High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/5/2017allowed

Kaur Singh & ORS v. State Of Haryana & ANR

2020-02-03Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan20 pages

! "# $%&' "%(%) $%&* +,(" -%./ 0/ "! 0-0-% "!

1 "!(!

0,0 ,"2,%,,%$,%0/ " !3%$ %0!

1 6

!"#$ %& ''& ( !"#$ )%& (

!"#$ &*%% #& +!

, - !+( !"#$ %& )%& ( .

/0 !"#$ *" 1 67

- % &% *%% % % %" & " "

1 * "0-&% (2 #%"&%$&&*%%& #0 2//" ""%% ( $$2"&%( ((% **(%$ %%("0-& *$2%2"$%3 4%$ 567 "

%"2"$%3 3 3 38 1 3

"38&7 (%$ % ( (% +%%$% 7%&%$% && &%*%%%*"% %$

"%$&*$"% 0&% (2 -" &%$ 92*%&2 (% " 2/& " 3 :% $&$ & & %"67 %"

& /$/*( 5*" 2("*% &%&&

((

%& &%

%$2(2% "%&#% 1

1 &

( %&&%* (2$(:

& % &*<& &- $&" &&2!;

%0% & *%% *% & 2*% & 0;% & 2/% & '

% & ( %& 2 9 % & " 29&"# % & "%

"$%&%& "=& "& :

&& #$ &%#%&% #2 "%(( $ ##& "

- &&2("0(%/% "0- %#%

0 % =& 9 % &

0( && " :

&&%$&( ""&%& " ":

&(( "<&&$/*( %"$2:

% "& %&%((%# &%(( (0(%/% "+2&% &$/*( / %" "% 2 =& *%

# 0(&$&:

" 0;

# 0(&/2&:

&> 2/%

# 0( &(&%*:

&>29&"#%

# 0(& ( &% & :

(;%" % & " 2* % & '

% &

2 9

#9%$90(:

&<&:

& %"

#%$ #&%/ / -*$ /& 2*&%$& $$2"* (&*( $=& &$/*( ( %&'

% !# % & 02 &:

& #,*% ( % =&*(%$ & $""& /&$/*( " %"& *67 8 . "%$2(&*%%& 2"& * &.:

& "$& *"%#%;2% &%$& 2"

3 ?

$ " 2" %@ A $/ % * &%@ ((- # ( % ( /%"(% %&&0("% * .

$ "2"%@ A $/%*# ;2 0#&&%*%&&0("% 3 :2%%@8A $/%*#( ( *$ (&% &/%""( 53" "%""%&$(2 8 +%2((% *#:5.- :2%%@A $/%*#% &/%""( $& "%""%&%$(2B . "%$2(&*%%& 2& 2"

& %%% ((-&67 %"2"$%3 3 8C 84 38

4&7 &# ( &#%$%/5%;2" &%" :/0 -,*% ( % &&"$

# *%%& %;2-

2(% 20D2&%$& $%3

7 """ 1 . "%$2(&*%%& 2&20/%"

& & % %&67 %D2%- $"2$"0- +=&* %#* &%D2%-* " 2" ?=& 3 17& "#%%"&%#%

%& %#%((

/ ( (% "2% #%%$ %&*( $ $$2$ %*$" "%D2%- $"2$"

/&*%"% %&&2 &*( $ $$2$ " %D2%- $"2$"/0&& * % * (- +2% #%%$ % $/*( * - " (( & * /%" % & 6% 7/ %*0& ( $$2"* & $$2" * - & " " (( & & 1 * /%"%&6%7/ %*0%$ A$*/ 2# 9 "29&"# "0&&* % "- 9 % & $%$2/ $ & %2 % $( A$*/$"2$% %D2%-

8 / 0& & * % $ $ " "2

**&%% &%&#%((

%D2%- $"2$"/0&&* % $ $=& 0-$ ((% *$ 0(*0&&* %%/- %$ 8 1 7$"2$" $ $%D2%- & $/*( * - "-

"% %;2% 0% $ 2"0- &$4*/%"% &6%7/ %*:

"& ""

* - "-

"% %;2- 0% $ 2":

&5 :

(0%% &0- & #; * '

" 2*

" 2/% "

"% $&% &*

&% &%%&" /&%$&%%$( & 0& &* %$ 02&2( "&* %% "- 9 %# ( /&%$&& *%0%(%-2&$/% (% & 0- %

%/ % 02&/0%(2/0 &% " &$ ((" %( "($ %& "

-&$$2$% 1

1 0 %"0$ 2 &""

* -& " 9& "& 0*

&%&*% ( (%&&"

-$$2$

"& #2"0 $9&/%&#% * / &% %D2%- / " / & % &02%

&*9* $$2" &% ( (% "% &2 & $2%-

( (% " 6 "$%#"* / /-(#(&2 &$ 2$ 7& #*2"&$ ((" %(/0%($%#"

/ $-0 $(( % =& /0%( 444 1 4 4

&%$& "0%& $$2" & &7+ & / 2"0%& / "#5 & &/0%(481

3 "0 %& $$2" 2* &7+& / 2" 0%& /+ 2*% &529&/ "

% & %&6%7/ %*& &E / & $$2" 2*%:% % & %D2%% 02 & /% 2"& & ( /:% % &% 29&/ "% "&/0%(481

8 "0%& $$2"'

&7+& / 2"0%& /'

% & * /&% /0%(*& "0%& *=& ($ % ((& 0#3/0%(&"

- $$2$"

" 1

1%&"

-%/& $/0 ( (% "&($ %%&#% % #%((

/ ( (%+2% /-%D2%-0&&* % "&%/% &00 13 %& #% 02/&$%D2%-% 2"& & % & & " 9 *( $ 0 13 18 % & #% &"

- 1

1 % "

9 % & ""2% % "

9 &%/ %$%"6/&%D2%-$"2$"0-$2%-

( (% 67+F% "/-%D2%- /- (#(%$/ %& 0$%/"&

1%&/% "&%3 "

2* '

" * %"

%(-/ &

&% &* " 0 ;% $/ &2%

"% ( (% "% "%& 02"& %&#% && "2"&%&2

( %& ((&%3 "%&%'*G+7 &%"

"&$ ((" %( 0#/0%( ($%/& /=&$ %(

%&2 &(-*2" / *2 (&%( "#%%$ %((% $& # 2 $"

!*& /$/*( 2("* % & " %;2" :

(;%" % & H :&%" % & 2 9 5 2 % & & " $ 2"

%;2-&& ":

(;%"%& **

2/ % & %&

$/%&$ -& *"

*02%&.:

& %;2-%& * " ((&%;2%& #0 &0%&0(2 * !*$/*( * - %;2%$ 2"

(%"H:&%"% &0- 2 95 2 % & %& ** * % & 29&"# %& %$9 #; %& "

2/% &%&

" 2*% '

% & " 2 9 5 '

; % %&( 02&$/*( & 2"(- %;2% %%*%0(& %&% & / (( &**%(( %#$"0(

%#% %;2-%&&% * 3! "&$/*( % & &*%&&%2$(:

"%;2% $ 2":

&0-& $$2"

* 0-**% &/ & - % & # " %;2- $ 2" 2("*, D2% %& &-%;2-

$ 2" $/*( 2("* &

$$/* -% :

(;%" &&2("*$ #& 9% "&&% (%-2("* % &&*%&&% 2$(& " $&"&* " 8% &%;2-$ 2"%&& " %;2":

&%/& &%;2- 2"%&& "& 0$ 2"%&& #- 0(20;$0$ 2&92((& ":

(;%" % % %(( 2((- %9" % / % & %"

"% &%%2 %$ 0$( "/& *%%&"$ =&2 &$%" % 9& 0# /%" $ 6/ & %D2%- $"2$"

3 1/&* 0-&*( $$$2$

#%((

/ ( (% %;2":

& /& * %D2%-/0&&* % "&%D2%- $"2$"/0&&* % $ $ 8 /0%( $ (( " %( " ($ % " / & %D2%- $"2$" &2 & $2%- !

( (% "6"$%#+* //& % &02% &*9* $$2" /&%D2%-$"2$" /-(#(%&$ 2$ %& 02"& &*( $$$2$% * &&2!;

%0% &5:

% & / ;0% %9& 5 '

/ ( (% ! & %/ $$2$&%$ 0& 2 9'

; :

(;%" % & .%( % & %" '

/ ( (% "%9% (%D20- 9%

( /&&2!;

%0% " "%

%&%&2!;

%0% & %& 0 2"& %& / *0-& / & & / (((%D2 & %/ 2 9 && "$ /&%# %% 9(- %0 % & / @0%%9&

"% & %&%%(" !;

" %0% &0& (0& "&&2 0&&/ 0- %&/ &%(:

(;%"5 :

(0% "+ (;% &H:"

5, 0%"% $&" &&2 !;

%0 /$-$( &

2 95'

; ":

&5.%( % **" & /$-$( :

(;%" ($ % 9 *( $00&&* % % &/ 2 5 ( $&"&* % / &%( '

%H 2;

5=&( % ( $&"&*

%$ &&(" 2 95 + (;H:"

$ 2"%;2- 2 90-*%$9%

2*"

/# *( & 2 95'

;

% &2*" &2 /& ";%% *( "&%

C & /%&& ":

&5:

(0%%

"% / &%(29&"#% &5:

02% ( /&* ";%"%&% & " ((&/ &$ 2"%;2%:

"+ (; % &H:"

02 %2%;2- 2"0- + (; &"%" $"2$"&%/"%$ ( !& %/ % & $/*( 2("* % & $ / - * & " $ / & * " $%#% & %/ % 2"#% &* %# * $&%&% #&%$( ( %&&%$/* % 9% 2 5 2 % & +2% &% 2 % & " &%

" 2* * "'

% &%;*

" #;5 &/$-$($ / &* %(( &#&%$( 2"# * $& " % &%D2%-2"0- 2 90 $9 &#&%$( * $& ":

(%"% &%%;2"

$"%% 90-&%*&2("* "'

% & A * $& $ % &% #&%$( 7 (%-

2 9% &5'

;% & 2 95 2 % & :

(;%" % & 5 .%( % & " 29&"# % &5:

02% &%#(#"%$ 2% %;2% :

(;%" 2&/& /:

5 .%( % & % % & 6% 7/ % * "2 /%(- ( % %& & $/*( * - ""2*(%%$ (%# (- "* - $% & / % /%(- 2 % 6//-#%%$ % %&%$ 2 % & 5 '

; % & 2 9 5 2 % :

&5.%( % "29&"#% &5 :

02% &%"'

/ ( (% 2"0 ( $$2" * / &% 2 % & &% #;% & " *% & 2*

% &/%"%&6%7/ % *& " $&"&*( $$$2$ &

4 % &%%&" " 2/% &5 $& %

(&* &%%$9* %& 0 $%/"& &1*%#(#"%&% & & #$ 2"%;2%:

(;%" &*& # 02"%$

"% &% 7& #* (- $""&%% 3 1 8 1 " 3 3

" & *( $" & / %( !" ((%

"%$%& #0 %#7$& (%$ %

2 9% &5'

;% & 2 95 & :

&5.%( % 29&"# % & 5 :

02 % & %" '

/ ( (% 0 %//"% (- " " & * 2" 0- &/ $ 2% %;2- 0 $#"/&%*% "& /0 9%*(%$*% !0 %% A**%% "A -*

"% %;2- 8 " %;2"

&9* F *%%0 9

"% &%;2%/&"$ 3!*&",E0(2 & /"%$ (:

(;%"0$"2$"&2 &: "

+$ 8 7 &% $ & % ((

$$2" &%%

% &$ $$2"

*02&%#(#/ &%&% & 0$%/" $%

47 0/#" =&$/*2%@ %$*-.%;2"

"&"$2/( " /002 & &%( 1$ ("%*( &*( $$$2$0

** "

!/2$& #%"$0$(($" "&%( $/*(% ((&/ (%% &$& (( &

0 *" % & 2 0 & *$%0"*%" *%*"

. "%$2(&*%%& 2&20/%"

& 0 "& %"%D2%- &*%%2"%$ &-9*%(2/ &%(20/%% &*2"$%

3 " & $& /"

% 2 & $ $$2"& $% % (=& /&$/*( $""%A /% %%$&% < "&% "&#%

%#%&67 "&#%"$& $/

%&*%%,% $A /% % "" % D2"0-&*20(%$*$2 & **(%$ %2"$%3 42//% & ""%% (

$$2" 0%("=&A /% %%$&%< $""

3 4

1 " 2" ? "& 1

1 02

*/ 7 "/- 2$(:

(0%% & %

/2&2&* "& $&" & &2 !;

%0 % & ;0% %9& %" '

/ ( (% & 2 % & :%& % *% % & 0;% 2*% :

% & 9% & & 0;% 2 % & 2/% $&& % & '

% % & 9 % & 2 9 '

;

% & 29&"#% &:

02% ((0-$ '

%9& %" )%((

/ ( (% ( "- *& "&- ((& #% ( &% "

** % "$ <&* % &2 & *( $ 9"& :

(;%"0**" && "%&$ "&%#%2 #2&%(( &%#%2 #2%22 " %"& "

& &2(" 0 9%((" %#% %;2% F* &% 9% & && "%(%$" 0( %& * && "/-2(:

&&%$& ( "" &% & " " & %;2- "* & /-2$((("& 2" <&7 %"$2/-2$( 9"& %&%(( %# -2%(( (09%(("2 7 %"

"/ %" "% * &* =& *%%(%$" 0(%&( &%&$&/- 2($ 0;%% &$ 2" "

0(&/2& /-2$( 2/%% &$ 2"

0(& (02$9/-2$(29&"#% &( &%0( &(&% &/-2$( 2*% '

% " 2

#% "9%$90(/-2$(-2$( %"

( / ! +7I! ! +7I! &%$& $" & 0-% &02 "% $/% &/ & * ((& %( %"

-/&*

( %&&%*$%# * <&%( % / &*&- %""

&& 0 #"

02%22&-%((9%((&%/7(*&%$ ((-%/"

%% &% ;

% "$ (("&%/! /%/'

% "!# % &+ & % / &*%& #&%$(&7 '

%% !# % &9/-2$(%& #&%$( "02 & &%/ ,% +$

#% %" "0$ 2 &/2$&%;2% "$"/-2$(<02 & /-2$(:/0 -,*% (% " &%/ "/%"

&(%$$ /%&&*% (

1 02

3 */ "$""/- / - /% JA< 5! &%$& 0 /- % 2 *% K!E ="

- $$2" 9% &H 2 9 2 % & 2 9'

;% & 29&"#% & :

02% & :

&.%( % *%&2=&& $$2" *7

"9&&*(%$9 - $%

%& * LAAAAAAA 0- & '+

!"#$ &

$$2"* ! &%

$A /% % &% % % ""&D2( ""$$2(! &%

**(%$ %2"$%3 4 2//% & ""%% ( $$2"& 0%("0-& $/*( &2 &*20(%$*$2B C . "%$2(&*%%& 2& 2"

& &&A /% %%$&%< $$(2"" 0$ A /% %&%% &*$2%/#" **(%$ %2" $%3 42//% &*%% ""%% ( $$2" 4 7% "%& %" **(%$ %& *&#% %# %&67 & *$%%$ ((

%&*%%&& # 2"%;2%%2& $&%$//0;$02&*%% $& (( "0-&*(%$ " & &-/ -02//" $% ( ( %&& $$2"& ( "- $% % (

=&% **(%$ % $"0-& $$2"*&

2"& &**" ""%% ( $$2"2"%$0-& *(%$ "$& (( *"

%&/ "&% & $/

%&/

"% $//%%$%2& $$// %% / (( & $$2" * 7 ( " & & "*%%/ "0-< %&%A /% %%$&%"%"%*% - $%"$2//&*%% ""%% ( $$2" "#& %" **(%$ % %("%&2$/*(% &$A /% % %"

%7 2& " % & **(%$ % & # *67

2*% & '

% " 2 9% & & /"

3 %& - * 2 &02//"&2 &&%*$%%$

((

%&/7 2& "*%% &%

024 - "&(- ((

%&%/%& && %"

""%"2 - *7 2& "& ((

% 2*% &%& &

# 0(:

& &%& *"

"%;2-&%0 $9%/%( (- 0; % &% (( "& # %# 0(&/2&&%;2"

& &%2$&$*"% %;2-%&.

=&% (2 (("& %" **(%$ %0-* % & %/*2 """

" 1

1=&* %#* &" " 2" ?37& #& "( "$2(0&&%" (( ( "20(%$$2& &

**(%$ %253 4& "& # &2 &$ %(/%2(- 8+2% %#%

% &*$2%2":

(;%" % &2% /%;2- %#2% 2"$( "

2(% ((2"$253

7 &%& " "& %"%;2- %;2- & 0

%02"0-&$/*( (( %;2"&%/( 9 % & 2 % & <& &

$$2"& # (0 %02""%%$(&%$&% 2" % $/%- %& & " / $/*( &%( ** % %&%0A <

(( / JA< 5! $"" 0-&%/ 0&*(%$"20 &A&"&

$$2"(%/% :

& -&%*$ &* "&%(A&% & $$2" ($ %(- "&%/D2 ((-(% 0( $% (%&$ 7&%

" (% $$ 0*( $"2*$ %("

8 &%% &("& &*/"% " $9 &"$ "%&9%#$//$" &% $ & $$2" & $$2"/20"/"& & $//%%& $9/2"&2 &&

&("% - * =&,M0(2*/2%

!!"

# "

# $ & &(" & 2 $ 2//

* ""%% ( $$2" %$/*(%$%-& *%$//%%$ ** 0$( =& ,M0(,,% &2%

' ( !)"

# "

#)! & 0#"& &*$%%$

((

%&*%%(-%&6702 %& /&$/*( (( "&% ( 2&%( 9% %$%" %&#%"$ $" & % &(- 2//" & *%%

""%% ( $$2" $ % ( ( %& & $

$$2"7&*$ ( &$&67 $( (- & / &* 2 & 0 2//"253 4&& "$ 2"%;2% %;2":

&/*( &%( ** % < ( /%"& / ((& $$2"

* & $ 2" %;2% &% 2$( :

(;%" % & 1!2$& & 2%$% 2//% % &:%& % & %% *% & 0; % & %%% 2* % & )

% &7) 0; &) 2/% $&& % ")7'

% & 9% & ((%"#%((

/ ( (% =&%( ( (% +%%$% ""%% ( $$2" % ( ( %&$ $$2"

,$ %"% /% &% 7 &0- (( &

**(%$ % % & "%("25 3 4 $& $$2"

/"%& **(%$ %%& "02 &0 2//" $ % ( 0 2//" "

$$"% (-B

. " % $2( & *%% & 2" & *%% &% ("*

" 024 - "%&%

" && *( $"$"&%7"%- "%2"0-&J($% //%%7"% "

" 3

44 $$"% &%$& *%% &%

" 024 - =& /% 9$" 9M!M

3 . "%$2(&*%%& (*( $" $" *&$*- & !

"& " *%% 2 % &% &%"

0%&

48 =& /% ( 9$" 9M:M

8 . "%$2(&*%%& 2&20/%"

& *%% &% /"%&67(-*%& % /%(- && $$2"* %& " *%% & % *&-%$ ((- %$ * $% " $ 2 - %;2- & (-

%02"&%/

. "%$2(&*%%& A 2"& &% (2 &%( ((% & **(%$ %2"$%3 4 (9"%%"%#%"2 ((&%A*%% "&

( ((

%*%% 2*% & '

2 9% & & %02"(-( *0(%&2 -*$%%$ ( &# &-& # (0 """;2%#(#% /%(- "*%& $& &-%& /"%& - *2" - *

1 . "%$2(&*%%& (%"2*& ;2"

/,M0(2*/2 ""% & *

* !"$#

#$+ &%% 0&(" 2" ?7" &D2% /&*%$%*( 2$% "%, "*% &E$ / -0$ *%2( " 2"$%3 4$ 0A$%"

0-&% ($2 -

"2% &% ( % 0 &$$(2%% ( 2// -*

$$2" " $&% (%& % $ $& % ($2%"& &%/K#%"$E

%2$&

* & 0 % &%$& #%"$ % $ 0

&"& & ** 0 2%(-$=& K#%"$E &% / & / % ( & % 02 & 0 & 2 "2% % ( 7 & / % (5#%"$$(($" 0-&7 &

%D2%-%$$" %$ 02%(%"$0 %

"2**&#%"$$""0-&2 %#9&*2"$%3 4"20 2$&#%"$& & 2 $"%A /% %%$&% %&2 $ A /% % % $ ( 0 9 % $%" % ,# %$ % %

"%$% -* %#&22"$%3 "% ( A "% - /& 0 A$%"* % (- "(-%&$ && $%$2/ $&$ =&" % $%%/& &" &%$&% " & %/ /% & $&

% & % *$ &/ $& & %(" (- & "$ #%"$$$2

% */ &#%"$("0&2& 2$&*&2("

0A$%"7%0A$%"% $ 2 (

# (%/ =&*%/ $%*%%&%$&%0

/"D2% #%"$& /*0 0%(%- &%$/*(%$%-B

. "%$2(&*%%& &2 2"& %& 0$ "$ &% (2& (-

(("& **(%$ %2"$%3 4((-&0 %& **2( #%< &%$&%&% 02% %&%#%

%#0&*(%$

C 7 *(- ( " % $2( *" 5$/*( & **"&* -&*%% "20/%"

& &%($"2$% &%D2%- &*(%$& $"" -$ A % &*%%. "%$2(& ( %"/2$& &(*%% *% & &% %02"

0(&$&%;2":

4 . "%$2(& "%;2-%&. :

&20/%& %% 02%&%$&& (( "(-0 2"%& 0(2 *%

. "%$2(2& 2"& *%%

2*% &% %02" 0(&(&%*%;2"

$*"% %;2- &%$& % ( $ "2"%&& 0("% "*%%8 0;H "#% &% %02" %$9 0( & /2& %;2" :

(;%" % & &2 & & % $*"% %;2-%&.& / &# %($((%

%&- *.

. "%$2(*" 5$/*( & (%"2* *, ( !"$# "

#$$ &%,M0(2*/2&%((-% 2*%

C (%;2"

/""%(-

*. !+"#

#) $& 0#"& "?#%"$B2"%$%

/ %% %A /% %%$&% ( & %&$A /% % . "%$2(*" 5$/*( & &2 2"& &%0 /# **(%$ %2"$%3 &A /% %%$&%&$/*( %$"" 3 . "%$2(& 2& 2"& %%((("

& &2$ A$%*2"$%3 4#& % & / / " % A /% %%$&% & % $$" " & 2 " % %(( $A /% % 2$& %2// * ""%% ( $$2" * /"% &67 *&& 0$& &" *#%""& %

** 2& 2$&*$ 0%" ( %&& $$2" $%

% ( 8 7 *(- ( " % $2( & *%% & 20/%"& &%(* % &%/*2 "" &% (2& $"" %"% & *%/ $% &#%"$ ("0&2 % & /*0 0%(%-&%$/*(%$%- . "%$2(&*%%& 2& 2"

& %#%(-

/0"'-# &% (2& ( $"" %"% & &#%"$%/& *%/ $% A$%" &%/ /% $& 02& % $% A& & #%"$ % 202" 2("( "$#%$% 1 !& % ( "$2(&* % 7%"/%%& **%%D2 *%% 3 "1 % & 2*

4 % "'

% & &((%

" 024 - &%/ %$%" " A$* # $ %

%02"&%/,%

%*#"/&%)7 " !

"& " "&& $$2" & %&

" & $% % (

0 !

%*%%3 "1 /(- 2*%

" '

% & & (- ((

% & &-& # 2"%;2%%&% "9%$90( &# &% 2$&$*"% %;2-%&.&%;2"

$ 7#%(-

/0"'-# &% (2 $"" %"% & *%/ $%#%"$("0-& *$2% % & / *0 0%(%- &% $/*(%$%-D2 *%% 3 "1 %

2*% "'

% &

" =&%"%*2 02&("( &("0- ,M0(2*/2% *,/0"'-#& A /% %%$&%2("/ ?#%"$B *$%

02 D2 & %" * & % $0 %/"%$ (#%"$ **(%$ %2"$% 4%%(" #- (-

%0 ""2$%

/"%$ (#%"$

=& &%( * (- ((% & * *%% & %/*2 " 2//% " "

" 1

1 % &0- %" D2

*%% 3 "1 % & 2*% "'

% & &# &%*%%%"%/%"D2 *%% 8 " %

*% & 0;H "#% " 2/% & 9*% % #%& $& & *$%%$ ((

%&/& &-& # 2"%;2%#%$%/:

& &%$&*%/ $%$*"

%&&%;2%"$%0"%&. * 1 6