High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/1210/2015dismissed

Raman Khangura v. Board Of Directors Of Punjab & Sind Bank ORS

2015-04-20Mr. Justice Satpal,Mr. Justice S.S. Saron13 pages

!"#"

$"%"

"" "

$ "

$& $ '(

)"*+ (&,& -.& /.0&

(0( # &3 $ ' (+ 0 4&5& 36 3#& 7& ( 1 (*

(

) 6.&.

8(! 30,*&&+"3 '& +

6. && &7+"3 '& + (*

( 9 6.&/.&

+"3 '& + (*

: 6. 607& 0*&+ "33 + +.& 3/&.+ (*

; .

( '&*&* (,&<5 &

403/,

(= (

= 9 .

403/,

035 3 $/ (= .&

( 35< .

$ 5 < "** & & (.

"** & &?

@:"

A0 :& 3&( 3& 3: "

A0 *&(( $ 5 <50 &+.& 3/&. (.

&?8.

5<.

3 .(3&8&(3 ' 3 3& 3 , 8.

7 &'& 3

,( & 3& 3;B:*&(( $(' &/(& + 0

: 6 '0C&

(0'

'&"(( (&

6 '0< ( "'+ (.

"'? .

'.&

/ ( &(

$('&/(&

;B:"

( & , /&/

& &3& D( &4 (' E, 3 .& / , /&/ 3 .

:9 (F0& <&3( 0(

9B+6 ' @G+.& 3/&.+ & 0 7.

&4 (' E, 3+ .

* '*& 5 + 8.'. 6. !&(5 6 /.-.& /0&+.

.0(5&

+& , ,5 0 4&5 E /(& "(( ,5<+ ( .

& &/ / $ ' & /0&& + && 3 3

( 0 &''

, .& (H' (6 & *&<.

&, &(* ,( &/

7((0 3&

9 "'

7+ .

& +

/( 0

: "' "

8&( *&((

;B:+ 3 .(3&+ .& 3/&.+ &7

< F0 (

5< &7

((&< ( *( '03 /.

5 &7

'7( (&3* ,( (

'.&

/( 3 0

9 "'5 &5< /& &**'&

,*& 3 0

B "' .

& *&(( 3 &

99"

A0 9/& /& (&0(F0 &( 3

*&< .

30 &, 8.

.& (0**< * (&

&''

(5<.

(&3 *&(( &+ 8&( '.&

/ 3 5< 8&< & &** & 5 "** & & 5< .

7 60'. &** & 8&( '3

@:+8.

8&( 5( 3.&.

( ( 8 / *&< .

30 &,

' (+++@9;9*+,&<3 8. &* 8 8

7( , 3& & 3.&.

7+8 035 &5 <

8. .

30 &, &''

3& 8. &8 (+ & +.

$('&/(& +.&(*&(( 3.

;B: 6 &**'&

B "'8&(*

&+.

7 3& &**'&

7 /3

.(3&& 3 '0 /.

( '0 3 &(( ( 60'. &**'&

8&(+ G&&+ ((

/ 3.&.

.(3&(

&*&<

/(5 && 3.

'& /

.(3& ,*

3.&.

3 &< /&''(&.

3 .(3& '

&0.

( .& A*

A0( .

5( 3&(0 )G I1.

.(3& ( 3 &< (&, 30 A&

0( &(

(+8&(.

30< .(3& 3 &** *& ,& &( 8 &( 30 ( &(((& (*

#& 7 50 .&( 5

(

& 3< .& .

(&, .(3&8.

( &3 .

* /.

7(( 30/ &' (8. A&

0( &(

(8.'.& .

*0 &0 (.

( 7&

< '

( (0

50*& /0& <5 3<

,< 3&8.

& '0 /.

30 ( / /.

0 3(8.'. & ('7<& 3('& 3+ ,& ( &, 3&

,< 50 .

(

, , ( 3 ( ( ( &3 &/ ( < 5 '&0( 8 5&'7(.

3 &<

*& *&'0& .(3& &/& (8.

, 0,5 &'

,*& (& &'. / .( 0+(8&&/ & &( .

( .( 0 & '

3+ .

(* "'&(8 &(.

& (&,

,&3 "'( (* &7(.&.( 0.&(&,* 3 &8. (0'.<* &''&3 &<

( 0.

+ /. 403/,

*&((

?5 /. 0 6, 6,&& -0,& 6& 0 4&5 BH@ 9 ( (0'

F0& 40(3'

.( 0 ((0& (0'.

( .

+ /. &5 403/,

+ .

.(3& ( 3 ' 3 &** *& &(((& "0.

( 3'

7&((0'

(.& & &3<

5<.

$('&/(&

&' & .

* &3 /( (*

(D&**'& 8.

8 0.

,* 3< * '

.(3&& '

&0.

(.& A* 3.

A0(8.'. .&

8 5 &

3 &< .& 3(

'0 '

(.&(0.

5( 3.&

.& 3 (3 + #& 7 ( < / .&3 *05' ,

< 8.

.& 3 (3 8. 8.

, .

( & ( &((( ,&7 / < 30 ( ( &.

&< /.

(&,

A J &0.

3.&.

* ,((

, .

$(' &/(& (

,& 3& < &0.

0 "' &7 *.<('&*

'0 3&(( 3.&(

< F0 38.

3 &0 ( (( ' & &8& * 5 , 7 &7

&&80 ,&

,(0'.3 &0 .

&3 ' 3.

.(3&

'0 (*&(( $('&/(& 8. 3&<(

3& &**'&

::"

A0 H '& .

3& 3 : *&(( & @:+.

&*&(( 3& +

' /.

& '& (( &03 '

3 .(3&+ $ *0< ,,((

& 6 .

5 5& 0 8&(

.& 5

,*0 0( & 3 &/& ( .

&',

&8 *&< / .& 3( 3 &0 (.

78&(/& 35 <

3 5 '

0 '

,* 3(

( *&(( & .

7 & 3&'

,**

9:: :5 .( 0+8.'.((&

/ :H 8

+ 8&( (& 3 .& .

.&(

,&7 / &( '

,,,

( .& .

8(.

( /0&C &( 8&(

< 8 .

.& .( 0 3 ' ,& & (&0( F0 (* ' ( '0 3 &(( (

8&( ,&3 '

&' .

7 /&3 /0&C&

8&( * 0 .& & (0, (+B9+@@+:H;9*( 0(& /&(

9& 3& &,

(;+B++ ( F0 5 3 ( 3 ,, 3& < /0&C &''

( &( 0 .& .

7 .&3 &< 3.

(

@ $ 5( 7 & 3 '& (0

( "'+ @@9 (.

<"'?(&( 0.& ,( 5< .

/( 0

B "'

99K.

&''

(8 (0**

:99& 99#0.

&, 8&(

3 (

& &*(

. .

+ & &** & 8&( 7 5 "** & & ( &( 0 .& .

( ,& 5 E 7"3&&+ 3 '

*&< .

30 &, 6 0.

+ & 0(& &

9:8 03(.

8 .& .

7 .&( (0** '

,* (&

&''

( +.

,& 8&(*00*5 E 7"3&&

9:+ 50.

3 (& <&,

,& '

035 35 E 7"3&&(&( 0.&.

0 (& .

/( 8&( .

A< /&

. 0/.6.

7&6 /.

5&(( &( &/

3& 9H+ 8.'. ( &( 3 / 3 ( &( * &3 3 .& .

.&(

,&3 <

&( 3

3 &**'&

3 0

B "' *

/ 5 50 &

&0&

& <*& 503 /((&3 ''0*&

(&, 8&( ' ''0* 3 .

.&( 3 & '

&((

(&7

5<.

7 8

.& .

&3 &

*& (&(

/.+ 503

3& <,

( &+ 8 ,&<

.& .

& ( 0( 50 ,('. 0( & /&

( 3 &/& ( .

(3 / '

"** & &5<.

+ G&&+* 0.&.

?(*& &/& 3&.

& 3.

,& &/& 3&.

G G&8 (3 / '

&+ 8 5 ( .0(+ .

( & ' & '

' ( & (3 / '

03 .& '0( 3 .,( ,& & .

< (

** 0 < + 30 '

0( &/0,

(+ &

* (( & < & /&

3&/& (.

(3 /'

"** & & &

.&( .

<&/0 3.& "** & & 8&( ( C & &** & 7 &/& ( & , *&(( & .

"** & & '

03 & 8 .

&** & & 3 ( &(3 *&(( &+ 50 '

((0 < 3

( 50 & <*

/( &*&'0&,&

60.

&.&(

40(3'

((0 <3

$(' &/(& 3D .(3& '(

: "'& 3.&.

35< $(' &/(&

;B: ( & AG*& 8.

0 / /& <

& 3.0(+ & (.

* '*

&0& 40('

( &( &/0 3 .& .

( &3< & 8 / *&<.

&, 0,

.(?, 3.&.

*&<.

&, 8. 0,

.(&'7(5

&G3 .

9 "'8&(((0

& , .& 9 ,

.(+ .

.&(

3 ( 3 & < &, .

50 &.&3 &</& 3,

*&<.

99 .

"** & &+ 8. *&(( 3& @:+.&3&( /& 3,

,&7 *&<,

0(& /30 (

.( 0+.

8 /

((

/0&C 8&(

3 3& 9 #0 (

& ,* .&( 5

,&3 3 ( & < &, .0( .

8 3( & 3 &'

( 3

,&'. &( ,0'. &(

30 /.

&(, .& 8 < &(+

&( /

<.&(

3 ( 3&.

0/..

& 0(& /&, ((& (+B9+@@+:H;9* &(

9 0 8.'. & &, (;+B++DG ( F0 5 3 ( 3 ,, 3& < /0&C (.

8(.&.

.& (.

( &3<& 38 / 3 (.

&, 0,

.(? , +(& & ,* /& , 8.

0.& /& <

*&< &, .

8&( &< 0.0 8&3( .

,,,

+( &(

&5 &, '

03.&

3 ( 3 & .

.( .

+ 8 3 .& .

/0&C &''

(

&' 30*

&** & "** & &(

''0,('5 35<& < ,&

(* ' '( 40(3'

5<.

"** & 50 & ,( 6

H "'"

&** &('

( 3 & .

( (& .

+ .

"** & 50 &'& *&((&(0'. (&(.

03*&(( ,(

B "'.

"** & &( '.&.

, &&, ( & 8 ,& *&< &**'&

B "' 3

3.&(0'. '&

5 (&3 40( 3 < ,&

3 .& .

"** & & 8&( 40( 3 ((0 /3

( 7

&, 8.

& &** & 7 &/& (.

, &

6& 3&3.& 3#& 7

5 -0,&+9@6;+ 60* 0 .

3 .& .

& .

, 3( &7

( '0 3 &(( ( .

( 8 03 5 8.

'0 3 ' 3 / ( .

F0(

0 0 H &5(

& < ((& .

3(0&

(8.

'0 ' 3 ,

( 8. ((& , .

5 &

0 H & 3 (0'.

0&<K .

( '0 3 ' 3 ( &7 0( , '.& (,* 3 30

: "' .3 (0&

( 8.

( '0 3 ' 3 &** &'.

( .

&/(& '

3 3 '< 0

: "'+ 8.

&/(& ( ('0 C &**'&

&(* 3 3 6

: &

(&( 3+ &0.

C & (05 3 & '

&(( ( .

& A&' , .

403/,

03 &3&(0 )G I9; .0(+.

85 .

, 3( '0 3' 3 &7

'0 3&(( ()G 9;.

(, 38 035 8.

'0 3' 3 / ( .

F0(

0 H& 3 8.

8. & < ((& .& '&( + .

&0.

&7 ( *(&((*0& 30 0 H

8&3( &7

& (& '0 3&(( ( &C &, (.&& '&, '0 3' 3 9; .

(

3 (0&

8 &( 8.

( '0 ' 3 ,

( 8. ((& , .

5 &

0 0 H ( /

.& '&( .

8 &7 0( , '.& (, * 3 3 0

: "' C ,&7 / &**'&

&/(& .

&/(& 8 ('0 C &**'&

&( * 3 3 6

:+ &

(&( 3+ &** & '

(05 3 & ., &( 3 30

:G" &7

&(( 3 3 '0,

( .& *0* &/(& ,&< &0.

C '

0( (0'. '

&( ,&< 5

((&< "

( &7

&(( ( & '0,

(85 8&3 '0 3' 3

9;9 .3(0&

'0 ' 3 &** &'.

( .

&/(& '

3 3 '< 0

: "'.

&/(& 8.

& +('0 C &**'&

&(* 3 3 6

:+& 3.

(&( 3+ &0.

C &(05 3 & '

&(( 33 '0,

(& 3 8&3.

, '0 3' 3 &( '&0( 9;&5 9;: < .

(0&

(&5 +&

( .& ( '0 3 ' 3 + .

(05( F0

(* ' 3 * (

0 H '

+ &0&

3(& '0 3&(( (+& (05( F0

0 ( , .

6 '0< (

0 (+ + (.&&**<J *&&, ' "' ( .& .

( '0 3 ' 3 (.

03.&

'0 3 &(( ( &'& ((& &C ( 30 ( &'. (&3 ' &( .

3 6& 3&3 .& 3 #& 7?( '&( (0*&+ .

& .

, 3(

'&( + .

7 .&( 3 &'

9 "'8.'.&'

(3(*0 (0 <5<8&< & &**'&

B "'5 &

(&3&'

7.&(&/. &7 0( 6

: "'&(.

3 6& 3&3.& 3#& 7?('&( (0*&

/( 5 & & .

(& /0&& &

/+& 3.&.

(

, *

+ .

7 .&( & /. &7

0 0( &#& 7.&(&/. &7

+8.

&+.

, &'+.

&*&(( 3& 3 /.

.(3& / ' 35<$('&/(& ( (0** .

(&0 /. ( /8..

7& 3.

&(05G( *05'*0* &C *05',

< +.

* &

8.'.&3& (.

&/ *05' ( .&( &''

* 3.

03&7 &'

&/& (.

3D /0&& 0

: "'

/(0

9: "'&

/&.

/0&& 5 &.

"' '( ( .

40(3'

(* ' , &(0 (05G(

: 6

9+ 5<.

'0 ' 3

( '0<"

$(' &/(&

: "'+'& '.&

/ 35 50 & /. 403/,

?5 60* 0 -& &<&&E&'.& 36&'.3 2(6& &.&&(.&+6 BH+&( * 35<.( 0 D( 0 4&5.

,'& 30( $('&/(& G'0,G$ *0< ,,((

+E03.& &+

H : 3 '3

H: .

+ .

& 8 .& 40(3'

*&(( ( 3 .(3& /

' *&(( $(' &/(& &( &7

: "'(

, &(0 ( (* ' &/0,

.& .

& '&

& * & .& &#&

/(0

"'+8 3.&.

403/,

( 30*

5< &

(0'. &(

3& &&'.& 0*&+ " @B 6 HK &/& & .&//& & 0 '*& * &

& 0,5&+"@B:6@K# &0&,

3&+ "@@:6BBK"

*+"699K"5.&< -0,& & < 6& #.&+ " @@B & & ;K -(.

& - 3& &. .

(+ " ; -& &&7& K .& & $8&7& &(&3+ " B &4&(.& @K 6

E&7(., 30'( 6& #& 7 3&+ " B &3&( :H+ $

& #& 7 6. 6..

&/&7 6&.&7& #& 7 E3+ " H 04&& & 3 0'.(

((& 6 0. E3+ #& /&

7 3&+ " H -& &&7&:+3

<8&<&3& &/0,

&( &

+8 3.&.

403/,

0& <&**'&

, 3&( .

8(0'. 403/,

( & & < ((0 ( &( 3

( / #

'. 403/,

04&& /. 0 $

& #& 7?('&( +3 &(8..

&( '0 3&(( 8&(.

3.&.

'0 3' 3 '&

5 3 '3 35< & 0

B "' + 8 403/,

.( 0 D( 0 4&5 .

,'& 30( (? '&( (0*&+.

/.(

&( '0 3&(( & &( F0 A&,

B "' 403/,

&4&(.& /. 0 .& &?('&( (0*&3 &(8..

/.( '

*&'

(& *&

< & + .

((0 3 (&3 '&( ( 3

403/,

E&7(., 30'(?'&( (0*& (

8. .

403/,

.( 0 D( 0 4&5 .

,'& 30( (?'&( (0*& " $(

'. 403/,

# ,5&< /. 0 3 &( !& #.&& 6< ' E3 6#+ 9 &.&&(.& E&8 !

0 & HB+ .

3 .& .

(

: "'+ 3

& < &3403'& < * (( & + .

* '* &0&40('

&&' 3.

35< $('&/(& ( 3 &(((& 0/.5<.

'0 ' 3 ( &''

3& 8.&8

'0< (( &.

** 3 &80&0.

(5<

G&3403'& <* (( 0 5( 3&(0 )G I1111.

(&3 * (

(

(0 .& .

/( 30

9 "'& '& ( /'& 0'

(

,*& 403'&* (( 8 7&(3

<&3403'& ((& 3&((0'.+.

* '* &0&40('

&&' 3 8 5( &

(5<.

60* 0 *&&; (3 '(

D(& ('

3&(0*&+&5 (3(* 30 &80<

&''

3& 8. .

(

"'+ .

$ 5(

<50 &(

*0.

' '75&'75< ( (&0( F0 .

+ '&

5 (&3 .&

(&7

(& +.

/.(

5 / .

3(*0 &3403'& 3 0*

( &0.

( '

&7 /*

83 &

G&3403'& < * (( 0

:+ 8 03 5

0( (&< .& .

/.( 8 03 (& & 38.

0&3403'&

J &/

8. .

& (&3 8 # ,5&< /. 0 &( 3 .& &'+ .

"** & & ((0 3

( 7 &'

&( *&< .

30 &, ( .

& + .

$(' &/(& *&(( ,*0/

8&(

5< & (0*( 8.

(0'. 8&(*&(( 3.

$('&/(& (

((0

& /.

/(0

: "'+50,&<'.

((0 &

&(.

,(#0 &0 ((0

/(&(.

35<.

# ,5&< /. 0 &( .

$(' &/(& (

'( &3403'& <* ((.

/(0

: "'+ '

5 '.&

/ 3 &(

.& & (.

8 '&0(

8&(

( 3( &( '

,*<8..

* '* &0& 40('

&( 3 .&

( & < &,5/0< 40(3'

& ((0 3

( $(' &/(& .(3&K .( 0+ '( ( 40(3'

"' ; &38."' B

+'& ((0 3

( $(' &/(& / ' (&0 (

( & .

(& 7

+ .

'& * & &(

5 &/ 3 &<.

*05',

.&( 403/,

(0** * & .& .

*&(( & ( &

0< 3.&5

403/,

('& A

&'(

'&( +8.

&.&(*&(( 3&

B "' / ' 35< $('&/(&

: "' &

3 '

.&(

403/,

( (0** &/0,

.&.

.&(&/. 40(3'

.( 0&.

.& &&.

3< &/& ( .

*&(( & 60'. 403/,

( &

& &(

.&8 .& .

&3.

&/0,

(&(

(&.

.& /&

& & 3< 8 &5 + 8 3

3 & < ,

(&, (3(,(( 3

"*+ 3(