High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2437/2008disposed of

(O&M) Santosh And ORS. v. Union Of India

2023-11-17Mr. Justice Karamjit Singh9 pages

!

# $ %&&%

'(

+,,)#$&%&&% -'#().

% /% 00 11'#( #,)# #",'

%%%% 0)#"

#( 44444 $ 56 % -

7 - 44444 83 9: $ % 2,031 -.' ;'< "!)+'(

*)

'00 11'#(%

% -.,!

73;'

-.' ;'< - #,) '# )3#

0)#"

#(%

44444 7 -

<

%

&% ., '00 '1 .'

*,1

'00 11'#( '8',#(

=3"8;

#( "'( & %&%

1',;

,93#'1< .'#",8' .

#+.

,# .) ( ?(.

,93#'1@< !,"

+1',;

'001,+'(,)# *,1

'00 11'#( *) 8 '#( +);0 #'(,)# ",;, "%

!"#

-39A,'#", %

&

'(')*!&+'+

+,- +,

.

#

%

/

0

$

0 /

0

0

0 0

1 "* 2 * 3 2 4

#5

*7 % 7

2

3 0

3 0 % 8 0

*

*9 72* 9 72*% + $ /4 % (97

(97

(97# (97

(97

(978

(97! * (97:

(97- ! 1 % 7 9 %2* .

!&+'

:

- ; 0 0 / 0

0

72* 72*

0

. <=79> #,)# #",'

!% ,#'

!,<

&B - C

.'

+)#( #"

'00 11'#( +)31"

#)#3,( ,;01:

+'3

( '!

1,#8 (,+D (

*)3#"

* );

01'+

,#+,"

#(

+)#+ 0)1,+

)**,+,'1 '(

(,;

0)( ,#0 +(,)#%

.

+)3# *)

'00 11'#( .'

*3 (.

+)#( #"

* );

3'1

( (,;)#:

E ,., ' D'.< ,( ,

!,"

#( .

8'!

1,*(

30() -39A,'#", -('(,)#<

1.,

.'!,#8 & F >,(.

.,;

9) )> & F * );

.,;

+)3#( +1 .'!,#8 1))

+.'#8

03 +.'

) ",#' :

+)#"

+1'

( ',# (,+D ( 8) -)#,0'(%

.

+)3# *)

'00 11'#( .'

*3 (.

39;,(( * );

3'1 ( (,;)#:

E< ,( ('#"

0 )!

9)#' *,"

#8 < >.) 9)' "

( ',# * );

-39A,'#", -('(,)# 8) '#,0'(

%&% %

.

+)3# *)

'00 11'#( .'

*3 (.

' 83 ';01

!,"

#+

, '!',1'91

+) "

"3 ,#8

',"

( ',# =)3 # :<

* * );

3##,#8 ( ',# ", +)0:

., 0)(;) ( ;

0) ( , G% < '1) +) )9) '(

+'

'00 11'#(%

$

0 0

/

0

. 0

0

.

*

72* 72*

$

/

72*# ? *9

$

# / 0 2

*9 72*

& $

&

$

% + + $

% + $

@ *'

%

,*

$

0 ;

%

0

$

/

@ *'

%

72* % + $ +

7

72*

<072*

%

@ *'

&

$ ,* * $ 0 A

72*

+

0

A (97

0

$ 0

4 (97

8 7

0

0

0

*7 % 7

0

*7 % 7

0

/ 9

!

5 6 <=79> 0 "

HE

(.3 .)1"

;

#+

9)":

;,

>,11

+)#+13,!

.)1"

,#=3 ) 9)#'

*,"

#8

*) +1',;

*) +);0 #'(,)# +)31"

;',#(',# "% )> !

< ;

'9 #+

(,+D ( >,(.

3+.

,#=3 )

>,11 8'(,!

+1',;

.

9)#'

*,"

#8 % #,(,'1 93 "

>,11

+1',;'#( +'#

",+.' 8 *,1,#8 '# '**,"'!,(

!'#( *'+( 93 "

>,11 .,*(

,3

+'#

+,"

*'+( .)># )

'(( #",#8 +, +3;('#+ % ., >,11 .'!

'1( >,(.

* );

+'

+'

9', *'+( *)3#"% .

8'1 0),(,)# ,# (.,

8' "

>,11 ('#"

G01',# '++) ",#81:%I ! /4 (97 $

* 9

#

/

* 9

* (97:

/

0

* 9

9

0

* 9

7 4 (97 $ 7 * (97: 0

. *

4 *

:

.

0 4 (97 * (97:<0 .

9 .

#

7 * 0

<0

9

- /

9 %2* B !&+'

%2*

$

B ' ;$

## G3

E&F%

# ., + ) G';,#'(,)#< E& '";,(( ,( *)88:

> '(.

"':

!,,9,1,(:

0 )0 % % #

1,8.(

'9)!

!,"

#+ < (., )3 ( ,

!, >

0)#"

#( *',1

('91,.

,#+,"

#( ,# J3 (,)# , +)!

G+ 0(,)# - +(,)# &

+(%

.

, #)(.,#8

+) "

.)> ,( +'

3,+,"

)

1* ,#*1,+( ,#=3 :

) + ,;,#'1 '+( *) ,#( #(,)# ,

J3, +);;,( 3+.

'+(%

!

, #) .'1*

0)#"

#( '(

(,;

,#+,"

#(

3#"

,#()G,+'(,)#%

&% #

1,8.(

'9)!

< ,( ('#"

0 )!

* * );

3##,#8 ( ',# 3(',# ;31(,01

,#=3 ,

", '(

0)(% .3

*,#",#8

+) "

,93#'1 >,(.

8' "

,3

)%&

.

(',"

>.,1

.)1",#8

9)#'

*,"

#8

.

", '++)3#( '# 3#()>' "

,#+,"

#(< >.,1

.

( '!

1,#8 ,# ( ',# 8),#8 * );

-39A,'#", -('(,)#<

1., -)#,0'(%

.

*,#",#8

,93#'1 >,(.

8' "

,3

)%

.

'**, ;

>.,1

.)1",#8

'00 11'#( >

#"

#(

"% % )# J3 #(1:<

'00 '1 , '11)>

,;038# =3"8;

#( "'( & %&% <

,93#'1 , .

(',"

%

.

0)#"

#(F#,)# #",'

, ", +( 0':

1'+ +);0 #'(,)#

'00 11'#(%

.

';)3#( +);0 #'(,)# ,

0),( >,(.,# ,)"

G( ;)#(.%

*(

0),(

+);0 #'(,)# ';)3#(< ,( .'11

",93

J3'11:

,# *'!)3

'00 11'#(%

7 - &%&&% '3 '!

-) )( Whether reasoned / speaking?

Yes / No Whether reportable?

Yes / No