← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3340/2019dismissed

Kuldeep Sharma v. Savita Sharma

2019-12-09Mrs. Justice Rekha Mittal17 pages



      

  !" "

# $$% "

!& '() 

  

 





   * +!"

!& '() 

 



 





  (

 ,-( #  # .(-

 

   !"

 #

%

 

&&&&

.(-/ ' ! 

  (()* +*,- . /*0, +*,-

#   ! 

 

1

# .  

# $$% "

#



!$

 !

!$ 2  





3 

4

5)*"

66 7"

7   # 1 !

"

!1 # 1"



# 1 1 (8, 9 3  

 :#

:;  66"

7   

% $$ $

1

#

 

!



$ 

3<  1

1 # (=*-

(,*/+**+ 1 1

3 !1"

 1"

"

 "

$  1 #



 1  

#

 ># 1

%    $ 1 

# $



3 

3

$

$#"

 $"

$$



#



 ?   '.

?   7   "



!

 





  @ 

+0*)+**+

#  0  

 ,0   #

 1 # 9

,*+,8,

+0*=+**+ ! ?  ' A



#

3 (0  

*0*/+**+ C "

 #

 "

# 1

;

(,*/+**+  # 

  , 

! 1 # 1  +0  





#

$$ 

  /*"***%5 ## 



#  

 

%     1 

$$"

# 1 1 3"

3

$

$$

 

   1



#



$$"

1

# % 1

(,*/+**+



 



3 

$$ #



# !  $ # #



%   $

!  1

3  > # 1 1  3"

#

#"

##    $#"

5> 5>



1

#

. 5#

 



     

 !

1

# 1  ! 

#1

(,*/+**+

   1 1  6  

$$  1



3

3  #



+**+ !

 

#

!

3

(,*/+**+

$$



(0**%5



 



#

$ !

1

   ? 

#  )  "

3 1

$$#

E

 1"

7   

 





$$

#1

3 7  



  

#

# $ # 1 1

#

#  #



 $ ! $

!

 

 

3  ?  1

$

+/*++**+ !#

##  

 

 

 

"

  % ?3  B$

1 *-,*//"

*-,*/= =/)*-/ 1 +0  

1

$ 

 

 #

 ,0   



 

 E +**+ 1

$$

 1 # !  1 #

#



$$       





3 



 . $

$!1 

 , F

$$ !





9 G

+ F

#



9 



$$ +0*/+**+G

( F

(,*/+**+  1"

    1

$$G

) F

$$ 13 ##    $#G 0 F

5> 5 >

 G = F

$$  #   $

G /   $





 #

#



 

#

# 

% $$

# 

 =

> 1  .

%    #

# #

 /

> 1  .



41 #



1   # "

 . !

 , ( 

>3 1

$$ $

 !

$$ 







## $

$$%

$ $

  B# E 1 7  

 . $$

$ 1

 .  

#

.

! 1





3

#

 ?  

 '.

?  $

% $$"

# ! :; ( 6 1

"

#

3 ,0    #

# 9

,*+,8,

+0*=+**+ ! ?  ' A

 6 $ 1



#

 



 ## . ! $ 1

;

  6 "

$$# ' 3 $$# 7  

! 

 #

# :; F+%

1

3 )*,, ! 

 ! /*"***%5

#



$$%

 6 3 1

 

"

 

   1  

 1

# $   1

3

#

$  !$





"

. 

#

1

   13 > #1

 





#



!



3 6 $ 1

  3"





 #



3 3 $

! 6 $ 1

. !

#1

  

 3

% $$ 1

!#



!





!13 $

$$%



 6 1

#

$

 

$ "

 !

"



  # 

!3 11

3

1 

# # 



#

"





# 

$  #

3

#

!



3

  

 1  1"



## 



!

3 !

#

$







3

1

  !  # 1

13  3

9 

#

!



  4 #"

"



+0*=+**+ 



 !"

 # 

 

3 







# 

#



#

1

1

#$#

$#

1

 

1 # 11 

$#

$

1

  ? 

1

#$#

$#

#

!3 #

+**+ .

$

 #

1$ 1  !

 

 !   1

 !

3"

#

#

!



3 6 

 "

$ #  

#

!



3

3 ## 

13

> #

.



 

#3 3

 



1    $

3

 

"

 

   !



$$ 6



"

 

 



 

3 #

 !   1 

$$ # 1 1 3

3

$

$$ 1

#



 

#



$$

$ 1

 

  ?  ! #3

#

$

  # #

#  +0  

 !3 

 $

## 

 



  1

 









  

  ? 



1 #

1

(,*/+**+ 6$

  ? 

!1 $3 



#

$

$$%

 

#

#

$

 "



     #



 1

%  



 ,0  

% $$ ! 

  1 # 9





##



 >

!  

# 



  ? 

(,*/+**+"

"

 #

# 3 

   "

#

3

 $

3

    

.

!



13

$

1  $



 9



# #1 

1



 #

13

> #

$

# E3"

+**/ 

(,*/+**+ 

 1 

"

#

*0*/+**+ 

;

(,*/+**+  # 

# !

   , 

  ?  !  1 #  73"

   , 

  ? 

(,*/+**+ ! !1





 6 $$# ##

 !

3 , 



  ! 1 #

 



1

1

3 #

 #

$

1



.

  ? 

;

#



3 ,  

$# 1 1 !3





#

. #  

 7  

    1

 6





 

   

  C  "

1

# 3  $

$$#

 1"

7    6

#

#  +0   1 

(0  



 

 



 

 (,*/+**+

  6

 (

"



1  +0 



$$





#

#

(,*/+**+ 

#

 #



3 +0  

 (,*/+**+ 

#3"

3 #

 +0  

 !3 

 $"

#

!

##

 



#

$



3 #

# "

!

##

 ? 

#

 $

3

 1 $



 +0  

 (,*/+**+"





1

6 ;   





#

 1



"

! 



#

$









 0   1

   

  ? 

 1

3 , 

 (,*/+**+ +0   (,*/+**+

  1 

$   ' "

$

##



 (,*/+**+



#

 $"

 



 3

   ?    (,*/+**+ 

#

 */*8+**+"











1 

 #

; 6

  # $ 3

$





+0*=+**+

!1 $3 





1

  ?  !

 

 "

>







3



#

 +0  

 



#

(,*/+**+ 



"

 3  



###   73"

$



#

    1 #



$ 1

## 

3 6 $$# ##

 $

 #





#1

3"

!

# 1

   $

 

1 #

# #

$



   



3

#

!

 



   E +**/ # 



$#



 $$#  $

# $ 1

.

9   

#3"

#

 $ > # $

 



9    $ :;

1 #

1  

 

#  !

6 !

#

$ 1  "

 $ ## 13 

# 



#

"

# # 

3 # # #  * +!"

. 1



 #

1 ## $ 1 #

. !



#

 "



!

# 1   (()* +*,-



#

1 5 3 

 .  #

  5 #

   3"

,(*)+*,8





 





3"

7  

,*,*+*,-

 > 1 



.







  

!



3

1

#

$ 9

3

 $

3



 

 



#







  "

 .  

3

. $

3     F



  5 

!

 G

 

!

1



#

## 5 3   (0**%5

 ! $ ,*,,+**) ! 

.



   $ 1

. . # 1



$ 1 1 #

 4!

"

    

#



 . $$



3



1

 #



#

 $ #

#

 > #  . 9

 6  ! "

  $ #

!

  # $ 1 $$

 3 6  # ;"

#

#

> 1 42 

.  0  1203 141 -35 2671# 87&"

!%)#*9  

;#

 (+"

(("

)( )) 9

 3 #

H(+ 6$



5E 1

#

#  .  B ##  13    

!

 > # 5 !     > #



 3 

11



 1

> #

 

#

 > #

 

 

# 3 #  

$!1     B"

I > #

 

. "



# "

;

# # 

$ 1 $# I6 11 

  1 "



E 1

#  B

 

41 .  $

$ 1 $# 5

#1

#

 



5E 1

# 1

;  B

    B



#$ 1  > # I 13

 3I"

41 . ! > #  3 

!

 

41 .



! 

!

#$ 



# ,,0

.

.

#  < #$

> #

  4!

"

1

$ 1 $#"

; $ 1 $#

41 . 

$3  $

# I## 1 !I'

3 

 B F $ 1 $# #

  

#%  ## 1 !"

9

#

! # $ 1 $#



1

#

$$   13 

  1

#

  1 11

 

#

1 $$ 

 3 #  13 # $ 1 

1 #1

>#  B  3 !

 !



!

41 . 

 . # !





.





3 #

!

#5 ; 





3

##

$ 1 $# #

1 3





3 #

 $

41 . 5

#1

#

#

 #%3

$ 1 $# #

.%3

!  B 





!

#$ 

41 . !



!



 

#

#1 $$ $ 1 #3

$ 1 #

.%3

!  "

 !

;1

# #  $ 1 $#"

 .

# . $

  B  #

  #



B 

((  . E $!  B   3 !

41 .

#



!



 . # 3 

$ 1 $# 3

#

5

#

#

$$

$ 1 $#

  





.  . E  

# ;





 B

)(F

 "

"



 

 . #



41 .  $

$ 1 $# #

7 



.%7 



3

#

#

#  $$

.%3

!

# 

;

#

41 .  > # 

# #$

$  $ 1 $# #

.%3

!

## 1 !

 $$

 ! $ 1 $# #

.%3

!"

$

 



! # 

 

#

# $ 1



#

  1

#

13

  "

$ !

 "

!  1 #1

># 

# #

#



$ 1 ## 1 ! 6

"

41 .

#

  > # 

 

 . # 





 1

1 1



41 .



$3  $

# #  13

 3

#  1

 #

  4!

"

$3  $

13"

# # "

13

 3

 1

#

"

41 . 

#



!



!

5

#

5 

#

#1 $$ $ 1 $#  

!

#

9

!

#   9  $# # $

 F

41 . 9

$

# ## 1 !"

3

;

!



 1

$$ 

#   13  13

)) "



 .  



#  .  B 



 

#

!

## 13J

. 1

(,*/+**+

#

 ! $

> #

!

1

1 #

"

$ 1 #

 '

1 "

 #



 1

 #    

!



3

(,*/+**+

#

$

 $ 



1  

  # 9 ! 

3"





 $



3 1    

#3

#

! ##  # 1

3

  *-,,+**)

 # 6   3"



# 3 

1 5 "

$ #3 #

!

1

 ' . #  

1

 # !

  

1

#  "

#3 #

! !1 3 #





3"

3

#

# % #  '

1 "

# 

 # 1

## $ 1 9 

   #

 $

$  1  7 

 #



 # #3   !

3"

> #



 1

!

1

$  1 #



6 !

#

$ 1  "

 $ ## 13 





 .(-      "# $! F

 

K

%