High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11673/2016allowed

Chand Singh v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2017-02-07Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan3 pages

! "#$ %$&'(')*

+")%,')-+ $#'#')$. (!

/$.(0( ,#"#$ ".1")"")%#+$.( $(2)%$)# (!

* 34 , 5 4, .$($)#*6 .,")%$$2".7"(+ +"+".8%9&"#$8 .#+$2$#'#')$. .5$(+"9 02#"8(('(#")# ".1")" +$#+$.#+$$2.#$.( :&":)$;(2"2$.<"1=$"::;$%# ($$#+$>0%-<$)#?

=$.$ $..$%##+$$2.#$..)# +$#+$.#+$>0%-<$)#(+0:%=$.$2.#$%')#+$%'-$(#? 66 66 4,

+$ 2$#'#')$. '( ;.7')- ') #+$ ".1")" :'&$ "( " ,0= )(2$&#."#+#"7 ) @8+'(;'

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

::$&#.")% '9':,0.-$)8+#"7 .'((0")&$ <$.-$)&1 $.#'

'&"#$8 ;+'&+;"(%$&:')$%=1#+$ '9':,0.-$)8+#"789'%$:$##$.%"#$%

66 @D D ))$A0.$66@!8 (#"#')- #+"# "( 2$. #+$ 2')') #+$

".%':-'(#8 #+$.$ ;"( ) $<$.-$)&1 ') #+'( &"($ +$ $<$.-$)&1 &$.#'

'&"#$ ;"( .$ 0($%8 ;+'&+ ;"( .$F0'.$% "( 2$. #+$ 9$.)<$)# ')(#.0&#')(+$.$ .$8#+$.$'<=0.($<$)#;"(":(.$ 0($% +$.$(2)%$)#(+"9$#"7$)#+$(#")%#+"#(')&$#+$.$;"() $<$.-$)&18#+$.$ .$8#+$$<$.-$)&1&$.#'

'&"#$;"(%$&:')$% +$("'%

A1-$)(2'#":8+#"78;"()#)#+$"22.9$%:'(# +$.$ .$8#+$ .$'<=0.($<$)# #+$<$%'&":='::(+"(=$$)&..$&#:1%$)'$%$(2)%$)# +"(.$:'$%02)#+$9'$;#"7$)=1#+$,.. $((.")%$"%8 $2".#<$)# ".%':-18 ,8+#"78;+;"( #+$2')')#+"# #+$.$;"()$<$.-$)&1')#+'(&"($ +"9$+$".%#+$:$".)$%&0)($:( .#+$2".#'$(")%+"9$":( &".$ 0::1-)$#+.0-+#+$ ':$ +$ $<$.-$)&1 &$.#'

'&"#$ %"#$% @ ))$A0.$66

::1!8'((0$%=1 A1-$)(2'#":8+#"78'(.$2.%0&$%"(0)%$.*6 G+'('(#&$.#'

1#+"# .(,+$$:",+.' +")%,')-+ .$('%$)# +#"7;"("%<'##$%')$<$.-$)&1) @ 9'%$ .) @E@;'#+ 6 )(#"=:$)-')";'#+)-')- &+$(#2"') .)".1")-'-."2+1.$9$":$%/6 '%4 C")% '% C%'($"($$. ")%,#$)##4 ")% ;"(%)$) @')$<$.-$)&1#("9$+$.:'

$ ")%%'(&+".-$%) @H +$2$#'#')$.+"(2.%0&$%#+$.$&.%8;+'&+(+;(=:&7"-$ =#+#+$".#$.'$(+$2"#'$)#;"( $$:')-0)$"(')$((")%(;$"#')-")%'

(+$ +"% )# =$$) .$<9$% # #+$ )$".$(# +(2'#": "# #+"# #'<$8 (0&+ (1<2#<(;0:%+"9$.$(0:#$%') "#":'#1 )#+$($&'.&0<(#")&$(8#+$ 2$#'#')$.;"(>0(#'

'$%').$<9')-+'(;'

$##+$)$".$(#+(2'#": .

'<<$%'"#$#.$"#<$)#+$ "&##+"##+$=:&7')- =#+#+$".#$.'$(;$.$

0)%")%#+"##+$(#$)#+"%#=$'<2:")#$%8-$(#(+;#+"#'#;"("&"($ $<$.-$)&1+$$<$.-$)&12')# 9'$;'()##=$#"7$) .<#+$ ")-:$ #+$%&#.8=0##+$("<$(+0:%=$&)('%$.$% .<#+$2')#

9'$; &<<)<")."2"#'$)#.<#+$2')# 9'$; #+$%&#.8#+$ .$F0'.$<$)##'<2:")##+$(#$)#<"1)#=$$<$.-$)&18=0# .<#+$2')# 9'$; #+$2"#'$)#;+$)+$(+$'( "&')-(0&+('#0"#') .#+$.$"()

0)$"(')$((8(;$"#')-")%&+$(#2"')8'#&")=$"-%&"($ .$<$.-$)&1 #.$"#<$)#+$.$ .$8'#'(+$:%#+"##+$#.$"#<$)#')#+$2.$($)#&"($'(# =$#"7$)"("$<$.-$)&1&"($+$.$ .$8$9$)'

#+$$<$.-$)&1&$.#'

'&"#$ '(%$&:')$%8#+$2$#'#')$.'($)#'#:$%#.$'<=0.($<$)# <$%'&":='::(') #$.<( 9$.)<$)#.0:$( &&.%')-:18 #+$2.$($)#;.'#2$#'#')'( "::;$%$(2)%$)#(".$.%$.$%#.$'<=0.($#+$<$%'&":='::("# ,8 +#"78."#$(8;'#+')#;<)#+( .<#+$%"#$ .$&$'2# &$.#'

'$%&21 #+'(.%$.":)-;'#+')#$.$(#"##+$."#$ EC2$."))0< .<#+$%"#$ #+$($;$.$(0=<'##$%#'::#+$%"#$ 2"1<$)#

4, !

(>7( +$#+$.(2$"7')-.$"()$% * $( +$#+$.$2.#"=:$ * $(