High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18618/2012dismissed

Amir Singh v. State Of Punjab And ANR

2015-04-27Mr. Justice Inderjit Singh10 pages

%&% #'#" &(')'*'#!"

+"%,*"#%

"!#$!%&$'

(" & )&*+ &$$!( , !

-.,/) 1 !+

, ! !

"!'!

-.,/) "

!.$,+ !

,3'

3/ "%"#- .

/ '0*12'#"

#!","# .

#!'&*!'

30**450&(') 4 !", '3"

'*" #!", "%"#,"# 7&'%!

,& "* *'#"* 8

"9& "- ,'%%"*)3 "%,*"# 0:!"

")30%&%,"% ,"

#!","# !'%)""# "'#"*'% 4"'1" #!";

**&"0:

#!&# %%& '3%!:2'&%"# 2"'*:

#!&#

'3,, #& #3 !"'

'%:"44'% *'#"*<

"9& "-<,'%%"*)3 "%,*"# 0:!"

")30%'2# !'%)""

'22 *"* "'# *'3%'%"'

"*4"'1"'* *'3%'%!'4 ,'3 4"'1"'*"9!'&%# #!"%'

")3# "'# #!"%&%,"% ,"

*'%=4"'1"

#!";

**&"> ?

430#!" '2#% #!"2'%"'

"#!'##!","# :'%: ;

'%"

%% %#'# #!" "%,*"#-",'

"#@":'%,4'2"*&*"

%&%,"% 1 *" *'#"*

8!'1 )"");"* 2'%"+ *'#"*

8 %#"

"*&*"

"2# <

'#4 2"#'# '* 70 %#

2#'

*;# '2

'40#!","# :'%'27& ##"* 2!'

" 1 *" (&* "# *'#"* 8

,'%%"* )3 "%% % A&* "0 '

*;# '27& ##'40 #!" ,"# %&)

##"* ' ',,4 2'# *'#"*

"7&"%# "%,*"# # %#'#" !

2" ."':!

4"0#!","# '##'

"*#!"' " %&,"

'&'# <

@:"1"

0 #!" ,"# :'% %#'#"* %"

2" 1 *" *'#"* 8

!","

%&%,"% :"

8#<

:'% "*#)"# "'#"*'%=4"'1" #!";

**&"> % *'#"* 8

"9& " - '* <

"9& "-<01 *":!

2!0#!","

%&%,"% !'%)""# "'#"*'% 4"'1" #!";

**&"'

"%&)("2# '##"

2!'44" " #!", "%"#:

,"# B"'

"*2&%"4 #!","# 2#"*%#!'#"

#!"

'3 # 2" '3,, #& #3 !"'

:'%'

*"*##!","# '*

,& "* %!'1")"",'%%"*2# 3##!", % +&4"< ) &(') 4"

2"%+&4"%0$4& "0'

#!"

"* #'%C#!"+&4"%0:!

2! 1"

%*"#"

'44:'2"%,'

*##!"

%&%,"*"* "

,43"" !

% "# B"'

"* 2&%"4 #!"

,"# & #!"

2#"*% #!'# #!" 51"

"# "

,43"" % '#"* )""

# 21"

"*4"'1" # "3&,#' '9

& ,"

* <

*'3%!")("2# '

"* +&4" #!"+&4"% %#, ' 2"# 1"##!""

,43""%#*"1#" "#

" 51"

"#%"

'*#2 ,"%'#"#!%""

,43""%:!*#'1'

4','

2&4'

&# 4"'1"*&

2" B"'

"*2&%"4!'%'4% "4 "*&,#!"

?"2!(&* "# #!

%& # &3 &',5"

3&*&'&

< 3-$353 &'3/&)&',!

< '*366&3'/ 5"

.'-&+&

. $*&', ( &/ !&,&',&'!

< B+ 80 %&,, # %2#"# % B"'

"*2&%"4 #!" "%,*"#-#'#"%&)

#%#!'##!"

%&%,"% 2'#)"# "'#"*'%*&#3,"

*'%#!","# !'%

"*')%"#

%*&#3)"2'&%" 4* +&*"

"2# <

!","

%&%,"% !'%

!#43)""2% "*'%=4"'1"

#!" ;

* *&"> B"'

"* #'#" 2&%"4 & #!"

%&)

#% #!'# #!"

%&)

%% % '*")34"'

"*2&%"4 #!","# '

"2# 3##!"

"2 *'%#!","# :'% 1"# 2"*'#"*

"#';

'3 *"2 :

#! " '

*#%&%,"% ,"

*'*#!" ",43

4"*)3!

:'% '4%2% "* !""

,43"

:'%#'# '&4#'*:'%#"1"#!"

2 ,4'

'# #!"+2'%"B"'

"*2&%"4'4%%&)

#%#!'# 1 ":

(&* "#% #!

%& #'%:"44'% @C)4"#!","9& #0#!"

,"# %#"# #4"* "'# ,"

%&%,"% '%*&#3,"

* 43#!" &*#!'#!":'%'27& ##"* #!"2!'

"4"1"44"*' '

%# !

B"'

"*2&%"4 #!" "%,*"#-#'#"!'%'4% "4 "*&,#!"

(&* "#% @C)4" #!" ,"9 & # #!" 2'%" 73"

'&6&'

& .'&

3+ &8'

6&5" &

!#& &&"

&&',!

"88< <<'* '3!'!#',3&&',!

"5"&3 &$3'/

%&,, # %2#"# % @"'

*#!"'

& "#%'*1'2"*)34"'

"*2&%"4 ,'

"%'*!'1"'4% "#!

& !#!"*2& "#%'1'

4')4" "2 * +&4" *"'4% :

#! '# '44:'2"% ,'

* # #!"

,43""*&

%&%,"% +&4"<, *"%'44:'2"%# )",'

* "##'%&%,"*"*"

,43""0:!

2! ", *&2"* !"

")"

"4"1'# "%41 #!"2# 1"

%3 * %,&#"- < !" ' 51"

"# "

,43""0 :! !'% )""

%%"*0 1"* 2 ,&4% 3 "#

"*0 %#'#"*'% ' "%&4# ',,"'40 "1 "1 ":0 :&4*!'1")""

% %#'#"*)&# "#

"#%&,"

'&'# :!

&*"

%&%,"% #0#!"'&#!

#32 ,"#"##

"- "#%!'442% '* ';"'%,"2

2 - ' " '

#!",'3'*'44:'2"%#)",'

*##!"

51"

"#"

,43"" #!","

%')%"2"

*&#3 24&* #!" ,"

* %&%,"% 0 , "2"* !

%%'4 1'4 2 ,&4% 3 "#

"#0'%#!"2'%"

'3)"D'* ):!"#!"

##!"%'

*,"

*%!'44)"# "'#"*'%'

*%,"#*&#3 !"

"#!"'&#!

#32 ,"#"## "- "# %

#!'# #!" 51"

"# "

,43""0 :! !'* )""

%%"*0 1"* 2 ,&4%

43 "#

"*0!'%)"" &443 "9"

'#"*0#!"51"

"#"

,43""%!'440%&)("2###!"

, % %&)- &4" 0 )" ,'

* !

% & ,'3 '* '44:'2"%#:!

2!!":&4*!'1")"""# #4"*0!'*!"

# )"" *

%%"*0 1"* 2 ,&4%

43 "#

%&%,"*"*0,

#%&2!*

%%'40 1'4 2 ,&4%

"#0'%#!"2'%" '3)" <#!"

2'%"%0#!"51#"

,43""%!'44)" 1"%&2!

, , %&2!,'3'*'44:'2"%'%%&2!2 ,"#"# '&#!

#3 '3, "%2

)" *"*#!'##!",'3 "# '44:'2"%&*"

%&)- &4"

%&)- &4"<%!'44)"%&)("2##'44#!"

2* %&*"

%&2!'44:'2"%'

"'*

%% )4" *"* & #!"

#!'# %&2! , , %&2! ,'3 '*

'44:'2"%%!'44#)"4"%%#!'#!"%&)% %#"2"'*#!"

'44:'2"%'*

%% )4"&*"

&4" 2'%" '44 &*"

%&)- &4" #!","

')%"2"

*&#3%!'44#)"# "'#"*'%',"

*%,"#*&#3 '44 ,& ,%"% '2'%" '44 &*"

%&)- &4"<#!","

* ')%"2"

*&#3%!'44#)"# "'#"*'%',"

*%,"#*&#3 &4"%%%&2!2 ,"#"#'&#!

#3%,"2

2'443*

"2#%#!'# %!'44)"%# "'#"* '3%,"2

"*,& ,%" *"*#!'#

#!"51"

"#"

,43""%*"%

"%0%&2!

'&#!

#3 '3*

"2##!'##!","

')%"2"

*&#3%!'44 )"21"

#"* #4"'1" '3;

**&"'*'*

%% )4"##!"

51"

"#"

,43"" #!" , "%"# 2'%"0 #!" ,"# !'% "* &*"

%&%,"% )"2'&%" %# 2

'42'%")&#%&)%"7&"#43!"

:'%'27& ##"* #!"2!'

"%)3#!"#

'4& #!","# %24'

#!'##!","

**&

2!!" "*%&%,"*"*)"# "'#"*'%*&#3

* +&4" #!"+&4"%, *"%#!'# 2'%"'351"

"# ,43""' '

%#:! , 2""* %!'1")""

'#"*"

#!"

"%# '2

'42!'

" !" %*"#'

"*&*"

'34':,

, "1"# 1"*"#"# %!&4*)"2% "*'%&*"

%&%,"% '3

* *&

2! !" % *"#'

"* 2&%#*3 % &*"

% "#'* %#'44:"*#* ':'3,'3'*'44:'2"%#!"

#!' %&)% %#"2" '44:'2"0 :!

2! % '#"* '22 *'2" :

#! #!"

,4"%4'

**: +&4" #!"+&4"%# 44

'4224&% , 2""*

'#"*' '

%#!

44!" "4"'%"*

*"#"#

'44:"*# "( %*&#3'*(&%# "# %'44:'2" %&2!,"

* %!&4*#!"

)" '*"'22 ##!"2

2& %#'2"% #!"2'%"@"

%,'

* &44%'4'

3 2'%"#!""

,43"" %'27& ##"* #!"2!'

" # , 1"* #!'# #!"

C% 4 ') #3 '

2& %#'2"% )"3* !

2# 4 #!" *"#"# )"

!"4* )3 #!" 2 ,"#"# '&#!

#3 # )"

&(&%#

"*+&4" #!"+&4"% ", *&2"*'%&*"

- E "

,43"" 51"

"# ' '

%# , 2""* !'1")""#';""

#!"

"%#

*")# '2

'42!'

" :! %*"#'

"* &*"

'34':, , "1"# 1"*"#"# %!&4*)"2% "*'%&*"

%&%,"% '3

*%*&

2!!" %*"#'

"* 2&%#*3 &*"

% "#'*#'44:"*#* ':

'3 ,'3 '* '44:'2"% #!"

#!' '3 %&)% %#"2" '44:'2" #!'# '3 )" '#"*

'22 *'2":

#!#!",

,4"%4'

**: &4"

%&2!,"

*%&# 4#!"

'4#"

, 2""* % #';" ' '

%# !

&# 4 !"

"4"'%"*

*"#"# '*'44:"*# "( *&#30 '%#!"2'%" '3)"'*(&%# "# %'44:'2"

%&2! ,"

*% %!&4* #!"

" '

)" '*"

'22 ##!"2

2& %#'2"% #!"2'%"0#!" &44 &#)"

1"43 #!""1"# #!"

'27& ##"* #!")4'

#!", 2""* #';"' '

%#!

" %'

"%# *")#0 #% )"

, 1"*#!'##!"

C%4 ') #3'

2& %#'2"%)"3*!

%2# 4 #!"*"#"# )"

!"4* )3 #!" 2 ,"#"# '&#!

#3 # )"

&(&%#

"*E !"%# &2#& " #!"+&4" %)& 4#'

&*'27& ##'4

)4'

'42!'

# %, 1"*#!'##!"

'4C%4 ') #3'

2& %#'2"% )"3* !

% 2# 4 #!" *"#"# )"

!"4* )3 #!"

2 ,"#"#'&#!

#3#)"&(&%#

"*!","# :'%'27& ##"* 2!'

" & '*#!"

!":'% %#'#"*22 430#!"

" % '&# 2

!# # 24'

)'2;-:' "% '* #!"

'2 '4 )""

"# #!" ,"

* %,"# &# %"

2" *

%%'40 21 2# #:

44*","*#!" '2#%'*2

2& %#'2"% "'2!2'%" @C)4"#!","9& # #!"2'%" &3 .53,*.

&"&&'3/&) 3)3

,&',!

"5"&

. &)

*"'4#:

#!#!"2'%"

2'&%'44')& : ;

+'('%#!'#'#"4"2#

#3?'

* @":'% 2'& !#:!

4"'22",# )

)")3#!"#

&,# ?& "'&:!

2! "%&4#"*

%%&%,"% '* %# '2

'42'%"@":'%21 2#"* '*%"#"2"* "3"'

)3#!"#

'4& # 2

"2"% ,& %!')4" &*"

&% , % "'* :

#! , %

"1"# #

&,# 2#08!"#

'4& #'27& ##"*#!"@"4,"

#!"2!'

"*' '

%#!

'*!":'% %#'#"*)&#*"

"* )'2;:' "%%&2!2

2& %#'2"%0#!"& #!"4*#!'##!"2

2&4'

%%&"* )3#!" , *"*#!'##!""

,43""2&4*)"*""

"*#)"#

"*#

&44,'3'*'44:'2"% #!","

#!"*'#" '27& ##'4##!"*'#"

430 &6"

3'&*&'&3-$353 &'3/&)4&'&.$ 5"&

.&&"".

0#!" ?"2! #!

%& *"'4#:

#!#!"%'

" %%&" '# 2%"7&"# '4)""

#%'27& ##'4

'42!'

")3#!

%& ##:'%%'

*#!'#

'4 &4" =: ;

,'3> %#',,4 2')4"#2'%"%:!"

"'"

,43""'4#!& !:

# : ; % ;",# ':'3

* %2!'

4')& # (&%#

3 %'4'

3 )3 #!"

'&#!

"% '&4# %#!"!":&4*)""# #4"*#2%"7&"# '4 )""

#%#!

%2'%"0#!"+:'% %#"

"*' '

%#.'#!& ''%%5&,#'

&*"

"2# #!"2#!"#

'4& #C%21 2# :'%%"#'% *")3 #!

%& #)3%#'# #!'##!""

,43"

!'*'*

"2# 4" #!"2!'

&# "4'# %!

, '%#"

'*%"

1'# #!")'2;

&,# 2!'

"% 4& " , %"2&# )

! "#!"2!'

#2&4*)"%'

*#!'##!""

,43"":'%;",#&# : ;)3'2# ,43"

'*#!"

"#!"7&"%# :&4*'

%" '# %'4'

*!":'%*",

1"* ,"

%*&#3'

"1 "::'%#';"

37.)&5"

3&*&'&3-$353 &'3/&)

2'%"% 2

'4'#& "0:!

2!4"'*%#,4 2" '*'* (&* '42&%#*3D '2

'4'*21 2# '2

"2":&4*)"

*",

1'# "

,43"

!#% '1'

#!"%"

2"% %&2!,"

%# )3#!"

:'2# )&#)3''2# #!""

,43""%&2!2

2& %#'2"%0 #!"#!" 3 '&4#)"2 "% "4"1'#%&2!2

2& %#'2"%0#!""

,43"

!'%#!

#*'%#!"'22&%"*-"

,43"" %21 2#"* '27& ##"* %# )4'

" ##)4'

%"4 !"#'#""92!"7&"

2'#4 !#43)"

)& *""* '2#%:!

2!*#

'#" #!""

,43"

2! !'%'32# 4!""

,43"

!'%4"

#!,# )&#43#:'

#'* :'#2! #!""* #!"2

'4#

'4!"4*!

%1 ":!'%)"")%"

1"*)3 #!

%& # #!"2'%" &$+33'/ 5" &

!#&*&'&&',!

43 &3 &$3'/ "%&"

9". &:4 @C)4"#!","9 & #!'%*"'4#:

#!#!" %%&":!"

"#!""

,43"":'%21 2#"*&*"

"2# <

)3#!"#

'4& #)&#!":'%'27& ##"*)3#!"@ !&

',,"'4!"

!"24'

"*)'2;:' "%&, "#

*!" "*&# %"

2"*&"# 141"

"# 2

'42'%"!"

)%"

1'# '*")3@C)4"#!","9& # ", *&2"*'%&*"

- E , %"2&# 0:!

2!&4#

'#"43 "%&4#"* '27& ##'4 %22"

"*:'%'##!")"!"%# )3*",'

"# #%"4

8 !',%*

"#2% % '3'

%"#!"#!"

!'*0

'%'2 F"#!""

,43"" ',&)4 2%"

1'# # 141"*

'42'%"'*

'421 2# )3#!"#

'4& #0 !" "#% '27& ##'4 ',,"'4 %&)%"7&"#430 #!" *",' "# 2'# '3 '"

)" &* '&4#:

#! !'1 ;",#!

&# %"

2"0% 2"#!"4':)4 "%0',"

%21 2#"* '

"2"#)"%;",#&#'*##)" "#'

"* %"

2" %"7&"#430#!" "'%% 1" #!"*"2 "4 "*&, %+'2!!*( !'#& ( !'; "1&,"

#"*"# ""

5&('

'#4"2#

#3?'

*0@

'#' '

H 0+88

I0 #!"',,"44'#%'

"#4321 )&#'

2%'2":

#! "'%')4""%%'%:"44!& !"92",# #';"##!'#,'

# #!" *

"2# "#2'# )" %&%#'

"* '* #!" "%,*"# !'% # )" %#'#"*0

2"0 #!" "'%% #!'# #!" "'

* %2!'

" :'% '22&# #!%"2

'4, 2""* %'*21 2# 430#!"

',,"44'#%'

":"44:

!#%#*"3)'2;:' "%##!"

"%,*"# #!","

*!":'%# %"

2"!"',,"44'#% 2'#)" '*"4 ')4"#,'3 #!","

* :!

2!#!"3 2&4*#'1'

4 #!"%"

2"% #!" "%,*"#!"@ !

& #0 & 1 ":0 2

##"* ' '1" "

0 '44:

)'2;:' "%'4%0:

#!&#'*1"

#'44%&2! "4"1'#'%,"2#% '*2% %%"7&"#430#!" #!"@ !&

% '% #*

"2#"*,'3 "# )'2;:' "%'

"4 ')4"#)"

'* %!"

")3%"#'% *"E 1 ": #!" '2#%'%:"44'%#!",% 4':"9,4'

"* ')1"0

#3 #!"

,& "* " "'# #!","

%&%,"% '%=4"'1" #!";

**&">22 430

# 2#"# % %"*)34"'

"*2&%"4 #!","# '*#!","# )"

*"1 * '3

# %!"

")3*

%%"*

9 :

,('