Avtar Singh v. State Of Haryana And Another
!" #$ %%&& '"
(
)"* $"
%
" * #$+! "$%%&& " ', -$"./+0+)"* " 1,$ 2(&0"#+!" " 3 0&&+! "$4%& 5" % 6
!
7$%" %%&$ 8 &( " $ $(& $(&7"8 2"! " + 9
#"#(&"8& 8" #:;6
( "
5 5 5 5 5 <5<
5<<<5< <-6 < $$(& $(&7"8 2"! " "# "2& "+ ""
+)"*
=("2 ("
"4 -6$! 8 & ( &*+$ "$
+$ + $( 8 %$.$4%& $8"(#$"&&*" $"$( $4+2"$&+ ."1&+) (4 $&,$4 $$"&&*. ( #$ " $".* $& 8( $4 7$""+$4". 4%"4 <
( 4*+$8! %"
$" , % ,&&$ $
4%& ; ("$"&&#$"(
< 2 +$ ( %"
%",!$&( $$( $4%& & /(" (% $"$( 8 +$"8"$" &.+3# $ $" & "8(&& &&."#4 $$ %& $ "! # #$ <5
"(
5 < +$& #"& ."&
$$( $ $( %"
& #.$$( 5%%&&
$"( , .
%"
4$"$( !$& 8",%
$#$"$( "! &> # & " $ .$
,&& & &,$# *& " $"$( $( +$
1"
(
&"$%%&& $$ %%&& $ 8 & &*4%& $%" $ 8$ $ 8"
7$ 4%& :("$"+$ :;$ 8 """$" %" 7$%%&&
( %"% $$" ".$$$" 4&#& "%"""8"$!"
#$$" :("$"+.$$ "! $ " %8& $ *+ $ ( %"* $ 4%& &( #$ /(".
$!4%"4 7$ %%&& & #.$$"( $!&"*&% 8" # 6 < <9
#?( #$:; $8 4%"4 " 1,$ 2(&0"#+!"" 3 0&&+!%(
%%" 8$&$4%& 5" % 6 + 4&*+* !+ .! "! "4 $(44%"4 (84
$$$ 8/ $%%&& &"# "#(&"8&
""#$%&"'( )!
"*"
7$&"
(
&$ &( *" $(" *.$$ , "" %" "+%% $#" "#(&"8& $%%&& $#"( $$%%&& $ !&*%"% $ &&# $ 4%&* (&* 8& $ )("$" (84 $ $%%&& !&! $" & ).!"+$(& "!" $$ 4%& $% # ?( #$:; % #8"$ (" . 3(# - $ ) @8& (%"4 (" A
'!#' (#+.$" %%"!& #
( ""&%" " ;
$ 8 "!
! " #
$ % ! !&
" ! !
$
"
!
' $ ("
)
"$ !
"
$ !! !
"
!
!
" !
"
$ *
+ )! #$"&"
(
&"$%" "%"( #$ ""$ +"
%" $$%%&& 8$ $8"
""#$%&"'( )!
"&"
;
4%& 7$ &"%"( " < " 2 . %" 8"$ "
(" "&$ $ 44($%"#"
7$(&%8&*+ *+.(&8"4 $4 "& 6 ( (& %("% $&& 8 "! 8* ("$" $ ( 5%%&& B% #$%%&& ("$" .$( $ %" %$"&8 # &( $ "(("+.(&8!&! "#$ ( ""& $
( ;
B% !.$&.&.
8*$) @8&(%"4(" ;
A
@
"4 &9<
!
"+
<9 +$ !&!4 $%%&& $"
.(& 8#"( "( #"
"#(&"8& ;
!.$8!+$%" %%& &&. 7$( +.$( 44 #(% $4" & 4*%"/($(4 $"&+$%%&& !" #$+ ""8"& "#(&"8& (" #"& $ ("
#8&8 ("*8 $ ;&&?# "57"&(" 6$ #8 "!$" 8! $&&8
"( =%"
% $ (" 4" $"&(" $&&%" .$(8 #%"/(8*8 "!
$ (" !
&'+'( ,
C$$" %, #5" D 56 C$$""%"8& D 56