← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/239/2008allowed

Bala Devi And ORS. v. Subhash And ORS.

2025-12-10Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma11 pages

-1- 

     

Reserved on:- 27.11.2025



!

"#$ 

!



      

     %  &'% ( ((  ( %      



       

  !"#  $% & ''''

(  ( %    ( )              * 

  +

,!((-,,. &

   

$%) /  

%     

 (00

  

(1223   

) 56  %  %   * 

%  

  7(2-,,8" 

  

 9      



  -2,.-,,! -   %    

      : % %   + &

  )      



  :   

;  & ( %(( ( '  ('

  ( < )     

% "   

%  &

  )  

+    )   &

 +  % 

%      +

-27        !"#  $% &

+ % &*

%   +   *   )   &  %

  ! #       

  

+    

 +

  ('')  % (  0 = 5  %  $   

     Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another *+

,-.("/0$11

2

+ 

+ %  %   

 

%  "

>30

                                                          

                                         !"#$%              &$    !"#' %     '(    !"#) %     

*                  +       

 ),-                           .              

-3-  !%     

/    0   

                  +    

    

            

       

       ),-            ),-     

                          

                

    

* * * * * * 42. *          !'%   !       

 2     %   

  "3!   ")&, &" &)  %        4 "5 &($,   4 "($"$)   4 ")$(',   4 "''"')    4 "$'(),    

      4 "")"))   4 6 )((,   4 5("()   4 )((5,  

-4- . = 5%$  

 National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. *+

3- .(.4 2   

+  

 (00(0<" (02

  

(122 

+ * 

"

36 

          *  ?     %  %  @ 36 

  %    * *  @ 3$6 *    & *% @ 36    *            %&    

    %  ? +

   @ 3A6 B 

  *   



*+

%  9@ "%&  ? & )    

9 *%   "

>52. 7   conventional heads      8 0 +     8 &) ,,,           8  "

,, ,,,    8"

,, ,,,       

       

 8 0

1  :   

       

           ;   

    7         

            

-5-     

       

  

     <                      

  

     

  

          

        +           

                   8 ") ,,,

8 ', ,,,    8 ") ,,,  

 

             =         *                           

    

         ",-       *        

> > > > > 59.3 *     ),-                  0     ',     

   $,-      ',),

  +      ),(,

-6-

    ")-  7              

59.4 +      !%    

  ',-             ',  

7 &)-       ',),   ",-     ),(,       

    

          

59.5 /                     $,$&1  ? @     

59.6.

    

1  ? A    '& 0 

59.7

          

59.8 8        

        8 ") ,,, 8', ,,, 8") ,,,

         ",- 

  2 = 5%$  

 %$5/$$#1$ /"$6'7/7081$ $/$#7$199 $/ 091*

4+ 4- ( :

2

    *($#$8/$+1"$- $$6(097+("$- 

-7- 



+*  *   % 

%

 "

C21 7 =     1 9 

                <               +      D D     D     D  D     D    D   D

      

            

   

*            

&"

"

Spousal consortium          

        D 



 

      0   D

&"

& Parental consortium             D      



     D

&"

$ Filial consortium               7                     

               

        

               40 

-8-         E                  40              

                                

4? 7                +                        

                                7 7               

         

              D D    1 9 +                      8 ', ,,,          

1 

   +

 9  +

-2& *



+   &

  % &

-9-

 

  *

&

*

 9  << &&  *   "% % A?"2 (, 

+ 

 ++; * 

&  * &  *0,,,8"%

=+   % & +  

%)  

)  *

&

 %

 <0,,8"&  *



% %%+* 

%

; +;)      +  

*  (( 

+ 

  ) 

 *(8< +  ? 

 $   *

 ?   ; * +



 +

%     ;<09      

+      ?   

  (-  



+ 

  )     & *%  <710$= 3

 +B

%  % *  

     %*% *



   ?     %)  

+

: * 

$   '

(  (< # +

+ + &

= 5%$  

  9 *% 

 + ) +

,!((-,,.   %   

  *&  )    "

%        %   

   % " "

-10Sr.

No.

Heads Compensation Awarded ( 

&# % <0,,8"

- B 

C7,D (77,8"37,D <0,,6 < 

  +     ? (87 (-0,8"3!,7,E(876 ) # % <.2,8"3!,7,"(-0,6 !

  (.

  & ..((-,8"3<.2,E(-E(.6 .

F A (2(!,8"

B A?  (2(!,8"

F $  % -1,7,,8"

 727,,?< 727,,?( B727,,?- 0$#/"1$07

>,3>4 ;

07 % + &

) 

1<> 4>

;

9$$/0

1.>3,>.

;

+

>,3>4

<> 4>

- (7  

         &= 5% $  Dara Singh @ Dhara Banjara Vs. Shyam Singh Varma

,:

3.

R.Valli and Others VS. Tamil Nandu State Transport Corporation + -!

("/0$11

3> 

 "

% *

 

C1D % 

 % %

  * % 



 G   (! ) #  $% & 

 

 %

 %    *+

 +

) +

   + %

 %

   &

9 *% ) )  





 %  %    *+

  



  

% 8    

 &

  ) 

-11- + ,!((-,,.) % 8  

  

  ;

  

)  (0   *  36  &   

!    +(  ( %-      

; *8  "; *; *   H

  I8