← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2110/2008allowed

Mukesh Lata v. Dinesh Kumar And ORS.

2026-03-25Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma14 pages



  



   

 



   

  

 !

"# $ %&'&% 

"()(* + ( $ ,&'&% -.

/ / ($ %&0&% Whether only the operative part of the judgment is pronounced? No Whether full judgment is pronounced?

Yes $

 12 3& 3  3

              

 

 ! 

    "#$ % &

''''

3

 & (

)  

      *     +    ,     -.

-/ /--0 *&     % )*  

1  

2 )* 34      (55     

 (600             +         

      ---7# +,   896  

           

 /:

-/ /--5

/

     

    ;      , *&  )*      

     ; *     *  &

3 33   2   32 

 3 "

)              #

        *&  )*  ,   *   )      &    

   *  ,     *      ,

:

      "#$ % & ,   & +  ,  + &*           *&  )*  + &* +   )    &    

 

.

$         ,    

3

2 24 

 3 

<3*    %          Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another 56 % 3)-"

+

)"

!

!

7   ,  ,              # =30     

           

    

      

              

   

     

 

     

 

     

          

 

         !"#$            

 %#  !"&$

   

 &'   !"($       

 



'

31)

       

       *           (+,                 









  

  

-  

   

 

     

      

 $         .  /

 

          

                 *  

 



            



                 32 

         

        (+,          

   (+,                 



 

          

             



        

   * * * * * * 42. )     



    &$          0

 1   $        !2    !(%+ %!

%(

 $

    

  3!4 %'#+

 3!'#!#(

 3!(#'&+

 3 !&&!&(

  3!#&'(+

 



   

  3!!(!((

 35 (''+

 34'!'(

  3(''4+

  >

<3* %    National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. 58 % 3 %7     ,

(55 (5"#  (50   

(600   ,+ #            +  ?

         @ 1A4

     + +  @ 1%4

+  *  

&+  @ 14   *  +           &    

     ?

 ,   @ 1B4 C      +     

+,    D*@ # & ?  & )    D+   # =52. 6  conventional heads

    

   

 7/

8*

    7 %(+++       

  7  !+++++  

   7 !+++++ 

  

        

       

   7/

 0  9 

 





       



   

 

 



 

,

   :    

       6                   

     



 

    

   

  

 

   

  ; 

       

       

  

    

     



   

  

            

  

*

   



        





 

        

    7 !(+++ &++++     7 !(+++  

                

   <

    

   

 )                         

   

 

   



   

    !+,    

 )   

 



  

 



   = = = = = 59.3)   

  (+,   

 





 / 

   &+

     

%

 #+, 

 

&+(+

 * 

 

 (+'+

     !(, 6   

   

 59.4* 







 $ 

   &+,

 



 

   &+

  6  %(,

 

 &+(+

  !+,

 

 (+'+

   



    

 

     59.5.             

           #+#%0> ?  



     59.6. 

         

  0> @ &%/

 59.7 

       59.87   

        





 

     

 7

!(+++7 &++++ 7 !(+++

  

    

  !+,  

 A <3* %     9+

( "

.

(!)"

(*

+- (:

2;+;

/ <!&

()  +

.;

!

=)=")  +  = "!

5 3

'7

+ 3 ".

< "+  !)-"

  "

( :

=;

3)-"

   

  ,+ +          # B216  <

  C  0 8         

  

         

  ;

   

      

 

 *  

D  D  

   



 D     D  D 

 D D  D  

             





 

 

  



    )  

      

       

  



 %!! Spousal consortium   

        

        

    



D  

   

     

 /  D %!% Parental consortium      



              

   D    

   

     

   

     D %!# Filial consortium             

  

 

   6

      

          

  

   

    

      

              22  





     

       3 /    

 

  

E     

 

       

   

 3

/                

   

           

 

  

       

 23 3> 

6  

    

      

  

 

 

* 

       

              

                

 C       

    

    6 6     

    

      

  

   

           

   

  24  

          

 

   D

  D   C  0 8*  



       

          7  &++++      

   

 

    + ,     , 



* * 5-&   +          &   +    ) )*   +    

,   +  ,    



   + & 

(-

$      <3*  %   %  3 > !

;

(;

?"

#&

;( .

(!)"

(*

+- (:

/&@    3 ,'0  *  / /)* ;(!

* ((

>

..A /                "

(

**)(

- (!;( ":

> ( ;

!+  &+    &      *      *&         

 *&,               

$ ,   ?

  +)( !

- (!;(

(/ 9"

);

:

      *&     &      &          & *              * * 

=

/ /)* ;(

"/!

=

+;.:

- (!;( ;!

- "+;

/@ ;

A)./

+)(

"

;!!)"

> ;(9 9;# (

=

> ( ;

+)(; ;* (*

"

9"

);

:

= "!

((

 & <3* %  

()+ ( = "

B) 

/ >:

2!

#& & ?"

+ !=

("& ,

3 %   +    

+    ) ?

  D+  

()+ ( = "

B) 1!

* !

!)-"

  # B!5  *           

           

         

  / "

 

  

 

    



 /

 

         

  

     







    



  

 

  /

 



 

  

   

  

  

   

        

   B

    A  



  

  

 3> 

6 !522 .     

  Vimal Kanwar & Ors. v. Kishore Dan & Ors. (2013) 7 SCC 476        

  Helen C. Rebello v. Maharashtra SRTC (1999) 1 SCC 90   F B!5 



     

  

7  3 07 G !555$!05+F!5550 $!54H*  



                 

  

    

 

            B

    

    

  

       



    

    

 

    0            

   

 3> 

6  



B

     A          

  

     F 0!!!!%#($ B#(<  



       

      



 

 



0 



  

  

   



    

 

 

     

3> 

6  

  



       I

      

0   

       







          



 



 

       

   

   

 

  J    

 0   



                       

         

   

 *

   



     



* 

    



      

  



 6   



      

    

   

   E 9              

   

   

      

        0    

 

 

            C  !#    %+    

 

 

    

  

       

     

    

 

    

   

   

3> 

6  

 K

 

  L   ) 



  

        

      

 

     



            

$

 

  

 



                 

         

 

 

 6



  



    6   

   /         

       

 

    

 

    3> 

6       6 





  6   

      3> 

6  

        

        





  A          

  

 C.

  

 

      

      

   

           



                Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Shashi Sharma & Ors. (2016) 9 SCC 627 and National Insurance Company Ltd. v. Birender & Ors. (2020) 11 SCC 356.A %+ M

  

       



  %!    



      

   

   

   7 !(%&4" 

7 #'%#!"   





   

      

 7 #'%#!" 

   

     (/

&+  * 

          

    )* 

     +  & , +    ,,& *  , ,      )          Rs.4500/> per month

("

       ,     )*   + &

  *  ?

    

+   5---7#   

(:

       ,       * ,           B

    +   * ,    C B?



)   , ;   +  %

 23 

(.

$ ,   , ,*& <3* %   *   D+  

  , ) ,  

'

-.

-/ /--0  +& )

  #                  ## Sr.

No.

Heads45 Compensation Awarded (  &$  :.--7# / C   8(-9  :.-7#1(-9 :.--4 "

   ,     ?

 (7"

 (5.-#1:6.-E(7"4 :

) $  ""--7#1:6.-#(5.-4 :

   .

  &  "

.5 :--7#1""--E(/E64  B

 (.

---7# > C B?

  (.

---7#

 B?

  ---7#  %   :- ---7#

  :- ---7#?(

.

+- (!

;( !&0@'@0C  /)* ;(

 , *& )*  !&%%@C (= (* /

+)(

!&'@%%@0C 0'0%% (5

       *&<3*  % Dara Singh @ Dhara Banjara Vs. Shyam Singh Varma 6  '8% R.Valli and Others VS. Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation  , 3)-"

+

)"

!

!

8@

 

  #      +       

869           +    

     F 

(>

     "#$   % &                  +,   ,  )* , 

  ,      &  D+

)  )*   *        +,

0          

 

)  

   

 *      )* 

(0

<,    &    "#$ % & +  * &             /

  ,  -.

-/ /--0

(6

+

    &    

3





,&'&% !    G   +7#  + H7 G   *  H