High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21481/2011allowed

Iqbal Singh ANR. v. Financial Commissioner & ORS.

2023-05-01Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj9 pages

!

"#$%$ IQBAL SINGH AND ANOTHER .

FINANCIAL COMMISSIONER & OTHERS

& '(&$)

*

)$+ ,,,,,

"

# $ %%%%% *

)$+-$./01 &

! '

((

) *

-

.# /0 1 !

" )

'

) + '

23

)4

+

5

-01 )1

23 -

.# 60

) +

") #,,

8!

"

)

. " 9:

92

! )

'6

;,

!

"

'

1

,

< =

> 49 $ '

6;< !1

!!

')

# !

-2-

)

+

*

:(: + "

"

!1 + 2

' # ! 1 .

'

''

"

<

"

+

<

?#

# $ !

# "

# '

1

,#! ' !!

')

#

!

# "

"

'

1&

:(:1

!!

') ) ) +

<

(: 2 "

'

'#, !

' 1

'#, 1

1

23

+

*

<

1

!

# "

" !!

"

,

#

"

1

#

&

!!

'), "

. @

,

! ,

"

)

+

*

<

;33 &

! '

) !

!

! !

,

= 1

"

"

5

4

23&

1

1)4

+

-3-

23 )

' 1

:(: 1 )

)

+

*

<

!

(:&

! ' )

#! +

<

,,

'

)

'#

) !!

23 +

?# )

!!

" +

& !

1

,

+

*

<

! "#

!

' "

(:

1 !

"

+

*

<

33&

"# ! ')

),

# !

2 " # $ A

#! 663 1

((

1

'

",

) / < ! "

#

62

1 ! ,

# ?# '

'

) #@1

! " !

)

!

# )= '+ 1

! ",

!"#!$$"

% !"&!$$'

-4- %

% (

% (%%

)%

% % % *!#!$$"

%

*+

%

, *!#!$$" - !"#!$$"

$"**!$*& .

-

/ + ; & !

"

!

!

3/

#' , " )&, ,

"

+

"

< "

1

)1

" &

# ) 1

'

"

(3 "

'1 ! "

1

#!

"" : & !

" #' , 1

1 1 "

)

1 #

! 1

#

"

63 @ 1

!

/6

-5-

< != 1 "$# ! ,

$

" 66 @ 1

# "

2( 6;( ;(( :2

1

222 '

# )

! & !

1

" $

"

) ;2 &

"

)

1 3 &

!

!#,

! +

#

!"# ,

! '.

< = #

!

.

6 A

!

"

*

+

,,

'

)

#'

, ="#

)

'

# ?#

" !

#)

"# $ 1 )

1 "*

+

#@

?#

" )

3

,

'"

,

1

")

-B)

0 "

" !

#) "# $ @

! , )

# 1

!#, #

*

+

!

!

,

< " !

#

! ) = "#

4

+

"

1

1

) +

23 1 )

'

# !

-6- 23=!

# #

#

' #

, "

1

) +

<

!

#

" "

'

,

@ "#

# #

!

# "

,

!

" +

;33

! '

,

"

)

= !

# ?#

) +

'

#

! !

" !#,

!

'

( = )

'# 4

4

) ) #,

:(:

1

"

!

(:

#

!

#,

!

)

'

!

#

, " !

,

!

!

# "

(:=

!

8 ,

1

,

)

+

*

<

)

(:

8 ,

!

1

$

:(: !

' #

# "" !

#, <

"

,

&!

"

1 !

)

+

*

<

1

# #

-7- < /29 94C :(: !

,

" :(: , ') ,

' "

+

, #,

"

"& #

"

) +

<

!

, " !

!!

!1

! "

#

"

= "# !

"

)

<

D7 )E

;33C$!

<

!

# " 1

" 2 ) " "

' 1 !

, 1

#

"

) A

!

!

!

1

<

)

. " ?#

$# !

1

=

'

!

@ "

) 4

#""

"

,

!

=1

?# '

!

!

1

!# )

,

1

#

1

&

+

) +

)

!

'

,

) +

:(:1

,

(:=

!

,

#

"

, 1

& 1

#

-8- !

!, "

"

,

*#

!

' "

) .!#

' ""! 1

<

F G

'

1 !"#

"

)

$!

9! '

, @ "

) 4

+

5

! !

) 4

, #

H

" +

!

#,

" !

!

1 ' *

#,

) 1 & +

"

)

!

!

&

!

, #

"

8

"

!#

! "

&

, &

, ')

" )

""! )

# #

,

!

23

)

+

*

<

# !

1 ! ! , ,, !!

')

1

#

!!

')

?# '= !

1 &

((

) *

+

23

) 4

+

5

&

)4

<

23

&

" ) ""! !

,

!

23

) # 4

!#,+

<

-9-

' ""!

"

:(: .*

)$+1 &#- 0 . H

'9

I 9< H

I 9<