + " ,7 , 0 !0 3+!0 , ! ,,

/+/. +/!," ,!7 9 !

,!" !3 "/+!0 + ,0, ,!,9 !"!! #$ * + -- ! + !

+" ," ! + @ "-7 !0 , ,,! /+ !0 *"

,-+ !

, 45 "' # ,***",%&# &$' +> ,!90!

+,-+!

" 0 /33+ 4

+/!," ,!

/, "94 +0!

+!0 +, + 3 !98/ ""0 !7 /!7 ,! !0 + !-6 7 /, -, ! + - ! "

!0 /!," ,!"!!

!0 ++ !"9 /!

/!," ,!0!

+!0 ,-+ !/!

! +/!743, + +,"!0 !" , 3! /!7,6-!

/+ 8 , C " " ! ;

!",/+

C "++ 3 +"94 +3+!9!-"

+707,4++ 3 !", 3!/!7, !0 'AD6 + " =$&D6 + . +! -+ + ,,-7 1 !0

+! + 3 #= " F& + + /!7 8 00,/ /!7 + ",00 / 9 3 !0 + + /, " 94 " +- " +/!

!0/> ,, ,!!0 ++ "

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 17 :

+7!-6 7/, -,"//!

",-4" 7

8+/!78 00,/ @/ +:/! ,! + ,/","!

3+!4

, !0 ++ +"94 +7"

+7! /, "94 +73 +/!," ,!0!

+/!

!,-, +!/!7, "3+,/+3 ,"/" 94 +0/ +3+!3 , / 3! " ,-0 !7 +9! " !0 3! /!7, " ," /" " /!7, * + -- ," ! +0!!3,-!9

,!!0 +, ,,!/+)6 ,

! ,

! !

5! !

(

( A

)

- !

!"#!$ !%! & ''(

* +@ "-7 "!!

*+ --:/! ,! ,0 " +- /!

+ ,/!0 ++ ,+,-+ ., ,,

"/!

+ ,/!0 ++ ",!

,"" !0

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 18 : +/!

!,-, 7439

!0 ++ 0!

7 " , "" ! + + +7 +" 94 , ,,!/+. +/!

!,-, ,,/,"/!0 ++ +!",-" +!,"" 8, /?+ "4+" +- /!

3", ,/ ,-+ ,"" ,-+ !0!3 +,!0 ++ + /,. 0!

./ 4", ,- ,+90 !7 +!90!

#% +, ,,!/+ + 0

+@ "-7 ,-+ !

, 1

2 01

3% ! %%3+ ,, 3+" + ,/ /, "94 "!

3+! +" ! 9 + *-,- , / " 3+! +" - " " - !"- +,!3 "3!

+/!," ,!0!

!0 ++ !"

+/!," ,!3 + ,/0!

"- ,!!0 +!3 " 0!

.3!

!9 1, !//! 3+, /!7 ,- +/, -,!0 ++ +, ,,!/+",00 "3, +

,3!0 ,-+!

+00/ +!3 +*-,- , / /! "9!", /+7 "+" /+,-3! " !

+ !/,787 ,!!0 8!/, -, ,,-0 !7

+!0+ ? !

/!/ "3, + /+/ " 0!

. "!!

8 4!,,! - ",- +72 00,/, !!

.+!3 .

+ , ,,! /+ !0 + *"

,-+ !

"," !

+!" /!," ,!/!

,!" ,0 +!

/!7 +/!/ ,!

3!", ,/ !"+, ,,!/+!0 ,-+!

+ ,/,!09,0 / ,!"!

,!7 #& * + -- + ," ! + 0!!3,- !9

,! !0 *"+4

"+,-+!

,0' 6 '(

! 4- & %% )6

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 19 : / , ! !

:3DD

(+1DDD

, ! !

(

:$"<! 5!

( +1DDD

: 3DD

: 3DD, , !

!:3DD

(

, , !

(

5! (

(* ,

! , ! < 7 !

!7 ,F34$G23,:"+2'<# !

/ !

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 20 :

H 5!

(+1DDD

: 3DD

: 3DD ! !

! A /+3334$"

* #' +!9

,!"!!

*+ --: 97,,!+ , ,,!/+!4+" +/!

!,-, ,,/,"/ ,,- !7 +!",-

,/ 79 !0 + , + /!74 " /!

9 4/> , "!

" ,,/,"/!

/!> /!0 +!",-!0 +,"+ 0/ . +@ "-7 ,-, *+ --: 97,,! , ,,! /+ // ,3 1 94 + , ,,! /+ !0 !794 ,-+!

7; <+, ,,!/++" " )6 ,

! ! < 7 !

!7 ,F34$G23,:"+2 '<# !

/ !

H 5!

( +1DDD

:3DD

:3DD! !

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 21 :

! A /+3334$"

* +, ,,!/+. 0!

.,0/ // ,3 , + / !0 /!7!, /!," ,! / 9 !

,!7 ,""

3!", ,/ /+/9!09,-/> , "!

" 4 !"!

/+" #( C 4.*+ -- ," ! +0!!3,-!9

,!!0 2 7 !

, 4 - 8- 1 4 6 ",* ,#$0 $ &)6

-! !!

( (

( !

! ! '

) * + ,

F0:343 +3 '34D#3 :&"4G- . F'1DDD#1+2 ,: 2"$ 'A #G F'34&3# 323 ,: ++ 'A)#G #

! ! ! !

- !

J-

! (

(

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 22 : ,

(

! ! !

! (

* /

, - !

; K33D& !

-,B

( ,

- !

* ' !

! !

# ,! :

' * #

! !

( !

! !

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 23 :

'I8 .1&3 1DD2# 7!

,0 1 0, F0: 34"" D '34"# $ ,: 144G G ,!

. *

-! 0 20

* #F +!9

,!, +4 -8- 14 6 ; </!

9 ",,! ,!*!

. + !9

,!"!!

*+ --: 97,,! 7 49/

- " , ! 9 3 +

, "! !

9,0 / /!," ,!"!

,! +7. + +!

,"D!

+ / "" 0 !7 "!,- ! "". + , . , , 90!

. 3 !

/!," "94 +2 7!

+2 7!

/!," +/ , 4 ",00 /! 8 ! "

" + !9

,!. , 3! " 9 / 4 " + @ "-7 , 4 - 8- 1 4 6 " #3+!+", +/> ,, ,!94 L!"0! ,! !",- ;L< !0 + + /, !0 7 ;!",-< C,7, " ; < 94 - " " A##AA( + /! "" + !!0 +- 3 !/> , '(E /!

!,-, ,!

/!74. /+,! C ";C< ,

,", / 4 +" + ! -+ !

"!3

7 /!7, + , C 3 !

,-+ . /+ . ! ,! ! /> , 0

+ , C + 7

/!/ "2/ ,!=;<;,<.74.

0 !0/, , , ", , ,7!

+" @ "-7 ", "94 + +,0 ,/ "4 !

" " +" , / + !

3 /!/ " 3, + +!0+ "!

3, + +!0 , 763,+!

" 3, +/+!0 +, 7 /! ""+"9/> , "94

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 24 : L 3 +" ,-+ "," !

0!3 0 !7 + + 6 /+ - M !7 !0 ,-+ . /+ . ,-+ !0 ,0 /D ,! /!

9 /!

" ,-+ , + - , /. +! -+ +!",-/!743! ".94

!0, + +!",-.+ , 00/ , / +7-7 !0, "!3

7 9,", ,., ","!

+ 0!

/9 ,-+ !"!!, ,3!0 + ,/,!0/!

/, - +6 3+" - ! +!",-/!74+"!- ,-+ ", / , "!3

7 /!7, , + 7

!0 ,-. !7, ,! !0 ", / "7-7 ,-+ 3+" ,! !

,-+ +"9 /> , "94L + ! -+ +/> ,, ,!!0 + + "!

+ ! -+ 8/ ,!!0 ++ 6 /+- 0 + ,-4B"/+!0 ,- ", . 3+,/+ 3 -" ! + 9 4

". 2 7!

+") !"

-,B !!

344+ -,B !

L !

0 ' !

: :L,0: !

J- ! '

@)# 5!

* !

, 7 /! "" +" 9

43 +! ,!> ++ !0 ,! /!7, 3+" ",- 8 /, !0 + ! ,!. + 7 ! ,! "," !

7-7 ,-+

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 25 : #= +@ "-7 " . +!794,-+!

+"/!7

+/!/ ,!

0 + + 3!

"> ,, 0

!/+, +!9@/ !0/! 77 ,-

/ ,!9 3C"L " ,

,,/

/ ,! 3

0 !0 !

G 1 -I3+,/+ ,-+ " 7 /!

", +7 G/, I3, +, +7,-!02/ ,!#;%<!0 +/ +,-+!

L/> , + + 3, +!

,-+ " 7 +L ! +!

+"/! "" , +"/> , " ,-+ + ! -+ + ! 3! +/!," ,!!0 +0/ / 2 7 !

/!7 +/!/ ,! +7

/!/ G -9 - 3. 0!

. 0! " 7

!0 0/ 3 !

0 !0K/, :!

+9434!0

0 + + + 2 7!

","!

+!" ,0, +"/!7 +/!/ ,! //!/ !0+ "!

. /! "9!9,0 / ,!" !

,!7 !0 + /!," ,! , " 7 4 9/ + 2+

/+ - "," !

, 0 9,0 / + /!," ,! > ,"" /!7! $A

,3 ,. 0!

. !

,/!, 3, + + @ "-7 , 4 7" #3!

" , . +,, ,3!0/+!0

+ " "- !0 + 2 7 !

, ( ) " #3+,/+" 3, + 4!, ,, 90!

? . 0!

. ,4 9! "94 +@ "-7 , 4 () " # $ + 0,

/! ,! 0!

" @/ " + ,9 3

,-+ ,/!7,- +/!/ ,! +/!," ,!! -+ !99,0 / "

!0!

,!" !3 "

,/ /!

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 26 : ) ;<

$# *+ --/! "" ,4 , + / 3 ,0/ ! /!," ,! 49 0!

4 !0 + /!

, " , / 6&,/ ",-0!

+- /!

/! ,",/ && && !+,9, + , 779 !0 + 29!! - ! " + 0, 7. /!7,"!

,!3""/!

!"94 +70 !7", / 4!

,", / 4 --,- 43+ , ", , 4 9 , ,7, ! !

, /!7 ,!3, + +9 ,!0 +/!74, !B/1

29!!C "!

!7+ ,-4, .", / 4!

,", / 4.,4 /+9 , $$ !

!0 +, /! ,!. * + -- /! "" 779 !029!!- ! ","!

+ /+,/8

, !/

4! /+ 9 ,,/!7 ,!3, + +9 ,!0 !B/1

29!!C " +,

- ".+ ," ! +!

" +!74C3! "" "##A==#

",- + 97,,!!9+0!0 +29!!- ! , 6, +00/

" !!6/!! ,!!0 + !B/1

- ! 100/ 0!

K,",-,B ,! !0 3 7 , 4 "

0 !0 /+!!-4 /!74. + !! !0 + 29!! - ! 7!

7 0/

!0 3 7 ,+! "9/! / "3"0 "+,//!

",- !+ ,",/ "7,,!!9+0!0 +29!!- ! , 3 + !B/1

- ! 3,!,!!0 /+!!-4" +29!!- ! ","!

/+!!-4 / 4 ! /!" / /+ 9 ,

. +, 97,,! //!

",- ! + . 9,+" + 29!! - ! +" !

/> ,

/+,/8

,0!

, , +, !3/ + !B/1

- ! +"!

+ 7 ! !B /1

29!! C " 2+ ! ," ! !9

,!, +!

" +!74C3! " +00/ "

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 27 : / ,! #= !0 ,- 8/+- - ,! / . =($. /!74 , 3+,/+ + !6 ," +!",- , 7!

+ %AE ; , + / !0 !B /1

29!!C "3+ , + !B/1

- ! +"'AE+ +!",-< 3! " > , + 7,,!!0

1!0", !/

4!9 , , ", =($6(%. + !

7 > , + !B /1

- !

" /, > , 4!3 +,, +/!749 /!," ,- +

/+!!-4.

1 !0 ", 7,

+ !B /1

- !

, 'AE !0 + > , 4 " + 29!! - ! !

+ 7 +, //!

",- !*+ --,",/ /+!!-43!0+,-+ "

9" , , + !B/1

- ! 3,!,!!0 7 2+ ! ," ! + !9

,! , + !

" !0 !74 C3 ! " , + ,! + 29!! - ! -" + ,7!

3 7 ,"/! 79"7!

+,7!

"7/+, 43 /+" 94 +/!74, + !B/1

29!!C "0 !7 + !B/1

- ! + !B /1

- ! +" ! 00/ 3 1 0!

,",-,B ,! !0 3 7 , 4 " + !B /1

- ! +"

1 ! + 29!! - ! 7," 4 "" ! ,7!

" , $% ? 3, 7 + 779 !0 + 29!! - ! "," !

! /+,/8

, ,7, 9 , +7 + "! !

" / &&7,- ,!0 ,7!

/ !!

/ && + 779 !0 + 29!! - ! 0 !7 ", / 4 !

,", / 4 --,- , ,7, 9 , !

, /!7 ,! 3, + + 9 , !0 !B /1

29!! C " + !,! !0 /+,/ 8

, > , 7 0/

!" / ,!

/ 4 !--,49 ,,7, !!

, /!7 ,! 3, + + 9 , !0 !

+ 7 K--: , !0 3,"

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 28 : ,7!

+779 !029!!- ! !

4!!0 +7/! "--, /+ 9 ,7 4, +4/! ",

/> , /+,/8

, !7!

4 +4/! " , !@!,

3, +!

+ /+,/ 8

, ! !" / ,7, -!!" " ! -- , ,7, /!7 9 ,+7 0/ !!0 +779 29!!- ! +" /+,/8

, +7 !7 0/

+-!!" , 4,

+, 9,, 4 !--, /+9 ,,!

"" ! +, !,- /+,/8

, > , "0!

,- /+9 , $& && "," !

+ 779 !0 + 29!! - ! 7 4 0 !7 ,- +, /+,/ 8

, 0!

+ ! !0 --,- 43+ , ", , 4 9 , ,7, ! !

, /!7 ,! 3, + 9 , !0 !B /1

29!! C " +7 0 !7 --,- 43+ , ", , 4 9 , ,7, ! !

, /!7 ,! 3, + 9 , !0 !B /1

29!! C " !

! + 4 , ", / 4 !

,", / 4,4 /+9 , , 3! "03, +, 79, +/ 0 +779 +29!!- ! !

4!0 +7, , /+9 ,. +4/! "+ 9 "0 !7"!,-!, ,3!0 / && $'

/" 3, + +,. * + -- 97,

/ && "," !

,"0!

4 40!

9 /+ !0 $( +,, 4,

"!!

,",/ / &&, 7,-!

3, +!

4 0 39 /+!0/ &&. + !B /1

- ! !

+/!74, !B/1

29!!C "/! "+ 0," / ,! ! +7 0 !7 "!,- ! 94 0!

/,- + - /!

+4 /! " ! + ! -+ "7- 0!

+ 9 /+ !0 + /!

+ /! ,! / &&,7,-"!0! ,. 0!

. @/ "

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 29 : $F *+ --0

97,

,0/ 39 /+!0

+- /!

+779 !029!!- ! +" 1!

D!/+" !7!0 +7!4!0 !B/1

29!!C " $= +,,!,

7,- 39 /+. 94 0 3! " !

,",/ + / 3 +7 !

9!- !

3 , "" !9/ " !* 49/ !B/1

29!!C "74!

0,"4/ ,! !0!

/ +- /!

, "!!

/ ,4 0!!3 + /!

3 +7 " 3 !

, "" ! 9 / " ! +474+ 0 ,"0 !7"!,-!0!

, 4!0 ," ! %A +/! ,! +/!

D- /!

3 +7. 9!- "3 7 !9/ " !.,9,"94 !0/ !

" , + !

" !0 + !74 C3 ! ". ", +" , 9 3 +

,,/ ",- - " +8,! !- 77.

/+!!-4. 0, !0 + !B /1

- ! ! -, /!77, 7 ! 9 4 9/1 + " , " ,/. 0 > !0 / ,- 94 +, 7. ,- ,7!

,0 " /!

+ ! -+ + !B /1

- ! " + 0, !0 + !B /1

- ! 1 0!

,",-,B ,! !0 3 7 , 4 "

0 !0 /+!!-4 ! !B /1

29!!C " ,7!

", + !0

"7 1 !B/1

29!!C "+"8/ , ,//0!

/!", ,! !0

" 7 1 G N6J I "

"7 1D

"7 0!

" "!7 ,/ + 29!! - ! -"4 3, + + 1!3"- " /! !0 + !B6/1

- ! .

-, ", !3

"7 1G N6/1

2 C*;C9<I,

/ !0"0,-,/#'"

"7 137,4 ", "!7 ,/ //!

",- + !B /1

- ! . + ,/ ,! 0!

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 30 :

,! !0

" 7 1 3 7" 3, +!

/! ,! " , !9@/ -,

,! !0 !B /1

29!! C " ,7 4 3, +"

3 , ,/ ,! ! + /!", ,! !B /1

- ! 3! "

-, ,

"7 1,, !37" !B/1

29!!C "3! "9 7,

!/! , !

"7 1,",//!

",-4.34 !B/1

29!!C "3, +"

3 +,/ ,!0!

,!" +,"

J29!!/!0, 7" +7 % + 3 !!-"-!

, ,!, +, - "+ ,!

+,-

!,",/ 3! /+", 0/ . !9 ,! 43 ", +,,/ 0 !7 +0/ +", , 0/ ", + ,! 0,"90!

+!74C3! "3+ +2+

/+- 3 ", !7 /+ 740 + " 2/ ,!A6 90!

+ +, ,-+ !

, !9 ,! 4 , ,3 !0 + ,! ",

,! / 3 ,

!" /" 94 +

, , + 2+

/+ - 4!07,, 3, + /+7

3! "1!3 +- ,/!, 3, +8 /,0!

! ,!!0 /+", ,/!

+- /!

, !

, /+/ + ,!

+,- !,",/ +43 ,

!" /" ! !," 8 %# + 97,,! 3!/!," ,!0!

+- /!

, 0!

@/ " ) %$ *+ --0

97,

" ,

,7 /+ + ,9 0," 1, !/!," ,! 7,- 7 !0 AAD6 /! " 9 /!," ! 9 + /!," ,! 0!

+ - /!

/! ," , + 2+

/+ - . 3 ! 0

9,0 / ,! " !

,!7 !0 + /!," ,! !3 " /+ !0 +

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 31 : /!

D- /!

/! ," , ,! / !0 + 2+

/+- 2+ 97,

7 +9

,9 !

+/!

D- /!

/+, &'.&("&F !

, %% +, 97,,! 7 9 @/ " 0!

3! !. /!"7!

,7!

+ +0,

4. ,-+ 4!, "!

94*2 ,. +,/! ,!3!

," 94 + ,- !00,/ !

3 , ," 90!

+ ;< !

90!

+ ,9 *+ --/! "" +,, > ,!!03 " +

7 . 0!

.! -+ !9!3" , +!, 90!

+! -+ , 3 !

," 90!

+ ;< " + ,9 * 2 ,: !9@/ ,!,30! ""+ ,!@ ,0,/ ,!0!

!3,- +

, +,!, 0!

+0,

,7, +90!

" +/! ,! 9 ,"90!

+;<!

90!

+ ,9 . !" /! " /!/, 94+ +" 3 !, 03!3 + ,

+, /! ,! 90!

3 3! " 9 " ,- !" !!

, 4!0"" /,- ,"/ !"3, + +7+,3! "9 0,

!" %' 2/!"4."7!

,7!

., +0/ +,/., 3! " 71!",00 / ,033 !// *+ --: 97,,!* + --749 ,-+ +8 ,!

+,- !,",/ +!

D- /!

3! " 9 7! ,4 3!

+ " !7 7! 4 ! -+ !9

,9 +7!3 . +,3! "!

9 9

/ > ,!!03!

7 ,0 / !3+,/+ /! "9! 3 + ,9 // !0 ++ 'A#% + + ,9 . 0!

. ,-+ 4+" !0 AAD6!

,!" !3 "

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 32 :

+- /!

/+ !3

, 0 /?- + +

"//! " ++ , + ",00 34+ ,! A'=A + 3

" ! +9,!0 %!02/+" 6!0

+? +8/ .=&(M!0 +9 ,3+!. F=A + !

+4,"9," =$#! +9,!0 !02/+" !0 ? + 8 / , 9 1 + , !

+,- ! ,",/

,! !

3 ",+! !

70," 0!

4 ! !

, 4 +,- !,",/ , , ,90!

4 ! ,,7!

, ! - ! " !0 90!

-, + ,9 : // /!0 ,! !

+ +7 + !

++ %( 7,- !7 ,!, !9

+ /!

D- /!

/! ," , + 2+

/+ - !

+ &&. , 3! " 71 ! ",00 / + !

,!7 !0 7!0 AAD6!

%AAD6 !3 "/ &&3! ", 4 9 !9 ? - 3, + + 0,",-!0 + ,9 ,

,3 !0 + 9!

0/ + !

,!7 !0 #&E !0 !0 +

!3 " +- /!

3!/!

9, %F +/, / 7 /.3"!!

/!," , ! , !, 0 3, + +"/,,!!0 + ,9 ! +,- ! "!

"!3 +,1, / 4

7, +7

+ ,9 0!

,!7 ) .

! " ## $% %= 2/ ,! #F;,,<;< ;9< !0 + / ," ! 94 * + --

" " )6

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 33 : + 0 2 02

, 34 0 2,

/ 0 2, + + 2 , 0 , / , 2 / 2 + 0 0 + ,2 +

+ 0 0 6 2/ 2 + 0 0 + ,2 +

+ 0 M &A 2/ ,!#F;,,<;<;9< ,,/9 +0/ +,/ +779 +29!!- ! +"!4%AE!0 +> , 4+ , !B /1

29!!C "+, + +!",- !- ","!

-, +7

,-+ ! 7- + 3+! !

9 ,4 + 3+! !0 + 00, !0 !B /1

29!! C "+ 7 !0 + /!9!

,! - ,7!

" + /!9!

,! - . + - "7,,

,! " 7-7 !0 !B/1

29!!C "3 !9, ++"!0 3! *-,-D8/ , / 3, +> !3 .! !9!7, "94 !B/1

- ! " +!

!9!, "94 +29!!- ! !

+ - ! 3 " !!7, + , / /+ ,,7!

++, 7!0 +! "!0, / 334 !9!!

+ !7, !0 + !B /1

- ! " + +, 7 3 !+ / ,-

, / /,0,"7

.!"/,,!/! "9

ITA No. 557 of 2006 : 34 :

194 +! "!0, / !

94 +/!748/ 94 + ,7! /! !0 +, / /!

9,". 0!

. +29!!- ! 7-" +3+!!0 +00, !0 !B/1

29!!C " & +, ,3!0 +7

., ,!

/ 4 !/!," 3+ / ,!#F;,,<;<;9<!0 +/ ,, ,3!0!

,/ ,"94 *2 , &# * + -- ,-+ 4 - " / ,! #F;

< /7 , ! 0!

/ 3, +00/ 0 !7AA%#AA$" 0!

."!!

4 + / 3+,/+

, +7 4 ==%6=& &$ +/! ,!. 0!

. +/!," ,!0!

+- /!

,&&!0 +2+

/+- ,9 8 " / ,!#F!0 +/ ,. 0!

. @/ " &% + > ,! !0 3. , 0!

3 " -,

D ",0 !" D+ //!

",-4",7,"9 3, +!!

" !/!

(S.J.VAZIFDAR) ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE (G.S.SANDHAWALIA) JUDGE 15th May, 2015 Whether to be referred to the reporter or not. √ Yes No.