R.S.Labour v. Food Corporation Of India And ORS.




   
  "#$ $%&'&() 

*' +,"-.//"('0/# (#/"%#/ $#&#&($/ 2$/'.'

3/0/"#&( 
(3&" #4$/'

$'0(3$(#'

 


 


     

/$'$(#)1 / -&(.##536%"#$ /#4$0$#&#&($/ / "7&(3$/8"953395 .(7"- /+ ./&536%"#$ //$'0(3$(#' (# /+.:&#"&(536%"#$ //$'0(3$(# ( ;;;

     

$#&#&($/1 &/:4"'%4"99$(<$3#4$3$%&'&( #4$/$'0(3$(#1

3/0/"#&( 
(3&"5=4$/$-8&#4"'-$$(3&'>."9& &$3&(/$'0$%# #4$ #$(3$/&(>.$'#&(5 $&#./$ $"/($'#:($84"'-$$(3&/$%#$3"(3#4$

&/:4"'-$$(3$-"//$3 /:0"/#&%&0"#&(<&("(8 .#./$#$(3$/' #4$ /0/"#&( /"0$/&3 8$"/'  /&$ "%#'  "/$  #4"#  "(  $1#$(3$/  (#&%$  ="'  0.-9&'4$3  (     &(6&#&(<  (9&($  #$(3$/'  .(3$/  #4$  =  &3  +8'#$:  "00&(#:$(#    "(39&(<    /"('0/#  (#/"%#/  "(3  "3  /"('0/# (#/"%#/ /:6$:$(# 3</"&('"(3"99&$3:"#$/&"9' /"0$/&3

8$"/' 4$9"'#3"#$ /(9&($#$(3$/'.-:&''&(="''#&0.9"#$3"'  -8? "(3#4$#$%4(&%"9-&3'=$/$#-$0$($3(#4$'":$ 3"#$"#  (3&#&(9"8&(<3=(#4$3&'>."9& &%"#&(%(3&#&('

"(3(3&#&(/$<.9"#&(<$"/($'#:($8"'0$/ 3$9$(3$/ /:

11 =.93-$/$9$6"(###4$&''.$"#4"(3"(3"/$/$0/3.%$34$/$.(3$/)1

  



 

    

    



  





  

 

     

   

 

  

  

!" 

#   $    $ "

 $ 

 



"   $ 





 



% 



  

   

& 

   '    

       



  

  

       

   

 

  

  

!" 

#   $ 

 

 

    (  

   

 

  

  

 

"

 $  

 

&    $    

  )   *  +    ,

"

 +   







 



  

  

       

   

 

  

  

!" 

#   $& "

 $   

 

&    $ - 





 ,  



  



   

,  

 + 



   



    &     &  

  "

 

 

  

  



  





 



  



 &

"   

   $ - .    $  $   $ " 

  

  "

 &  "

 $ 

 

" /"       

 





 &

  

 

& 







 

   

 

   

/"  - '

0 "

#  

  











  







    

 





 

'   

" 

   

0 "

#  

  











  







 

"

 

1 2  



  )  

"

  

 

   









 !"

 # $ %&'( )") * + ,





 

  -%-.( 

"

 

" 

    "$

/0-012

3 

      



   

& 

  

  "     

   

      " 







/0-012

3 

  3   3

   

  

%50-

(

  3 .

.. .  

3 6

   

 





 

  (



      

  & 

 





 & 



 

  &  

"  $ 

  &



 

   

"

 $   



&

 



3    

 3  33    





7  )   *  +  

 









"

1"

    

$



  



 

  "



    

 

   

  



  

"

 

  

   "  





,     



"

 

)*+

0     





   $    

) /"    





 



/, 8  03  



 9    

   

  9 3

 . 



$  

3  

   



3 

  0   0 3   6     9 3

 . 

 "#   3  

 

 3  .

  

 

3 

 

3 0   

   0 7   3 3  3 3 2  
.

  3  

 3 

 : 

9 3 2  
.

 





3  .

 



7 

      "  

%22,6 3  "



(

(    "

 

(



 



   

   

 

"

 

 

    

)*+ 



   

 

"

 

        $  )*+7

11 

$#&#&($/'.-:&##$3(9&($-&3-.##4$'":$="'/$7$%#$3(#4$ </.(3  #4"#  #4$  @0$/&$(%$  $/#& &%"#$  4"3  (#  -$$(  ./(&'4$3  &(  #4$ 0/$'%/&-$30/ /:"4&'9$3##4$ &9&(<  AA &(#4&'

./# "(3 6&3$7.3<$:$(# 3"#$3    "&6&'&($(%4 4$93 #4$ /$7$%#&( #4$#$%4(&%"9-&3 #4$0$#&#&($/#-$(#7.'#& &$3&(9"="(3 "''.%453&/$%#$3#4$'":$#-$$6"9."#$3"<"&(
(0./0/#$3%:09&"(%$  #4$3&/$%#&('&''.$3-8#4&'./#5#4$/$'0(3$(#'%"99$3.0(#4$ 0$#&#&($/  6&3$  9$##$/  3"#$3    /  3$0'&#    $"/($'#  :($8

$#&#&($/3.983$0'&#$3#4$ (  =$6$/56&3$&:0.<($3 /3$/  3"#$3     "#  (($@./$  1  #4$  /$'0(3$(#1/0/"#&( 3&'>."9& &$3#4$0$#&#&($/1 &/:&(/$'0$%# #$(3$/&(>.$'#&((#4$-"'&'

#4"#"(  '

*1 ($ #4$0"/#($/'(":$98+4 "7+&(<44"3 -$$( $&#$3(? -8#4$ .(7"-+#"#$"/$4.'&(</0/"#&(5 "9"(34"/"(3"%%/3&(<98&(#$/:' (3&#&( #4$ 3$9$(3$/

/:#4$0$#&#&($/1 &/:="'&($9&<&-9$ ./#4$/:/$5(3&#&( #4$ 3$9$(3$/ /:4"'-$$(&(6B$3#3&/$%# $&#./$ #4$$"/($'# :($83$0'&# 'A5??*1"(3 &#4"'-$$(3$%&3$3 #-9"%B9&'##4$ 0$#&#&($/1 &/: /"0$/&3 8$"/'=$ ?  ,$"/($3%.('$9"00$"/&(< /#4$0$#&#&($/1 &/:4"'"/<.$3 #4"##4$ 3/0/"#&( 
(3&"4"'"%#$3:"9"

&3$"(3&("6&(3&%#&6$ :"(($/
(#4&'/$<"/35&#&''.-:&##$3#4"#:$/$98("%%.(# #4$ "%##4"# #4$ &/:4"3$"/9&$/'.%%$''

.998%(#$'#$3#4$/$7$%#&( #4$#$%4(&%"9-&3 -8  &9&(<    AA     5  #4$  /0/"#&(  ="'  -$(#  .0( 3&'>."9& 8&(<#4$0$#&#&($/1 &/: 
#4"' ./#4$/-$$('.-:&##$3#4"##4$ &:0.<($3  /3$/  3"#$3     (($@./$  1 !  4"'  -$$(  0"''$3  &( 6&9"#&( #4$0/&(%&09$' ("#./"97.'#&%$"'(00/#.(&#84"3-$$(

</"(#$3##4$0$#&#&($/#$@09"&(&#''#"(3"(3($&#4$/="'#4$%:09"&(#5 =4&%44"'-$$(/$ $//$3#&(#4$&:0.<($3/3$/5:"3$"6"&9"-9$
#4"' "9'-$$('.-:&##$3#4"#+4 "7+&(<4'( +44"##"/+&(<4&$($

#4$0"/#($/' #4$0$#&#&($/1 &/:4"3($6$/"009&$3 /"(8#$(3$/=&#4#4$

.(7"-  +#"#$  "/$4.'&(<  /0/"#&(  "(3  "'  '.%4  #4$  >.$'#&(  

$&#./$ #4$$"/($'#:($83$0'&#-8'.%4/0/"#&(3$'(#$6$( "/&'$"(3%('$>.$(#98#4$6$/8-"'&' 3&'>."9& 8&(<#4$0$#&#&($/1 &/:

6&3$&:0.<($3/3$/3"#$3  &'((1$@&'#$(#

/  +  ./&5  9$"/($3  %.('$9  "00$"/&(<  (  -$4"9    #4$ /$'0(3$(#1 3/0/"#&( 
(3&"4"'/"&'$3"0/$9&:&("/8-7$%#&( #4"##4$0$#&#&($/4"'(#&:09$"3$3#4$%(#/"%#/(":$98 *'C/&'4"( C.:"/&(=4'$ "6./#4$%(#/"%#"9/$"38'#"(3'"="/3$3"(3#4$=/B 4"6&(<"9/$"38%::$(%$35#4$=/&#0$#&#&(&'9&"-9$#-$3&':&''$3(#4$ '4/#</.(3 ((17&(3$/ ($%$''"/80"/#8  (:$/&#'5&#4"'-$$( '.-:&##$3#4"#"%:09"&(#4"3-$$(/$%$&6$3"<"&('##4$0$#&#&($/1 &/:"(3 (#4$-"'&' "(&(6$'#&<"#&(4"6&(<-$$(%"//&$3.#"(3.0(3.$ 6$/& &%"#&(  /:  #4$  .(7"-  +#"#$  "/$4.'&(<  /0/"#&(5  &'#/&%#

&%$5"9"(34"/"'/$<"/3'#4$  +4 "7+&(<4'( +44"##"/ +&(<45($ #4$0"/#($/' #4$0$#&#&($/1 &/:4"6&(<-$$( $&#$35#4$ &:0.<($3/3$/3&'>."9& 8&(<#4$0$#&#&($/1 &/: /#4$#$(3$/&(>.$'#&( 3"#$3   4"3 -$$( 0"''$3 .('$9'.-:&#'#4"##4$"%#&(

$&#./$ $"/($'#:($8"'"9'-9"%B9&'#&(<#4$0$#&#&($/1 &/: /"

0$/&3 8$"/'&''#/&%#98&(%( /:&#8=&#4(3&#&('"(3 #4$ 3$9$(3$/ /:  ,$"/($3%.('$9 /#4$0"/#&$'4"6$-$$(4$"/3

11 A
#  4"'  <($  .(%(#/6$/#$3  #4"#  #4$  &:0.<($3  /3$/  

$&#./$ $"/($'#:($83$0'&#"'"9' -9"%B9&'#&(<4"'-$$(0"''$3 =&#4.#"

/3&(<#4$0$#&#&($/"(00/#.(&#8 -$&(<4$"/3
( "%#5&# ="'0"''$3=&#4.#$6$('$/6&(<"'4=%".'$(#&%$.0(#4$0$#&#&($/1

&/:%"99&(<.0(&##'4=%".'$##4$0/0'$3-9"%B9&'#&(<
#&'-8(==$99'$##9$3#4"#-9"%B9&'#&(<4"'#-$0/$%$3$3-8 "'4=%".'$(#&%$ $ $/$(%$&(#4&'/$<"/3:"8-$:"3$##4$3$%&'&('  #4$(D-9$+.0/$:$./#&(

   !"#$% & !

 '  $ #!"(  )*+,+-  *  

(  ..+ "(3 $!

  #/ !&0  #!1&/#"  " $1#!

2# $% 
$%#3 & '$ #!"().4*5-+(

(*46 4$ &:0.<($3/3$/3"#$3  &(' "/"'&#-9"%B9&'#'#4$0$#&#&($/1 &/:

/"0$/&3 8$"/'5"''.%45%"((#'.'#"&((#4$'4/#</.(3#4"#&# 4"'-$$(0"''$3&(%9$"/6&9"#&( #4$0/&(%&09$' ("#./"97.'#&%$ E 4$/$&'"(#4$/"'0$%#0$/#"&(&(<#-9"%B9&'#&(<#4"#=$=.93 9&B$#"33/$'' ? %(7&(#/$"3&(< (3&#&('"(3%(#"&($3&(#4$ 3$9$(3$/ /:%9$"/98&(3&%"#$'#4"##4$#$(3$/$/=4'$$"/($'#:($8 3$0'&#"(3*/'$%./&#83$0'&#4"'-$$( $&#$3-8#4$ 3/0/"#&(  
(3&"/"(83$0"/#:$(# $(#/"9/+#"#$6$/(:$(#/"(8#4$/

.-9&%+$%#/ (3$/#"B&(<&(%./'"(&($9&<&-&9&#8 /0"/#&%&0"#&(<&(#4$ #$(3$/0/%$'' ./#4$/:/$5& "(8&( /:"#&( ./(&'4$3-8'.%4#$(3$/$/ &' .(3#-$&(%//$%#/ "9'$5"0"/# /: $&#./$ #4$$"/($'#:($8 3$0'&#'.%4#$(3$/$/&'"9'9&"-9$#-$3$-"//$3 /:0"/#&%&0"#&(<&("(8 #$(3$/=&#4#4$ 3/0/"#&( 
(3&" /"0$/&3 8$"/' 4$>.$'#&(5"''.%45=4&%4"/&'$' /%('&3$/"#&(&'"'# =4$#4$/&($6$/8%"'$ "#$(3$/$/&(%.//&(<"3&'>."9& &%"#&("(3.0(

1A1 "(8&( /:"#&( ./(&'4$3-84&:*4$/-$&(< .(3#-$&(%//$%#5=.93#4$ %(3&#&( -9"%B9&'#&(<-$&(6B$3&("/.#&($"(3:$%4"(&%"9 "'4&( "(3%('$>.$(#98=.93&#-$&:0$/"#&6$ /#4$".#4/&#8%(%$/($3#0"''

"(/3$/ -9"%B9&'#&(< /#4$:"@&:.:0$/&3$(6&'"<$3F 
(./%('&3$/$36&$=#4$"('=$/#'.%4"0'$/4"'#-$&( #4$($<"#&6$4$"'0$%#  -9"%B9&'#&(<%":$#-$%('&3$/$3-8#4$ (D-9$0$@./#&(7" !

"&  &92# " '
#2&/3" '" #$%:#" # 3 ' $ #!()*+;6-*

(;4*
#="'4$93#4"# #4$%(%$0# $>."9&#8 00/#.(&#8=.93"0098$6$(#:"##$/' 0.-9&% %(#/"%#'4$+#"#$4"'#4$/&<4###/"3$-.#&'"9'.(3$/#4$-.(3$( 3.#8#-'$/6$$>."9&#8 6$(#4.<45"(&(3&6&3."9:"8%4'$(## 3$"9  =&#4  "(8 0$/'(  -.#  #4$  +#"#$  %"((#  %4'$  #  $@%9.3$  0$/'(' "/-&#/"/&98 
#  ="'  4$93  #4"#  "(  /3$/    -9"%B9&'#&(<  4"'  #4$  $

$%#  

3$0/&6&(<"0$/'($>."9&#8 00/#.(&#8&(#4$:"##$/ 0.-9&%%(#/"%# -9"%B9&'#&(</3$/$(#"&9'"36$/'$%&6&9%('$>.$(%$'9"%B9&'#&(<="' 4$93#-$"(G&('#/.:$(# %$/%&(H  4$/$=.93-$(>."//$9=&#4#4$0/0'&#&(#4"##4$0=$/ #-9"%B9&'#"0$/'(&'"($%$''"/8%(%:&#"(###4$$@$%.#&6$0=$/

#4$+#"#$#%"//8(#/"3$/-.'&($''"(3:"B&(< %(#/"%#' /"(8 0./0'$ 4$/$($$3(#-$"(8'#"#.#/8</"(# /#4$$@$/%&'$ '.%4 0=$/4$9$<"99&:&#"#&(54=$6$/5.0(#4$$@$/%&'$ '.%4"0=$/&'

#4"##4$+#"#$:.'#"%# "&/98"(3/"#&("998=&#4.#&("(8="8-$&(< "/-&#/"/84$-7$%# -9"%B9&'#&(<:"8-$'$$("'"($

$%#&6$:$#43# 3&'%&09&($  3$6&"(#  '.009&$/'*%(#/"%#/'  4$  -7$%#    -9"%B9&'#&(<5 4=$6$/5%"(($6$/-$#%::$/%&"998$9&:&("#$"%(#/"%#/9"%B9&'#&(< &'"0.(&#&6$:$"'./$"(34"'#-$%::$('./"#$##4$"%#' :&''&(

1E1 "(3%::&''&(&(%9.3&(<:&'/$0/$'$(#"#&('* "9'& &%"#&( /$%/3'"(3 #4$/-/$"%4$' #4$/$<.9"#&('.(3$/=4&%4#4$%(#/"%#'=$/$"99##$3 $/$&(=.939&$#4$"009&%"-&9&#8 #4$0/&(%&09$ 0/0/#&("9&#8&(#4$ 3$%&'&(:"B&(<0/%$''-8#4$%:0$#$(#".#4/&#8=4&9$-9"%B9&'#&(<" #$(3$/$/ ("3:&(&'#/"#&6$3$%&'&( -9"%B9&'#&(<4"'#%(#"&(#4$ $9$:$(# 0/0/#&("9&#8"(3&#=.93-$&:0$/"#&6$.0(#4$3$%&'&( :"B$/#'#/&B$"-"9"(%$-$#=$$(#4$"36$/'$$

$%#' '.%4"(/3$/( #4$&(#$/$'#' #4$#$(3$/$/"(3#4$($$3#"30#0.(&#&6$:$"'./$'.0( 0"/#&$'<.&9#8 '.%43$ ".9#B$$0&(<&(:&(3#4$-7$%#"(30./0'$&# &(#$(3'#'$/6$4$0/&(%&09$ 0/0/#&("9&#8=/B'(#4$"''.:0#&( #4"#"3:&(&'#/"#&6$"%#&(.<4#(##<-$8(3=4"#&'($%$''"/8"(3# "%4&$6$#4$3$'&/$3/$'.9#'
#&'(##4"#&($6$/8%"'$ 3&'>."9& &%"#&( "(3&(/$<"/3#'.0098 :&'9$"3&(<&( /:"#&(* "9'$&( /:"#&(#4"##4$ %:0$#$(#".#4/&#8=.93:$%4"(&%"998&(6B$#4$0=$/ -9"%B9&'#&(< "(3  -9"%B9&'#  #4$  %(#/"%#/  /  #4$ :"@&:.: 0$/&3  $(6&'"<$3  &(  #4$ /$9$6"(#%9".'$
(./6&$=0/6&'&(=&#4/$<"/3#-9"%B9&'#&(<=&994"6$ #-$6&$=$3"'"($("-9&(<0/6&'&("(3(#&(#4$("#./$ "0=$/# &''.$-9"(B$#/3$/' 3$-"//&(<"%(#/"%#/ /#4$:"@&:.:0$/&34$ >.$'#&(=4$#4$/#3&'>."9& 8"(3#-9"%B9&'#"%(#/"%#/& "#"99"(3 =4"#0$/&3=.93/$>.&/$$6"9."#&(&(#4$ "%#'"(3%&/%.:'#"(%$' $"%4 %"'$  36$/#&(<##4$ "%#' #4$0/$'$(#%"'$5#4$0$#&#&($/1 &/:

4"'-$$(3&'>."9& &$3'#$('&-98 /#4$/$"'(#4"#"($"/($'#:($83$0'&#  ($ &#'0"/#($/+4 "7+&(<44"3-$$( $&#$3&(#4$8$"/ -8#4$

.(7"-+#"#$"/$4.'&(</0/"#&(3$%&'&(#-9"%B9&'# /"0$/&3  8$"/'4"'-$$(#"B$((#4$</.(3#4"#'.%4&( /:"#&(4"3-$$(

1?1 %(%$"9$3(%$3$3985#4$&:0.<($3/3$/4"'-$$(0"''$3(#4$-"'&'

&(6$'#&<"#&(.0("%:09"&(#"(3&(=4&%4#4$0$#&#&($/1 &/:4"3(# -$$( "''%&"#$3  .('$9  /  #4$  0$#&#&($/ 4"'  "36$/#$3  #  3%.:$(#' 09"%$3(/$%/3"#(($@./$' 1# 1A#%(#$(3#4"#4"3"%4"(%$ -$$( "

/3$35#4$/$="' '.

&%&$(# :"#$/&"9 =&#4 #4$0$#&#&($/1 &/:# %(6&(%$#4$".#4/&#&$'%(%$/($3#4"#&#'0"/#($/+4 "7+&(<44"3($6$/ "009&$3  /  "(8  %(#/"%#  9"#$3  -8  #4$  .(7"-  +#"#$  "/$4.'&(< /0/"#&("(3"''.%45#4$>.$'#&( $&#./$ $"/($'#:($83$0'&# -8'.%4/0/"#&(3&3(#"/&'$
#&'(# /.'#$@":&($#4$&:0"%#

'.%43%.:$(#'"(3#/$#./(" &(3&(<"'#=4$#4$/#4$0$#&#&($/4"3 '.009&$3 "9'$&( /:"#&(/="'<.&9#8 %(%$"9:$(#
#="' /#4$ 3 /0/"#&( 
(3&"#4"6$&''.$3"(#&%$"(3</"(#$3##4$0$#&#&($/1

&/:"(00/#.(&#8# ./(&'4&#'6&$=0&(#(#4$%:09"&(##4"#4"3-$$( /$%$&6$3+.%4%./'$ "%#&(5="'(# 99=$3<"&('#'.%4-"%B3/05 &#="'&:0$/"#&6$.0(#4$%:0$#$(#".#4/&#8#4"6$#"B$("/$"'($3 3$%&'&("'#=4$#4$/#4$0.(&#&6$"%#&( -9"%B9&'#&(<="'%"99$3 /& "# "99"(3 /=4"#0$/&3  4$"-6$%9".'$':$/$98$(#&#9$#4$/$'0(3$(##-9"%B9&'##4$ 0"/#8 /"'0$%& &$30$/&3
#3$'(#%:0$9#4$/$'0(3$(##3'
# =.93-$0$(##4$/$'0(3$(##-9"%B9&'#"0"/#8 /9$''#4"(#4$0$/&3 '0$%& &$3/$6$((#"#"993$%&'&(&(#4&'/$<"/3:.'#-$"(&( /:$3 ($B$$0&(<&(:&(3"99#4$ "%#'"(3%&/%.:'#"(%$ #4$%"'$
#%"(4"/398 -$'.<<$'#$3#4"#"3$9&-$/"#$-/$"%4 #4$#$/:'"(3%(3&#&('=.93 &(6&#$#4$'":$%('$>.$(%$'"'"(&("36$/#$(#$///
(#4$%&/%.:'#"(%$5#4$=/&#0$#&#&(&'3&'0'$3 -8'$##&(< "'&3$#4$&:0.<($3/3$/3"#$3  &(' "/"'&#-9"%B9&'#'#4$

1 0$#&#&($/$"/$54=$6$/5.("-9$#</"(###4$0$#&#&($/" "(3":.' #%('&3$/&#' &("(%&"9-&3 /#4$=/B&(>.$'#&( /#4$/$"'(#4"#&

'.%4/$9&$ &'</"(#$35#4$'":$=.93$

$%##4$/&<4#' "#4&/30"/#8"(3&(

"6./ =4:#4$%(#/"%#4"'"9/$"38-$$(&''.$3'$6$/"9:(#4'"< "(3'.%4#4&/30"/#84"6&(<(#-$$(&:09$"3$3"'"0"/#8-$ /$.'4$ /$'0(3$(#1 3/0/"#&( 
(3&"=.93-$"#9&-$/#8#0"''" /$'4 /3$/=&#4/$<"/3#-9"%B9&'#&(<5& "(85"

#$/"

/3&(<#4$0$#&#&($/3.$ 00/#.(&#8 -$&(<4$"/3"(3&(#4$9&<4# #4$-'$/6"#&('%(#"&($3&( #4&'/3$/5=&#4&("0$/&3 #==$$B'

$#&#&(5"%%/3&(<985&'3&'0'$3 )<&%'!- )#=& '#!&   & '"- /& 
&#% "&/#  '#  *>*4.4*6 9.%B8 4$#4$/#-$/$ $//$3# $0/#$/F$'