Sugar Federation Common Cadre Officers Welfare & Tech. Association v. State Of Punjab & ORS


  


 

  !

"

# 



 " $
  $

 & '(



        

  

 

  

     !

"



$
  $

 & '(



        

  



  

     !

"

"

" )*) + ,)- ./ 0


 '+ 1!2 '

$

3
 3 3 '

' 2 1!2 '

$

3
 "

3 3"



#
$ %  &

  "

  $'&'( )( " % &

'

   "

*

  $! &

 "

*

"

3 3" / $     

"  +,-,,./

,
 -,---/ 0

 &&



 

 

 %  1) & 

    



2  +,-,--/

% 





 0! ,-3

 

"

& $  & 4 !   -6  4    7  -6  ! 75    

  --3 )

% 

  "%







8.%  36%   "

   



      )2   )

    

   "

&    $   9

 4



   

   7

75 

"

:

%





 "

& 

 -84 7 -8  $ 

 "

&  



 "



6/
 -8 "

:

%

  )  0

  % !





  "

 "%

  &  



%  &  

)  



 "

:  

% 

    "

:  

%    2     

;


 

 

 &    "%

)

 " ""& !

<

 

6/
 

 "

:

% 

 !  % -6 "

! ,-3 

-6!  "%

""

  & ) 



  8.%   < % --3 -6! ) 

 "



! ,-3 

  )   )8.% 

 :

36%   

! 

"

 )   #
 

        

 
  

 

  ! "

# $    % 

 

   !       &%

"   

  

 ' " !  %    % ( "    

  &      
! 

   "

  '%    

 ) *+

 !% 



" 

,  -,       

"   !    

"    



% ! 

/
"&% !      % = 

   " 





 "

 "&     

  6/
   !      

 



   

     &       

"%

 & 



% "

:

%)

 "  ""& !

"

& 

%> "

 ""  ! )

%  

% "

  ))

 % 

%))



!

"

& 

  2 

 

  

   

"%

    8.  %     36  %   

 !

"

& 

  

 ;..8--;  4 :
,5  



   $  (   

 &

    ""&       

 ! 

   

8.% 

36%  $ ( ) 0

 "

  !  





> ( )  "

 

%  

 !  :"

  

%"

 

""

  

 

3

! )" "  ""& &

 



6.,--/ 

 )""&

%   

       "

   

   "

 )%   

%"



6/




"

:

%) 2 !  

 





 &  "%

)

 " ""&

!

 < 

 

6/
  

"





) !

)

"

:

% 2

    %  !  &      &  

   

"%

1    

  

 %

"& 

6/
 -8



   "



"



  

  "

  



&

  

  + 

 6.,--/     

 ! 

% "

% 



"

 &  &  

6/
  " 



# .


     


&

" "

,   /    

   "    %  ,  

 

 

 



8

" ! 

"  !

   

      & 

"  !    "

            &  

"      


0 1

 

"

 

   
,&

"

'

  %

   

 

   !

  

  

"          !    %  2 < 

"

 "   



!



;.8--;)

%""&)

     ! 

 

 

8.%  36%  

+

6.,--/)"

%  

 !    0 

6/
  % " ""& % !

  



% "

:

%  "

)

   & 



6/
                  !

 

  ! < 



%  ?

  !

  "

    "

&   "

 

@
"

& 

 & 

 ( & > 

   

 

  



   !

"#"

 $%&'() *+",
- 

"

  !

    -8



   

 

  &



# .-

!

      

!    '  "

 

  

"      *     

%

            

  !      %  " %      "  

     



  "  !   

 

    

 % 

"

 "  %    

 " , %      

        

" 

    " ,            

   

  "    



" "  

"!  " 



"  !     

 

 

   ,       !  

 %  "   

 

"



   !    

 

6
   ,

  "

  

  

 "  

   

"

   (   %              %      

  !

3   "  %   



   4  , 

     !  

%%

  

      

            

 &  



    

 "

,  " 5 ,



  



   ! ! %  3&   + 

 !

   



    

   

 ! 

  

2    &  ) :  &

%

 6/
 -8  !

7"

) " ?

%

17   "    .

    

/    #

  

)

  

$%
0" $0%/  ,5  ,  

+ 1$$                   

  ! "

 !  %   +

 !

,

     

-
 !   

&

!

 %!    " 

"!  

! %

 +

 !  

"       

 !               % 

  

"    % 

 !

  

6 "70 8551

   5  %   %!   

     ! 5         %!!&

!

 #   ! "

 %!  %  ,&

!

   %!        "         

    ! !% * ! , ",  

'% 

 !

5

'

 " 

 !

, 

"

  , % 

  & 

       " 

         !  

   %  

    

 !

"  ! "

 %!

  %       !         

              '    !%   

!

" 

'% 

"  

"' !% 

 

'   

 !

!  "

  



      '            

       !   

.
   

  /  "!  

 !

" 

"

%    ! !

 "  *  



   !     +       +

  9% 1 ,  ,   %     :)+

 !

    % 

 !

 

      %!      %     +

 ! 

    

  

    !   < 

 :



  

""&

% > ( )   "

 

 !      &

      

) 

)

 > ( ) :

 



  :"

  

)

2





 ""





,84(5 -8

"



,84(5) %

 



  







  )



"&          !    !

  %  ""   '&  "%

        )   



:"

% "

 ""   






 )

"



,84=5 "& 

 ,@4;5    4/5     -8      ""%        ""

 

  

  ,84(5     

%      ""





,84(5& 

")   ""





,@  "



,@4;5  

 !

    

 %



 & & ") 

"

% 

 

%   

% 2 

%

 0

 

%

,4 5 -8





  &   %"

& 

% )

&  

 )     



%  

     

 

     



"& 

)

    ""



:"

%

 > ( & ")  "

% 

 &   %) 

"   > ( 1   ""&



 %    



""&

> (    "

   

,

 



% > (  

   )

 

   9   "

  

 

"

&  2 )% &

  

"

  

  8.%     





   



< 





  

      :



  

" %



   %

   

%&

   "%

 2 )% <234 / )

5  4 $%&'",

60,/





  

)  

   &

% & 

+ 1,6 /      % 

   "

+

# ; 9 ! :)   < !              %     

== ="  % 

% ==" 5 

   !

 ' "

  < !    

 

%     1

"

  %      % !    !       

%

         

;
 ! 

  

!  %  

7 5,  ,

   &  

     *  %

   !  

    

7( 

       

    %    % !   !* "   !     !  3       

!      !     & 

    !       +    4&%    %    

 

  

!   2 



>  17  "  

:

  52*

  $%
6"$  6,-     )   (  %)  

'&   

 -6;







&  "%

8.%  36%  &   6...  &  "%

    ....  "     

"%

) "



   



 

17   "     "



        

  & 

# .-

   > 1

  "

 

  !

/
  ,

% ,

  "

    ,

 ,



    & %    /           ,   ",    &       %       # %  !    

,

& ,      +

, 

  ! "   !  !  %   5  ,   

%  %       !  "



        

  %    

 

   !   ",     )     

% %       !   ' !   "

  

 !

  !

 %     

!

"    

  !

    !

        

        %     ! %       !

!   % &   % % 

! 

",         !   

"



  "

%   

"     

  

" 

  !  "    5! ",   

     

   

 %

    %%     ?

3
  ,   !     !     &  

"@     ,           %

 

 %    * 

   !  "

%   

" % 

 %

  

 %  

"!

!  /  

"    

,          ,         *

   &

!  8%   

   !

! 

       ! "%  !%

 

  "  ?,   

       "  

 !     !,

 

"

% ,

  %! 1

  %%! "/  

"   

     

    *

  !  ,    ",         %      

! %" ! "/   

"1  ,   +

 

 ! 

         %

 

! %  %  



5%    &     "

!   '   "    ,

>   



 ,

%  &% %      %

 

  

  .1     ",   /  

% 



% 

     !

!  

2

8
A++ =,7B++
8C0((D # ,  

!%    ! "    

"     '    %    ,     

 %

  !*

    " %

  "  &   

   8%  !  '     +

 D

 4 B .D

         

  %

,  "%



%

    /  2 ( & >   / 5   /

.

 

    /

 ,0$$" 3),6

     

-66  1%

""% $2

"

&  & 4 5!  -8-

   

8.%  36%  & 

# . /     

  +   E      8   )       

 

 !

   

      %     ="     " 

  3 "  "

 9 '%  +

 !   !  
+

  + 

,   
   !"  F   

F    5         

  

@


,%    

 !

="     

,%       =  "         !   

! ,&  0" 

%  "



 !+

 '% 

  !  

   0   % D

%

  

 

  %   %%         %      

      % &  

"  ! "

  

     % 5"

,   !   

 

%    %         '%   

    



 

%   ! ' "3 F    +

      5 2*

 /  /()$%
6 66$  ! 

"3 F       +

         2    7   8  9  



    / 

2   / ,0$0"&  '-&  %    

"

  &

!

"    % "    

  552*:

 

", %    !    =="  

  ! " 

 

% 3 F

6
   +



 %        "   

"

   '

" 

%%     = " ,"!  %!' "  

       

     

 

  " "   

 !   7((0(

  " ,

!

" 

  "    % !     %         5  !     *

       5 2* :

   

",    

      

 2    :

 "  

  

   "&  



  % % 







< ) 






 

 %

)

 %



"



! )  



  %""%  "%



%  "

& 

%)  " ! ""%  "%

   





 

  

% 

"



 

 

&3 3 '

' 2(

& "

3 3" ( 

"

 " ,)- ./ 0

 GIANENDER KUMAR 2015.05.26 10:39 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document