Shambhu Kumar v. Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal Cum Labour Court , Chd. And Others
! " ##$$ %&' "( ))* ++),("- ) .") .") /, / " , ".-, )*"
.
("
"#0 ! !" ! #
& !&12 3&1-04-
&3##$$ 55555 !" $ %&'
()
.3##$ &0 0$6
06&/
$73##$ +& 3 & 0 3 ##$- 3 1 $$80 030$6
06&/ $73##$00 &*+ ,,-&' .3 ##$$ 3 3$$70 3 2'071 $&0 7$ 3 00
9
- 83&:6 3 8& # #& &&0 :6 31 3$$77 3 8&0 00 9 ;'& / #0 :6 3 &07
&- )0'&$ .&:'$/'1/:'& ,'&/))- ,307&3 3& && &&0<3.&:'$=3:010
&0'$ &3##$$':133##$$8 00 & ##&'6 3&7 0 3 3 0#$&6 #&07 8& 0'0 83' $$87 0' #&0'& .3 $$7 1##&#& '0 '73 34 : :$30 3&'73 7 40 3$':13##$#& &&0:63�/ > '0&
3 )0'&$ #' - 9? 3& & & &&0 <3 9?= 8 1:$- 6 3 .&:'$ &:&&$6 $$80 9 3- 3& &- ':1 3 3 1#'702'071 3 7$@'07#&4&- $0##& 3 3 1 & & '$0 34 : '11&$6 010 :6 3 .&:'$83' &17#&$1&6'
&0 9 )3 3##$$338#0,'1& 0 ,"
7 3 &6 ,4$ && &3- ,307&3 3�/ >'&73'&30:&3-3 #0 47 ' 3 1 3 $- +&1& ,3 & &636& $3'73- 3 $30;#&0 3 6&
A 0 '0 3 ' & 1:BB$7 1' "A- A-
C/
8 #$0 '0& '# :6 3 ,1#C#$&6'3&6 -&1 &A 3 1&0'1 $1 #$&6 &0'& & D&>1 00 9
+)" 8 $ &7&0 7 31
A ,3&7 3 8 '0 3 ##$$- :6 3 #$&6 '3&6
E
?- 7 0#$&6 #&07
&
1##&#& 16 .3 ##$$ &0 0'&$ 0#'
A ?-8338& &&03:'&,11& & $ 84&- 3 $ #&07 $0- 0 $'& &#&8':10:63:'&,11&E ? ) F'- 3 0#' 8 & &&0 3 .&:'$- 83& 3 ##$$ 3$$70 3 3&7 3 0 3 0#$&6 #&07 0 7 31 ) 3 11- 3 �/ > $0 ##$'0&
3 9?: &3.&:'$>7 #&1 ' 83 3 0#$&6 #&07 7 3 0 '$7 1#$6- $'07 3 ##$$ .3 .&:'$- 40 8&0 00 9;'&/-$$8030##$.3& &- '# 1#$ 3 0#$&6 #&07- 3 ##$$ 8 010 &1&4
;'&/
.3 $6 ' & 0& : & 3 ,'& 3 833&3.&:'$82' 0&273& & 3##$$ 1:$:68&000 9)8'$0:#& & & 3 9?8330 83' 0'&$ 0#' &#&0'0 3&'0& & &06 & &/
)1 &13#$&07 /30'&$0#' &$6 8&>103&70-010-&&30&&10
&1 &4 84&- 3 - $6 3 3&7 3 0 3 0#$&6 #&07 0 7 3 ##$$ 8& 3$$70 : &3.&:'$ A )3:3$0:63 '#&1,'&3
$ !
-37&$$63&73-:3$$700
3 &73 30$F'.3$6;#3&'$383 1 3 3 3&7 3 3 : '0 :6 3 1# '3&6.3&$4;& 32'071&#&0'03&'0&/ !"#
$
%
&
'
&
(
&
%
&
)
&
1#3'##$0 ? D&7&18332'071 $&0 7$ 3 9
3$$7$68110:63.&:'$#&1731#$6& ' 83 3 0#$&6 #&07 :6 $$87 3 ##$
$0:63�/ >'0&
3 9? &3 & 3
3 9? ;#&$6 #&3: 3 1#$6& &103&77&#'37-30$F'1#$60'&73 #06 6#&07: &3.&:'$ E )#33$$773##$$8& &''&83$&47,'1&0,"-330 1:BB$0 '0:6 &'0'$$6#7 47' 3 1 &1&,3 & &6-8330$&06;#&0.3
'#&1 ,'& 3 -,./0 -+-%&' &+&1-% ,,-''&/- ./23%*/0&+4 /2-%565 7&*#.8&%!%*9&5/&9& !)83$'#3$07301$&0& 3:&40 33:>1#$61'0#$6'1360040'6 .3&$4;& 32'071&#&0'03&'0&/ *" +
$
&
, &
- ,
. /
*
0
!111
!2
' !111 1#3'##$0
) 48 3 :4- 8 do not find any illegality 3
1#'702'07101738&##& &&0:63##$$ .3&##$0010 $$#071$$'##$$00#0 !" #
:
D33& #>7C"0 GC D33&"#&:$ GC A