High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12785/2014disposed of

Shamsher Singh And ANR v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2015-03-23Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh3 pages

!"#"$%&& '( )#( *'"$+( $, $( * ""$ *# - *#.# '

*/ $ $,( *# #0$, $#

'% 1*""$

( 2,3!

*( 0 ""$ *# 1#

4"5 1$+ 2 0./,3!

$ * 42 */ $ 1* ( 2,3!

** #0$, $# $, !

" $ ("# 0 ""$ "4 , .$, * *"!4 # 67 ( $#"."$$,"

2( 0 ""$ *#( 3 0* / ,*"##.

$! 8*""$ ( $ .* ! *"* *"*9.

#("$+( $""!

"$#, ,:

;$$ <.* = >"##. ,.$, *' !"$ ( ?

$,!9."#""$!2 :

;"$#(*@( !A>2, ,

&;$$ <.* =>.$, *' !"$6 ( ! $,( *,, ,

;$$ <.* =>3", 8("!(( $,( 0 ""$ *#( #B $ !9."* , .*( *2 0* / *( #B $ ) , ,"* !"$+( 3 *$) $ */ $ 4484 0# ( # ", $""!

"$# $,( *,.$, *' !"$ ;>( "+(

"* )0 $# "$ $,* $#0 * $!/"$?

$,!9."#""$2 ( B"4"

# 4 ) $!2 &;( * "$ ** ** , #@ &!A>

# 0 * ( 3 *) $# ) , "$ ( 8*" 0 ""$2 ( 0 ""$ *# * 8$ *# "$ 0## ##"$ ( 4 $, ) #.*"$+ 66 #9.

* / *,#( < $:7:#( * #!)0*"#"$+"$5( #* 67:72 ,B # #".

,8"("$( * 3 $. #

"#( ' (2 C "( 4 '

*/ $ "##. , $""!

"$ , , :

;$$ <.* = > .$, * ' !"$ ( ! * !9."*"$+ :

!* #4 $,"$!4.,"$+( 4 $,( 0 ""$ *#*( 0.*0# 2 " ."4"D "$ $, , 3 40) $ * * #", $"

42 !)) *!"

4 "$#"."$ 42' !*2C "( 4 ""$ *"4 ,("#BE !"$#.$, * ' !"$ = ( ! $ :

;$$ <.* => ( * *2 $""!

"$, ,

&;$$ <.* =>.$, *' !"$6( !

#"##. , $,( *,8 #0 ## ,$

;$$ <.* =6> *"##.

$! $""!

"$.$, *' !"$6( !2( * #0$, $# * 4 # ,( 4 $,) #.*"$+ !* # ,E ! $( 4 $,( 0 ""$ *#B.( "*4 $,( ,$B $* 4 # , $! 2( 0* # $8*"

0 ""$!!*,"$+( 0 ""$ *#2( !9."#""$0*! ,"$+#( 0# ,"$3" 8' !"$ ;>( &! $! 2( 0* # $8*"

0 ""$ & ?

*$ , !.$# 4 * ( 0 ""$ *# #.B)" , ( ( 0 ""$ *# * "$0(/#"!

40## ##"$( (.# #"$,"#0. !)0 $# "$( #$B $0 ",( )8 #!4 ") ,( "$#.!( !"*!.)# $! #2"$3" 8' !"$ ;>( &!2( $""!

"$# .$, *' !"$# $,6( !( ,4 0# ,8 #.*( *#.B)" , ( #"$! $, ) $,$"! !4 ")"$+( * 4" #!4 ") ,"$* #0 ! 0# $""!

"$#( #B $"4 ,8"(( * #0$, $#2 4"B */B +* $ , ( 0 ""$ *# "4 , "4 , $, !)0* ( $#"3 * 0* # $ "$ B * ( 00*0*"

.(*"/ B/ "$!*0* "$+ (

# +*" 3 $! #* "# ,"$( 0* # $8*"0 ""$2(8 3 *2,"* !"$B "##. , ( .(*"/ !$! *$ , , !", ( * 0* # $ "$ <0 ,"".#4/"$ ") B.$,) $$ *"$ !!*, $! 8"(4 8

*( *"$+4 *$ ,!.$# 4*( 0 *" #20 *.#"$+( 0* # $0 ""$ $,8"(. <0* ##"$+ $/0"$"$$( ) *"#( !

# 2 8 ,"#0# ( 0* # $ 0 ""$ B/ +* $"$+ 4"B */ ( 0 ""$ *#"4 , "4 , $,!)0* ( $#"3 * 0* # $ "$* "#"$+ ( 04 # #* "# ,"$( 0* # $8*"0 ""$B * ( 00*0*"

.(*"/"#,"* ! ,( "$( 3 $ * 0* # $ "$B "$+"4 ,B/ ( 0 ""$ *#8"("$ 0 *",8)$(#*), /2( # ) #( B , !", ,"$ !!*, $! 8"(4 8B/0 ##"$+ #0 5"$+*, *

* *,"$+ $00*.$"/( *"$+( )8"("$ 0 *",.* )$(#*)( , * ! "0* 0* # $ "$( 0 ""$ *##( B $"4 ,4 , $/ 3", $! #.B# $"

( "*!4 ")B * ( !$! *$ , .(*"/"44( ) *"#, !", ,B/( # ", .(*"/2 # .#9.#( 44B ) "$ "$ ,B/( 0 *" # $ !

% &' ()*+ #" $!

% +B# &'