High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/3910/2019dismissed

Gurbhag Singh v. Rameshwar Singh

2023-09-21Mrs. Justice Amarjot Bhatti5 pages

!

"# !

$ %& $'()*+&!,-!./+%&% ,$.)%../ $ % &' ()

#* +',- % !"'&%'-!

(#* +'.

-"

% )'

/' !"'(#* +'.

00000 %&% ,$.)%../0, - "

!

1-'2 ) 2- -' .3# - "

+*3

*

!

+34 .-

!

#',--"

'5

' #-&"!2

*3 !#29!

:(% -'3,-.!

# +

-

+# -&' ' " 3', ;'

-"

"

!-'--'# .3#'""3+'

<+3!#'..#'*'

#*# .= 2-( '..#'*'

#*# .=(*# .=6%'2, 2-'

-# <-1#' =?@ =?@ -*# .A'

%!1'

'/ ) 2- "

! -' > ) 2- = .3# - '..#'*#'#B49<=@:

66'2'

"3'+#

'..#'*#'#'

#-'2'

'..#'* #'# 4 9<=@:

- "3' .. + !3#

'..#'* . > ) 2- - +

<'& '

+-.,'

##

66'

#-,'

+

<'& #+'

1<'& # +-.'2' ' ='

#- '..#'* <=@ +'

1 # =- - . '..#'* #15 2-=( -,'

<'&

,-*# .= +'

1 '/

# '

# - !3# 1 <+3!## !

&

( %'2, 2-=6 #- '..#'*(,'

##

3& '.. &'

'- ,' '#& # -&( - .

- '& '3 3'13 1<+3!## A'

%!1'

'/) 2-=?

'""'

#' , 1!- '& ,'

2 #15-- *3 !#2

-# <=?@ =?@1'

-+ .+' .-

#!#2

1'

- 2 '!

- .

(- '&+'

1 '/

# - #'""3+'

<!

,' .3#,'

+

#15- "'

515.3 "35

<!

- '# '""3+'

,' ,

235 #+3 # 15 "' 2 &"!2 #

#'# 678,-+-

<!

6-3'

#

,

235-3# -'-"

-'

>!#+-"

+# ,

+

#!+#' " - '13 -#"

+#!

'

#-"

*

.

- .

(-"

&'5/ #351'33 ,#'

#&"!2

*3!#29!

:( % -'3&'5/ #351 ' #'

#- '#

&'51# +#

+#' " 3', 6 ;'

- 1 .'

2!& !-'-'""3+'

.3#15-"

1.

-

.

<+3!# 2-*# 2-='

#'..#'* #*# .=( '& 2-=6' ,33' - "

*#

#15A'

%!1'

'/) 2-=?' =?@

6 =7@,- !'

51' -+' .<#.

#. +*# +'

#' -' 13'# '2 - '""3+'

-' 1 .3#

35 #3'5 -

+# 2 .-+' -&"!2

#'#678"' #15

*3!#29!

:(% -'3 .!335>! .#'

#'33- ' "+ .-"

+' -'*1 #'3,--"

-'

>!#+'- 3*'

& 1>+

,'

' # 2- '& 2-

##' =

1>+

,' ' #,- - &

2-=6,'

##%

2 .<-1 15-

#

&'

-'- '## ,

"

*#

#- '&'

1 '/ ..-

#-"

.3#15-"

,- !& #- '&&'5/ #351# & # -'*+

#-'

2!& '

#-'*2

-

!2--

# 35,33#'3,-- '& 2-

##'

=@=

# "!#-' '335 2- #- '..#'*#'#B4

66'

#

- #'- , ,'

+

<'& # - '. '

'..#'* #'# ,' "3'+#

#- '&, ,' !3&'35 <'& # ' = ,- '2' # - '..#'*

#

4'

#-, ,' +

<'& # , !1 C! 35-

.3#'""3+'

<!

<+3!#- '&

. > ) 2-

##' =' ,33 ' +

#'..#'*#'# - '.

'# .'+!'3 "

+3'

35 #+' -' - +

"3' .. #'..#'* 2-' =

'..#'* #'# ,' "3'+#

# '

# - '. '2'

#'..#'*#'#4 . '&, ' =-

3'"

-"'

.3'

-"3' ...

2- '..#'* . '&, - +) &3'" '3 -

-"'

.

# # ..+ ,- #! * 2-##

+-'- '..#'* . '&, ,' 1 2 #&'

#'2' #. '335 -3'" '3

-"'

.+

-#. #'

-"

"

,- ##

1>+ 2- .'..#'* > ) 2-' .

#'1 * '- ,- -'..#'* 2-,'

#' =@#'#4,' '3 +

<'& #- '& .-, 1

##!

B !3

-+' -'

#-

353'"

-"'

."3' ..@

,' -'

" &

,' !2-.

&-

,-3 .

'..#'*' = '3 2-35"

!15-3'

*3!#2 9!

:% -'315"' 2&"!2

#'#678-' -"

@#. #'

-'

>!#+' - 2* .!33 ""

!

5 +

<'& -,

2- '.

'#.'+ (#

. '

<+3!#-'..#'* > ) 2-#'#' - '&,'

# *#

5+

,' +

#!+#

'..#'*#'#B4-+ &"3 '& 2- ' = 7 -3'

-"

(.!

"

!-' ,- - '& 2-=6,'

##-,'

'#& '-'

# +

#35,- - '& .A'

%!1'

'/ ) 2-=?,'

##- '# '& ,'

2 #15-3'

7 # ..+ #-# <-1#15-&, '3

2 #15-3'

# # ..+ -'*+

#- ' "+ .-"

+' (-3'

-' 2-35 3#!"

-"

*

.)+

.- #'

*# ++(B4,-+-"

*# -'

' " 3'! 9: .)+

.+

! - .

( +' '

,' 3. 1 2 #15-- # ..+ (+'

1 2 #15- !1 C! # ..+ %

* (-# <-1#

-1' .- '& .',

##

#

'#* . ++'

1# ', .'

5 '&

<-1# ,' 3. 1 2 #15-- # ..+ - .

( &5 "

(#

. '

. -&"!2

*3!#2 9!

:% -'3'

#- '& '++

235!"-3#'

#- +*3 *

'

# #+3 # 86 1%&% ,$.)%../2 " # ,-+ =-- "'/ 2@ '

#$ @

=-- "

'13$ @