Harminder Singh And Another v. State Of Haryana
!
"#$# %&'(')
& *+ ' ,,,
! " # "
$ %%%%% ,,- ' .
/ & ! '() * * + , -').- -( /( )/)/ 01 -2
! -() 3* *
4 5 !
)
& 4 ! ! 73 , 8/8 /9 -/ )/-( ! 4 ! 5! 6 ! ! :/9 :'- ;/8 -'( -'< 3* ! );)9 ! ! , -
! ! :/9 3* -( -/ )/-( ! -9:0)2 * * ! 4 )/:/ /9 /-< ! :'- ;/8 :): :' 3* * 73 , 8/8 /9 -/ )/-( ! -9:0)2
* * )/:/ /9 )/-< 1 1 .) .:
:
& ! 4 4 ! -() * * -( /( )/)/ !
! ! ! :/9 3* ! -9-( /( )/)/ 1 1 .-2 & 1 .-2 !
'
& ! . 4 ! 73 01 .)2 ! 4 /9 -/ )/-( & !
! !!
! ! :/9 3* -( -/ )/-( & ! -9:0)2 * *
4 4 ! :/9 3* 4 2 )/:/ /9 )/-< 4 -( /( )/)/ !4 ! -() 3*
! '8( * *
4 4 1 ! !
4 ! -() 3* /8
4 ! 4 = 4 ! &
! ! ! ! :/9 3* -( -/ )/-( )/:/ .9 )/-< 3 !
4 -( /( )/)/ 4 4
4 4 +
! ! ! 01 .'2 4 4 * ! # ! ! 0 ! 2 !
! -() 3* !
4
!
& ! 7 >
4 /- -) )/-< 01 .;2 4 4
! 4 !
& ! ! 4 !
7 > &
4 4
#! 4 !
! &
! ! :/9 3* ! 4 4 + ! ! #
! "
" #$%&'(
) ! *" " #$ +
,&
) * ! )" " # - ./
0 1$ #2'
0 3 4 5"
;
& ! );
-) )/)/ 4 #
= 3
!
!
! &
4 !
!!
! ! !! ! 4
! 73 ! 4 /9 -/ )/-( & ! -9:0)2 * * )/:/ /9 )/-< ! 4 -( /( )/)/
!
? !
4
. + # ! ! & ! .
! 4 -
6
! "
#
" # "
#
$
"
"
"
"
#
# 3'3 , ' ! ,3!
1 1! 1,
$ 33 , '/, / !
,
/'!/17 7/ $ ' '!/1 7 , $ ' "% ! )4 """ ! ) """ 6
! )4" % 8&! &9! 3, , 3/ "
#:7!, ' ,
3 ' $ 338! &9! ! !&
,! ! #$ 7, 1 , 3/ "
$&
$ '
( # 1 $ ! , 3 ' /, / / 7! & 1 ;
$
'
" '
" )$
"
<! ) " //!/ , 3/ $
* $
( # ' ! //
! ' 8 ' ,
&& 1 ! 1 , 3! ! $
1 '! ! ! ! / 8 '3 & !,
1, 3! ! $'! 3 ;
$ #
# ""
# " "
$+ "
'
, ( & * ! @! # ! ! ! -() 3* & ! 4 .
3 !
! "
" =$ *
.
A-- & ! 4 4 * !
= ! @!
BBBB BBBB BBBB - &
" . "
/ +0& 1 3 ! C2" / " / 0 33)$44
$-)) 1 5-&
6
7 / 0
" 8/ "/# / " 9 33:/+7 / " 4
/ + 0 " & 2 33 )
+4;-< 33:
=/ <-
0
"/ +0
'
4:::> &
" 9 33: # " .
'
, 3 ! ? / "@ / / 0
7 0 :::$)44
$3< 1 <)! "
/ +0&
/ +0
'
!
33- 33A "
B C
"
,
! )4 /3 ! ">!!,! !!33 , 1 // 3"- 3/
! )4 """
# " " .
'
" /
/ +0
'
/ +0 "
/
" 6
" / +0
" DDD DDDD DDDD DDD 59 & "
" "" "
&
'
=/ <-3
0
# ""
#"
&
, & * ! E
FE / 0 ::3$44
$ 1 53B " +4 ::
9<:: + 9<:: #"
+4 "
& "
" / +0
::)& #
9::)
+ 9::)
# G
+4
:: @ 9<::
#&
9<::+
::)& " .
# H"
G 9::)
/ <- 0 '
/ <-0 H"
# " .
:+/ 0 // "3I2A ?J /
0 "
" "
"
' "
H 0# / =0 3$
-93
" " H"
" <- <A)0 I
"
? / "@ K/ / 0
7 0 :::)$44
$3<&
& "
33A& "/ +0 +
H"
G 333+
"
/ <-0+ 2" / "K / 0 33)$44
$-))
# "
& " .
#
/ <-0, & * ! /B I?
/ 0 "? / 4H H :- ::3 B":9::$ 4 4 .
5-B "
" "
= +4 " ;
.
C# & 6 7 / 0
?L$4 +4 " " ;
&
+4 9:<:
&C # " "
"
"
::) 2
H"
& '
/ +0 ' &
"C"
A&
/
"
"
/ ) ##!#"&
" #"
&
"
#B
" +4 :::
9:<:+ 9:<: # +4 " "
" ;
C/ +0
9:<: # " +4 G
::) &
9::)&C
"
::) " .
" # 9::)
+ " '&$ 4$ 3"2"?$* B '
0 "
"
"
" ' "
- 8
"
@"$ 44 #$ / $)
" " H"
" ! )4 * "" - 0 & %' "
, 3!$ . ! 3 $ #$ /3#$
$ " 0
+
33A &
"/ +0+
0
H"
G 333+
"
,
! )4 "" + ?& & "
#$ /3#$ )
# "
0
&
" ! )4 ""$ # " .
/ +0 C 6 " " & 6, 3 ! /
/ " / 0 4H H ):)-< :: /
:9:$ 1 5+
::: / +0 9:::) &
'
B / <-0
'
" &
/ +0
' '
':::> & " "
"
?
"/ <- 0, 3 ! 4 C / 0 4H H < : 2 A:$ 1 5B
/ ? G
0
/ E
? 9:::-
&
CB'0$
9:::-
<::: &
/ <-
0 &
3/$-9 / 0 // "33)$44$-))2"
/ " / 0 ::3$44$E
F E / 0 &
"C / +0 +
C B' 0$ 4 C /
0 " 2
H"
+7 6 " "
6,
& * ! H
CG
/ 0 4H H AA9 : 2 :)$
4 .
5& " "
"
B
"
/ +0
"
+4& " #" " " "
G
)::::B
" " #" " "
"
/ <- 0 " # "
" . "
" .
#B / '
# " .
"
$ '
&
/ '
(
'
" (
'
"
'
"
"
/ +0 '
# " " .
/
/ <- 0 ?
" / <-3 0&
/
# ""
#"
+ #
# ""
# " "
&
+4" ;)
# " " #"
# " "
? #"
B
"
?
"
)::::
):: &
#"
/
" + ? / " @ / / 0
7 0 :::)$ 44
$3<
/ +0
H"
&
E
FE /
0 ::3 $ 44
$ &
"
? / " @ $ &
1 MB " +4 ::
9<::+ 9<:: #"
+4 "
& "
"
/ +0
::) & #
9::)
+
9::)
# G
+4
::@ 9<::
#&
9<::+
::)&
" .
# H"
9::)
/ <- 0 '
/ <- 0
H"
# " .
M +
"
# "
" .
)::::
G
#
/ +0+
&
& & 6 " "" 6, 3 ! B C 2 /
0 4H H <<- :) /
::9$ 1 5-B
"
/ <:9:: /
2
H"
H#:)B <9::
0
#"" "
/ +0 &
@ :) B'0 )
/ <-30
#" 0
&0
#"
" "
/ +0 & <9:: :)
A & "
6 " 6, A B "
/ <-0 / <-3 0
" C
'
"
/ <-3 $0
#"
+
/ +0
' ' &
/ -- 0 0
B H " #
" .
#" >
<
3 ! 73 ! 4 /9 -/ )/-( ! 4 !
! :/9 3* -( -/ )/-( ? ! -9:0)2 * *
! )/:/ /9 )/-< ! :/9 3* &
!
4 ! :/9 3* !! ! =
! ! ! -() 3*
4 ! ! ! :/9 3* & 4 -< /( )/)/ & 4 ! -9:0)2 * *
!
)/:/ /9 )/-<
4 /- /( )/)/ ! 4 -( /( )/)/ & ! -9:0)2 * *
! ! :/9 3* 4 * !
= ! @! ! .!
-/ 3 4 !
, -').- -( /( )/)/ 01 -2 ! -() 3* *
4 5 ! +
,, 010$ -) =
.$4
5#%16.
$ % !
& $6
..
4 .
7/
& $6