Jagtar Singh v. State Of Punjab

   

       

 !"#"$%&%'(

)
  *! +,%'*- ".%&%'%&!

/"+&0& ,! !"0'1 2 "&3'#"'!

 (  45   , 6 5,  +"&"'!(7

+!08 %'9#.$ !"9++".%&%'%&!

+ 5 : +9,"'%+ 0'1 2  ;-"!-"+!-""3+!"+&8$ 8'":&3 3"+< =2" 88:"#! &""!-"10#*<"'!>
 2"+""++"#!!-""3+!"++'!  ;-"!-"+!-"10#*<"'!&-08#2"+"3+!"#%'!-"#%*"&!> 77 77 5, 

5 -%&+".%&%'%&#%+"$!"# * %'&!!-"10#*<"'!# !"#
9 3 &&"#2=!-"8" +'"# ##%!%' 8 ,"&&%'& 0#*"9 !% 8 9 %+<%'* !-" 10#*<"'!$'.%$!%' '#+#"+&"'!"'$"# !"#?
93 &&"#2=!-" 8" +'"#,02%.%&%' 80#%$% 8 *%&!+ !"9, < ' 9:-"+"2=+".%&%'%&!: & $'.%$!"#0'#"+,"$!%'&
@ '#?7  '#: &&"'!"'$"# &0'#"+(7

'#"+,"$!%'

,"'!"'$"

@

,%A<'!-&+%*+0&%<3+%&'<"'!

?7

:=" +&+%*+0&%<3+%&'<"'! '#!3 =  %'"&9 79%'#" 08!3 =<"'!%'" !0+!-"+0'#"+*&%<38"%<3+%&'<"'!+'" <'!- 88!-"&"'!"'$"&:"+"#%+"$!"#!+0'$'$0++"'!8= -" $!&!-"$ &"9 &< #"0!+<!-"8:"+ 0+!%8" +"

!- !' =

9  +' %8,%'*-92+!-"+%'8 : &%&!"+4&-0&2 '# -03%'#"+,%'*-- #$<"!.%88 *" 8: '#% 8 B9 88%'*:%!-%'!-"

7
7 10+%&#%$!%'    8%$"  ,! !%'  , # +9  , < ' 9  '  -%&  &$!"+  2" +%'* +"*%&!+ !%'??7@)9< +B4 1 1 -"! B4!"+! B%'*<" 8&%'

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

-"+ &%#" !-" + #  +' %8  ,%'*- &0"+"#  <08!%38"%'10+%"& %'  !-" $$%#"'!  -03%'#"+ ,%'*-  '# -%&  $0&%' 2+!-"+ ,0B-:%'#"+,%'*- +"<."# +' %8,%'*-! %.%8&3%! 89, < ' 9:-"+"!-"#$!+#"$8 +"# -%<2+0*-!#" # '+"$"%.%'*!-"%'!%< !%''!"8"3-'"+<  , , < '  20!!-"#" !- +' %8,%'*-9 38%$"3 +!=-" #"#2=,, -%2 ,%'*-9'$- +*" -:B% 1": &9+" $-"#, < ' -&3%! 8 '#+"$+#"#!-" &! "<"'!-03%'#"+,%'*- A;  '#!-"+" !"+9 !"+< B%'*!

"'#+&"<"'! ! 20!( 9+< 8 A;@ : &+"*%&!"+"#!

8&$<"&0!!- !'!-"& <"# =9-03%'#"+,%'*-< #" &! !"<"'! 0'#"+,"$!%' + :-"+"%'-"<"'!%'"#!-"' <"!-"#+%."+ '# '0<2"+!-"!+ $!+-"&%!"38 '38 $" $$%#"'!: &3+"3 +"#-" 3-!*+ 3-&38 $" $$%#"'!:"+"$8%$B"#-"3&!<+!"<!-"#" # 2#=: &*!$'#0$!"#'!-"'"A!# =%"
C

$$0&"# *! +

77 ,%'*-: &3+#0$"#2"+"!-"38%$" '#: & ++"&!"#-"!+ $!+!+88"= : & 8&! B"'%'!3&&"&&%'-"!+ $!+!+88"= &:"88 &!-"&$!"+: & <"$- '%$ 88="A <%'"#  '# !-" +"3+!  !-" <"$- '%$ A;
  '# A;

: &3+"3 +"# '# !"+$'#0$!%'*!-"%'."&!%* !%'9$- 88 ': & 3+"&"'!"#%' 0+! '&033+!%!&$ &"93+&"$0!%'"A <%'"#-03%'#"+,%'*-

;9     1%'#"+  60< +  ;
9  6 8%  - + '  ;9 /%'#  ,%'*8

;?9+ &- 6 '# +  ;C9, +1%'#"+,%'*- ;9608:%'#"+ ,%'*-9 !  '!+= 3"+ !+9 %$"9, '*+0+ ;9608#""3,%'*-9 ,!"'9   %$"9  , '*+0+ ;)9,, -%2,%'*-9'."&!%* !%'*

%$"+ ;@ '#,0B-:%'#"+,%'*-9 '!-"+"=":%!'"&& ; '# !-"+" !"+$8&"#!-"3+&"$0!%'".%#"'$" '!-"&! !"<"'!+"$+#"#0'#"+,"$!%' + 9 $$0&"# #"'%"#-%&%'.8."<"'!%' $$%#"'!"&! !"#!- !' $$%#"'!!B38 $" :%!-!-"!+ $!+!+88"=9 & 88"*"# 8&": &8#*"# +' %8,%'*-: & #+%.%'*-%&&$!"+'"*8%*"'!8= !  &!&3""##0"!:-%$-9-""88#:'' !-"+ # '#&0"+"#%'10+%"&3+."-%&#""'$"9-""A <%'"#'#"+1%! ,%'*- ;90#-,%'*- ;
 '#$8&"#!-"#""'$"".%#"'$" !"+-" +%'*!-"8" +'"#&&%&! '!028%$+&"$0!++!-" ,! !"9  !-"  8" +'"#  #""'$"  $0'&"89  !-"  8" +'"#  ,02  %.%&%' 8  0#%$% 8

*%&!+ !"9  , < ' 9  .%#"  10#*<"'!  # !"#  ?
9  $'.%$!"#  '# &"'!"'$"#!-" $$0&"# & +"& %# - ."-" +#!-"8" +'"#$0'&"8++".%&%'%&!9!-"8" +'"# ,! !"$0'&"8 '#- ." 8&$ +"088=*'"!-+0*-!-"8:"+ 0+!%8" -"8" +'"#$0'&"8++".%&%'%&!- &."-"<"'!8= +*0"#!- ! !-"+"%&<%&7+" #%'* '#<%&7 33+"$% !%'".%#"'$"!!-""A!"'!!- !

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

+$<%'* 0!!-"%3" $!+=9!-"!+ $!+ &:"88 &!+88"=- #$<"'!-"< %' + # '#!- !!-" &$!"+#"$" &"# +' %8,%'*--%!!-"!+88"=+< 2"-%'#:"."+9%'!-"&! "<"'!%' 0+! &;9-03%'#"+,%'*-- # !+%"#!%<3+."-%&."+&%'2= &&"+!%'*!- !!+ $!+!+88=#+ **"#!-" &$!"+!&<""A!"' '#!-"!=+"&!-"!+88"=3 &&"#."+!-"&$!"+ !-"#"$" &"# +' %8,%'*-:"."+9!-%&%&$'!+ #%$!"#2=!-"+"3+! !-"<"$- '%$ ;
9:-%$-&-:&!- !!-"+": &'8=<%'+&$+ !$-"&' !-"+" +&%#"!-"!+88"= '##0+%'*"A <%' !

;
- &&! !"#!- !!-"&"$08# 33" +#0"!8 #%'* '#0'8 #%'*%'!-" !+88"=, + &!-"<"$- '%$ 8+"3+!&$!"+ A;

%&$'$"+'"#9 %!&-:&!- !3+2 28=!-"+'!&%#"!-"&$!"+-%!&<"21"$! '# !-"+" !"+!-"&$!"+"88#:''!-"+ #9$ 0&%'*# < *"!!-"+'! <0#*0 +##"'!9+'!&-:#"'!9#"'!%'*$- &%&92+" B%'*!-"- '#8" '#!-"-" #8%*-!-"&%!"38 ''!-"%8"&-:&!- ! !"+-%!!%'*!-" !+88"=9!-"&$!"+: &#+%!"#!!-"+%*-!&%#" '#"88'!-"B !$- 3 !-

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
B%8<"!"+3"+-0+  %!%&&9!-"&$!"+ $ ''!-%!!-"!+ $!+!+88"=*%'* -" #%! '##+ *!-"&$!"+'!-" B !$- 3 !-!

-"+ #%& &&"+!%'!- !!-"+" +!=+"&!+88"=3 &&"# ."+!-"&$!"+%& 8&'!$++2+ !"#2=!-"+"3+!!-"<"$- '%$ -03%'#"+,%'*-- #'!<"'!%'"#!-"+"*%&!+ !%''0<2"+!+ $!+9'+ -"<"'!%'"#!-"' <"!-"#+%."+%'-%&&! "<"'!+"$+#"#2=!-"38%$" 20!
E-0+& !"+!-" $$%#"'!:-"'-"$8 %<"#!- !-" 8'*:%!--%& $0&%'2+!-"+,0B-:%'#"+,%'*-: &88:%'*!-"#"$" &"# +' %8,%'*- ' <!+$=$8" &!-"=:"+" 8&!*!, < ' %'$''"$!%':%!- #<"&!%$:+B  <!-".%":!- ! !)( 9:-"'!-"&-3& +" 20!! $8&"+ 8<&!$8&"#9%!%&#02!08!- !-03%'#"+,%'*- '#,0B-:%'#"+ ,%'*-$08#- ."#<"&!%$:+B !, < '  -03%'#"+,%'*-- # #<%!!"#!- !-%: '%* +-7, < ' + #%& :%#""'0*-9':-%$-!-+""."-%$8"&$ '38=&%#"2=&%#"%'#%$ !%'*!- ! "."'%!-"!

+ $!+!+88"=: &*%'*'!-"+ #9!-"+": &&0%$%"'!&3 $" +!-"&$!"+!3 &&:"."+9%! 33" +&!- !!-"&$!"+: & !

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

+%2&9!-"80'*&:"+"30'$!0+"# '#!-"+": &# < *"!!-"8%."+ ' !-"&"$%+$0<&! '$"&9 < !-" .%":!- !  ! !-"%+&! %'&! '$"9!-"3+"&"'$"-03%'#"+,%'*- '#,0B-:%'#"+ !!-"&3!%&

77 #02!08 ,"$'#8=9"."'%!-"&!+=30!+!-2=-03%'#"+,%'*-%& #<%!!"# &&0$-9!-"#+%."+!+ $!+!+88"=: &'! ! 08!-"&$!"+  +' %8,%'*-: & !-%*-&3""#'!-"< %'+ #9:-%$-%&:%#""'0*-! $$<<# !"!-+""."-%$8"&&%#"2=&%#" '#-"-%!!-"!+88"=+<2"-%'# ' ##%!%'!!-%&9!-"%#"'!%!=!+ $!+!+88"=%&&0*-!!2" 3+."#'!-"&3! 2= /%'#,%'*8  ;?9:-$8 %<"#!- !-"- # 3+#0$"#!-" $$0&"#2"+"!-"38%$" '#!-"!+ $!+!+88"=%&+"*%&!"+"#%' !-"' <"-%&2+!-"+ '#!- !-%& !-"+%&!-":'"+!-"%+<

,,-%.

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

+"8" &"#+!-:%!-9%'!+"D0%+"#%' '=!-"+$ &"

5,    

)
 &1B& ;-"!-"+&3" B%'* +" &'"# ( "& ;-"!-"+"3+! 28"

( "&