Karun Bansal And Another v. Dvisional Commissioner And Others











 




 !"#"$
%&&
'

()$
 $# -

(#

"."#"$ (0


"."#"$0


(#
-& #1$+

/
%
 

 

! "

!#!



!!
(
%
2(&
 (.

$
')/

(30
+.!

(

(&
444

! "

!#!



!!$

 %!& 

(#
,
!/
5 "*"$3
(+ (
7, 56

"."#"$ #
(

*
1(

(#
)$+ (
9 "$
:;


$+"

$
9

/1
!

0
<==0
!$ "(/"$3

(+ ** +

+
&&=
7, 56

+

!)

+
"$
.)(


(#
+

+
&&;
"#
#)3, 
5
"/1)$+ +&

?

($ +
!)$# *
#)5/"

( #1$+ #
, 7($3 )**6

$+
1)(!,

(#

5


#

/1
+) 6
,

$
7($3*6
$, 
#&00;0;<@
"$#

+


3("!)* *
* $+
7"

,

/1
+) 6

#&A:0=;0@&

?

($ +
!)$# *
#)5/"

#
1

#
(
,#"*
9)$ /
+, /
9"$3,
 "+
+7$
56
** (
(

6

(
 
7& & &
&;&0
$+
(/

5)$+ (6

//"

)1 ', +"6 *
 ,
B)1 
+ ,


!( C
7 
5

3("!)* $+
(
( *
)#

5.

0

#
7

*6
"> +&

(0

( #1$+ #
,
7($3 )**6


5

( *
$




,
3".

$
/6
,)3, )*
!$#"+

"$

#)5/"##"$#&
:


)$+ (
( "!*
;

$# ) "$

$+"

7,"* (!"#"$3
#)1 (."#(6
8)("#+"!

"$0
(

$
(+   0
7)*+
,
*"/"

+
#!1

"$


7
"$
,"#
( (+
"#
#

+
56
$D5*
9)1(

"$
E


 




 

    D0
     &




"#
1(+)!

#
)$+ (%

 !   "# $ 

%! #  %! #  "

&%' "   (   !

  '

)  "! * "  !

! #  %%

!   !

  +"!     #!

!* ! #  " !  %!

%  # $    "!

!!

 "  $ !

#  !  #

%*  #'   $  !#!

"  ,*  !

 -

  #  !! #   !!  + %    !  ,* . $

!

!

%%!* # %!

!  '%/  #

!   %'  !   '  % ! !

 ! !

0   %' ! ! '!

!

 0

 ! #  %!

!&!! +   '!

#!

 #  !! )  !  "'! #  %  ! !

  *! * ! #  # &#!

!* # !

   #  ,*  -  *$  !!   # 

%  #  % 1 !  &%%   !

      #$    "!

!  "   # &#!

!* # +  #  #' # # !!   "  -%%

 +"!  + ,*  



!  #    ! #  ! !

 -

  #  !! # !

 !  *'! !

 %% $   "!    

! "

 ! #  %%

 #' !  '!!   

%   #   !* ! %%   %  $ !  "! "!* ' $  %!      #  %   !  #   #!

 #!

!* #  %%

 #'  % + !  %   !  *'! !

 %%   !  #!

!* ! #   ! #  

" % + 2&  3! ! 

! # !!& ! ! # '  !

$   4!* !

!    !    !

$  4 ! !#!

   '%'"

 !



 )  ! *'!   ,* . !!

! #  %!

%  #  !  % # !#!

"  %  !

! #  # &#!

!* #' 4 !* *! *  ! #   * # # &#!

!* "   #$   #      %%!* #  "!  "  %  !  0  #  !/!*   !

  #!

 # ! #   #

!

!  "  $   &%% ! #  !

  "  % 5 A

(
, /"$
1*

#
#

)1
56

(#
5 $+
, #
)$+

$+
,

$
#*+
(/

 166 ,

$+
(/

 166
,

*#
#*+
*
* **#
)$+

+ :
7($3*6
/ :&

$
."

7

"+
) "$+"$3#0


$+
(/
7,"!,

(#
, *#

:
1)(!, +0
5

#
( *0

"#
$
1(."#"$

3("!)* *&

, $+
7)*+
*#
,

*
* $+&
;

/"$"$3
"+
#1 (7"# *#

"$+#

"$

*
1(

+
56

(#0
6
, /# *.

+
"$
1
&:
#
)$+ (%
+      

*

 !

!*  '!! !  '%*!    !

'!* 7  # 8 166 #

 !  &36 !

9:( 7 #

 !   -& ( +     

*

 !

!*  *!  #    

!

 ;:

8!   7  !

%%

! %  !

'!* 6 -  ; 8!  ( 7  #'  ! 8 ,$ !  !

  ! %! # 8 166 !   *!  %! #  

!

  %%

!        '!!    %! #  %! %%

!  #& #'  !
&< $ "      *!  #  !*  !

*

$   !!!

!*  '%*!

 !

 %% <
(/
5.

0
"

"#

(#D
*

#)("$3
:
!( #
A
F *#
=&
/ (* #
"#
(/

8"$

&

,)#0


#
/ +
"$

(+ (
"/1)3$ +0
, #
5

$
#)5+"."+

$+
#*+
(
1 (#$#
"$!*)+"$3

(#&

$!

(#$#0
7,
,
1)(!, +
* $+
(/



,

#
( *0

$+
7)*+
*#
, 
5

#


( *&



,

1

(#D

#

+

+

(

*

*#

+ #

$



$67,
/ "$



$)/5 (


$+
#

*6&

,)#0
$+
, #
5

$
("3, *6


5
( *
(
7,"!,

(#

( G)"( 6

/1
+) #
1( #!("5 +
(
*
1)(1# #&

,
(+ ** #
)1, *+
56

(0
0
+ #
$
7 $6
"$

=
$
."

7

7("

"$
"#
' % ! "

!#!



!!&

'( &&
=< !> ) %
!*? !

@?1 ) %"

@?1