High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12341/2015dismissed

The Punjab Pvt Self Financed Dental And Medical Colleges Association v. State Of Punjab Etc

2015-10-14Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari36 pages

!" #$ % & &'" $

#!()$ *) + "',--.

$ % % "

& '

% ( % % ") *+, - % % ") .

/ % % ") ,--.+ "

" -" ") ,1

%! 2 % % / 3 ,5*6

7 6+4

/ & ,5*6

& - 8(221,5*6% / "

" ,9 ,5*6 7 .

& -

") 01:

- /& ; & /

- " *55< "

" - & - & % "" - " 1 / & &

" & '

/ - "" 8(221 ,5*6 " & %/ &"

& % ; ;

" " 1 ") *1 ,6 , ,5*6 7 *

& " = 2 8 > 7 &

: "- 1 ,5*6 / " - ? ,6 .

,5*6 7 ,

" % ") *

@ " ) 01'

- = %

;

A :

-B @ 8(221,5*6% / / -) ' 27 & %)/ 8 8 %)/ 65< ? " "

/ - 8

A8B

= 2 8 ! & % 7 ;

% ,554

A,554 B

" 6 7 , / & &&65<& ;

& ; / 05< - 81

") .

8 & % & / " &

" &

% %

' 7 & " & ") 01:

- ( & / "

/ " @ *, " ,3 % 65< / & &>&

- ? / *6< )!8 ? "

/ /

% &"

,5*6/ %/ *5 ,5*6 ,9 ,5*6% 7 .

/ - " ) 01

- & & -? 8(221 ,5*6 & % / "" 7 & ? -% &

& ; '

- & %* ,5*6

7 0 %

&/ - / &

&8(221,5*6&

% & / "&

" &

'7 & " & @> "

- ? / - " ) , 3 ,5*6% &

%/ & /

-/ "" / -

") 01:

- / & ; &

" ) , ? "

" -% - " " "

,554 %

& & - -

& ? - 7 & "

% &" 8/

& - %

& "

/ &"*5 ,5*6 " =C "7 8

& / ""

? - "

7 &

D ,5*6 7 !*

1 / " /

&" & 8 ** ,5*6 ") 01:

-/ % % &" "" ,* ,5*6 8 "-% & - 8 D ,5*6

& * ,5*6 0 ,5*6%

/ (( %

;

& "

$& (" %

" % ( & % &

% / ** &&

*5 ,5*6%

& - / /

/ - " / ; &

7 !0>D "

&& 2 /

& / && - ! / " " / % 0+"1 - 2 # "

- "3 / & " "" , ,5*6 / " -=C "7 8 " % " ; /

-- "65< ? 65< & & / " - " " - *5 ,5*6

& ( &

& * ,5*6 " & & & &

' &" /

" / "

& 8 " 8 :

-/ -"

$ % % " - & " "

" ,6 .

,5*6% " 1 / / & / & &&65<& ; & %- " & ; '7 & !

! % ,55D/ " & & & & ; ' ! & &

! ( % - "% ' " & / / ?-

/ &

0!', - # "3 8 ,4 .

,5*6 27

&& / ?

/ % *903

- " ) , / / " & /

/ & % & - " 1 % / ? 8(221,5*6

& ; '

/ " ) 0 & "

E 8

& *5 ,5*6% 1 ' " & " / & "

- & 7 ,

& * ,5*6 / 8 ! % ,55D "

& "

,554 & / " - "

% /

" 8

? % ,6 .

,5*6 7 , ;

& #1 , ( "

- = %

; @ &

8 ( > 2 27 & 1,5*6 8(22>8(221, 5*6 - ) ' 27 & )/ 8 8 % )/ 65< F 7 &

: "- " "

/ -8>8

= 2 8

! & % 7 ;

,554 GGGG GGGG GGGG GGGG GGGG 8(22>8(221,5*6

-1&1 ;

7 & / 7 &

>>( "& > "5 6 "

1 / ""

-= + & -H % ( 8

8(22>8(221,5*6 -) ' 27 &

8 8 % )/ > 7&

: "- 8

& ( - & && 65< & ;

8(22>8(221,5*6 =/ % " %

;/ % & && & ; 05< -8>8

/ &

& && & ; "

8(221 ,5*6% ( & / 8% & - % / & && & ;

=/ %

&8(221,5*6&

% &

% & / &

" &

% %

7 & " & '

- =

; GGGG GGGG GGGG GGGG GGGG *, ( /

8 / - @ GGGG GGGG GGGG GGGG GGGG ,3 8

8 /

# ( F 1 65< &>

- F 1 65<

*6<)!8F ;

=/ % ? &

- / GGGG GGGG GGGG GGGG GGGG

.5 & , )!8

""- &

-':= & & :

- /

/ - "

( + :

- "

" "

/ " - / 7 / '

- = %

; & /

& " 8(22>8(221,5*6 &

7 , % / "

" / /

1( % - & && 65< & ; 8(221,5*6% (

05< !

8 %/ / "

" % /

% & / ' 7 & " & '

-% " &

/ & &"

,9 ,5*6

7 .

% #1 A* F 8(221,5*6 - & , % / "" 8(221,5*6

? -% %&

& ; ' .

8 & / &"- / % &

) * ,% & B %

& * ,5*6 7 0 /

- / /

" & & @> "

& ; '7 & " #1 A8 "

& ) 6>..>,5*016=('1888>03. ,6 5.

,5*6% "

6 ) - & #1 A=/ %

&8(221,5*6&

% &

% & / &

" &

+ '

7 & " & @>

- B % &" / ; - / "" &&2 - " ) 01

- / " & & " # A8 ) & 1 *6>59*,6 ,9 ,5*6

8 /

- 53 ,5*6% & & ,5*6 (11 (,&778 GGGG GGGG GGGG GGGG GGGG AH "- ) & 1 *6>59*,6 ,9 ,5*6% !

-= %

;% /

- / & &

'> ,5*6% -

- = %

; ) / & ; & % / B 8 !

! % ,55D

A,55D ! B "

& & &&2 - ( & - &"

- "" - ( &%

-> "

& -% &

& - @&"

- & ; ' 7 & " & &

- #1 A-797 :##;#-:,!(&6(:7-:6&7:-$

* "

& &

, & & &

& - " -/ "

( "&

& - &"

- ( & - &"

- "" - ( & - :

-> "

& I

& - @&"

" &

+ '

7 & % 7 &

" & &

-I

/ " & - ( & :

- -

@ 7 & -% & && " & ;

- & " 65< - 05<

1( &

-" - &"

- & -" % - & & &

B 8 " 8 /

" ,5*6 7 !* & & ; ' 7 & / ""

&& 2 / " &

/,55D! & " &

! " #1

A, - &"

7 & & - & ' 7"% ' %

>C7 &

- ? - 7 & % & ; ? - 7 & & - ; % %

" &

% %

+ '

27 & % 7 & " & &

-I .

&" - & - %

>7 &

- ? - 7 & % & '

& ;

? - 7 & *5J,

" &

% %

+ '

27 & 7 & " & & :

-% / ""

>? - &"

7 & % / & - " !

' ! % ,55D !

! %,55D "

8 % 27

&& 8 & ,4 5.

,5*6 )/ % "

*4 5.

,5*6 - C % / & ' % / ) F >)"" 227 & 27

&& +

" &"

@% ( &%:

- / "

& '> "

' ! % ,55D !

! % ,55D% "

-% / ; - % *5'

&& % *99. *4 %*903% & - GGGG GGGG GGGG GGGG GG

/ % 27

&& && -/ ?/ "

& '> "

' ! % ,55D !

! % ,55D% "

-% & -% / & '>

8 ! / ""

>? - "

7 & % / & - " 8! K " ! ,55D// " & - %

65< && 2 " ,

L " / / & "

" / " "

"% & & & /

' & " ) 01

- "7 (2 <

" =" - ) " < " >/? -

@ / ? / 7 & :

- )1

-2 8 8/ % -% - & % /

" &

& : 2

8 "

% 7

& 1 "

% - @ / / "

8 / % -%

/ ( & ( &&/ / %/

/ / % % - %;"

& - %/ " -' 1A

,< "="- > ?- : ,554 / / &

= 2 8 - / &

& %

% & - 2 ? - 7 & ( & ; &

8(221,5*6 & ; , .% ? - 7 & '& ; '

-% /

/ & 0 * / ,55D% - 8%/ "

- , %.+0 # !"#$%& '

(

)

+, )

,.*

* & / 0

)

& / 1

"#+, )

( )

)

"# 2

* + , ) 3 )

* "

#+, )

)

* & / 0

* * *

+, ) -

,.4 5 ) +, )*

,.*

)

"7#8 6

#* + , ) *

)

"9# & 3

"7#*

)

* 6

)

* ":#; *

* 6

)*+, )

)

6 1 7"#

)

+ , ) !"# + , ) *

& /

(

)

# <

)

2 ; + *

& / 1 9"#< )

)

( 3

"#< )

)

( 3

#"======#1 "7# < )

* )

( 3

' 8 " 8 "

&& - /

" ( & !

& & =C "7 & - " # " : - ) " # "%%%>@?-

-% 7 & ? - & ; / 7 & / && 2 "

/ & &

& ;

/ - =C "7

&" " @ " " &&2 / & -? - & ; && /

#1 A2 27 & "1 ? - & ;# ,D H && 7 & & " & % &" " & ; & && ? - & ; "

7 & 8/ %/ %

- ""

- "

- & && ? - & ; && 7 & ' / "" && 7 & " '

7 & / " ? & " & (22 & -

,3 & - && 7 & "1 & & -

/ '

- & - & ? - & - & & '

7 & & - &

H &

/ ""- &

" & % " & ?

" & ; '

7 & & -% " & & - ?

& ;

& -

- / /

;/& - " & ; '

7 & I / & - & ; && 7 & % % "

/& &

% "

- / " '

7 & &

- /

% / %

-% " % - "" 7 & / &

& & -% / - & ; '

7 & /

% / & ; - "" 7 &

- /

/ "" % " " && 7 & & - " " - &&- ;

&% % ; "

- & /& - " '

7 & & & K K

% & - ? - 7 & /

& &

"" 8 " @ % - && 7 & ? - & ; "

" 7 & / &" ?

&" " @ "

& &

;/ " @ "1 / " /" " ,9 & % % -? - & ;"

&& 7 & H % / % / ? - & ; "

" &

- ) & - " & ; - 7 & &

H %/ % & & '

% -% & % 8 " &

- & - ? - & ;.6< ? - & ; 06<

- 8 % % - 7"

- ; 8 & /

&& 7 &

@ (22% / ? - & ; "

- - I % / & /

% / %

- ? - & ;

- - "1 - " / "7 &

" &

-" / "

- ? - & ;% 7" - " & % & & & 8 & ;" / "

- &" 7/-? -

" -

8 " - 7 B -% 8 > 8 / "

/ / ! / - / & - " #1

A6D 8 - ) " < ( A 2 + < # " >"

?% "

8 & & / - / * / & -%

, / - && - / H / / / 8 )'

' -

A B < # " >C%%4D / -

& $&

)

M "

8 / - $& +

+ "

& ! -

& - / / & '

! & - 8 & '

;

! +

N*9D9O*6D, " 635 8 %*964% 8 " 7" - & && &

&" "/ "

- & & %

- "

1 ? &

/ ""- ? - "1 & H " & / B GGGG GGGG GGGG GGGG GGGG 4, 8( 8 )'7 ' < !" ' # "A9 "2< ( >C%%@D/-

"1 & / - / " &

"" & 7 & % / 7

/% "

& ( 8 2 + ! %

$ L ) & +

-/ "

8 "

& % / / & -&<# "- 6< # " >"

? /

-$& +

( 8 2 + ! %

$ L ) & +

# * H 7 & ? /

" &

"1 & I , && 7 &

! & - 8 "1 &

& && ? - & ; " 7 & & .

H / & && ? - & ;

- "

"1 & ? / & - 8 "1 &

2 & && ? - & ; /

- % / "

/& &&? - & ;

- & && ? - & ; - " ,5<

- 06< - " &

*6 % &

-" & " " - %" "

" &

% -

B & /

- ,5*0

+"1 - 2*"'" "

/ - & / & ' - -"

*5J,& ; ? -&& " " 8/ - & / &

8 %*99D / & D ,5*6 - 8 *5' *4 %*903 / - & & / / -

' 9 " (11 %% 0( - 2 # " - # "% @ / / ? / &#1

' ! P,55D & - 8 - "

8 & ! ,5 % *903 ! " " &=Q "

& + $&

)

M + 8! *93*,506

% + : 8 ,5*.

*06.9

! &" &"

7 & % / & :

- %

&7"

1 , + 0 ! 88 8

7 & & - 8 %

" % / 8 % &"

7 &

- % & & ; ? - 7 &

! 8

GGGG GGGG GGGG GGGG GGGG

-066

& % / "

& & ; ? - 7 & ! " " 1

,.) 5D 5.

,5*0

8 .

& & ;

? - 7 & I % &

& ;

? - 7 &

8 - % &% - &

8 - "

& &- "

% % &

& 8 % % & =Q "

& ! + ! :

- = + ,5*, *5 DD5I / - )

=& + ( + ,5** . 4*D " & + 8 + ,5*, . 0.5% "" 1 " & &"

" -& " - & - & ""

'% -% 8 &" "/ "

- & & ! & -

&" & -% && / & - "

" - / / ' ? - 7 & & "

& / / " / &7"

& / / " & & " / / && "

&& / / - ( &&& " & & / @ % % & "

& ? - & ; / "" ! "" - % &65%555>1/ & " -

-&"

&&" / & /

- &- 8 "

% " && *5 ,5*6%" 1 / " - & / " &

/ " / ;

! -% ;"

/ & - >"

" / ! % ,55D ,554% &" 3 ,5*6

7 6 + 4 - -

% / - / ! 8 "

,554

-% "

" &

& *5 ,5*6 & & - " 1 % / @ - "1:

! 8

"" && :

& >,--.? + #' 0""3