← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/20941/2011dismissed

Ashish Someshwar Murakar v. Vijay Bank And ORS

2016-01-11Mr. Justice Satpal9 pages

  



 ! "#$# % # &# # # # % #

 

 %' ( )*

+"'

,'-./ #*0*01 *03','4' 

*,* 56'-'$'

4'

* 

* 

  !"#$%#&'"!'#('!!

+ 11 '0'

'.#( )'

 54'*1 80.#( )' 

* !'#('!!

)$  0'

   0*  3  7

 *   *  (' #

 '

(;#

 7'** <-

30 <-*

0'

(*7

(30(, 0*7

    *  )

(  0'  7

  '77 (   * 

'4 8  1)' 30

= 56'-' $'

4 

 3'*  * (  '

(  '77 ( '8' *  1)0 (, '* )' -( '77

 (' (>?>.#

=#*7 0* @, *.0 3'*'

*

2  6 ' 8

') .0'

(8'0,7/><,0* @, * )0'

  7')   7 * 8  3'*  (

(   .  7

 4 ( 30

## 

#** )' * 21 7 2< .>

)   ?  '*  '

  #** )'  '4 8  :

), .

' '*% )1' *#** )' *30$'

4 2

2< ? #,8,*.

*,<* @,

-3 4 (30A*10'2 '

!  27'

-B2 ( '*! ()  2"'

'- '-C'

'*'4 8) 30A* D#,

($,*

**1 ,

*B2 (% 2< C ;

'   6

(  %

'  $'

4  '*  '

 1)'  "'

,'-/'

(0** 3'*)

2 (30 %

'$'

4( 2 (' (;>>

.

0** )

'*1

.'4 8  1)' 30

.0  0 *'(6 <'%

'$'

4#*7 '77

 (' (>?>**, (<-

.7

(*3

'*   2  0  ('   6

8.  30)0  2'-  <

(  <-  0

=$'

4 *(*)

 '7

:)

( 8'

- '5( )),'(' (C??#

 =**, (<-

'() '% 7,-

''

*3'*( )(

(,) 7

( 23 - '* *:2

0* )'*

*  30  0'(  3 4 (  30  7,<)  *   <'

4*A )' *,

*

=$'

4)

2 * * *2' *,'

*.( '* 30 2' 2

( 7''/

37

*)

(0' '2''( 2'

.*

  3'* 

  )

2 ( 

 3'*  (

(  7 @,* *  4

-'

 ' 3'

.  2 <  70

.     30    7  '

'

' 3'

.'((

'C *7  ' 3'

)

;

3'*

' 3 4

*0 3'*'77 ( 17 )'* ) '4 8.( *7 ) 22, )'

(' (/ '

8

') ***7 ))'-2

( 0*) 22, )'

0''4 8 **0 ,(< :),* -,* ( 2'4 7 (,)* $'

4'

(<,*

**(

'

 3 4 ' (    2'4 8 

  3'*  '

*  (   2  8

' ) .  0'

(8'0    $'

)0  ) .  $'

4  '  '''  ,

 

  ; (  (' (   #

 =

3'*'**8

('-7 8

'<'

4 8(, 0'

2'4 8'

(0 3'*' (-*,<6 0''**2

<-

;'0 *'

( ) ,*

30

  *<*3 '*

)   

(    0

  3'* 

(  

*:2

0*(  (' (CC#

 =

E** *3 (*7

(30( 27,8

('  #

 =

 8 ( 0'  0*  7

(,

3'*

*'*') - C





-'8, *0' 7

'

4

**7 ) *:

0*  '*  7  #

 =    ) ,( 

  0'  <

(*:2

0* 2/> 0 (' 30

$'

4

*7 7 ,'  8'-<-

(  7

(  *,<* @,

-     *:  2

0*  ')0 

 3

))'*

* / !,0 2 .  7

  3'*   ) (    3 4  '*  '



'*) 30 '*.0 *''4 817 )'* 

*,)0'*,'

.'77'*'  0* 3 4'

(7 

*'*') - '6 <0 3'*

)

*'

*2'

 *-, 6,* *'* *,<2 ( 0''*7 )),'

; C.0 *'

))7 (, 7 ( ( '77 8'17 )'*) '

'*  )   )' -  0  * 

 '(0

   *,)0 7 (,  >   *  '8, (  0'  

 

  =% 7,- 

' '

 3'* 

0   )

    '

*

  

'''$'

)0'*'

'$'

4 8) 

3'*0 )

)0'

)'( 7

 217 )'*) 

' $'

4 8)  B



*,<2*0'0

$ '(    % *    

=$'

4  0'*  ( 8' (  *  7 8'( 8'77

.'

* '

2 '

 '

'8 8% .

*

)

 )),2*'

*7'- (0'0*37

(*2** ?

  )

'.  

(  )     

  30

, *'('8,2

*. * )',* '

(/ '77

  (' (  >?>    0

 

*    1

'

='4 8 *,<20'

=<'

4'*(*)

)'

7

(<-',0 7 

-

*7,' (7 3 - '*

*'*  8,'

C 56'-'$'

4 *1 8,'

*.

?  ) #

 .**,<2 (0'0 *'()),' 0'*  <

 **, (  *,<* @,

-  1,)0  <

  0'( 

  <

 4'

(7

3'*' '(-, '77'*'7 .0 .0 3 ,(<

(<-0  2*'

(

0*'77

  

*2'(  )',* / '77

 *,<20'0 $'

4*3 30 *80 ' '

-(, *

 30)02'-)

*( 02)

'

$'

4'*

0'*  0  80   *A'

*

    '

-    * $'

)0 *A *(

( 8,7

:8

)  @,

  **7 ))'-*,<2 (0')'(

3'*

)0'

3'*. ')'*4

/ :),* - 4 

 2'4 8  *(  (  #

/ 

  3'* '(* )

' :),* -

2'4 83 4<,*0*  3'* 

   (  *'*') -  '*  *  '77'

   #

 ?5' ,* *.#

*   3 **,

    27  0*  7  <,  0  3'* 

27

  #  ' 8'

*    2''( *  '8' *  * 

*

'

(;.30 '

<'

4' (

8  )'

(<'* ** )

'-.**,<2 (0'

0'*( < ' -)

' (' ,* *'(( ** 02 < 8 8'< ,27

 0*3 4 

' 80 '(

 7' *'

(8 0 ,800  .(

 ('

-8 (30)0)'*

<-0* ,',* ;'

( '77

 #

 =  '('*, +=

/ F; & ,3<

7

 '7 3 - '*  20 (' - ,6 $'

4'

(- ,3<

*( ( )

2'

 * .*,<6 ) - , *'*') -7 .)

(,)'

(*'*') -   2  0 ) #,0  *  '< ,  - ,  )0'')   '

*  %,

.- ,* *)'

2 ' (<-8 8

2

0E*

) 7'-2

2

0E* ,2

*  ,0

0 $'

42'-.

. *(*)

(- ,7

<-,0

:)

( 8

- '- ,( *   '

$'

4''

-2 (, 7

. ),(

(7

.'

-.

,*0'8 ;2

0E*

)  $'

4 7'- 

 

) ( 0*  *    '((

   )

(

*7,' (

4 0* G ;

8,'

 C    0  56'-'  $'

4  ) E*  1

8,'

*.?( ' 830'77

.7

.)

2'

.

7

.*

-'

2 '



* 8'(

7 (,) (  , ('- '(*'*, += C    #   ( )-  '77 (    ", '

'( *0'<

7

 '7 3 - '*  #

$'

47 ('*'

",

'( *0'<

7



- ' ;# '77 '

- 8'( *0'<

7

 *,)07 ('*2'-< ( )( (<-0 $'

4 ( (0'0 

#,0 -2'- )'* - . (,)

(*7

307

G 

   )),'A) 22, )'

 (' (  C??

> #

 =   *   

 ''  

 

  * ,< (-8

(<-)

(

0*'77

'*3 '* 8,'

* 5(  2 (' ( C??.  (,)

(  0'*  <

2 (    )'*   *  30  0'(  ' '(- 4 ( 7,<)* <'

4*A )' *,

*<'*



'7  <'

4(

)

*, '2'

('  (,)

( )'* '0

*' '(- '77 (( *0 7 '

(,)0 )'

( )

2'

  0

E*  *

:7-   *:

0* 

 6 8  0  <'

4    *  '77'

  0'  7

  3'* ' ,2 ,* ,  * 27 0*3 4'

(,)<,

*,)027

3'* C 

  

(  )   

  0'

3 )

2 (30%

'$'

4.0 .

')



=$'

4

)

2 80** * 8'.

*, ')) 7'<  *)

2'

30%

'$'

4(

0' '

' 8300 )

 *- 0'

(.

0 )'



 02 ', 2')  )

2'

 30  

 

  .  30)0  0'* 

)

30'*

30%

'$'

4'

(*'(2 (-'* 7''

- /

@,'-( ( 2 *0 '8,2

0'7

3'* ) 3 4

* 

'*) 30 '*0 *'

'4 8 17 )'*  ) .  0 .  '77'*'    0*  3 4  '

*',-*<

, 20  (0'0 3'* 4 8

* 1

'4 8

3'* 2

?

0*7

7 5( #

 =.(' (>>0

3'*  (,-  '77* (    0*  7  < 8  ,   7'    * ))'-2

(0'7

3'*

,* :),* -30 (, 2'4 8 ' ,*7 (,)* <'

4

3'*'(*

27 0*7 <-0 0 '

 $'

)0<,0

((

7'-0

'**8

(2'4 8(, *#8,2

0'

 

    3'* 

  )

    '

*

2' *, *,<*'

' ('*0 *

*,)07 '( 8 0* 

0 '

-*,)0 ,

0'*<

< ,80 2-

)  > *

-'8, (0') ' *3)0 

'*  )'(  *  7 *)< (    )),'  ;    C #*   0

 

  '77 (     )0'

  0*  )'( .  0 .

'

*  802 $'

)0 ' ''' 2 8

') ' 0'

(8'0'

('**8 8

'<'

4 8(, *.*27 (  , 3''

(    )

'-.  ( ),2

* 

  (  (

 )'

-)0'

 )'(

'77 '*0'*,)0 ' 2

*0'

'*

-30' 3 )'2 ,'8 0*

7  ').* (

0'*,)

, -3'* '

 27 0*7 *

-30

((

) ,7 2'4.0'0** *3 (*7

(30 (,

 ? *'*  (7 *

'30'0 *3  30 *80* (*7

300 * '

 )'*

0*  7  * 

   (  *'*') -  (, 8  0 (  7

 

  0'* 

  * (  80    )

2'

  



* 1

'4 830

 



*, '<  , - 8'- 2- 27,8

 7

*.')) ( 8-.(*2** !*+( "'

,'-./  $,-.

*