High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18736/2012disposed of

Sukhjinder Singh v. State Of Punjab Etc.

2019-09-11Mr. Justice Arun Monga8 pages

#$% $&

$!'$$ $

$&$!

& ( &))* + +

!"#

& &

%$&

!$*

,%-

!+ # .

$! $ '()(*+, "'

'-.*'/+/0+1/ /123456/+( 75'+8(0(+9+95*(')9* /*3$

/')8"(8:/23456/+( 75'+8(0(+9+95*(')9*

9::23456/+( 75'+8(0(+9+95*(')9*& &

8/:9;/:23456/+( 75'+8(0(+9+95*(')9* /*3%$& "'

.*<23456/+( 75'+8(0(+9+95*(')9*& ") /19*/89'2(0.+=3456/+( (*('/:2.*-/> "'

*/*+ /+/'9/23456/+(75' '()05*3(*+)5 /*3&9* %$&/*3& "'

/*-((48/'1/23456/+( 75''()05*3(*+)5 /*3&9* /*3

+8/'81(323456/+( 75''()05*3(*+)5 /*3& 9*$

/9*)23456/+( 75''()05*3(*+5

/*-((45*923456/+( 75'+8("/'?(+5119++((28/'9;/:9*& &

@@@@@ $! $/ #+

!$- (+9+95*(')8('(9*2 )((?9))./*6(57/;'9+9*+8( */+.'(57 75'A./)89*<57910.<*(35'3(')3/+(3 /*3 **(B.'()$/*3'()0(6+94(:=#2;8('(>=2+8((6'(+/'=2 .*-/>"/*395/'30'56((3(3+5/**.:+8()(:(6+95*1/3(>='()05*3(*+ 5 &"/'?(+ 5119++(( 493( ;8968 +8( 0(+9+95*(') ;('( )(:(6+(3 '(49)95*0(+9+95*79:(3>=0(+9+95*(');/)3(693(3/</9*)++8(0(+9+95*(')C 493(5'3('3/+(3

'9(7>/6?<'5.*3 * /*3$

0 +8(05)+)9*A.()+95*/'( 9# *(.6+95* (65'3(':/)) 99#;5 85;?93/') :/)) 999# ;5 :('?) :/)) /*3 9# *( .6+95*

(65'3(':/)) 99# *(85;?93/':/)) 999#;5(;/3/'):/)) 2'()0(6+94(:=275';8968/34('+9)(1(*+;/)0.>:9)8(35* **(B.'(&# (:(4/*+ .:()8('(9*/'(.*-/>"/'?(+5119++((:/)) **(B.'(#!:/)))('496( .:() **(B.'(#D.*-/>+/+( <'96.:+.'/: ('496() "/'?(+ ('496( .*9)81(*+ ! 00(/: .:() **(B.'()&# & * 2+8(0(+9+95*(')/'(/<<'9(4(3>=5'3(') 3/+(3 **(B.'( $# 0/))(3 >= +8( (6'(+/'= "/'?(+ 5119++(( /*3 **(B.'( # 0/))(3 9* +8( 0(+9+95*(')C '(49)95*0(+9+95*)>=+8((6'(+/'=<'96.:+.'(2'()0(6+94(:= *$ 2+8(0(+9+95*(')/'(/<<'9(4(3>=5'3('

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

49#0059*+1(*+) 8/4( >((* 1/3( >= +8( 8/9'1/*E(6'(+/'="/'?(+5119++((<949*<>(*(79+) +56:/.)('(:/+94()

*+8()(+('1)+8((6'(+/'="/'?(+5119++((8/)/**.::(3+8(

()5:.+95*)3/+(3% $ /*3% % 57+8("/'?(+5119++((2 9*//</'/*3 ()5:.+95*)3/+(3% $ 2& & /*3& & "/'?(+5119++((/'5+/91/:9*<8.*3('(6+95*&& # #57+8( .*-/><'96.:+.'/:'53.6("/'?(+6+2 $

(49)95*);('(79:(3 '3(')+8('(57/'(/:)5910.<*(3>=;/= 57+8(;'9+0(+9+95*) 8('(49)95*);('(79:(3/)9*+('1)57910.<*(3 5'3(') 3/+(3 +8( 0(+9+95*(') ;('( /.+51/+96/::= '(:9(4(3E+('19*/+(3 8('(49)95*);('(79:(35*+8(75::5;9*<<'5.*3), 9#5*5+96(5'5005'+.*9+=578(/'9*<8/3>((*<'/*+(3 >=+8('()05*3(*+5/'3 99# *:=+8("/'?(+5119++((;/)6510(+(*++5/0059*+ +8(0(+9+95*(')/*3+8(5/'3*5+>(9*<+8(6510(+(*+ /.+85'9+=65.:3 *5+8/4(+('19*/+(3+8(0(+9+95*(')C )('496() % 8(65*+(*+95*57;/*+575005'+.*9+=9)*5+96(3>.+8/)*5+ >((*3(/:+;9+8 8(7/6++8/+*55005'+.*9+=;/)<'/*+(3*5';('(+8( 0(+9+95*(') /))569/+(3 ;9+8 +8(0'(:919*/'= (*A.9'= 9* +8(5'3(') 3/+(3 9)65*6(3(3 8('()05*3(*+)3(7(*3+8(5'3('3/+(3 /*3+8( 5'3(')9*'(49)95*3/+(3 9* #/*3&

9*$ #>=)+/+9*<+8/+*55005'+.*9+=;/)'(A.9'(3+5>( <94(*9*+('1)57(6+95*&&2 9#/*3 999#57+8(6+ 8()/1( 0('+/9*+5/**.::9*<57 ()5:.+95* 8(5'3('(105;('9*<(6'(+/'=<'96.:+.'("/'?(+9*<5/'3 /*3<949*<891+8(05;('+56/*6(:+8( ()5:.+95*)>=+8(+;5"/'?(+ 5119++((#9)5*'(65'3/)**(B.'( E9*

8()/1( 8/)>((*9)).(3.*3('(6+95*& $# 99#57+8(.*-/><'96.:+.'/:'53.6( "/'?(+ 6+2 0('.)/: 57 **(B.'( E '(4(/:) +8/+ +8(

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

(*6()6/*5*:=>(0/))(3/7+('5005'+.*9+=/*3+8(0'9*690:(57 */+.'/:-.)+96(8/4(+5>('(/39*+5+8(+/+.+(;8('(5'3('9)57/34(')( 6949:65*)(A.(*6().*:())+8()/1(8/4(>((*)0(69796/::=(B6:.3(3>=+8( +/+.+( (7('(*6( 9* +89) '(</'3 1/= >( 8/3 +5 / -.

8.)+8(/6+95*9)49+9/+(35*+89)/665.*+

0('.)/:57910.<*(35'3('3/+(3 **(B.'( #'(7:(6+) +8/+ (4(* +85.<8+8(65*+(*+95* 57 +8(0(+9+95*(') +8/+ *5 5005'+.*9+= ;/) <'/*+(3 +5 +8(1 >= +8( '()05*3(*+)5/'3 >(75'( 39)19))9*<+8(17'51)('496(8/)>((**5+(3=(+2+8()/1(8/)>((*<94(*/ 6510:(+( )85'+ )8'97+ >= +8( 00(::/+( .+85'9+= ;89:( .085:39*< +8( 0.*9)81(*+5'3('3/+(3 **(B.'($# 8/4(<5*(+8'5.<8+8('(:(4/*+/00:96/>:(('496( .:()9 ( .*-/>"/'?(+5119++(( :/))#('496( .:()%/*3+8(.*-/>

2 +/+(<'96.:+.'/:"/'?(+9*<('496( .*9)81(*+/*300(/:# .:()2%% 1(/*+75':/))/*3(10:5=(()57+8("/*395/'32;8('(9*:/.)( /*3 .:(%/'(93(*+96/:/*30/'/1/+('9/ 5''(/3='(7('(*6(2 .:(

'(0'53.6(38('(9*>(:5;, ! " #" "

!"##$

% &

' ( !"##

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

#8(0.*9)89*</.+85'9+=)8/::3(:94('5'6/.)(+5>(3(:94('(3+5 +8((10:5=('/650=57+8(/'+96:()5768/'<(2+8()+/+(1(*+57+8(

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

6+9*< 57 +8( 9*A.9'=2 75::5;9*< .*).)+/9*/>:()+/*38/)>((*+/?

'(+.'*, F& . !% ' '

$ // ! 1

+ '

' ' ' .' $ &

).3

' !#$43$%4!!!#$4#$%4!!'

' '$, *+8(/75'()/930'(19)(2910.<*(35'3(')3/+(3 /*3 65*+/9*(3/+**(B.'()$/*32'()0(6+94(:=2/'()(+ /)93(;9+8:9>('+=+5+8('()05*3(*+)+50/))7'()85'3(')9*'()0(6+57

()5:.+95*/7+('<'/*+9*</*5005'+.*9+=57>(9*<8(/'3+5+8(0(+9+95*(')/) ;(::/)/::+8('()05*3(*+) *+9: +8( 7'()8 5'3(') /'( 0/))(32 +8( 0(+9+95*(') )8/:: >( /::5;(3+565*+9*.(9*)('496( *6/)(2/*/34(')(5'3('9)0/))(32+8()/1( )8/::*5+>(910:(1(*+(375'/0('95357&3/=)9*5'3('+5<94(+8( 0(+9+95*(')/7/9'5005'+.*9+=+5/))/9:+8()/1( +1030 3 )

00:96/+95*)/'(39)05)(357;9+8+8(5>)('4/+95*+8/+9+;5.:3 >(/00'(69/+(3 97+8('()05*3(*+)/:)5 3(/:;9+8 +8(65*+(*+95* 57+8( 0(+9+95*(')'/9)(39*+8(0'()(*+/00:96/+95*)/*30/))/00'50'9/+(5'3(') ;9+89*/0('95357&3/=)2/)9+9)65*+(*3(3>=+8(:(/'*(365.*)(:75'+8( 0(+9+95*(')+8/+)919:/':=)9+./+(35+8('0(')5*)8/4(>((*/665'3(3+8( >(*(79+57)/:/'=/*35+8('>(*(79+)2;8('(/)+8(0(+9+95*(')8/4(*5+>( <'/*+(3+8()/1( 85+5650=57+89)5'3('>(0:/6(35*+8(79:(575+8('65**(6+(3 6/)() + +

$! $ )1'9+9 # &

8(+8(')0(/?9*<E'(/)5*(3 ,I()E5 8(+8(' (05'+/>:( ,I()E5