M/S Surya Overseas Through Authorized Proprietor v. Indiabulls Housing Finance Ltd And ORS





             


 

 !"

#$% &'

(%)*+*&,

--






  







 









 
!

"




























  










!

 ./ !- 0 

 0-   
#$

%&" 
'

%   (

) 


 "

%  


"


 
%  
*
"



  

+

%  



" ,
%  
*
  
-.

/





00000

 0- 2 - 3#4"

. 1"


"

 
 


"

2 
  
3434/3.5
2"

6
"

 
*


6
"

 $

 "
 
 
//718
*
"

!

 
%" 
%  .9:;
" 
6


, 
6
"

 ,  
!&
% 
76 
 
 8
  
1 ,
1

 



/  * 
"

* 

" 
"


*


  
6 * "

 ,  
!&
% 
76 
 
 8
  
1 ,
1

 


" 

" 
6  
 
*
.

/< .< 9<9$

 
=
.>?
 
,

 

  

 
  
>.3./3.>

6

/

  

.44


, 
*
.

;/ 3>;$
"

2 


 
" 
 

 
" 
"

2

6

 

*


" 


,
*
.

;< ;;5$
2 



 
" 



"

"


2 
* 

)
"

6  

343:/3.4


,
*
5 ;> ;9;;9
2 
   
2 
*


" 



 
*
2
@"


, 
 
*
"

 
,

2"
 
=
/4?
 
,

,  
*
, 

" "  , 

> @"

  
*



  
6 *
 ,  
!&
% 
76 
 
 8
  
6) 
 
" 


 
 , 
" 
6  
"

 


A 6

,



@"

*

 " 


"

6


 " 
   

 
"

 ,
B

*
"

 

, 

"









 *


*  
*
   



) 
2 
  & 
 
 
//17:8
*
"

!

 
%" 
% 
.9:;

  
*

"

 ,  
!&
% 
76 
 
 8
, 
"

  
6
 

 #$

   

         



                   

       





  

 

         

    !    "   

       

      

        

 

     

  #   

      #  $

 

>

               

    # 

       !  

  #

   



  %

&  '()

 #

  

 

 

 

  

    

 ! #  * $         



     +,, 

      

#      !   

 #  #     

    

  !     %-( 

&  + # 


 !  .

    !  %#   

    

 (       

   

# /01% 

/

0

 (

 

 





          !

     ',  

         #  2
3 !   

2$

/01 





   

 -     

    /01     

         !  

#



    

   

         

   !  

     45    6     # 7 -

 !  

 #

 

  %  

  ( 

4

      45 $   # 8    

  

 /01             

     !       

   45. $       

&  +  # 

    !  



  9

 

'         

+9       

   



 $  

&  +

     

         

   

 

#  ! #        

         

    

     

+,,

 #   

 #      !   

      

   #   #        # 

             



     

          :     #  , $    "

;   

       

 

   < !"

;

0



 =

 

& >$   "

; 

  

& 

  

 < !"

;



 =

   <  "

;

 =

  

!     

  !   

  

  

 

  

    #   

<

     

    )  

&  >   >?*'?

>   <

 /

 "

;      /

 0

 =

   #  

     

  !  

 

   



 

   # #  

 

& 

  <

/

"

;  

   /

 0

  

      

&  >$   <+

& 

 #

            

&  >      

  !   



    

    

 

  

    #  

 

#

 

   #   ! #     &    #5

   



  # 

 



  

   

         

  !

  

 #

$       #

 

& >: 

 ;

     ;



  #           #

 

&  >:



? $    <

=  @ 

  = <#@

:@

) =   @    = <#@

   )



 $ #

7 /@0= 17 3 

  )

7 : 

1 %3(17 % (

        

    

 

5

;  

  

    

    # 

 )    

 

    <  5   7

B -  "

;8  % (   

 

        

     #          

               

#   

   

          #     ! 

  /# 

    



    

      

        

 !  



  9

 

'         

+9       

   



 $      # 

         

    < '??,    -     =  =    



  #   ) >  = '??'$  

    

   )  3  / 85   



     -  )

     

   

# . 4 
2 
"
"


" 
"

,
*,
*


" 


2 
  6

 

 
62 


2"


"


 *, , 
 

<

 
 

;

5 @"

A 
2" "
 



2"

"





 "
2 
*


"

 *
*

 





 , 2"

"


 

"

 

2 




 "




 
 , 
; !

 


 

6 "

*
*
"


 
" 
"

 

A 
" 
6


   

* 
*
"



 "

" 


, 
2 

 
2"
"



 "
"2

"

  


"


" 


6
  



 
 , 
7 8




  

*"


 
" 
"

  


 




 "
" 

6


 
6
"
1
  






6++&)*#$*&, &'

3&7%3$8 3&'%++*&,#4+
 0$#$% &'

#38#,# #,( &$9%3+D

././/3//
  


"

 *:*4"

5

 
2" "

2 
"


" 
"

E  
 F

"

E F


"

 ,

"



6
 

   
)
 




C 
*
"

6

) , 
 

 #$
    !

 ;   

;

  

         

    

       # ;

&



    

    

 

      &    &   #      

 



  

 &      

  

#        

  &      

    &   )        =

  

 

,>, )  ' %

( 

     

  

:

   #    



      



        

      

 %

(% ()) '$       



      

   

  

0       

  6 



        

  # $  6                    

     



   ; $          

 #

      

         

    

 

   

  !  #  



*    #

 #

     

         

    

 

 

      

 -     $           



         

  

       )      #

    

  # #     

    

 

  

          $ #      

 

   = 6            

    

  
   

  .#       4 



           $  



   3  <  %

&  3!*(     

 



   #

  

9

  

  # 

     

  

    
  

  .
: 

 

*"





"

) , 
(#$%( --

  
6
"
1









G;

3#<#+9

#3#,=

9% %3;#,%,$ /&< (#4#$ '&3 >?4*) $*4*$8 0%3:*)%+ #,( #,&$9%3@

 
" 

*


" 


 
6



  62 
9 

"
  
" 
"

 
"


6


 

6"
"


6
"
1
"

2 
  
6
"

 ,  
!&
% 
76 
 
 8




6
 
 
.3 1

*
"

  
 


"

) , 
 
6
"
1
"2

"

 
" 
"

 

A 
2 
   

* 
*
"


 
 , 

"

 ,

6

A  




 "

" 


"

 " 
6


"


   6

6
"

 ,  
!&
% 
76 
 
 8

.. %



"

6

$ 
6) 
*
"



*
"

 

 


*
"

 
" 
 *  

"

 
 
*,
6, 
6
"


2"



" 
6



 
" 
"

 
*
 H 
,  

"

 
  
*,
2 
E "F

*"


 
" 
"

 
  
*,

A 
2 
 
6
"

  
 



2"
$     
7%
1" " 8

*"


 * 

"

, 

 
6 2


"

 
2" "


% C
$/
2"



"

 ,
G D

 *


,  


  
" 
"


*

.3

EF

"

 ,
" 

6




  

"

 C
*
"

 
6, 


6 

  
2 


*
6, 




 "

,
*C 
*
"

 ,

,  
2 

" 

 

"   
*
"

62 


./ 1

*
"

  

"

"


" 
"

, 

*

% C
$.

2" "


 
  

 

" 
  
" 
"

 
 
  

 
2 
 
6
"

 


 
 , 

2"
"


$      

*"


* 

"

   
*



6 
**C 

"

 ,
B


"

 
  

 
  
>.3./3.>


"

  
" 
"

 
2 
* 
   

* 
*
"


 
 , 



* 
*
"



*"


 
" 

"

,
2"



  
2 
 *  
6 *
"

 ,  
!&
% 
76 
 
 8
 ,
2 
*


" "
"

" 
   

$ 

&
I, 
2"


"

 
2
 
" 
6


*


6
"

 
",

*



"
  
" 
*
"

 

"

6


 

* 
*
"


"


  
 "

"


*


" "
"



 
",

*

.> -
"


 , 
" 
6


  
6
"

  
.4 
"

"



 


 

6 "

*
*
"

 

"

" "
"

 , 
  

2"
"

 
2
 

2


"

 
  
.< @"



 

* 

"


*
E F
B
E  
F

  
"




 "




 
6

 

"



6 



 
 , 
6 ,

..

 


,,  
  
7  , 8 
*

 
 , 
, 
6
   
*,
  
*
"


 
 , 
"


 
 , 

*

,,
 


"


  
  
2



,  
  " 

 

*,


 
 , 
@"

 , 
"
6, 
6
"






6  

 ,

 
*
"

  
%
 
*
"

 
  
*,
"2
" 

" 
"

 ,
*
  
"
1" " 
7%-
-
%19:>:J8

%
1" " 

"

$   
7%-
-%%-1>..< 8


"

 ,
*
 H 


 *


,  

G

G "D
 "
1" " 


"2


E1$   F
2"
"
 H 
 


G "D

%
   
*,



*


*







E

 "F
 
6
"
1" " 

-
%-
-
" 
6


,  

"


G "
1" " D

"

G  
 D
%
 


, 

"
 
6
"

E%  F
B
E1$   F
 , 

E  F
 *  
E%  F
 
"

 
62

 
"

 
 
*,

E"
1" " F

E


F
2" 
%
1" " 

 "
1" " 

$"  


.5 
"

%-
   
*
  62
   
*
"



 
"
1" " 

"

6


,  

"



  
  
*
%-
-
*

 
 , 
@"

 
 

*"


 "


*,
"

   
%-
   
*
$   
%
1" " 
.; @"

  
*
 
2 
"
6, 
*


6 "

*

./

*
"

 
62 

 "




 



 
 , 


6



"

%-
   
*


 
 , 
2 
"

6


,  


, &
*
 *

 


.: "


 
 
.>
*
"

+
1  
% 
.:9;

2

"

G  D
"


 

G  D
@"

 
1 

 
"

 * 
6

2#$
+ C  

  !   D=  E



    



 

 -   &! % (#   

  

  

 ; 

 F

 %'( # 

   

  



    

     . .9

,


6 
6 &


&
"


* , 
, ,6 

$   
"


"

 $"

$


*

2"
"

 *
*
E  F

"
*
+
1  
% 




6 
2*


6 ,
E1$   F

2 

, 


 ,
"

62 

6

 
 , 
2" "


    
*
 , 

"


 
 , 



6, 

  
  
*
 
" 

6




"
*

 , 

 

 
*
"

  


,
, 
*
 ,
2 

 ,
 
*
  
*
 "
 ,


6  


 ,  

/3 

 
" 

 
"

 
  
*,
6, 
6
"

 ,
2 
*

* 

"

 ,
*



.>

 "

" 
"
2*
2 
$      

"

 
 

@"

2*
6 

$   

,

*
"

 

 
"

, 
 
6 2


"

  
2 

" 

6 
  *


, 
 
6 2


"

  




6 

$     
2 


  

"

 
  

2



"

, 
6 2


"

  
7 


 *

 
*
  "

 8
"

,
* 
" 
"

 ,
**C 

"

, 

,  


2" 
2 

, 
" 
"

 
2 



, 

"

6


 

* 
*
"


 
 , 
@"

, 
*
EF
" 

6
 

E "

F
"

   
*
"

 ,
" 

6

"

 C

2" "
"

  
" 
6


6, 

% 

1


J  

 "$
EF
" 
6


 * 

E
"
 
78
 
6 2


2
2

"2
" 
"



 6

F
@"



 

% C
$.
6
"

  
6
"

 
  

 
 
, 
6
"

 
"


6


   

* 
*
"



2"
"
$   
%
1" " 

/. @"

 ,

"

 
*
"

  

 2

* " 
,


6 
 ,

,  



  
2 $  

"

  

2


"

 
  


"


,
6


, 

"

6


 

* 
*

2 

6

 
 , 


// "

"

 , 
*
"

  
" 
"

  
*
"

 ,  
!&
% 
76 
 
 8
2 



 *  
" "
"

" 
   

2"


"

 
" 
,
6 *
"
1

  
 ,


   

@"



.4


,  

2
" 
 
"



 
 
"

 *  

 
6 *
 ,  
!&
% 
76 
 
 8

" 
"

 

"

" 

"


   



"

 
 
 
//$1
*
"

!

 
%" 
% 
.9:;




*

6
 2
 

"

 "
" 
"

 
" 
,
6 *
"
1
2"


"

  
" 
6


 *  
6 *
"

 ,  
!&
% 
76 
 
 8   
1 ,
1

 
" "
"

" 
   


"
"

6) 


"

  6


2

/> 



*,

 
*
"

2 
" 
"

 ,  
!&
% 
76 
 
 8
  
1 ,
1

 
" 
* 



 
" 
,
*,
 , 
*
*


" 


2 
*   
*
6 *
*
"

 
62 

%
 "
, " *
6
, 
*

 ,
**C 

 
*
"


 , 
2 
 * 
"


6) 

6 "
"

  
@"


 
*
"

 




"

 


62 




6   

 
 ,  
!&
% 
76 
 
 8   
1 ,
1

 
2 





  


 "

, 
*

E  F
2"
 
"

 
*
"

+
1  
% 
.:9;

2"
  
" 
"


*

 
 , 
2 




  
@"

*  

"


*
2


   

2


  
6
"

 ,  
!&
% 
76 
 
 8
/4 
2
*
"

6

 

2
 

#44&A%(


"

2 
  
3434/3.5
7% C
$;
8
  
6
"

 ,  

.<

!&
% 
76 
 
 8
  
1 ,
1

 

"

6
 
 

@"

*


" 



"


*
5 ;> ;9;;9

2"
"

 
" 



"


*
.

;< ;;5$
" 


6
"

  
 
1, 

 

6
 * 

"

 

2"
 
=
5?
 
,
*,
"

 
*
* 
*
"

 
6 *
"

 ,  
!&
% 
76 
 
 8   
1 ,
1

 



/< !


"

,
6
6 

* 
*
"


2"

 
*
"

,"
*,
"

 
*



*
* 

*
"
 

"


*
*  

 
"

,
2"
"

 

*  
  
"

6  6


 
"

 
=
9?
 
,
"

* 









 0- "

--



  

K"

"


 &   

#

L -
K"

"


  6

#

L -