Jagdeep Rana & ORS. v. State Of Haryana & ORS.
! !
" #$%&'( ) ! * "+,- ""./$
$ 0$&$ /1" "'""./$
$-,$
!"#$ " $ %
!"#$ $#
&&&
$% /-$
2
2"/"3"),#"")"'""4/ 2 1"5"/1"+"),, ,#"")"'""
66666 $# ' /$/-,/-$4-$4// /5$#5-7#$/-4$# ,&,$&89 $#:
; 1#( /"'""2&#-"-"#) <<= : $/) <<=#;,#"+/2&#-"&#)58""'", 2&#-"&#)58""1",""$"2&#-"-")58""8' ",,+&"""
/+"# /-$)$/)$/""$-/ -$$ 1# 9 /"'""2&#-"#) <>(",$&89 $#:
; 1#( <<=#)8 -5&+" #+/
2&#-"'",,+ 4"+$"$2&#-"-") --&' /"+4"$+"'83#$4$&+/ $&-- /" 5,$&85$$)"#/"$8",/-$$ #$ =(9", =(9 /$& ,"$&85/" 2-"""5"$"""/"+"--&" "#$5 #5-$, 5 ,$#$ ", #$$+ 4 5 2&#-"$ "#/"'"$/#+&&$""$$-# ,8'/ 8'-&8# #"8"2-""" 2
2"/"3")",,#"")"'"""$$$, 8' 2 1"5"/ 1"+") ", ,," ,#" ") "'"" $&85,/"/#$'/$+",/"$"",'8$"$8' /$#/ /$&"
( )*)+,) - +.
+/+")
)0) )) - +'
123 ',#,, = !
!
) 4/ #$,+ / 3&,+5 ,, 8' ?8 / 1&-5& )- " 4,) - +.
+/+") ()5,) )- +,) - +'$316"73'4//"$8/,"# /5 '+#$& /2&#-"'7,+ $5$"+$" &#)4/#/,$@&"'--&' /"+
/"/",/",,#"")"'""", "--"$,/-"-8A
1&89$#:
; 1#( <<=#",$"$&,%9 B/55"') 555)8' #"/ #" "C) ,#" "' 5&#-"' #&,+ "" #5-$+ &" "" " -" / ) "') 8 " -"A4"$B/2&#-"-" :"5 -";D
7
5 / -" ", $5- ",+ / " 5, -$) $ #" /" / 5 $ $, 4/ -4 -5&+"/5&#-"'",/$-$ " ,+"' --&'
15"--$#"58,8",&-/3&,+5 #,$&-")4/)4/#+/",#,,#&,&/ 3&,+5,,/) ) 8)( ) 5,)0)')
)9)) -
+.
+/+") / 9):) - +'
6
1' ,#,,!
!=
!
)/"$8/,/"--&' /"+ /-&-$ 7,+$5#$& 2&#-"' $@&,8+/#"""$8+"+$" &# +$""#$/#"",-5&+" "+"& #,&# 4/& #-"#&"#"$$)4/"$"",5$""#$/ 5"A+",$$& "$-# #,#/"--#" "+"& " -"#&" #"$ "##,"# 4/ / @&5$ -#'
$& 2&#-"' ", #$ 2&#-" &# 8' ",,+ 4"+$2&#-"-"$/,5" / +$"&",)/&$)#"8@&$, /$"A 8')" - /3&,+5",$/&$%9 B "#)"$#/ /$& >
!!*,"5 "#/"'")2"2"3"",/$ 1" &3"8",/$),#,,!
!=
!
)/"$"$/,/" $"8$/5 " 2&#-" 55 $ " +$" &# /"7"# 5/$",3&,+5",$"$ &,%9 B15"$/4 ///3&,+5$, &-8'",#&$ /-$ 2","E" 1" &3"8):
!!<; (F",," 1&#$ E5, 1#"') -"5 E#"
2 ,$):
!!F;= /3&,+5$ , 8'/",#&$ /--#, / "$$&5- /" " #" #$&+ " 2&#-"' 7,+ $ 5&#-" 5$ $ ",5$""& 1&#/"$$&5-4"$-8"8'
/"$/"/-$$ /##5-" " --&' /"+ / 3&,+5$ ,8'/",#&$ /-)/ ,$# 84 / ",5$" ", +$" &#$4"$8&+//# /&)4/#/ /"$8$&83#5" #$,"8 /"+ #/$ /G81&-5& $-# / 2&#-"$"$"$/""+&$-$$) / &#/3&,+5$ /$&/""A/ $5"4 / )"# /",#&$ /-/$#/3&,+5$ /$ & / 3&,+5 / 1&-5 & ",1+/",$$ 1" 5"#/" ",$/", $) <*>1 (<)$ /-- / 3&,+5 ", 1+/G$ #"$ :$&-"; /"$ 8 #$,,/#"$$",/"$8,$+&$/,
/ )4 ,/""# /1"5 '+#$& /2&#-"'7,+ $5$"+$" &#",/$"5),$ @&"--&' /"+ &$#/$"& #5-"$"--&' /"+)/+& +" --&' /"+$/$"5"$$ @&, "",5$"@&"$3&,#" &# $&#/--&'#",5#&,--&' -$"/"+ /&$)4 ,/"" #"#$&+2&#-"'" #""8$/+2&#-"'$""# +$"", /&$#" 85-&+,/+&,$4/#/""""8 ",5$" @&"$93&,#" ,$ #+ / , #84/+$"",",5$" &#)
$ #/ "5 "#/"'") 2" 2"3"G$ #"$ :$&-";)8$,"$&,%9 B4 /"8)#"8/,/""+$""# $/#"",-5&+" "+"& #,/& #-"#&"#"$$)4/"$" ",5$""#$/5"A+",$$& "$-# # ,# / "--#" " +" & " -"#&"#"$"##,"#4//@&5$ -#'
E+$"$/-#$$&$&"'-"+ &&) ",5$" $ / -#$$ - 5+ -"#&""#$) $$&+-"#&",$ 5"A+ ,#$$4/#/"--'+"&$-"#&"#"$$
",3&,#")///",)"--$$-# # ,,&"$$&"$ &)/$"'"8", ,$#$ / 83# / &) / "#/ $ "--#")/+/$",8+"$"$+& )$ ,, #-"$)-$", &&$)$ 5)/5" $-5&+""$5 "#$ 4/#/5"'/-,"4+/84+$" ", 9+$" "#$ / $", "#$ /" 8 "--, /,+/"/ 7" -#&,/ -$$ /$$"55,$#" &,/##'#) !!()"+$""&
1&#/-#-$/"8"--,$-# / #$& /2&#-"'7$ $5$) / #$&#/3&,+5$$5",/" -" 5/" $",3&,+5)"$#/ "5 "#/"'""$$1A/" 1" &3"8",/$) :
!!<; = )/"$"$"A/$"54/""# #$& "2&#-"'$+$""#
"$ ,/""-" 5/ "#/"3&,+5/ #"$ 0 H"-:$&-";/"$8 &,8,&,"8' / 1&-5 & 8& / ,$# 84 " ",5$" &# / +$" &# 4"$ 8&+//# /&/3&,+5$ E"+
; #/$ /G81&-5&"$#$,,"5
"#/"'")2"2"3"G$#"$:$&-";4 , / -&$" /& / )/$",3&,+5,$"'
,4"8,+-#, /$&
$@&')4, ,"'5/-$ 4-
$5$$, #"5"&5, & / "#/"/4-$ -,+",3&,#"$# ! !4/&"'5$"')/ )#"&$ "#"+,'"##&,+$&$
$"&-$/ &"$+)/4-$,$5$$,
< " $ % = <$# = !%8 !%8 /07'1 )( +, , +> )* 4? )+
- @ +?
, > ): @ +?