M/S Franchise India Holdings Ltd Thr Sachin Marya v. Assistant Commissioner Of Income Tax Circle 3(1) Aayakar Bhawan Sec 17 Chd
!"
#$%" &%$ '(%)"
*
$%)$
%% +,- .
/""%"$
&
%(
$%)$
-" 3-/
'345*, - 6.
1&,
6 +/7/-
'&,# 6.
1&, '345*, - 6.
1&, 8,,/9
&5/* " $:$;
5$"$(
% /<$
-% 9$$
/<$
%% ".<$"% 8))$
/<$
" >>>>>>> 8,,/9
&5/* 6 " %%
0%( $ %"$ $"""" "?%) % @$"%) % AA
%""
A &
B C0 " D/EF
A
= %%4"
$0"$% % : # ;$ 0%( %"
($%) % -"B G !
""
ACF /
$" "( "%;
3
%) $"? %"
"
%0
$(0 $<$%($
"; 0% ?
($ %""
/ #%" &0 $% - C#&-F )$ ()
(%
/0 %%) "% 0%
" (<$ ;$ 0%%) 2""
$% $"
(%?
"%""
%"
<;$ 2""
$<((%) %%<"
%) "% = $ <%"
;$
$ %"$((=$ (
-" ! 3 A
$%" )$ %%4"
$2 (<$ ;$
D8%) "
% $% <% $$ G
<%"%"
$ I+&&
(% =%
$"""" % 0((=%) 2""
<%"%"
$ $(%$ ( -" AG!
-"
!
-"
GA!
-" A
! () $"
2""
$ $<$%($ $"$% =
$"""" J 9%) <%= %0%$ $%
"
$"""" 0 (%$
%"$((= "% AC$FC%$F &
B
$($ "
$"""" "= -" 2""
$;$ (
0 $;
$( K< $<$%($
0
$ $((=$ 2""
!"
A5 &
B %"$%"
"( % -" ! %<(<%) $2 00 -" GB G !
"#"$"%&" $2
$($ " " "%;
"%"
($ $<$"
" ($
(%$ %(%%"
$ 0 $<$%($ /3 @" 2$ % = $;
($ $<$"
"%;
"%"
$
"%""
""
JE 1$0 %"" % AA
A =;
$;
$""""
0=$ $""
<
1;
$
D#
%0 $%
" $"""" !"
#$%" &%$ '(%$;"
*% %
L A
$%)$ %) #M B % 0((=%) 2""
<%"%"
$ $(%$
$""""
/<%" -" AG! - -"
! % 2""
-"
GA! ,< 2""
-" A! 1$( -" A G! "(
%"$((= <%"%"
"% AC$FC%$F $
$?
5
%"$((= / %""% "( % -" A G! <%=
& $"
(%<
% "$
$" 0$%( $ $"""" %"(" (;
0((;
$((
$%$( 0$"E /0 %"%)
B 0%( %"
%""$ $0"$% %
A
) A :
$?) 0$"
) " %% ?? "
%"
$00 (%0" $:$;
5$"$(
% /<$
$$%)
$(0
% % ) %
A
" ) 00%< (;
0
""
;
BB " A
$$ GA ;
ABA
'=<
$ % "(;
(;
% %"
(;
%%%$( """
) % 0%(
% %$(
""
($
<%($% %%("
$$( :"% 0
% (;
($ %%4"
0%(%) $(%$% -%) &0 $%
""
"(% $(( (<$ " <$( A
0
)%< ) $$ GA
$0 "%%)
0 $%
1$0
) ABA
$$%) 0
00%
&
$%)$ $"? )%< $""
=;
$%
$? "$ (;
$0 % 0
%"" ) % AA %%
1"
% ) $""""
%)"
(;
%) $"?
0 $%
0
$ "(
%%%$% ) $""""
%)"
"( (;
%
%?$ 0
$00 ABA <%%$ % %)" "%(( 0
% %%%$( B
$ $0 "$( %( $(( $%($"
2""
%
%(%) 2""
$<%"
%) " =(
" =%( $(% %"
% @$ $(( "
$
1"
) $""""
%)"
"?%) $""""
$"
$% " $(%
$%) ($ "% "(
(;
$) %% %""% ($= $
".<$"% 8))$
/<$
$$%)
$(0 "
% <%($% %%("
$$( :"% $(()
$ %(;
$((= %" (<$ $(( (<$
) $ ($ "$)
"(%
:%
"=
%%
$""""
%)"
:"%0%
%%) ) %%%$((;
=
$;
0 $%
= ) ABA
@"
%"
$ %%"$%< $$%;
)%< $""
=
$
$%%) (;
% "$( 0 % %%
%)(;
$%" " "$%"0$% %"
$ ) % AA
A
%%%$%) $""""
%)"
$)$%"
%""
.
AG
%0 $""
(%< $;
"(
$)$
$2 "$
=(( =%% %"
%)"
%%%$ %)"
"%
($=
%) " $2
'=<
"$%"0$% %%%$ $""""
%)"
%"
=
$" %?$ $
$" "((;
:%"
- %)"
$
%%%$
(;
$) %% 00%
&0
0 %
%% ($%) $""%)
$ (?
$" $) %%
<%= %"
%"%
%% %%%$ %)"
$" = $)%
$%$( /2 &%$ ,$" ="$
%;
+"
&
BGB
B &1BB F
( <%= 2""
%$( $;
& 8$ (;
"% %0 $% %%%$ $""""
%)"
0
$0 "%%) :%
%"
= % %%
0 ( % = %%%$ %)"
$
2%" <"%)
%$<
%"$? %"
$ =%( $""%)
&
8(%
+"
9(<%$ &%$ *
&1- F
=%( %%) ="
D$"
(%<E "% AG
/2 ( $
$) %% $?%) %"%%
= = <%= $""""
/2 ( = <%= '=<
= $""""
<% " $""""
$) %%
$" " $)%
$%$( "
%"
% $0
$
=0 $%<"
$ ("%
"$ 0
$" &&& ' #%$ *
+"
/""%"$
&
$2 $
A C5 F
8%<%"% 5 5
$;
'%) %
AG
(%) D = (
AG
"= /""""%) 300%
%0 $"
(%< $;
$)$ $2 "$ $;
;$ '=<
%"
(%0 "$
$"$
(%0 /""""%) 300% % "(0 $
%% $!
(%0 " $%; 0$
$ &%$ ,$" ="$
%;
<
&
= 8(%
B &1- $) BB ( = "$
"
%
/""""%) 300% % "(0 /""""%) 300% $
(%(;
0((= %% $%;
" $%<%) $
(%0 "$ " 0$"
=(
% $""
;$ G
%$% $ %%$( :% $%;
BB
$""
(;
$;
$)%
$%$(
(;
%% 2%"%)
$%$( $($;
1%"
%"(0 %%$"
% $(%$%
%
/""""%) 300%
0 %"" ) % 3 %"
) $(
$"" % :%"%%
/""""%) 300% $
0$( G '=<
%""%"
$ %"""
= $ 2$ %%)
$(" "( "%% ($= =
0 2%;
0 ;$"
0
(<$ ;$
" $""
= <;
=% '=<
< ) " = <;
=% ; " = =( :"%0;
<%= $($;
$""
$
& < 9(<%$ C&%$F *
&1- $) "< = $""""
$((;
%00 0
= <%= /""""%) 300% "$% (;
= $""""
0(0%(( $% %% $ (;
" $"
(%< "$
"
$)%
$%$( ("% "$ 0
/2 $% )$
%) <%= "( $? ($ 1%"
0((=%) /2
$ $%% &%$ * < /( &1 A &1- G ( < = $""""
=%% 0 ;$"
0
(<$ ;$
"
$"
(%< "$ " $"
(%< "(
$) %% 10
= 0$"
<%= %) %)%$( %)
$"" " $""
%) 0$"
=% $;%)
=(
<%= % )$
$""""
1%"
=(
$) %% " $;
$)%
$%$( "00%% $"" :%"%% %"" ) % 0$
$ &$ ((($ * < 8;
& $2 &1AG ( $((
$%$( )$ $%($ %""
0 /""""%) 300% ""
$(
$
"$% $(% %"
% $((
$%$(
0 % #
"<
#(( 5 8(% '%)
$ &1 < 9(<%$ &%$ * - &1-
= %
$%$( ($
0 /""""%) 300% $ % %)%$( $"""
ACF " % $
$%" $(% %"
% $(( 0$"
%<(< 1 00 8%<%"% 5 :) %"
$ 5$?
$%$($ +"
&
G &1- B 3 $(;%) "( %%("
($= 0$"
" $"
= $ %% "<"
(%0 50 %)%$( B $""
(<$ $""""
"; 0%
3 "$( 0%%) 2""
"= %
= $ <%"
;$
%)
" ( "
% -" !
3 A
:% $%" @$ 00 @%
@$ 2""
$<%"
% "<%"
< 2""
1"
<%"%"
AC$FC%$F " 2""
(%$
%"$((= $
$?
$""""4"
3
=
0 $%
) ABA @" "((
$""
%) $;
$% :%"
)%" ABA
$"
D9%(;
0 ;
$%) B GA :
% < :%
$%"
&/ /%"
% <%"%"
"% I+&&5
(% =%
1"
0((=%) 2""
$ (%$
%"$((= $
$?
!"
AC$FC%$F &1 /
1 /<%" -" AG! 1 -"
! 1 % 2""
-"
GA! 1 < 2""
-" A! %"
)$
; $ @" " ;
= :% $$
&0
$""
0 %0 ;"
; $ @" ?%(;
" $% "))"
$?E C, $"%"
"(%F "
%?$
($%) %%%$% %)"
$)
%"
(;
$""
0
00%
' % % %
%%%$ %)"
$""""
( 0%" $""
%$ %"
%"% $ $" )$%) $$ (;
"%0%$((;
" %""
00%4"
"" "%( %"
%"" 2 "$%) %0
";
' $ %(;
" $;
$%%) %""
"%
%"
$ %%"$%< $$%;
=(( =%% %"
%)"
$"?
%"
%$
$?
%"
$% $""
= 0 ($?%)
"%$((;
= "
$%
$ $;
$%
$""
<%"%"
($= /0 % @
$$(;
= $%)
""%
$ )
%$% BA $""
=%) $ $%%) "%
)$ 2""
""
$ % ($" $;
"
"(%
=%) ) GA 2$ %$% 0
0$
@%
($= 2""
%
=$"
$<%"
% "<%"
< 2""
1%"
%0 $% =( D$)%
$%$(E
0 %
$ % = %)%$(
$
=0
%) $""
($ "(%
$""""
%)"
%%%$
$;
$ % 0$ %) %)%$(
0
)
"; 0% ?
($ %""
%%
1%"
0$ =( % =$"
"$ 0
$2 5$"$( ($ ") (%$
ACF
"$"
" $
1%"
=<
($% % "
" ($%)
5$"$( =<
%"
"
" " % $
0"
$;
@% $2
$ "
' (% %
G $"
D ' C$F $"""" (% <%"%"
$ I+&&5 )$%) % $2 $ " )$%) $;
0 % $( K<
3
M"!
&0 <%"%"
$ I+&&5
(%
($" )%< 0((=%) $%(">
$ (;
/ C%F % $ $(( C%%F
0$(( ("" % $ @%
C%%%F ($ C%<F
$% % $( K< ($" )%< $%("
$""
< C%F C%<F <E 5$"$(
0
%"
"
" %% $2
$ " 1" 0"
0$ " $" %)
$"= @;
$ %
GC$F %)(;
"$;"
D3E
5 $"= @;
$ %
GC "$;
D/E % $(%$ (
1%"
$(;
%
%"($%)
=%(( $"" %%4"
$0% ""%
$(%$ (
0$ $%"
=<
$"= %
/ $"""" =
$?"
% "$
$%
;
$ $ "$;
"$ 0$"
$2 0
( %"< % "$
<
( ()%% $(;
)
%"
"$
< " $;
% $2 %"$
$; "% 0
@"% $"""" $;%) % $%" ($ <%($% %%("
$$( :"% $%"
$(0
"
"% (;
:
$ % "%% % %" (<$
0 0%( %"
%%%$% $""""
%)"
,< =%"
%
$"?
$ $<$%($ -%) &0 $%
"= $;
:% %"
) <%=
=% %%
%) =% $;
%
%"
%""
()*+ , )
( -)., "$ " $"!"$?%) M"
!
$ M"
!