← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4026/2023dismissed

Sumitra Devi And Others v. Jagbir And Others

2026-04-07Ms. Justice Harpreet Kaur Jeewan4 pages

      

     

     

     

               





           

 

 

 

  !"# $%&%!'()**   !"# $%&%!'()**   !"# $%&%!'()**   !"# $%&%!'()** +,-%.

 /% '#!0 .& +,-%.

 /% '#!0 .& +,-%.

 /% '#!0 .& +,-%.

 /% '#!0 .&  ***11 22 '

***11 22 '

***11 22 '

***11 22 '& 3 .&,& 3 .&,& 3 .&,& 3 .&,&  45%.  45%.  45%.  45%. '#!0 .

'#!0 .

'#!0 .

'#!0 .&  *** &1!'# '

*** &1!'# '

*** &1!'# '

*** &1!'# '&

 ( 67  +* +  8  9

 ( 67  +* +  8  9

 ( 67  +* +  8  9

 ( 67  +* +  8  9 . & '( . & '( . & '( . & '(

&*8!- 2 '

:#/!$  : "!. .*50%- ';,+%'40:#/!$  : "!.0  11 22 '&*

.*%4 -8*0 .#< =:#/!$ "!.. &1!'# '!*'&,.

'$  !-1 ';*  8  9:*  8  9:*  8  9:*  8  9:* * 11 22 '$2 '& .  & >%'4 '0 '$ - ' !" 0  %!' -!,' < .# #5;0  !!.$$%# ' %-&.%5,'

2:

,.,4.

- 0 . %'

" . . " .. # ! & 0  ?.%5,'

: & >%'4 '0 '$ - '!"$!-1 '& %!' < .# #. 4 .#%'40 # 0!"7 2+%'40 &%'$ # $ & # :%' .!

#&%#  $$%# ':<0%$0!!>12 $ !'*** * 0  .%5,'

2 /%#  < .# #  # **: < .# # %!' !" &*:@:A ! 0  $2 '&: 0!2#%'4 0  0  & ##% ##, !0 .!

#&%#  $$%# '<0%$0< & . &,2!".

&0

'#' 42%4 '#.%/%'4!"0 .

$!.5 .%'4. 4%&.

%!'!*  ):5;. &1!'# '!** * 0  .%5,'

2 $!'&%# . # 0  4  !" 0  # $ &  ;

.&B && && #0 %'$!- !"0 # $ &&*:CA1 .-!'0: '#

0  %'&,.

'$  $!-1 '; !" 0  !"" '#%'4 .

$!. < & !.# . # ! 1 ; %!'!0  11 22 '$2 '&%'0 "!22!<%'4- '' .( +.*!* +.*!* +.*!* +.*!*  #&  #&  #&  #&

!-1 '& %!'< .# #

!-1 '& %!'< .# #

!-1 '& %!'< .# #

!-1 '& %!'< .# # * '', 2%'$!-  &*:C:A:CD  *  #,$%!' !< .#& 1 .&!'

E1 '& &FA.# &*:):GA:C:HGG:  *

,2%12% . ) * 7!&&!"# 1 '# '$; Rs.12,37,880/- (1,76,840 X 7) C* 7!&&!"$!'&!.%,- &*:: * ,' .

2 E1 '& & Rs.16,500/- )* 7!&&!" & &*:CA !

2( !

2( !

2( !

2( &*:@:GGA &*:@:GGA &*:@:GGA &*:@:GGA + ;&*:@:A + ;&*:@:A + ;&*:@:A + ;&*:@:A * 0  1. & ' 2: "%2 # 5; 0  $2 '& & >%'4 '0 '$ - ':0 &5 '$!' & #5;0 %'&,. .!"0 !"" '#%'4/ 0%$2 * * .' # $!,'& 2 "!. 0  11 22 '& $!' '# # 0  0  & #< &;

.&!" 4  0 %- !"0  $$%# ' '#5 %'4 . %. # -12!; :< &#.

<%'4&*:A1 .-!'0 &1 '&%!' '#

2&! .'%'4&*:A1 .-!'0".!- 4.%$,2,.

2<!.>:5,0 & -  & '! 5 ' $!'&%# . #*   < & ",.0 . $!' '# # 0  0  .%5,'

&0!,2#0 / # #,$ #A0%'& #!"A.#!< .#&1 .&!'

'#2%/%'4 E1 '& &!"0 # $ & #* *  . $!'.

: 2 .' # $!,'& 2 .%'4 !' 5 0 2" !" . &1!'# '!*%'&,. .$!' '#&0 %'0  5& '$ !" ';1.!!"!"

4.%$,2,.

2%'$!- :0 .%5,'

20 &.%402;. = $ #0 $!' '%!'!"

0 $2 '&%'0%&. 4 .#*+%22",.0 .:0 # #,$%!'0 &5 '.%402;

112% #* C* 0 / 0 .#2 .' #$!,'& 2"!.0 1 .% & '#1 .,& #0  1 .5!!>* * 0  .%5,'

2 0 & .

 # 0  %'$!-  !" 0  # $ & &*:CA!'0 5 &%&!"0 # 1!&%%!'!" / '>,. %&0.

:9:

' -12!; !"0 +   '>!"'#% :<0!1.!/ #0  '> $$!,' &  - '!"0 # $ & #"!.0 1 .%!#".!-

;! $!5 .:  E* *  0  '.; !" 2 & 1 '&%!' . $ %/ # !' ** < & $!'&%# . #<0%2 #  .-%'%'40 %'$!- !"0 # $ & #*0 . %&'! #!$,- '

.;1.!!"!'. $!.#0 0 # $ & #< &#.

<%'41 '&%!' -!.  0 ' 0  & %# -!,' !. 0  0  < & 0 /%'4 '; %'$!-  ".!-

4.%$,2,. * !'& I, '2;:0 "%'#%'4&!"0 .%5,'

2#  .-%'%'40  %'$!- !"0 # $ & #. I,%. '!%' ." . '$ * )* 0 .%5,'

20 &# #,$ #A.#!,!"0 %'$!- !"0  & # !< .#& 1 .&!'

'# 2%/%'4 E1 '& &: <0%2  !5& ./%'4 0 0!,40 0  2 4 2 . 1. & '

%/ & !" 0  # $ & # %'$2,#%'4 0%& <%" : $0%2#. ' '# -!0 . .  '%2 # ! "%2  ' 112%$ %!' "!. 4.

' !" %!': 5, $2 ' !&* !  5 %'4 - =!. $0%2#. ' !" 0  & #: $ ''! 5  0 2# ",22; # 1 '# ' ,1!' 0  %'$!-  !" 0  & #*0 .%5,'

20 &.%402;0 2#0 $2 '!&*5 %'4 &!'&: 4 #  '#  ;

.&: . &1 $%/ 2;: -,& 5  .'%'4: <0 .

& $2 ' !* 5 %'4 - ..% # # ,40 .: -,& 5  # 1 '# ' ,1!' 0 .

0,&5 '#*&&,$0:# #,$%!'!"A.#".!-0 %'$!- !"0 # $ !< .#&1 .&!'

'#2%/%'4 E1 '& &0 &5 '.%402; 112% #* G* '/% <!"0  5!/ #%&$,&&%!':'!$ & "!.%' ." . '$ %' 0  "%'#%'4& . $!.# # 5; 0  .%5,'

2 %& - #  !,B 1. & ' 2 %& # /!%#!" ';- .%&B '#& - %&0 . 5;#%&-%&& #* @*  '#%'4 %&$ 22 ' !,& 112%$ %!'& : %" ';: &0 22 2&! & '##%&1!& #!"* )* )* )* )** * * *  J 8  9K J 8  9K J 8  9K J 8  9K

,2& 0%  

 

 

  90 0 .&1 >%'4A.

&!' #(  & !

90 0 . 1!.

52 (  & !