High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12365/2015dismissed

Amit Sharma v. Union Of India And ANR

2015-12-07Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu3 pages

!"#$#%&'&()#% *+ ,&"-.!/,! #"&"&(#/ 0#/'1'

(&(($&!!($!(/ #'2($#("' ) 34 - --

/#'#(")5 /0&6!'.!"/!".+$7%!"# /".#2#"&"&(#/ / 1(##"12"!+$7%!"# //#'2($#(" /!,&"81,!/+$7%!"# //#'2($#("

&".".#%('#("2!/"&#'+".#,!&(%!'#:.&%.:!' 4&'"#$/; &'2/#2(#$!($$&'2'#$<=".&'/$#/ .#2#"&"&(#/.!'&4#$".&'2#"&"&(<#&(> !>>/&#7#$ ".#2/7&'&(&(".#!$7#/"&'#,#("/".#&7&4-#/7&%#?!,&(!"&( :.#/#<= %!($&$!"#' :. !22#!/#$ &( ".# &7&4 -#/7&%#' ?!,&(!"&( <1" !/# ".#/:&'# &(#4&>&<4# / &7&4 -#/7&%#' ?!,&(!"&( #&".#/$1#"!""!&(,#("122#/ !>#4&,&"/ #?.!1'"&((1,<#/!""#,2"'!7!&4!<4#/".#&/%!"#>/=+'.!44 <#2#/,&""#$!(!$$&"&(!4!""#,2"&(".#&7&4-#/7&%#'?!,&(!"&( .#%("#("&(&'".!"4&,&"&(>".&'<#(#&"(4="'1%. %!($&$!"#':..!$!22#!/#$&(".#&7&4-#/7&%#'?!,&(!"&( <1"("#?"#($&(>".#'!,#<#(#&""'1%.%!($&$!"#':.

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

:.#/#&(&".!'<##(

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

#' 4&6# ".# 2/#'#(" ".!" !/# &4#$ !"#/ ".# #'"!<4&'.,#("".#/&<1(!4'+.!7#"<#$&',&''#$(".#>/1($ ,!&("!&(!<&4&"=+4#!7&(>4&<#/"="".#2!/"&#'"!22/!%.".#/&<1(!4 &".1" &( !(= :!= 2&(&(> ( !/#'!&$ $&7#/>#(" !22/!%.#'".#C$1('#4/".#2!/"&#'+".#2/#'#("2#"&"&(&' $&',&''#$!'<#&(>(",!&("!&(!<4# .#2#"&"&(#/:14$<#!"4&<#/"="!22/!%.".##("/!4 $,&(&'"/!"&7#/&<1(!4/7&($&%!"&(.&'>/&#7!

-- $&(#'.