High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18559/2012allowed

P.S.E.B. And ANR. v. Presiding Officer, Indus. Trib. And ANR.

2019-01-24Mr. Justice Rajiv Narain Raina7 pages

!"#$%&$''($ $ )$ $'*

$+,'

$#-$ #.($/0' $

$12( ##$+.'3 $(0$ $/( (+.'3 $$0'

,(0+(0$4&$'(#'(5$' ''

0' %(,'

$#-$ #+6 $'0 $*$*$4 70#%7 ( ' $0'85$97 $7('5( ( 5$'70$#*5($% $7(' '7'

$ $7('5( $(5$975$ $470#%' %(0$8&$'+5((3$#$

-( (0$4*7((5$97 ('5$9' $ :'% $7:

:5((. "; 3"*$+!

3+($5#-('0 5$' $ ( $7 $#0 %$($ *('7'$3' (*7(%$ $$''#%(*$ '

(! (,'

$#0 .+

= $($>(.? 53#' %(*7$$+5$9$''( (('0$ $#$*( $470#%7+( #'(3 *3(7+(( #'(3;$'(( $470#%7

$ $*(

$-(*7''70#%5(/ #=@ '== (,'

$#0 $#/ #+

= $($>/ #

=? $7' '$(.-($ $'$3 5$' ( 3 $ $470# (.-( $ $$'(-$ #55(($(5$97 $470#%' ' +5( (5$97#' : A0+(*700$' $(-$ # ' '(($ $57 #(5$97(' 00#' $$470#%7(0$0$*5(00#5$ 3' $7('#%5*5$9$ %(*7 (&$' !07 $+

=' ((5$97('#(0$ $#$*(

$ $470#%7 '$ ! < (. $ 5 #(' 7 $ #'*"*#(' 500$ :

=3'5((00#5$3' $7$$(''#% 5*$ $ $470#%7+ ( 5$97 '' 00#% $ $4 70#%7' ((#7%$7'%( #'* 39*! 4< (..0$#7$% 59( ($ $57 $$'5(0* %$ $7(##*'

$7'( $ #'#%( ;0#' %( 5$97.($ 7 #%5($%0$ 5($##*' $(5$97'(' $470#%'

=+(' 70#''0$($ $5($#9#%

7$+(*7'7'((5$975 **''#%5*$!07 $+

<# $37 $+

:+5( % $7'0$$0$7 $7(B"8,($* ' #% ' (7# $7 '

($ $ -( 0$

5 '$ # ('7' %(3$ A ( *7&$' $'

7 $$('5$9$.77 5 '('' %(( "*$ $'$* $4 70#%7 '#%5*$,5'0 '(5$9$5(('

::='% $35$##' $$35'$470#%' %( *7-( (5$975(70# / # = +5$C $' (7 %$*$'3$' 7$#% %0 #500$ ,5#$((7 95 ($470#%7 7 $-((00$('( *7'

$'(7# $$470#%7((('

+($'('0 $*$'*$470#%75((5$ $$'

'-( *3 %(&$' $0 # ( 500$ 5 ( ($ 5$ #$* 7 $ $$('

70#%(3*$'$'$3 7$(::='%

-(*75'7'($4;7 ($*$'5$3'(5$97$C $' %/ # = 5((0$3'(#'% $('5((( 3$ ##'+(70#%$(##$$* $'0#%( $' 0 0# ( 0$7 '

$# #(7+'# (3'(###*37 ( 3 % $*$' 0 ## ( $$(' 5$9$ #* # '$'+(''$*3 %(7(7 ($ $$(7 -( -$ # (#' ( ( 0$'

$ ('

##5''(3( 4'$ ($*(

(0$.0$ $#$*( $470#%7 $% $ '$'*#%+(0$'

$( 7 # #% ##5''

# $'5##7 470# 4< (

.$'3$7500$5##7 70# (0$0+(-$ #00#'( '*7 3 &( 6 $ <*( $

!"## ''' @ @ -( ( *7 $ ( 3 &( (6 $<*( $5(7$'3$7( 500$5##%5%

'! <+ (($ ('+( #' 93 $('($*'5$97 00#%'*(7# $'-($* 750' %( 3&(< # $*3$*$' #( $* 7'3' %(*7$*$'70# !

<$'-(-$ #5$$7*(# (($53# <'(*$ '#( 5$975$'$3-(70$0#( 00#' % $ $ $%&% '(

!")!*( 3# < #'(0$ $#$*(! < 7($ (5$970$'

$ $3

##5'($(( '*7'(5$'

(-$ #+($0'45$97($#' ( + $,- . /!0$12 3

&- ( ! 12 3(! 4D+# ' +

6' (.'(7 * 4 70# (0$3-($ C $$#5((#*# 0$0##''5( '*7(! <7'$%'

( 70#'5( %(*7 '$9 (7 $$7 $3 **$3'0$

= <53$+5('*( 3#*#0+( 0$7 5(( ! < ( . # >$7?8?$$(7? (70#%'(' $*** 0$(7 +('$*#$'$*( ;470#% $7''3'

##%($$ 7 7'((% 7%7 $5$'(%$$'-($$(75

:-('7'5$' ,(' 3+ ($5 $ #'#% $7$$(7($*(

0$ $# '$ 7* ; * ( ( 7* '#%(0$,((*77% 5$*0#'($5$7(#( *($ '($#7 7 $$ $$*'0 70#%7+

'7(5$9759 0 $7# 7 $%7 '$'

$#'0 , (5($5$97$' ''$#'0 $3$''+ *$3 '*$30$ ''($'(0(*7#($$'

$ 0$0$* 5$ 7 ' ;0 0$' $$' 3'$'$ (0#9(5$7 &'+(5$97 #';0#%*'

$ 5((5 %'($#+('7'5(('$$'(7 $('7' $$470#%7 ( #'*, ($# 7% 3# # $(9* .($ $5(($ $7 $7*$*$# ( $0'45$97($%0$##*' $( 5$97 ( '7' ' ' $470#%' % ( *7

=(3 7'0$($ $'(

@ $*( ( $5$9$7%

' $(0 $0 $% (5$97 '($ $

-($ ## ($ $ 5(( 5$9 * ( $0'45$975(0#''((# $37 $+

:5( %7'0$$0$7 $7(B"8,($* '+ ($ $+ #% $7' $7 '

% ' #% -($$ #(0#'*-(#'0$*7 $ (($0' ''( $7

:5$'(5* 0(

$ ( $ 7 , ( $ 7+ ($ $7$$$(75((($%*$' !

(..'7'#%+($$7$'$; (0$, (+((*(#%'

#5(($( 0$3 (.$$'(77% #3# $7'70#%5(5 #'(30$ $#$*( $470#%7-(3#0( 70##%3$4#9' % (-$ #.##(' %(5$97$ #$7 '$*($470#%70$0''

'$20* 35##(7'+,7 # 00$(5$' (-$ # $470#%70$5(( ''( .'7 ( 7$4''$% $7 $0# ( .$5##95 '(0$'& (00# (0$0#( (00$#''

$ $ #'+ *$'+7% 3' #(('0$7 (5$97##5' $'( #'* # 0 '+ ($ $+ ( $ ( 0# '

$ 7$((# +' ' 3+'%$#

5$'' %(-$ #

= ,35 ( 3+(5$0##5''( 5$'''

0' %(,'

$#-$ #+6 $'0 $ '

! " # +5 6 ) & /