Sat Parkash v. Punjab & Haryana High Court And ORS

  
    
 

 !"

#$% &%'()(*+  
 

  

  

     

   
!+ , -!.
.  - , -!.
.. - /%)%*$+ !/.#*0(1 #*)#23&1'#$% /$4%5%$($(*%/  #0%)4 (*&#2 4%5%$($(*%/364()#5/#'$()(*7&1'#$%34#) (2%&$4% 5/%)%*$5%$($(*(8597*(*7$4%8%8&#$%&  31(&%64('44%6#) (* /8%&$4#$4%()*$%*$($2%&$:%*% ($ /%2#;#$(*(*8(*(898#*& 8#;(898#7%2(8($3#)*$( (%&:<$4%.$#$% 9*0#:1(&%8%8)&#$%&    #*&=   3 //%'/9($8%*$(*9*0#:.95%/(/9&('(#2.%/1('% -%#/*%&'9*)%2 /$4%5%$($(*%/)9:8($$%&$4#$$4%5%$($(*%/ :%2*7)$.'4%&92%&
#)$%'#$%7/<()&#$% :(/$4()>

* ?? 3  $4()  '9/$  (*1($%&  #552('#$(*)  /  (22(*7  95     5)$)  

&&($(*#2 ()$/('$ .%))(*)9&7%)(*$4%.$#$% 9*0#::<6#<

&(/%'$/%'/9($8%*$4%2#)$&#$% /)9:8())(* #552('#$(* /8)6#) ?

> 4%955%/#7%2(8($5/%)'/(:%&6#)><%#/)#)*$4%2#)$&#$%

/)9:8())(* #552('#$(*4%5%$($(*%/3:%(*7#'#*&(&#$%:%2*7(*7$ .'4%&92%&
#)$%'#$%7/<3()%*$($2%&$/%2#;#$(*(*955%/#7%:<<%#/) 4%5%$($(*%/#$$#(*%&$4%#7%  <%#/)#)*> 4%)9:8())(* ()$4#$$4%9*0#:1%/*8%*$1(&%8%8)&#$%&   #*&=   %;$%*&%&$4%955%/#7%2(8($ //%'/9($8%*$(*1%/*8%*$)%/1('% /8?

  $?@<%#/)4#$/%2#;#$(*)492&:%8#&%#1#(2#:2%$#22$4%'#*&(&#$%)3 648#<:%#552('#$*$) /$4%5)$) &&($(*#2 ()$/('$ .%))(*) 9&7%)#*&#)#'*)%A9%*'%$4%/% 3$4%955%/#7%2(8($ (;%&(*$4%'#)%(* 4#*&:%&%%8%&$:%(*'/%#)%& /8>$>@<%#/)#*&$4%5%$($(*%/8#< :%7/#*$%&55/$9*($<$'85%$%(*$4%5/'%)) )%2%'$(*$6#) 9/$4%/ )9:8($$%&$4#$%1%* /$4%59/5)% /%'/9($8%*$(*
.9&('(#2"(*$4% #&1%/$()%8%*$())9%&:<9*0#:9:2('.%/1('%
88())(*3$4%955%/#7% 2(8($4#):%%* (;%&#)?@<%#/)#)#7#(*)$?<%#/)8%*$(*%&(*9*0#:
(1(2.%/1('%9&('(#2 /#*'4"92%)3  /)4/$3,$4% 92%)"  $%/4%#/(*72%#/*%&'9*)%2 /$4%5%$($(*%/36%&*$ (*& #*<8%/($(*$4%)9:8())(*)8#&%4%5)$ &&($(*#2 ()$/('$ .%))(*)  9&7%364('4  ()  (* $4%'#&/%   .95%/(/ 9&('(#2 .%/1('%3 () 71%/*%&:<9*0#:.95%/(/9&('(#2.%/1('%92%)3

@ /)4/$3,$4%

@92%),"92%$4%/% 35/1(&%)$4#$*5%/)*)4#22:%#55(*$%&$ $4%.%/1('%364()2%))$4#*?<%#/)#*&8/%$4#*><%#/) $4%#7% 4(/&5/1()$$4%# /%)#(&92%5/1(&%)$4#$$4%1%/*8%*$8#< /8 $(8%$$(8%3(*'*)92$#$(*6($4$4()
9/$3/%2#;$4%955%/#7%2(8($4% )#(&92%()%;$/#'$%&:%26+ B7%C5%/)*)4#22:%#55(*$%&$$4%.%/1('%364() 2%))$4#*$4(/$<C (1%<%#/)#*&()#:1% /$<C (1%<%#/) $4% #7%*$4%2#)$&#$% )9:8())(* #552('#$(*+ /1(&%&$4#$$4%# /%)#(&955%/#7%2(8($)4#22*$ #552<$$4%

('%/)$4)%64#/%#2/%#&<(*$4%9*0#:
(1(2 .%/1('%9&('(#2 /#*'4"+ /1(&%& 9/$4%/$4#$(*$4%'#)% #'#*&(&#$%64 :%2*7)$.'4%&92%&
#)$%/ #'D6#/&
2#))$4%955%/#7% 2(8($3)4#22:%)9'4#)8#<:% (;%&:<$4%1%/*8%*$ /8 $(8%$$(8%+ /1(&%& 9/$4%/$4#$$4%1%/*8%*$ /8$(8%$$(8%3 (*'*)92$#$(*6($4$4%(74
9/$38#</%2#;$4%955%/#7% 2(8($E $()*$$4%'#)%)%$95:<$4%5%$($(*%/$4#$$4%1%/*8%*$ 4#&  %1%/  '*)92$%&  $4()  '9/$  /  /%2#;#$(*    955%/  #7%  2(8($  /

? /%'/9($8%*$$9*0#:.95%/(/9&('(#2.%/1('%*$4%#:)%*'%$4%/% 3$4% #/798%*$$4#$%;$%*)(*(*955%/#7%2(8($*$( (%&:<$4%1%/*8%*$1(&% #8%*&8%*$(*9*0#:
(1(2.%/1('%)%*%/#2#*&
88*
*&($(*)

.%/1('%"92%)3

> /)4/$3,$4%

>92%),")4#22#9$8#$('#22<#552<

//%'/9($8%*$9*&%/$4%

@92%) //%'/9($8%*$#)&&($(*#2 ()$/('$ .%))(*)9&7%()$$#22<8()'*'%(1%&34%*'%3/%0%'$%& 1%*$4%52%#$4#$955%/#7%2(8($6#)(*'/%#)%& /8?$?@ <%#/) //%'/9($8%*$#)
.9&('(#2"()#2)$:%*$('%&#*&/%0%'$%& 4%
.9&('(#2")%/1('%()71%/*%&:<$4% 92%)92% $4%/%

5/1(&%)$4#$*5%/)*364()8/%$4#*?<%#/) #7%/ )9'4#7%3#) 8#<  /8  $(8%  $  $(8%  :%  (;%&  :<  $4%  1%/*8%*$  /  %*$/<  (*$ 1%/*8%*$)%/1('%3)4#22:%%2(7(:2%$#552<4%# /%)#(&5/1()(*(* $4%92%'2%#/2<5/1(&%)$4#$955%/#7%2(8($3#) (;%&:<$4%1%/*8%*$

/%*$/<(*$1%/*8%*$)%/1('%3()#9$8#$('#22<#552('#:2%(*92%) 5/1(&(*7  /  /%'/9($8%*$ #)  
. 9&('(#2" %*'%3 $4% #/798%*$  $4#$ /%2#;#$(*4#1(*7:%%*7/#*$%&(*955%/#7%2(8($ //%'/9($8%*$(*
.

9&('(#2")4#22#9$8#$('#22<#552<$

@92%)()$$#22<8()'*'%(1%& #*&&%)%/1%)$:%/%0%'$%& /$4%/%#)*)8%*$(*%&#:1%36%&*$ (*&#*<8%/($(* $4%5/%)%*$5%$($(*4%)#8%()3#''/&(*72<3&()8())%& #0%)4 (*&#2"

9&7% ..#*&4#6#2(#"

9&7%    8D