High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13021/2014dismissed

Balwant Singh v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2018-02-05Mr. Justice Arun Palli35 pages

! "# $

&# '(&)&()

##### *+

") ",-.

! "# "

# $%## %## &#

" ## '( )) '*)+ ,-&-

) .

" # " # */ *( '*)' )'

'*)+ # # " # " 0" ## # '1 *+ '*)1,&-

! ## ! #*'

*1 '*)1,&- 1. # # #+ '2,. 0 % " "

3 )4 0 )3+1 , . " (( '/ )'

'*)+ #" +* *2 '*)1 +# '

" 0 " % )/ *1 )3/4 " # % )( *4 )343 &

*+ *'

'**'

)* *2 '*)*

"# &% #*/ *( '*)')'

'*)+ -" 565565 57

& #'+ *( '**()'

'*)+

&% 5 "

565 565 ## "&% 57

" # &% " - +

"&%

# #

" !#

!#! #

# # )/ &%#

# # #

" +* *3 '*)+

%## &#

, +.

*3 *) '*)1,&-

'. # # # "

#89

(

# " #" # &% ! # %## &-

#! " # " '

) '*)1 #

;! 7 &% <#" # &$$

" " # #

9 $ " # &% 0 8 9 0 &-

+ " :

" # '* *+ '*)1 "=## $ #! $% = # #

" ! #! #

$% =

# , ! $% = # # #" 4 )) '*)+

> % =&#

" #" 3 ) '*)1 # & " # 8&"9 "# " '( )) '*)+ $ # #- "# ! ? 6"# == " " # # #

" "

++=& 0 " # &%

# #

- " ## '/ *+ '*)1,&-

(. %## $%## 5- " ((

" >

1 /

%! ? "

$ $%##

# '+ )* '*)+ "#

" 8 # # "9

%## ## (( " #

" 3 )4,).,. 0 )3+1 .

% @ < A "

" "# #" # # "

" # ! " # "&% " #

@ A - # " # # (( # " 6"# 3 )4,'. 0 )3+1 , .

0 #

% )01 !- ") ",-2)

"4 - 1!

,%B 4)+4'*)' )( *) '*)1.

# " 0 # # $ " > # %

7 # 0 # $ " % ) 1 "4 1) ",-2 )

"4 - 1!

)33(,1.%/2* "5 1) ",-2)

"4 - 1! '**3,).%2'(

# "

#@ < $ & &"6 # # )4 # 6"# ((# # # '(5! "

),.

# #'(5 ! " #

6 " " 6"#

" # (( " # +# "

)3 )4

# # " + '2,. 0 % " "

) )

))

> # # " " $ " % " ((" 6"# ! 0 # 57 * + 2)

"4 - 1! '**/,).%'44 - ,8 " !!2)

'**),+.%'3)

0 # * !-2)

"4 - 1! '*)',).%//* )'

" # 6"#

= #&-

1 " " 6"# ! (( #3 )4

" :

% 8:%

1 ", ;

"! " ,). ?

,. # #" #

! " " # C , . #

,'. # D! " C ,.

(( " # # 5 C ,.

((

" # 5 :

" " " "#

6"#" (( &

" 6"#"

((

,'. 6 # " " 6"## 7 " " # " D! " " & # # # #

,).

# - - "

, . # # # #

D" ##

## " " C , . # "

?' "! # # # # # # #

6 # " " 6"#

6"# 0 # # #

?+ "

" # ;

# 9 # "+ '2 0 % " " , ) .

8+ '2,.;- " "6"## #" #

# " #- - # #

----- ----- ----- ,.

6"# # % 6"# # " # # # 5

, .

% %

6"# " " C , .,.

" , .

% %

" 6"#" " C "

" ## A " 6"#" " "

" ## A " "

- # " &## - " # " "

- # #

C 6"# # ## # # "

& 6"# # 6"### " # # "

, .

" 6"#" " C , .,.

" C , .

" 6"#" " C "C

# 6"# #

----- ----- ----- ? + % ,. , . ,., . 6"## # # # " B 6"# # # "

# " #

----- ----- ----- ?/ # # ,.,. " - - 9

G# " 3 )4 # %:

, .

# " # # '( " # # # ,.

)C , .

# # # '( " " 6"# #

'C , .

(( " " #

#,.

)C , ".

# # (( " " #

# #,.

)

# "

), ## ,.

6"#" (( & #

" 6"# " # # (( " # # #

" # # '(" # '( " "!

3 )4 # # #'(! " ((

H " #'(" (( #

# '("

# 6 # " 6"#

7 (( " #

#= # 6"# )(

) # (( 5 #5 # ,"

# # .

H % # # ((,+# # ((." 6"# !

# # '(" 6 ## " 6"# # '( "

' =

# '(" (( " " ? " '*'( = #'("

1((* "4)+ " 5# 5, (4 .

" (( " # #" #- ##+ # " " " " #" ,+. # #= "

# #@ A " #

$ " 6"# # " #

)/ ?

)3 )4

' # # 6 8 6 9

" - # (( # # " 6"# !

" " 6"# # # ((! )4

B # " - 0 # # # (( #= # " '( 3 )4 & 3 )4,). 6"#" ((

" 6"# " " #

#= ((

" #'( " ,.

) " "

/ ## # ! =

# # # ,.

)3 )4 " " ,.+ '2 % " "

= # '(" ((

3 )4 # '( " " ! 6"# " " # 6 ,# 6"#. # C (( ! " 6"# ! " " # )3 + '2 0 % " " ,

. % 6"##6"#

# " # +# , " #+# 5 .

" % %

6"#" # # (*

6"#"" +( 6"#" " +(

((

3 )4

+ '2,. % " "

6"## (*((, # . # '(" " 6"# 6

(( " !

% " " " " 6"#" ! 6"# # '(! " (( =

" ( +'

&, . 0

% " "

, .

" " 6"#

6"##

= #'(" ! '*

" "# %

# " # - $ " % ,. 3 )4 + '2( +',&. ( +',. 0 % " " , .

# ((

# &%

& )- *!- 1) ",-2)

"4 - 1!

'**4,'.%2)2 $ " 3 )4 # # (( # # 0 " " # # &%

, &# . # # " (( " &% $ " # "

(( " &%

') &

" 0 #

0 #*/ )* '*)2 %B (2*''*)(

" 0 #

> & /'('*)1

# $ " )1 *) '*)( & 0 # $ " # # "

" " 6"# A ! # %! #

> ,%. )/31('*)( # # " # # 0 #

%# 0 # &"

# # '("

" (( # "

# #! # "

"# 0 # 0'(" ((

,. $ " I

# 0 # ((

0 # ## '("

0 ## $ "

0 # "

" "

%# $ " 0 #

# >" 0 #C 0 #$ "

,. "

$ " > &

# 0 # 0 # " 0 , B 5. "

) 44- *)

+ ", ;;

& - !-

'*)),).%%231 ! 0 # " 0 # 0 0 # " 0 #

8 % ?# # "-#

> " 9 #89 # # # ; ""

- 8! 9 "

" % & )1) %

# #

!" # $%

,1 ; . '2: &

(& )

, '3/ 34 (/4. # :

& " # " 0

'3< /'3:&; +**.

+* >

# C " # "

: > 6% $*

! "

D "

- #

% + , $ * "

":,%% '214.

8- J # # # # #

% 0 # % .

$ "

% ": 8/ #

# 0 "# " " ! # & 0

A % A

# " :,0

++%% +'*)*.

J 0 # " " )1,). )1,'. & 0 # # # # # *

# )1,).,'. & 6

)

% 0 # % # " # % %% ))* ":,%% (*+ *1.

%&'(

)& )*

+ , -

. !

# $ % *

/ 0 +

, &* &*$

)2 3

, &* &*$ 1

+ 1

4 5 #

,,,

, 1

, ,

)2 3

,/ ? " 0 # 0 #%

" !0 #

%B (2*''*)(

$ " 0 # $ "

" #

" " 0 # )'4)'3 " "8% 0 9 !0 # '2

- " 0 # !0 ##!

" " !0 # " " 0 # # ! 0 # " 0 #

5 " 0 #

! 0 #

" 0 # $ "

0 #

$ " 0 # !0 #

3 )4 '/

%# # >

# " 0 # $ " %

- 0 # # % 07"- ** 42)

0 +

'***,2.%%+/* >" # #

#%" ",> . " # # &-%

# > ,%. )/31('*)( > >" # 0 #

" #%

5#"

0 # %

- #

/ 8)'

# # " " # 0 # " # B 0#" #

" " 0 7 # # #

" # " " # 0 - # 0 #

" " "

0 - #% & )+')+2 % & )+')++)+1" & )+2 0 #%

0 #% 0 " ## " " " 0 " " 0 # % & )+2 "# " " 0 & )+2 " - ##" C # % 0 # #

0 A ?

C " #% " 0

- 0 % & )+2 % :6

" C 6 # " 7)2 #%# - & )1( % ----- ----- -----

# :

, .

" " # ## " # ## #

# " #

, .

0 & )+2 % " " ## "

" "

, .

# " # 0 - # 0 # # " # 0 " # # K & )+2 % #%#"# # 0 #

- 0 -

% 0 " # #

, ".

& "#

# & "

& # % - ,".

" " # G # #% # & )1) % " #%

! 0 #% &-% # # # %0 " # % 0 ! ," .

7 " 0 #% " # C # "# # #

," . 7 "

" " " #% 0

% " "

,). )71/% % ,&# " 0 #.

-# " &

% # >"

%50 # 0 # # # >" # % "

> # # %

5 0 # %, $ " . C " 5 0 # " "

" 0 #,

. 1 0 #,. '4

%! # # # = ((# "# 6"# #3 )4 0C

" # # = = #'(" " 6 , " 6"#.

%# # ((

& " &%

#*/ *( '*)')'

'*)+ 5 ="

= 5 " &% ! ,

-&-

). " " # 5 5 # " = = " @ A # &% #! ## #

" &% " # "

" !# > # # # # # #! # #

# # $ %## %## &% C "# " +*

" # &-

' , "

( ".

! " %## &%

-# , %## . # # "

7 %## # # # $%## "

#- " #

# !

- # # 5 ""# ! # " "

- "# &% $ %## " # 0 " " " " "" # " # # # %## ## $%## &-

+ "

# # # " " " "# #

# "# 0 +'

" $%## %## 5#

" # # &% # # #

? #

0 " # % - #

"# # "

# ? # " " " - ! " 0 " &% ! 0 - "#

%# # (( 0 "&% 0 # #% 97"

- !

"4 " - 12-

& +

1. 1 ;

"4 " - ,)33'.'%%'33 #%

8, .

&# # # # #

# " , .

6"##

6"# " # 0 " "#

, .

0 " - # # # 0 - B

% %-# # # , $, . " ,. L # ! "# C

, ". 6"#, " %## # . " " # L # ##

= " " 6"#" #

"# # # # # , .

,".

& # # ! %# ## " # # 9 +1

& !0 #, #%. 41 "

-2

2 1"* "

* + 47 ,'**4.4%%+*( " # # #

# # ## # # "#

"" 0 # 5 " 5 , (4,(.%% .

# $ " % 2 "4 1) ",-2)

"4 - 1!

'*)),1.>')* # # # &%

)4,'. 3 )4,).,. ((

& 0 #$ " )

2 ( + 07* 17;

)33+,1.>/*'

#% )

2 *7"

)- "9 1& !-1

,)33/.1%%/ ) , & % 6"# # 0 # & # (( ,.

-# # 0 # $ " 0 #

$ 0 # #% " " "4 2<307* 1

9 ,)33(.2 %%11' 7, +- "41 ) 2)

> 1%%(3 #

" &% !

'# # " # # # # # # (( =

# &-

1 # # # "

(( " ! +2

" # &-

1 " # &% &-

) 0

%! #

13$.

% =&()>

) =M H=? '

B M H=?