High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11246/2016dismissed

Satpal Singh v. Hindustan Insecticide Limited And ORS

2023-09-14Mr. Justice Jagmohan Bansal19 pages

!"#$%#&'('$) *+* ,!"-!.,')/0 1#"'"'$)#2 3#2(4( ')54("!))(#&"'&'5#6'7'"#5!)5"0#2( 1#(-$)5#)"( 8 6* ,

, 6

, 69 *2!.

! ""#$""% & ' ( )* )+ ,- . "+/ # )0 #- . 00/122 3! &!4-5:6/ ( "7

) "- . ")/12 1 & "

!! !

1 1

8 1 ! ! ( 11 1

) " - . ")/ 1 !2 ! 2!2!1

1!! "7

) " 111!2 ,

9 :

&! ; 2! < =( )0 )7

77)1 ! 1 !1 ! > 9!9 ! ! ! # 6 ! ! ! !2! < ?< - 5, ,6/ 2

77# !#1.2

1 ! !

@ <11

! )# )%

77)

@ < 1 . 2 77# 2 ! ! # 6 !

@ < ! ! # 77% !1.2<?< 77% "))" !.#1.2 <?< '1 ! 1 1 < !

@ < 1 < ! "))0 1 2 "))+ 2

@ < 2

<! 3! &! < -5,:,6/)0 )"

) "# )7

3&4 12!! 13&421 1( <3&< *

&A #"+% ") ,2& ( < ! 3&4 & )

), , 1 !2 2: 0111( ! : 0 1 .! 2! 1 0

" #$% &

& & &

! &

' (

(! " ! !

) #

! , ), , 2 9B!C! -'$&/ ' 9 B! 1 ! C ! -'$&/ D 1 1( 8C !"

), ,E C! -'$&/ !1&

C! -'$&/1 ! = D ( 6 9 B! 1 )# )# , 12 3&41 "*

9B! 1 ! C ! -'$&/ )

), " * )% 0 ! 8 D & 2!! ! !

! ! ! .)# )# , F*

* +

, (- -( ./0$ *

123* -.

-% $-.$ .4 -5 $-.(

1 + 2

6 ! * 1

.4 -5 $-.(

& *

& + 7 8

.9 -5 $-.(

* 6:

6 !

& *

! * 3

! & 1 ) %

)# )# , 1 1& '1!>2 21 !

& & C = D 1 = D )* )+ ,12

!! 3&421<3&< 1 < !"))+1

@ < 1 "))0!!

@ < 1 ! < ! !2& C1 2 # )0 # ' 9B! 2 !9B! 21 +

B ! 9B!12=D ! 2 9 B! 1!! C ! ! C ! 1 ! = D ( !9B!11! C -8/ 9B!1=D 29B!!2!!2=D2 9B!.1=D =D ! 19B! <24 2 <2 4 . 1 < 4 2!!2<42 12

;

1 2 77# 1

@ < 1 2 77% 1

@ < . !!

@ < < !"))01 "))+ ! <3&< 3&4

@ < 1! 2 1 2

! 1 ! 3&4 1 !!!1

!!2 2 9 B! 1 1 &

2 2 & C ! & C ! 1 ( 1 C! 1! & 1 !1 5' 1!16 2 ! 2 2 ! !1 2 : 1 1

! 2!2 122! 2

@ <11 1

@ <1 "))0 11 "))+< !

@ < < !

@ <1 <3&< !! 1 < ! 1 1 <3&<1E 3&4 ")

1 211( <3&< ! ! 3&4 !!1!! E!2!

)

' !!2 12! 8 ! 2!!1 E&

A )* )+ , !! )# )# , 2 C 8 11G

A1! < ! <! 3! &! < 1 )"

) 3! &!41 "*

)0 )7

77) !

@ < ! !)# )%

77) 1 . 2 <?< 77# 1

@ < 1 . 2<?< 77%

@ <1 < ! "))01 2 "))+

@ < 2 <!&! <1 )0 )"

) !!

@ <"))0") ) 1. 2 <?< 1 1 <3&< 2&") ,( <

!3&4 11 )

), , C ! -'$&/ C !

") ,1! 9B!1 C -8H / D! C ! )

), "

* )% 9 B! 1 ! ! C

! ") , =D ( 9 B! 1 )# )# , 12 1 < !<3&<1 )"

)

@ < <3&< 1 3&41 "*

E 2 1 3: -/ A )* )+ , !! )# )# , 2 C 8 11G

! =D (6 C 8 ! 9 B! 9B!1 1 1 ! C !

=D ! 1 C 8 !! )# )# , 2 C 8 1 1

2 ! 12 2 . 1 !

22$1 ! $1 D62!< &

1 E '&

< .I. D !! 12<+0D ;<

") %&

< .I. 2 2 &

< . <+0D;< D62!< &! 2 &

2 &

. 1 ! 2&

! ! 2&

1!2 2 &

! . 9$ +

& ! &

;

, : !

$. $-$-!

4<(= >

@" & 0(<.= ?

! !

0(<.= &

" $.

$-$- ?

, .-5<.=

& , $$9 ?

! !

) ' C! 1 2&&A: #"+%") , & !2 ! 2 C !

1 2 &1! &A : #"+% ") , !! C ! 1!1!1 C!

1! E C8

9 B! 1 ! ! C ! =D (! C8

! 1 !=D 1 ! C 8

1! )# )# ,.1= D ! !

1 1 = D ! 1 8 !"

), , ( !2=D = D ! ( ! C 8 1! 11 ! C8 1 D ! )# ), , 1 ! C ! ! C !

)

), " * )# ' 2 ! ! > C! 1C8 1 = D ! 12!! ( !2=DC8 ! 1 ' ! 9 B! !1

D!! ! '1 =D ! 1

2! 2 2 & 1 ! 1 2 = D C8 1 != D 11 3: -/ A 1 ! < !<!3! &! < 1 )"

) 3! &!41 "*

! )0 )7

77)

@ < )# )%

77) 22!1.2<?< 77#

@ <1 2<?< 77% '1!!(12<?< . !( 2 1 !#

@ < 1! ! !#

77#1 2 77% ' 2 !( 2 . 2 <?< '12 2 1

@ <122! "))01 1 E ! "))+

"))0"))+!

@ < 1 1 < <3&< )0 )"

)

@ < <3&<! ! 1

@ < !! ") , !! 1

@ < ! <3&<

@ <1!!2! & C ! 6 ! 211C! '&( 1!11 !22 !1 C 1 ! C 8 . 1 = D 2 ! 12=D 4C8 12!=D1 !! !

3! &! 4 1 2 !! 1( <= 1 ! ! ! ' "# )7

12 ! 1

3&41 !1( 2! < =( !

1 1( .2!1

!. "

A B 1

C 1 @

" +

& D *

B& 3 B& 8

' &

& $ "

& ) 8 ! 2 ! 2! ! ! 1( 1 2! < =( 111( . 2!1 "# )7

11( < !1<3&<1 2!13&4 1 21 <3&<

;

1!!1 ! 2 D ! ")

") , 8 &") ,21! 1 ! 1 C ! ( !! !! 1 3&4 ' 1 ! , .!! ! 3&4 ! ")

! ! 3&42 E !")

1! <3&< 3&4 $ ! <3&< 1 !! 1 1 !

C 8 2 2 <

! <3&< 1 )"

)

@ < ? C 8 3&4 1 "*

! 3&4 2 "# )7

'1 !1

!11!!1 !! 1 ! C 8 !!1 (1!1 3&4 1!! 1 1 1 2 !! !!1 2!!2C8 !!1 (1 !1 1! 2! 3&4"# )7

! 1!!E , 2 '1( & C8 1 !2 )# )# , 3&41 "*

' 1 2 E12!1

1! 12=DC 8 = D )* )+ , 1 1

1! <3&<

@ < 1 ! 3!&!42!!! ! 2! ! ")

") ,11 ! 2C8

3! &! 4 1 "*

2 2 2 !

, 6

*+* 2 E 3

F 3'