High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13027/2014dismissed

Harjas & ORS v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2015-12-24Mr. Justice S.S. Saron,Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik13 pages

! "

#$ %# &# '#( )#* %# & +,

-%%##+##../++#0*1../,$(,203

1###,#+###3 4 -%%#%$(,20%(.,1#+#,%23 # 5#56)%#07)# ,87/% 5#)(.9)%#07 ,87#%+# 5.:527 7#*7 ##+, 4 ; 5#(#8 ,.7 ,87 ##+,< 5# #$%/#)2%9/#7 ,87 ##+,= 5#)952 5#5$'%%7 ,87 ##+, 5#5(%(+7 ,87 ##+, " = %#,#%..,+#,/#+/..% /#+0,%%#,#7,.>( ./,#8.8,..%/#+/8#7#%.* ##7%#12:(+#0- 4! ;

%+#/#+7#(2% /#,1*% 6, >( ..#7 % .,?/# %8 @(, . ,, 8(# % +#8 #+,7 /%% . ,, # (1$ 0# %..2%+#/#+..%#/#+7%.,, %81@(,1*%.,?/#1#%(2% /#, %+#7/%#/#.,0+#2 A9.. AA

B=?!C7 "B<? ;C7 AA A A B ?;C74A B"?

C7 B;? C7=A B<?!C7=A ?!C7 DA B ?=C7 4B=?!C0(#2 ;9."5#.(,%#8( '..29(,.7%. #)+7#22#8,2%>( ., 0(#2 << 4 # .(,2 % ., 0(#2 ;"! # (, % #8( '..2 9(,. 8, ,,

!! (,(,#) %6, >( 7 =D B#%# E% FC # +(1. +(#+ 0.* E# ,8.+0 #,. , 00#. )# G "=7 )+F % +# %8 ., 1$ (%71(%)8#0+#,,+(1.% (,#)<% = !!

#+.,0(#2<"

# .(,2 % ., 0(#2 # '..2 9(,. 7 %##7(,#)D% /#(, = !

, % /#, (,

#+ ., 0(#2 !;"

#(,'..29(,. #%(0% /#,7#* %#8(##,/0,8,#+#H0%,,

% (+ 1* % +# % #. /#

#* B C / @(, 8(# % +#8 #+,

# % (0 % /#, % 0 ,7 ..1# 2#0,2#0../#.#, +* %..1# 2#0%1++,,/%%/#+

@(#?

/+(#(%2#0..7%.,, /# @(, !

!4 !!< ,A# %# 8#( , % 0% 5#%7 !!<.+,(%%(2%%#+/###, %#*..%.,71( 4!"

!!;76 ;;A!;/2#, #+.,0(#2"4"! #.(,2%.,>( % 2#8 % +# % % . ,, /# @(,%1+/##*7/%%,#*+/# ..%.,,%81@(,#%82%.,/%% )8#07%##7%/%#2#,%2#. ,8.+ .* % .,7 /%% 8, /% % ) 8#07 ..2.7#1##*,/%($(#, . +, ( % % +# ,, ., 8. ( %..22%.,,1#%8.(# <!= 7/%%/ /%,#/ 4!"

/% +#0 . % +# /# + %##7%1$(,20%(#- D!D< ! ., E) )2% %# ' ) #* %#F ,,,

! 47 % +# %8 (2% ,.# % % . ,, @(, 1* %0 # ..2.7 8, , 8 >( % #2% % +# % +# %8 +.,, % % ., # #0 (01#,,8/%%>(#2(%#*7(++.0#* /#,#+(+##((#/1,1*%2#2..7 1(0+%1,%(+##((#7%., ,8/%%>(#2(%#* %%#%,75#52,(#2%(##2(0% +#,(,%00(,, ;

!!"B5#:?IC8,/%%%., >("4"!" #/#.,#0>()(%#.

.,/+#,,1*,, !D !!"B5#:?C%##7#1 )(%/++#8,1*%%5# 4

!!"% #.8@##0%,, !D !!"#,(,# J5A0@(28.+#86,%++.,#2# . # ., 0(#2 "

DD" # % #8( 8..29(,.7#)+ +#,.2+2

, % %H# +. .2 EF # 0(#2 "4"!" # % / , (,# , < % 6, >( , % /#, /%% / (,

7 (,# * ,++#%#,#%F1.2%(#%, ++.%,++.,#%2#.#,8.+2+., .*8##"

DD"#%.,0(#2 D# , ..2 :%# AA4A A 7 AA A 7 4AA= , ..* >(#, , 1 ,#, # 2# . % (10, # ,# , :2 , #2#,2 (#%# +#,2>(./ K##,#+.L %/#0.,1%.#+, 47 # . +.,, % #+, " G 5A 0@ (2 8.+#6,..1#/%= .,?/#(10,++. !D!= !!

#2#.(,#%+#8#*8.+0 , 2(.#1 # 7 D;"B#%#E% D;" FC(+ #,. +., .* % ., 0(#2 1( <! # . +,(%+#4G)0(,#)2% 0.2/% %# .,?/# #, ..1# 2#0 /% #+, "G5A0@(2,8.+#6, (.*7 !!

#+M %#.,0(#2 =9."5#.%(2%+#4/ ++. # .7 1( % ###, % ., 8(# % +# 0.* #$ 9(0# , )2% #+8.*7 8, #., ,, ,, !"!;

7 /%% / ++#8, !=!= !!

+, ( % 6 ;;A!; / 2#, % 0 +# /..%#.,?/#1*#.2%.,>(#0 >( +#,2 2#..* , % % ., % +#0(#2 =9."5#.,#.,#0>(, #0+#6 ;;A!;2#,8(#+# # ,8.+0#,.+.,?(0?#(+(2.*#.# "4"!" # . +, ( % 5A 0@ (2 , 8.+#6,++.,###.8(##+, =G 5A/* .#86,7#+, ;G5A(#*/%+ 8 6,7 #+, < G 5A ,2# #+# 8 6, 8$

.#86,8,++.,, !!< !!; ..%0+# % 0+ #+, G 5A $ 8.+# , ##((#6,.+,(%+# @(,. ,, 8(# #+, < G 5A ,2# #+# 8 6, !4!4 !!<+,(%%.#+,%8#.% ##.,,7%+##22#8,7%*0*8..2. #0,* 8.1. % #2#, (#%# +.,, % . # ,8.+0.*(,#% D;" 2#,#/%% %8 1 (, (,# ) < % #+ ., >(78##,%../2 J= &%++.A,8,(..,/#%#(2%..1## 0+*++.,#2#.#,8.+0#,. .* !D!= !!

1# (0 /#, % ., //,1*%++.1#((,#)

/8#7 # (0 /#, 1* % 6, >( ..#7%.,?/#.,,#+-;DD4 ,;DD !!

7 4;D !!"7 4;D ?D4 !!", 4;D=?DD

!!" 1# % F1. (# , 1, #,# * ,+ 8/ % 18 , +7 % /

@0, 1* % +#0 A 8#0 # 2# . 1* #.2.,++.,#. #12#,#%) 8#0%#1+#07.,/#.,#0 >( 1* % #1 +#0 8, .# ,,

;

!!",6 ;; !!;/2#,#,8.+0 % ., >( (+ #. ., , ,+. ###,181*%F1.(#8,#,#,, !"

, ! !D !!" @@ @@ 5# @@ @@ = %%8#00,+#=%+#/#2 , ,, +# (10 0, +# 7 4 ! % +#.0#*(107%./#2#,1*#.2., +#+.*%8#07/%%%81(+%.,1*%F1. (#0*./#2%%++.#2# . # ,8.+0 % ., ,+( /# (10, # (0/#,%++.#2#.1*% ,8,(. ., /# %#(2% % ..1## 0+* /# (10,+##(0/#,8.1*#.2 ., @+ 6 ;; !!; /# 2#, 1# (0/#,

6 ;;

!!;7.,/#.,#(0/#,:+28/ %%%.,/#%,.,/#+1#%F1. (#%..22% >(+#,2,1,#,# * ,+ %##7 % ., / #., #, /%%+.*%)8#0L +# #+.* ., 1%. #+, ; G 6,

>( ..#7 8##, % % + % ., % +#/%,,8#%#7 %, /#,

,#*%%,10,% + $0% 8,#+ ,,

+#+##+.*.,1%.#+, G5A $ 8.+# , ##((# 6,7 8, ,(0 @(# ?

;

+.,0(#2 ;9."5#.,8,,(0 @(#

? + ., 0(#2 9. +(#+#,.* ,.8#, 5A 0@#(60,#+, " 6#, (. # % +# % 8%0.* #2(, % # (2 % /#,7 % ., 8, /% % ) # #0 .. (01#7 %##7 (% ., (., 1 0, (1$ 0# ..,,%%.,(.,1#.,#0>( #%82%.,/%%)1*/*#0 ) =% ./+.,(+K(.. %$(,20% (# 05(#)# %#')#* %# B($1C "

%%#%,75527 7#*7,0,%% 0( 0+ % %# 1 #, % +# # ,+,1#% #(#%(2%%0.*2,+,/% %6, >(..#+,(%%+%., >(#,%1:%,%>(@+%.,7/%% (,#*,+2#,1*%(#,0,%%#/ *,+#+.,0(#2 ;9."5#.7(1$ 0#+#/#+ -%%(.1:2#(,,#2(0#,7%>( #>(#, 1 @0, #N BC /%%# % ., %.. 8 # #0 .. (01#/%)(2% /#,7#BC/%%#%., (.,1#.,1*%)%100(,,

!!" /%(#0) =%

/8#7 1# ,.2 % , >(7 % #.8 +#8%6, >( 7 =D ##>(#,1@#,% 0#(,# J &*+,$-(&'(.($'/-00#%!$1B C%,*@,7# *%#,*/%%%>(#*%1,$(#,7%..# %..+#,>(#%1$B*C/%%*+# #,%,+(#(28(,#D% 0(#00,(,#=7,%8.(%.,, %,%+(1.%(,# 7(1?

B C7,%#+8#%+#.02% 0+,%..0:/#,(,#%%,O BC %#(#%.,N BC %0+/%%%+%(.,1../, #%.,N, BC %++#0%,0+02..% +#:/#1.8,1#,%.,7 /%07#/%.07%%#07/%%# #%*%8#+8.*++#,1#%0N @ @ @ .($' 00#%!$."#&!/# ,&(01B C)(%/#,%..1 .,%..#P,%..7@+%##+#8,,7 1 . , .(8 8,7 1/ % ..# , % +##,7/%%#%*%8#+8.*++#,1#% ..# # 7 % #( # , 8.( % .

,7 , % ++#0%0+02%+##, C %..#%..2800,%/#,(% % +# #, # +# +#..* # 1* %# #+#8/%%/#,0, @@ @@ 2 .#$ ! !(3# 4))#)),& 1 -% % ..# % 0, /#,(,# 7%0*:+%.,7/%%%.. %#(+ 8 1.(.* % 8#07 # #0 .. (01# @@ @@ 5640#!,& (%*+,),!,&&!%64+0)$-/+!%64#&)(!,& !/#(.($'#'."#&&!%640#!

#4<7%8#0%..1.1#*/%,#/#0 %>(*.,/%%+%1: C -%8#%28#0/%,#/#0*(%>(7 %..#%..,#0%0(0+,(#% ,02(#,1*%/#>(%#* +#,2 %#(,#7 , %.. +* (% 0( % +# #,7 2%# /% .. #1.* (##, 1* %0 % +#(%+#,2(,#% #.2%,., B4C %+#8#% %..++.*7#0* 17 % ,#0 % 0+ +*1. (,# % L 0 5(# )#F B(+#C7 % #.

% ) 8#0#(2% /#,/,#,1*%K(.. %1* #02%../2/>( J @@ @@ BC -% % 6, >( ..# ,+ % 0(0+,:*01.+N # BC -% # ,+ 0+7 (. +%*. +:L -%. ,#2 % , >(7 % % 1#8, , .(,,(,# J < %#2%%.,?/#%..2%>(#% #%(.+%*.+%1:/(.

/#,(,,%0+,#0,#++#8. % ) 8#0 (,# +#8 ) B C % %)8#0%++#8,%0(0+ ,%..#%(,% /#,N0(0+ ,+, , % /#, # % % + :7 % 82.,0+.8(#%)%(2%%.,?/# 0* .. %8 #2% 0+(2 % >( #0 % $(,20###,18%##%)8#0

/%,#/ #0 % >( .* 1* +(1. (,#) =% #%(2 /#,N,+ 0(0+,%#.:2+ @@ @@

4 ,, 1* 5# , % +(#( % #00,%2%/#,00#/%,#/.#0 >(7 (,# ) = % % 1 +(1.%,-,%%/%,#/.>(.*%1 %#+#%2%/#,00##*%%0 % ,..2.%/%,#/.#0>(%11* /*,1*../2%0+##>(#, %0#>( @@ @@

; 8/%187/%.,% BC %)8#0/%@(8+/# : + (% +# # (%#* 1# @#$(#,##,(,#%+#8 6, >( 7 =D (,# ) < # (,#) =% 1(%.,1 .* 1* % ) 8#0 , 1* /* % N, BC

( % + % 1 : 1* % 6,

>(..#+#% /#,(,1*7 % ) 8#0 ../ % >( +#,2 .+ /%( +(1. (,#) =% 7.2##, >(.,L

+# 05(#)#FB(+#C7#%82., /%%)8#07%.,1#.,.*#+(1. (,#) =% /8#7%82%.,% 1,10+.,.*%+%1:1*%6,

>( ..# +# % /#, , % 0+ +, % +# #, ., %# ,A # ,+ % 0( % 0+ % (# /%% ## (,# ) = /(., 1

(10, )(% % 8/ : 1* % F1. )(+#0 (# ( 5(+.#+# %#'#:%,5#0.).: %# C4) =4

,0,.*7%0(0+%1#,# ,+,1#% #(#%##7%.,1*%K(.. % %(# 05(#)#FB(+#C+# <7#+#,(,187 %82.,0+.8(#%)%82 0+.7(,#) =% 0,#*#% #.%.,%##7%,%)8#0#. %.,#0>(%#(2%00(,, ;

!!", ,*%(#*+#882%.,0+.7% .,.,1*%+#,+(#%,1*%+#8#+,1 ,1..2.#/%(*. % >(N /%%#7 % . ,, @(, (., 1 ,+(,1*%.,?/#7%1@0,1*%(#-""= ! 4 ., E% 0 %# ' % ) #* %#F ,,,

! "7- <;;" ! ".,E'$*. %#' )#* %#F,,, != ! ",- 4< !!D ., E9. 0 %# ' ) #* %#F ,,,

;!= ! " '$* .F B(+#C7 % $(,20 %# 8

%))2%FB(+#C/###,,,2(%,7/% %1%.,%../2 J))2%FB(+#C7#2(0/#,%/# +%1.,#%@+#*%.0:2 , % . ,, % 1 .* %., % % /# $(#, %(., 1 8:, /%( * ,.* # .% 1( % +#, ( ( 1 2#, , % +# .,

8.(,+(%.,,/7/(.,%811##,1* .0%.,,/#@(,1*%+#8+## %+(1.%(,#) =% %( /,%%%..2%(,#) =%

(##02#,.*,.% % #.# /# + ., 1* % +# %8 1 ,0,,2%%-#(#%++#+##(0% (#,#,%(%#%.,?,2>(#*/%% /#+/1#,#+#)(%#,#/(., #$(#,%(%#(,#%6, >( 7 =D N #* #1 8.+0 (%#* 7 D;; # #* #1 8.+0 , 2(. #1 # 7 D;" ,.#%.,,(..,8,%0+(#,.# %.,,(..,8,*%2#(,%8.(# .#0*1/#(# *8#(#,#+,1*%(#7 $(#,1##,%(%#,.#.,, (..

,8,%##7.,,1,.#,1(.. ,8,1*%(%# % ,+(, >( % /%%# %# / 0#+#7 # # #(, @#, 8# % +# @( % . ,, (., 1 @0, .* 1* % 8. (# /%%0+,.#.,,(..,8,%2#(, +.,, % 1 % 8, ., 1# )(% ,+(, >( # 2#..* @0, 1* % -# (# %##7%#,#+,1*%0+ (%#*%% $(#,,.#%.,,(..,8,1, 1..2.,(/##,L %+#7%.,,/#@(,%*# !!< %(%..2%.,,/.

,%*# #0# %%#*#%.0.#,,(04*# #0%,/%%.2%+.%8%#(0# ,#..

7 %*

@(,#./# #*,#,2#0.. /....1#2#0%./2#,%+# /..%##7%+#1+#0,,+(%.,, #%#*#@( %(2%7 % ( .,7 (. # % +. % 0, 0%(12/%,#//%+#08.%#0,* /#+71(8(%.1#*2#,1*%(#+#02% /%,#/.%(7%+#1+#0,,+(%. ,,#%@+#*+#,.01*/*+#/#+ 8/%187/,,*0#%+# /#+%0##,2.*,0, 7 8 9

: 7 8 '0. 9 $ ()# ($!,#)(6# -

9%#)2%')#* %#

- =;;

! "

%% %#')#* %# 4 - 44D"

! " 6@0 %#')#* %#

- 4"

! "

$ %#')#* %# " - 4";4

! " 0')#* %# < - 4<""

! "

$9(0# %#')#*