High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13935/2025dismissed

Nahar Singh v. Financial Commissioner Appeals Punjab And Others

2025-07-15Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger9 pages

"#$ '$()*)%+

, "."/ 0)+1.

,,,,,, $#)#)%+$/ 2$/*3*

)+"+()"4 %55)**)%+$/

66$"4* 3+7"8 %#.$/*

,,,,,, $*6%+'$+#* 9: ,

0 0 /$*$+# /, 0.$//;

<, 0)+14"=

'>%("#$

6$#)#)%+$/,

/, )/5"47)# 0)+1.

)?"+"= 0$+)%/

3+7"8,

, , 0 =

, $#)#)%+$/

"."/ 0)+1. )+*#"+# ()>)4 ?/)# 3+'$/

/#)(4$* - %+*#)#3#)%+ +')"= )+#$/ "4)"= *$$@)+1 ?/)# +"#3/$ ($/#)%/"/) *$##)+1 "*)'$ %/'$/* ,

B , ,

*# /"'$= %/)+'"

*.%/# %44$(#%/= ?.$/$8;

9$;9 9C$$59 *"+"'

#"@*$$5 .">$ *"+(#)%+$'= /$*6$(#)>$4;,

&3/#.$/ 6/";$/ 5"'$ *$##)+1 "*)'$ -,

)+"+()"4 %55)**)%+$/

66$"4*= 3+7"8

*.%/# )+"+()"4 %55)**)%+$/9= ?.$/$8;

/$>)*)%+

= "1")+*# 6/%($$')+1*%/'$/* ')*5)**$'

/)$&4;= /$*6%+'$+#

>#"/ 0)+1. "+ "664)("#)%+

*$$@)+1 7%)+# 5$"*3/)+1 <"+"4 - "/4"*= (%56/)*$'

<.$?"#

7"5"8"+')

*)#3"#$'

>)44"1$ .)"+63/"= $.*)4 %/)+'"= )*#/)(# 36+"1"/,

+ "664)("#)%+= )564$"'$'

6"/#;

/$*6%+'$+#

&#$/ *"+(#)%+)+1 4)&9

6/%6%*$'

5%'$

D *"+(#)%+$'=

.$/$"&#$/=

= &%44%?)+1

! # $ % &

(

)

* &

# + , # , -$ ! # +

! )

$ .

! . .

! 0

1 %

+ 1 $ . &

, .

+ 1

* &

# + , # , -$ ! # + .

! )

$ .

! . .

! 0

$ , $ &

/ 3 038*$F3$+#4;= 9$;9 "66/%>$'= , , , #/"+*6)/$* 6/%($$')+1* ("5$ &)+"4)G$'

%44$(#%/=

, , = .%?$>$/=

, , (."44$+1$'

/$*6%+'$+#* &)4)+1 "+ "66$"4 8$&%/$ %44$(#%/= %/)+'"

*.%/# 9%44$(#%/9= ?.% , D,

= 6"/#4;

"44%?$'

"66$"4 *$##)+1 "*)'$

, ,

/$5"+'$'

("*$

')/$(#)%+ 6/%($$')+1* ("//)$'

%3# 5")+#")+)+1 $A)*#)+1 6%**$**)%+ 6"/#)$* 4"?,

6%+ /$5"+'=

)+)#)"#$'

6/%($$')+1*= ?.$/$)+ 9$;9 /$($)>$'

&)4$,

+ /$($)6# 9$;9= #.$/$#% ?$/$ ("44$'

/$*6$(#)>$ (%*."/$/*=

%44$(#%/,

, .$/$"&#$/= 5"##$/ "'7%3/+$'

&)4)+1 9$;9B .%?$>$/= "66$"/* *)+($ +%%+$ 9$;9= ("5$ "66/%>$'

%44$(#%/= ,

.$/$"&#$/= 9C$$59

"66/%>$'= , ,

- 6/%($$')+1*

(%+(43'$'

'/"?)+1 *"+"'

#"@*$$5

)+*#/35$+# 6"/#)#)%+

,D "66$"/* "&%/$*")'

6/%($$')+1*%/'$/* *"+"'

#"@*$$5 ("5$ (."44$+1$'

')/$(#4;

8$&%/$ #.)* %3/# &)4)+1 ()>)4 ?/)#

= .%?$>$/= ?)#.'/"?+ 4)8$/#;

">")4 "4#$/+"#$ /$5$';

&)4)+1 /$>)*)%+ 6$#)#)%+= ,

, , .$/$"&#$/= /$>)*)%+

8$&%/$

)+"+()"4 %55)**)%+$/ "4%+1?)#.

"+ "664)("#)%+ *$$@)+1 (%+'%+"#)%+ '$4";

'";*,

, .$

)+"+()"4 %55)**)%+$/= )5631+$'

= ')*5)**$'

/$>)*)%+

= 6$#)#)%+$/,

+ "&%/$5$+#)%+$'

()/(35*#"+($*= )+*#"+# ()>)4 ?/)# 8$&%/$ #.)* %3/# /$4)$&

*= +%#)($'

.$/$)+"8%>$,

D, :$"/+$'

(%3+*$4 *385)#*

$//$'

4"?

&"(#* (%+'3(#)+1 6/%($$')+1* )+"*53(.

6/%($$')+1* .">$ (%+'3(#$'

8"(@ 6$#)#)%+$/,

*385)##$'

%66%/#3+)#;

"&&%/'$'

/")*$ '3/)+1 6/%($$')+1*,

&3/#.$/ *385)##$'

"+ "/$"

"/4"

?/%+14;

'$'3(#$'

.%4')+1 6/%>)')+1 1")/ 535@)+ /"*#"

"44%##$'

"83##)+1 /%"'

.)* '3$ $+#)#4$5$+#,

+$A# *385)##$'

"44%##$'

&/"15$+#$'

)+&$/)%/ F3"4)#;

(%56"/$'

4"+'= ?.)(.

"44%##$'

%#.$/ (%*."/$/*,

(%+#$+'$'

"44%##$'

(%56/)*$'

<."*/"

= ?.)(.

1")/ 535@)+ "/$",

(%+#$+'$'

)+"+()"4 %55)**)%+$/ &")4$'

(%+*)'$/ )**3$* /")*$'

8$&%/$ .)5 ?/%+14;

')*5)**$'

/$>)*)%+

= 6$#)#)%+$/= )5631+$'

, ,

$"/', ,

* /$1"/'* &)/*# (%+#$+#)%+ (%3+*$4 ("//)$'

%3#

8"(@ %66%/#3+)#;

."'

"&&%/'$'

&)4)+1 6/%($$')+1*B %8*$/>$'

)+"+()"4 %55)**)%+$/ ."'

"66$"/$'

6/%($$')+1*= .%?$>$/= .$ ')'

&)4$ "+;

%87$(#)%+,

&3/#.$/ 8%/+$ %3# /$(%/'* $>$+ "&#$/ 5"#$/ /$5"+'$'

%44$(#%/= , D,

%44$(#%/=

= ."'

(4$"/4;

/$(%/'$'

9$;9 /$($)>$'

5"##$/ "'7%3/+$'

&)4)+1 9$;9,

= 5"##$/ "1")+ "'7%3/+$'

)+>)#)+1 9$;9

= 5"##$/ "'7%3/+$'

&)4)+1 9$;9= .%?$>$/= +%+$ 6"/#)$* /")*$'

"+;

%87$(#)%+ 9$;9= "((%/')+14;=

%44$(#%/= ,

= *"+(#)%+$'

9$;9= ?.)(.

&%44%?$'

9C$$59 6/%($$')+1* (%+(43'$'

'/"?)+1 *"+"'

#"@*$$5

&3/#.$/ /$>$"4$'

)+"+()"4 %55)**)%+$/ ?"//"+#* 6%**$**)%+ ?$/$ )**3$'

-, , = ?.$/$36%+ *)1+"#3/$*

"."/ 0)+1. "/$ ">")4"84$ ?$/$ "3#.$+#)("#$'

0"/6"+(.

.%?@)'"/ >)44"1$ .)"+63/",

66"/$+#4;= 6/%($$')+1* ?$/$ (%+(43'$'

'/"?)+1 *"+"'

#"@*$$5

?"//"+#* 6%**$**)%+ ?$/$ )**3$'

-, , = .%?$>$/= ')'

/")*$ "+;

(."44$+1$ 6/%($$')+1**"+"'

#"@*$$5= 3+#)4 ;$"/

?.$+ ')/$(#4;

"66/%"(.$'

#.)* %3/# ?";

&)4)+1 ?/)#

?.)(.

')*5)**$'

?)#.'/"?+= ,

= *% ">")4 /$5$';

&)4)+1 /$>)*)%+ 8$&%/$

)+"+()"4 %55)**)%+$/,

.$/$"&#$/= /$>)*)%+

6$#)#)%+$/= ?.)(.

')*5)**$'= -,

, %+*)'$/)+1 "8%>$= ("++%# (%+'3(#$'

8"(@ "+'%/ %66%/#3+)#;

"&&%/'$'

6"/#)$* 53(.

4$** &)4$ /$4$>"+# *#"1$,

.$/$&%/$= "&%/$*")'

(%+#$+#)%+* "/$ /$7$(#$',

* /$1"/'* %#.$/ (%+#$+#)%+* /")*$'

"/$"

"/4"

'$'3(#$'

.)* *."/$.%4')+1= +%#)($"84$ 4"3*$ 5%'$ @."4

?"#$/ (."++$4 6".)

6"**"1$ *."44 6/%>)'$'

+$($**)#;

%3# 7%)+# '$'3(#)%+ *."44 5"'$ *."/$ 4$">)+1 (%55%+ 64"($*= #.$/$&%/$= ("++%# *";

"/4"

"/$"

?/%+14;

#"@$+ .)* *."/$.%4')+1 6/%>)'$ 6"**"1$, >$+ %#.$/?)*$= 4"3*$ - 5%'$ 6/%>)'$* '$&)()$+(;

$A#$+#

"/4"

4)"84$ )1+%/$',

((%/')+14;= &)+'

5$/)# 64$"

/$7$(#$',

* /$1"/'* (%+#$+#)%+ .$ "44%##$'

"83##)+1 /%"'

%/ ?/%+14;

"44%##$'

"/$"

(%56/)*$'

<."*/"

= ?.)(.

1")/ 535@)+= %8*$/>$'

%+($ ."'

%66%/#3+)#;

&)4$ 9$;9= ?.)(.

">")4$'

.)5 6/%6%*$'

9$;9 "66/%>$'

%44$(#%/= ,

8"*)*= 9C$$59 6/$6"/$'

6/%($$')+1* (%+(43'$'

'/"?)+1 *"+"'

#"@*$$5

#.)* *#"1$= ("++%# 6$/5)##$'

#3/+ "/%3+'

/")*$ %87$(#)%+ /$1"/'* '$'3(#)%+ "/4"

"/$"

#%?"/'* 6/%>)')+1 (%55%+ 6"**"1$ (%*."/$/* "+'%/ +%+6/%>)*)%+)+1 "83##)+1 /%"'

"+'%/ "44%("#)%+ *."/$* /$*6$(#)>$ (%*."/$/* 6"/#)(34"/ 5"++$/,

3/#.$/= /$1"/'* 64$"

.$ ?/%+14;

"44%##$'

(%56/)*$'

<."*/"

= ?.)(.

1")/ 535@)+= %8*$/>$'

7"5"8"+') ;$"/

D "/$"

<."*/"

/$(%/'$'

<"+"4 "/4"= %3# ?.)(.

"/$"

$A#$+# <"+"4 /$(%/'$'

"1.

"/"+) 8"4"+($ "/4"

"/$"= $+#/;

1")5 535@)+ .%3*$, ,- :$"/+$'

(%3+*$4 &")4$'

*.%?

"+;

5"#$/)"4 ?."#*%$>$/ .%3*$= ?.)(.

"44%("#$'

9"1.

"/"+)9 "/$"B /$&4$(#$'

/$>$+3$ /$(%/'*,

.$/$&%/$= "&%/$*")'

(%+#$+#)%+ ?)#.%3# "+;

5$/)# /$7$(#$', ,

3/#.$/ /$1"/'* 64$"

)+&$/)%/ "44%##$'

6$#)#)%+$/B *3&&)($ *";

5"#$/)"4 64"($'

/$(%/'

*.%?

3+'$/ ')&&$/$+# >"43$ +%/ "+;

*3(.

%87$(#)%+ /")*$'

/$4$>"+# #)5$,

"66$"/* %87$(#)%+ 8$)+1 /")*$'

%+4;

*"@$ /")*)+1 %87$(#)%+ ?)#.%3# #.$/$ 8$)+1 "+;

5$/)# #.$/$)+,

((%/')+14;= /$7$(#$',

, ?$44 $*#"84)*.$'

("+ +$>$/ ("//)$'

%3# 5"#.$5"#)("4 6/$()*)%+ *%5$ "'73*#5$+#* "/$ "4?";* /$F3)/$'

5"'$ (%+*)'$/)+1 >"/)%3* &"(#%/* 4)@$ +358$/ (%*."/$/* 7%)+# 4"+'= *."6$ 6"/($4 3+'$/ 6"/#)#)%+= 4%("#)%+

?.$#.$/ "83##)+1 /%"'6"**"1$ %/ +$"/ >)44"1$ "8"') %/ #%?+ $#(,= +"#3/$>"43$ 4"+'= *%3/($ )//)1"#)%+= $A)*#)+1 6%**$**)%+ 6"/#)$*= 6/%>)*)%+)+1 6"**"1$ *?"#$/(%3/*$ *= (%+*#/3(#)%+ .3#5$+#*.%3*$* $#(, .$/$ 5";

%#.$/ &"(#%/* ?$44 ?.)(.

5";

("44 ("/>)+1 %3# 84%(@* /$*6$(#)>$ (%*."/$/*= 6"/#)(34"/ 5"++$/,

, %+*)'$/)+1 #%#"4)#;

()/(35*#"+($*= &)+'

5$/)# )+*#"+# ()>)4 ?/)# "((%/')+14;

')*5)**$',

$+')+1 "664)("#)%+

*= )& "+;= *."44 *#"+'

(4%*$',

*7@* .$#.$/ *6$"@)+1/$"*%+$'

!$*

% .$#.$/ /$6%/#"84$ !$*