Somwati v. State Of Haryana & ORS

   

       

!"#$#%&'&()
 *+,!"& #"&"&(#- '

.#-'/'

*"!"#!-0!(!!($"1#-'

#'2($#(" '

)  34  * 5 4*  -#'#(")6 -*5!$!78$7%!"#8-"1#2#"&"&(#- -!7##(*1#-!(8#2/"0 !-0!(!  1#"1#-"1##2-"#-'9%!9(#,'2!2#-+!0:#!99,#$" '##"1#;/$<+#("=
 :#-##--#$""1##2-"#--("  1#"1#-"1#;/$<+#("'1/9$:#-#2-"#$&("1#$&<#'"= 66 66 4* 

4 *+,!"&62#"&"&(#-  1!'  '/<1"  "1#  &''/!(%#    !  ,-&"   %#-"&-!-&->/!'1&(<"1#&+2/<(#$-$#-$!"#$?
 ((#@/-#66A 8 ,1#-#:0  "1#  %9!&+   "1#  2#"&"&(#-  -  %+2!''&(!"#  !''&'"!(%#  ,!' $#%9&(#$("1#<-/($"1!""1#",'('"1#2#"&"&(#-!-##!-(&(<' 8 62#-+("1#!%18"1#-#-#8'1#&'("#("&"9#$"&(!(%&!9!''&'"!(%# /($#-"1#!-0!(! @6<-!"&!&(!(%&!9''&'"!(%#""1##2#($#("' #%#!'#$ 7#-(+#(" +290##'/9#'8
?  -'1-"3"1#/9#'
?3  1#/($&'2/"#$!%"'"1#%!'#!-#"1!"*/:#*&(<181/':!($   "1#  2#"&"&(#-8  ,!'  ,-B&(<  !'  !  10'&%!9  -!&(&(<  ('"-/%"-  ,&"1 -#'2($#("6 $/%!"&(#2!-"+#("'&(%# 
?  1#'!&$*/:#*&(<1 ,!'  "  -#"&-#  (  
8  :/"  /(-"/(!"#90  1#  $&#$  &(  1!-(#''  ( C
? 1#-#!"#-8"1#2#"&"&(#-!229&#$-#@6<-!"&!%+2!''&(!"# &(!(%&!9!''&'"!(%#(
 
!'2#-"1#/9#'
?*&(%#(

6
6 -#'2('#,!'-#%#&7#$8"1#2#"&"&(#-!22-!%1#$"1&' /-":0,!0&9&(< "1#,-&"2#"&"&(&# 
AA
8,1&%1,!'$&'2'#$:0"1&'

/-"87&$#-$#-$!"#$ 

8,&"1!$&-#%"&("-#'2($#("'"2!''! '2#!B&(<-$#-1#-#!"#-8"1#2#"&"&(#-1!$"&9#%("#+2"2#"&"&(&#

?DA
 !($(90"1#-#!"#-8!'2#!B&(<-$#-$!"#$?


((#@/-#66A  ,!'  2!''#$8  $#%9&(&(<  "1#  #@6<-!"&!  %+2!''&(!"# !''&'"!(%#("1#<-/($'"!"#$!:7# ("1#-#290!9'8"1#*"!"#1!'"!B#("1#'"!($"1!"'&(%#", '('"1#2#"&"&(#-!-#<#""&(<+-#"1!('8 62#-+("1#!%1-+ "1#+&9&"!-0'#-7&%#8"1#-#-#8"1#2#"&"&(#-&'("%7#-#$/($#-/9#A "1#'!&$/9#'
?!($8"1#-#-#8'1#&'("#("&"9#$"#@6<-!"&! %+2!''&(!"#&(!(%&!9!''&'"!(%# 1!7#1#!-$"1#9#!-(#$%/('#9'-"1#2!-"&#'!($1!7#!9' %!-#/990<(#"1-/<1"1#&9# 1#  #@!+&(!"&(    "1#  /9#'   
?  -#9!"&(<  "  "1# %+2!''&(!"#  !''&'"!(%#  '1,'  "1!"  "1#  /9#'  2-7&$#  -  #@6<-!"&! !22&("+#(" ( %+2!''&(!"#<-/($ -#@6<-!"&! &(!(%&!9 !''&'"!(%#

($#-"1#'!&$-/9#'8&(%!'#"1#!22&("+#("(%+2!''&(!"#<-/($&' ("'/<1"8"1#!+&90&'#("&"9#$"#@6<-!"&!&(!(%&!9!''&'"!(%#""1#"/(# '?88 6/9#
&& -#!$'!'/($#-)6 E
 @@@@@@ @@@@@@ @@@@@@

& @@@@@@ @@@@@@ @@@@@@

&& #@6<-!"&!%+2!''&(!"#&(!(%&!9!''&'"!(%#""1#!+&90 "1#$#%#!'#$87#-!($!:7#!99"1#-'#-7&%#:#(#&"'8":# 2!&$F'?9!%'8&(%!'#',1#-#"1#!+&90"1#$#%#!'#$ $#'  ("  2"  -  #@6<-!"&!  #+290+#("  -  ,1#-#  (  '/%1 !22&("+#("%!(:##-#$,&"1&(!2#-&$"1-##0#!-'-+ "1#$!"#+!B&(<!(!229&%!"&(:0"1##9&<&:9#$#2#($#("

66 +#+:#-"1#$#%#!'#$ 7#-(+#("#+290##G- @@@@@@ @@@@@@ @@@@@@H /9#A"1#'!&$/9#'
?2-7&$#'-#9&<&:&9&"0/9#A "1#'!&$/9#'
?&'-#2-$/%#$!'/($#-)6 EA 1#%-&"#-&!-#9&<&:&9&"0/($#-"1#'#/9#''1!99:#!' /($#-)6

!

1#!+&90&' &($&<#(" !($ $#'#-7#' &++#$&!"# !''&'"!(%#  -  -#9&#  -+  &(!(%&!9  $#'"&"/"&(  !($ $#2#($#("  /2(  "1#  $#%#!'#$ +&''&(<  7#-(+#("

#+290##

1#+("190&(%+#"1#!+&90'1!99("#@%##$ '8 62#-+("18-+!99'/-%#'"1#-"1!(!+&90 2#('&( -"1&' 2/-2'#8"1#&(%+#"1##("&-# !+&90"1#$#%#!'#$ +&''&(< 7#-(+#("#+290## ,&99:#"!B#(&("!%%/("!($(";/'""1#&(%+#"1# $#2#($#("  ,1  1!'  !229&#$  -  !22&("+#("  ( %+2!''&(!"#<-/($'

% 1#!229&%!("-!22&("+#("'1/9$:##9&<&:9# !($  '/&"!:9#  -  "1#  2'"  &(  !99  -#'2#%"'  /($#-  "1# 2-7&'&('"1#-#9#7!("-#%-/&"+#("-/9#'

$ 1#-#'2/'#"1#$#%#!'#$ +&''#$ 7#-(+#("

#+290##&'!9-#!$0&( 7#-(+#("'#-7&%#8("1#- $#2#($#("+#+:#-'1!99:##9&<&:9#-!22&("+#("- #@6<-!"&!%+2!''&(!"#&(!(%&!9!''&'"!(%#

# !--&#$'("1#$#%#!'#$ +&''&(< 7#-(+#("

#+290##,&99:##9&<&:9#(90&("1#-+#+:#-"1# !+&90&'#9&<&:9#- 7#-(+#("'#-7&%#!($1&''2/'# &'  ("  !9-#!$0 &(  7#-(+#("  '#-7&%#  !($  /(+!--&#$ #9&<&:9#$#2#($#("&'(",&99&(<";&('#-7&%#!($<&7#' !(!&$!7&"""1&'##%"

 1#  2-#'%-&:#$  #$/%!"&(!9  >/!9&&%!"&('  !($ 9,#- /22#-  !<#  9&+&"'8  '1!99  ("  :#  -#9!@#$  - !22&("+#("

< (%!'#"1#$#2#($#(""1#$#%#!'#$ +&''#$

7#-(+#("#+290##&'("#9&<&:9#-!22&("+#("( !(0<-/($+#("&(#$&(%9!/'#' % !($  "1&'-/9#8 "1#!+&90+#+:#-'1!99:#<&7#(#@6<-!"&!!''&'"!(%# '?9!%'H 1#-#'2($#("'&("1#&+2/<(#$-$#-1!7#!229&#$%9!/'# /9#A"1#'!&$/9#'
?8,1&%1&'-#2-$/%#$!:7# 1# 2#-/'!9'!&$%9!/'#'1,'"1!"&""!9B'!$#2#($#("8,11!'!229&#$- !22&("+#("  (  %+2!''&(!"#  <-/($   "  $#'  ("  "!9B    #@6<-!"&! &(!(%&!9!''&'"!(%#8,1#-#!'"1#"1#-%9!/'#'"!9B!:/"#9&<&:&9&"0-#@6 <-!"&!%+2!''&(!"#!22&("+#("!9'  9!/'# < %9#!-90'1,'"1!"&( %!'#8"1#$#2#($#(""1#$#%#!'#$ 7#-(+#("#+290##&'("#9&<&:9# -!22&("+#("(!(0<-/($8+#("&(#$&(%9!/'#' % !($  /9#A "1#'!&$ /9#'
?8"1#!+&90+#+:#-''1!

99:#<&7#(#@6<-!"&! &(!(%&!9!''&'"!(%#'?88 6("1#+!""#-#@6<-!"&!&(!(%&!9 !''&'"!(%#8    (  #9&<&:&9&"0    "1#  &(%+#    "1#  !+&90  &'  2-7&$#$ 1#-#-#8  "1#  -#9&!(%#  (  /9#  A :    "1#  '!&$  /9#'   
?

+&'%(%#&7#$!($+&'&("#-2-#""#$:0"1# -#'2($#("'8,1&9#2!''&(<"1# &+2/<(#$-$#-

('#>/#("908  "1#  2-#'#("  ,-&"  2#"&"&(  &'  !99,#$   1# &+2/<(#$-$#-$!"#$?
 ((#@/-#66A &'1#-#:0>/!'1#$1# -#'2($#("'  !-#  $&-#%"#$  "  2-7&$#  '  ?88 6  #@6<-!"&!  &(!(%&!9 !''&'"!(%#  "  "1#  2#"&"&(#-8  &(  "#-+'    "1#  !-0!(!  +2!''&(!"# ''&'"!(%#""1##2#($#("'#%#!'#$ 7#-(+#(" +290##'/9#'8
?8!'-#2-$/%#$!:7#*&(%#"1#&(!(%&!9!''&'"!(%#,!'!229&#$&( 2-&98
8"1#-#-#8&("#-#'"!""1#-!"#DI2#-!((/+'1!99:#2!0!:9# !"#-"1-##+("1'8&#'"!-"&(<-+C
"&992!0+#("1#%+29&!(%# "1&'-$#-:#+!$#,&"1&("1-##+("1'-+"1#$!"#

6?6 -#%#&2"%20"1&'-$#- 

4*   


 ';B' 1#"1#-'2#!B&(< -#!'(#$ ) #' 1#"1#-#2-"!:9# ) #'