Dilbag v. Financial Commissioner Haryana & ORS
!"# $ %!&'()%&*# +"# , -%.
/'0'
%&%11''+%2%%3*'
'45'
!" #$%&'" '&!(#$)*"
'( )
6%*+5&%+ !*4
) 6%546.*)%+6 +%2%%+ !*6%
) /*%05*%2+5&%+ !'45 $
77777 '&!(#+,- * 4 ' %..5 ! * 140.5 5 5%5
#
# "#
890 ;4%''5-2* %&%11''+%2%% 1%5-2*'0555%5"
"
"#
4%''5
<$, !"## 890 :,;+=*-2%5&=%'''05 * %&% 11'' 5&5 * 1% .%5.+ * %441!>%1-%5%+ +*'41'+''& -2%?.&'5%1'%55:1'!*'4&4%'
)
6%*+%5&0'!*4'0-1'*% 1%5+*4*%515%%44&%!4%&.&5 %55%5&01'590 : 5%5"@
"#
+-02*'%1 *%-&5-2* %&%11''%5+*0'+*'
.''.%2 $/1%=%'!%&.= '-%. <"
5%5, $ "##<+056&' "
+ "$+ "@+ $ %5 @ 5%5
@ "##,+056&' $ + "
+ "$%5 $ + &6%+0*%+ *0.*50.*45&2!*1%-!*&+ @
'45 $*%'-%&A05%5'4&! <"+=* *%5-%&A05+''&=**' %44&%=%'&'55+* '%1=%'45.
$*%5&%&*504*4%&*%2% %5+''&*%.'*&%&*5%5 !0* '0-1' *% .%5 *%' - . * 4''! 0 :!* 0B%->%5 0 0'%'%44&%- *6%!%2%%%'*!%*!*4*%555'&' *6%%'*5%' 44%5'%- *'!%&'= A05-455C?5 -.%=%'+*0'+B504 * %&% 11'' 5&5 * 1% 4%.1%&%2 %5 -B&2
&%+ ) / *%05*%2+ %5 &0' ! '45 $'0-1'*%'45 $'150&%5*%* 4 ' *&%''4%''%520.%.%5*%'.1%2&%'' !!%124%.+10&*''54.*%&&0'!'1% '%.'
**%'-%5*&*4''! 0"#!* 0'+ %5%'&5*5!*'0+*!+*'.%2 %54'2 *%*%5*%5&0'!*4%'+%44%'5* 4%4 -? %5 ! * = *% * ' 1 %5 !& * '0-1'''!*%5&0'!*4%'*&'!* %44&%890 : ;5%*%*&!&%90
=*.%5*'&'55-2*'!%*%' 44%5'%- =%'4%%54%&!*'4%'25%*&!&%=%'
%%&*5%'90 '*=*%*%.&00%%5=5-2*' !%**%'5504*1%5*'-*%5'1*5&01' *% - 4%&5 &5+ *0'+ * & =* .%5 * %5*&*4''! 0 :!* 0'++'1''
'.%5'**%'4&'+*&&554'&5' *%-** '+'45 $*%'-%&A05+*0'+*' 5!%&! 0 @!* 0'+ $' *&%''4%''%5 20. %.%5 *%5 &-05 *'&*1' %' &5 %-+ =*%'*4+%*1!&'5%!*%44&%+=%' 5%5,*&%''4%''+*0.**!%5 #*&%''
*'!%&'*% -'-2*%0*'
%1!*=*%**%5-%5*& *5!*0+=*-2*1%=%'1%55-%&? &%' ! !& ' 1%5 0 4 '%5'
5'1''5
,./(0 + '&!- ,1 2/ #$)*"
/ / 23 ,4 56 ,2
/ / ,9