High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15827/2013allowed

Satnam Singh & ORS v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2017-02-13Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan11 pages

!"!

#$% "%&' () *+ "!"& ,-.!/ "%&' '01 23 3 !.!4 "%&' () *+ "!"& ,-.!/ "%&' '01

2 3

!'.#" #$%! "%&' () *+ "!"& ,-.!/!! "%&' '01

!'!

.#"5!-' () *+ &/ '01

!*"!' #$%! "%&' () *+ "!"& ,-.!/! "%&' '01

3 5!

!6.#" "%&' () *+ "!"& ,-.!/ "%&' '01 333 3 %#$!'! #$%! "%&' () *+ "!"& ,-.!/!! "%&' '01

! "

# $% & ' ()

**** 5-6# #$%9. ): "

& "& !

! ! ! , !

! , !

! !! .

, &- & . " &' !

!/ & 0 " & / "/- /! 1 & 2- & - ! 2 %" 34 (355 # $% ! &- %" &

"& 6$

7&- "8 # $% ! " (339 :"

& / "/-/! -&544)544;

< &7=' 5339>(33)&- ?"

- & & 0 !1

&/ "/-/! $ - "

- !

544@1 - - (339- 3;

3@ (339

/-/! 544@1 & &%"8() (335 .?( - &- 5) (339 " : " "- & & %" &!

" &%" " %"

& - %" (@ (355 & %" (355# $% !

"A &/ "/-/! &"

&1 (339 - &- " &- 6$ 7&- "8 %" 34 (355 # $% !&&2 # ' () "" 1 : -

"(339 = - -544)?4;

7! & / /- /! @4 - B & '%(

') *

'+, 7 )3 3C 5449

" " ."

" ! "& : "

"&- 7! &-." 72-)5 544C ((9 " 7! " : - " 7! &1&)5 544C "& "" ((9 ' (55((9!7: " -

"7!&! .!""" ."5@9"

-! &." . - 3@ 3( 544C 34 3( 544C 5) 3( 544C

.#?(/) """.

: -544; "5)9 7!& " :55 3C 544@& &"&- %"! &- 7! ! & &"&7=' )((((3337=' )9@3(3337=' )9@@ 7= ' )9@@ (333 7= ' )9@4 (333 7= ' )C5C (333 7= ' )C5; (333 7= ' )C() (333 7= ' );55 (333 7= ' );)( (333 7= ' );>> (333 7= ' );@@ (3337=' )@5>(3337=' 9C>>(3337=' 9;C@ (333 "5( (333 & " &-- : & "544@ "!

" "

& - - "" & D' 5(@54 (333 " &- . 7 (@ 3@ (333 &- & 7= ' 554@) (335 >@)9 (335 5(C@9(3355(C@C(335!1 %" - () (335 &

"&- $ 7 (335 . #?(/;

- & &- 5)97!&-- ""

3( 3@ (33( & '-. /%

'+, " & $ 7 & "

"B 7"" &- B8& '

2- " 7= ' (3()3 (33) ! 1 " (3 (33) .#?(/59 " : " 7""&-

" ""34 (339 - %"""1 &

" & ,

- "" . . #?(/5C 72-

" "&- "

: & - - &

& / /- /! " & - ?

! " : %" " -# $% !() (335

- 1 ! - "

- "

- :

" " %" 1 ! / - "

- "

- & F - - &- 5) (339 : " 59 3;

(339"""&- 7"" . #?(/5C . "" 7"" ?

, 12 " )

%.- 3 4 1 %"

55!6665

" 4

1 1 % % 2 %1 ) %

-2

7 8- '% % ,( ') "

,% - ;< ;<1

9 9 #4 " %.- 72 7) % 0

+ -

" )

) 2 )

" )

(

1 2

- )

, %

%-.

" %"

) 2

)

" )

(

1 2

% 4

2 %

1 ( "2

- 4 "

, 1 1-

1 2 '

9, "

) 2 )

" )

(

1 2

-2

+ -

, )

" 11

, -

% %"

) 2 )

" )

(

1 2

2 0

2 - "

2 )4

1 0 " 11 - "-

" )

) 2 )

" )

(

1 2

9 1)4" "

666 6* " )

12 - %) +1 21 +$"

)

; 5) (339 . #?(/5;

"" ? </

" 11

) "

# $% # ""

% " "

- ) )%= - "

- ""% %) %-"

" - 1 1

" "

# - = "

2" - (

, ; "" 7"" 618 "" & GB +"H 5@ (339 . ?) . &' '.2

' %.-

" & 0 "

! /- !/"

- & "& -

& / () (335 - " - && .

" ? - & & (@ (339 : &

" " 35 3@ (339

" - &

& "" (3 (355 . ?> %" ! & "

- 1 & & %" ' 55/)9/(333?9:::/5)35 () (335 "

(355 .?@ %" " ' -

& / /- /! !""" - 1 B %" -"() (3351 "

- - &- 5) (339 : -"

" ' 2

"I G

" 7"" -

&- " - "

- -!/ "/- /! &

" %& "- ""-

-&& &&- ! -

72- G

"J& 1 &" " 618 %" " - () (335 1 - %"() (3351 "

- 1 < 1 &- ! & / /- /! & "

&-&! & , 2 G$ 7&- "H " 35 (339

- "

- "I G$ 7&- "H (33; .?4 ""35 (339"! "

35 (339 "- & "

35 (339 + ::

" & & 1 -+::& "

- "5( (33; " : " 1 3( 3@ (339

" & / /- /! & "

2-& &! &7# ,

- (33; +::& &- " " 72- ?

" " " " -

&&- "

!"#$%#& '

( E" 77)0=>+)1 4 + 77)'0)?: 4 +