Jagmohinder Kaur And ORS v. Union Of India And ORS

  
 

      
   

  !"#!$ % & #'()*+,!-#"!#+,.)!/  .*.*+!/ 0!/"/

+*+
+,*##+,.)!/ 1 /2+,+./






 
 









 



!/+.

 3!-#!#+ "2.#% ,04#. 2.*.*+!/  3!  "!*% ,,*.*+#5 ,04#. +!#5%

"+6# 

78
 %

 




25$*5,*+.)"!.*/.#9++!4!,  )2.*.*+!/)#04)#55+',.),4*/*+.) :#+,4;"*/*.*+554.!% "+6# ,#.,<  =)5,*+' .)#. .) ,4*/*+ + .) #225*4#.*+ "+,! 4.*+ >  .):#+,4;"*/*.*+4.?*55 .#9+#.!.)*+#5,4*/*+  .) *') "!. ! .) "2!( "!.  ) #225*4#.*+ 4.*+>.)4.?#/+.) #/*/#+#?#!, .) !+4"!.?)*4)+)#+4,.)4(2+/#.*+*+ #+#225*4#.*+"+,! 4.*+.)4.*5, $.).)!

>> 5#+, ?+!/  ) #22#5 #'#*+/. .)#. !,! */ 2+,*+' *+ .)*/"!. = ) :#+, 4;"*/*.*+ 554.!@/ ,4*/*+ . 4+/*,! .) 2.*.*+!/@ #225*4#.*+ "+,! 4.*+ >  .)4.#.!.),4*/*+.)*/"!.!#.!.),4*/*+ .) "2!("!.*+.)0+.#+#22#5 *+'*5, #'#*+/. .)#. !,! */ *+ #44!,#+4 ?*.) .) 6",'(+. 

"2!("!.*+# " #(#+,.)!/0 .#.  #+, #+.)! ABB&C  "2!( "!. #// B #+, *+ 2#!.*4"5#!2#!#'!#2)=B.)!?)*4)!#,/#/"+,! D
 ) +E. ;"/.*+ */ ?).)! 554.!F:  + !4*2.  .) #225*4#.*+ "+,! /" >/4.*+ AC  4.*+ > */ "+, . !,.!(*+ .) 4(2+/#.*+ ?)*5 .) #?#!, #+, ,4!

 */ 2+,*+' 4+/*,!#.*+ *+ .) #22#5 *+ .) *') "!. ! #2255#. !"(
 ) ,/ /% ?).)! #?#!, 4.*+ >AC */ *55'#5G
. */ /..5, 5#? .)#. .) ,4!  .) .!*#5 4"!. './ (!', *+ .) ,4!  .) #2255#. 4"!. ?)*4) #5+ */ E4".# 5)*+#5*.$.),.!(*+#.*+.) 4(2+/#.*+ */ #..#*+, ?*.) .) ,4!  .) #2255#.!"(% *..)*')"!.!.)*/"!. #9!*+/.#+4.)#.H@%H@#+,H@#!

>=> *+.!/., 2!/+/ *+ .) 5#+, +.**, "+,!

4.*+AC#+,.)4(2+/#.*+,.!(*+,*+ .) #?#!, "+,! 4.*+  H@ !4*0, .) 4(2+/#.*+?*.)".2!./.H@#+,H@!4*0, .)4(2+/#.*+"+,! 4.*+="+,!2!./. #+, /"'). #+, /4"!, !!+4 "+,!  ) 4"!. +)#+4, .) 4(2+/#.*+ !( .)554.!@/#?#!, / %

. / %

 H@ ,*, +. *5 #22#5 "+,! 4.*+ & ?)*5 H@ *5,.)#22#5)*')"!.%/"22/%"!.)! +)#+4/ .) 4(2+/#.*+ . / &%

 ! !,"4/.)4(2+/#.*+. /&%

2!#4! H@*/#2!/+#''!*0,+5$..)E.+..) E4// #("+.#?#!,, *.)! $ .) #?#!, #+, ,4!  .) 4"!. "+,! 4.*+  ". ) ?*55 +. '. .) +)#+4(+.  "!.)! /"(  / &

 '!#+., $ .) *') "!. *+ #0"!  H@ ) ,4!  .) *') "!. */ .) E4".# 5 ,4! (#, *+ #0"!  H@

+5// !,.!(*+#.*+*/92. #49.*55.)#22#5 $.) *') "!. */ ,*/2/, % *+4+'!"*.$ ?"5, (!' "22/ .) .#. *5, #22#5 *+ .)*/ "!."+,!!.*45=#'#*+/..)*')"!.

>> ,4! #+, .)*/ "!. 4+*!(/ .) #?#!,  .) 554.! #+, /./ #/*, .) ,4!  4*0*5 4"!. 4.*+  #+,  .) *') "!. "+,!

& )! */ +.)*+' 5. !,.!(*+#.*+*.)#0*?./#0H@!H@!

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

>&> #22#5 #'#*+/. .) +)#+4, 4(2+/#.*+ *+ # ,4!  *.)! .) 4*0*5 4"!. ! .) *') "!. #+, ?*55 9+? .)*! 2+,+4$
+ .) 4#/  #22#5 *5, $ .) *+.!/., 2!/+/% .) 5#..! /)"5, *+!( .) 554.!F:   .) 2+,+4$ #22#5!.)!?*/4(/.9+?*./)"5, 92 #225*4#.*+/ !,.!(*+#.*+% !4*0, "+,! /" >/4.*+ AC  4.*+ > ?*.)*+5*(*.#.*+2+,*+'%#?#*.*+'.),4*/*+ $ .) #2255#. 4"!.  ! 2!4,*+' ?*.) .) ,.!(*+#.*+% ) /)"5,  .#*+#+ #*,#0*. !( .) 2#!.$ (#9*+' .) #225*4#.*+ "+,! > .)#. + #22#5 #'#*+/. .) #?#!, (#, 4.*+!5*,"2+ $)*(?#/*5,!* )#, + *5, ?#/ ,*/2/,  $ .) #2255#. 4"!.#+,.2!,"4.)4!.**,42$,4!

 #+,6",'(+.%*#5!#,$,*/2/,I  )5#!+,4"+/5!.)2.*.*+!/.#./.)#. *+.).)!(#..!%?)!#+#22#5*/2+,*+'#'#*+/..) !,!  !+4 "!. +)#+4*+' .) 4(2+/#.*+% .) 5#!+, *+'5 ",' )#/ '!#+., #+ *+.!*( /.#$ + 4+,*.*+.)#.& J.)+)#+4,#("+.*/,2/*.

>> ) 5#!+, *+'5 ",' "!.)! 2!(*.., .) 45#*(#+./ .)!*+.?*.),!#?.)#("+.,2/*.,?*.)"./4"!*.$ )*/4*!4"(/.#+4/%)?0!%?"5,+.+.*.5"/ ..#9#,*!+.0*?!(.)+.#9+ $.) "2!( "!.*+ 

4#/A/"2!#C & 44!,*+'5$%.)?!*.2.*.*+*/,*/(*//, A 78
 C 

 




 !"#!$ % &  A 


 3
C -