← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19001/2012disposed of

Pritpal Singh & ORS v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2015-09-04Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi5 pages

 



       

   

  

!"#!!

 

!  $%

& !

!"#!!

 

!  %

 &!

!"#!!

 

! $ 

  



!"#!!

 

! ' '

()*)+,- (.-"*-+*()+/0,-121!/(/,.)3(4()+/0,-1 5 666

  

!"#!!

 

!  6'$'

  !  !"#!  



 !  !"# $%&'!()*+,' (,-  , ,  

-710(80()9!-+2:(/,;*/0

-)*<,10!0(-<(9+2:(/,

-   0=-(9!-+2:(/,;*/0

1!0*70((*+7(9+2:(/,



-*7-(<3*/!*)>0(3;(9+2:(/,

-/0,=,/*/*),- 1

1.),,/!0,70)9++?9.)3(4

-.108()(/!(-2,10()+

-(.-(2(/0()*(9+2:(/, --,1=)+,)/1 *) 1$%9 #

-10*10 (;(?9+2:(/,- 

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

(+08(<*7!*70*8(40*8()0,8:?(*<=(-*/8/-,(/<,)/*)/0, <(//,-=(8 ()+ (??;():,1 ;*/0 -,>.?(- /,(:0,-1/0,*- 1:0,<, ()+ /,(:0,-1 ;-7*)> .)+,- /0, (10/-*8( (+08(<*7 !*70*8(

 40*8()1:0,<,)/0,=-*):*=?,D,B.(?=(8-,B.(?;-7E(1/0,8 1(8/0,;-710.?+,-/10.?+,-()++/0,1(<,-1*<*?(-;-7 0, =-*):*=?, 0(1 4,,) -,:>)*F,+ 48 /0, !.=-,<, .-/ ()+ /0*1 :.-/*)(==-=-*(/,:(1,1*)2(-*.13.+><,)/1*):?.+*)>*)* 1.2 3- /*43 3 *2*?==,(? $$%%% (-*1*)>./!& '%% )),G.-,C %95162*43-1* 1.2 %%'

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

(/,+-(=,-*+/0-,,=-*- 8,(-1;0*:0+,<()+0(1)/4,,)>-()/,+ $ 0,:.)1,?(==,(-*)>-/0,-,1=)+,)/10(1(*-?81/(/,+/0(/ /0.>0 /0, -,1=)+,)/  0(1 *?,+ ( +,/(*?,+ -,=?8 / /0, ;-*/ =,/*/*)1 ()+ /0, <(//,-  =(8 0(1 4,,) :)1*+,-,+ *) /0, <,,/*)> +(/,+ %$ )),G.-, C9 4./)/ *)?*>0//0,(-,1(*+ 3.+*:*(?=-,:,+,)/1/*11/(/,+48/0,?,(-),+:.)1,?/0(/(1/0,*11., *)2?2,+*)/0,1,=,/*/*)10(1(?-,(+84,,)1,//?,+9*/;.?

$ ,)+13.1/*:,*(+*-,:/*)*1*11.,+//0,-,1=)+,)/1/:)1*+,- ()++,:*+,/0,+,<()+/0,=,/*/*),-1-,B.(?=(8-,B.(?;-7 *)/0,-,?*>0/ ' !*):, /0, <(//,- *1 :2,-,+ 48 3.+*:*(? =-,:,+,)/19 /0*1 :.-/ 10.?+ )/ 4, <(+, / ;(1/, */1 /*<, ) 1.:0 ( <(//,- ;0,-, /0, :<=,/,)/(./0-*/8<.1/(:/0),1/?8()+(*/0.??8+*1:0(->,*/1+./8 48<(7*)>(3.1/+,:*1*)7,,=*)>/0,?(;+,:?(-,+)/0,1.43,:/*) <*)+ 5 0,-,-,9 ( +*-,:/*) *1 *11.,+ / /0, -,1=)+,)/ / / :)1*+,-()++,:*+,/0,+,<()+/0,=,/*/*),-1-,B.(?=(8- ,B.(? ;-7 *) ( (*- ()+ 3.1/ <()),- ()+ *) :(1, -,?*, *1 .)+ >-()/(4?,*)?(;()+)(:/19/0,<),/(-84,),*/14,,G/,)+,+//0, =,/*/*),-1()+/0,*-=(84,*G,+)=-*):*=?

,1=(-*/8/-,(/<,)/ / /0, ,G/,)/  =(8*)> /0, <*)*<.<  /0, =(8 1:(?,  -,>.?(- ,<=?8,,1-/0,1(?(-8*)/0,<*)*<.</0,=(81:(?,1+-(;)48 /,(:0,-1;-7*)>.)+,-/0, (10/-*8( (+08(<*7!*70*8(40*8() --,(-19 * ()89 / /0, ,G/,)/ (+<*11*4?, *) ?(; <(8 4, >-()/,+ *) (::-+():, ;*/0 ?(; ;0,) /0,-, ,G*1/1 () ,B.(/*)  +./*,1 ()+ -,1=)1*4*?*/*,14,/;,,)/0,/;1,/,<=?8,,10,),,+.?10.?+ 4,+),;*/0*)(=,-*+/;<)/01-</0,+(/,-,:,*=//0, :,-/**,+:=8/0*1-+,-):(1,9/0,<*)*<.</0,=(81:(?,*1 .)+ / 4, (==?*:(4?, ()+ (+<*11*4?, ) (:/1 ()+ 3.1/**,+ *) ?(; /0,)*/;.?+)/4,),:,11(-8-/0,:<=,/,)/(./0-*/8/=(11( 1=,(7*)> -+,- ()+ /0, -*>0/1  =(-/*,1 :() 4, +,/,-<*),+ ()+ =,-(/,+/0-.

>0*:,-+,-1):(1,9()+-()82(?*+-,(1)() (+2,-1,-+,-*1:)/,<=?(/,+9/0,)/0,=,/*/*),-1;.?

' /4,0,(-+()+/0(/;.?+),:,11*/(/,/0,=(11*)>(-,(1),+-+,- +*1:?1*)> /0, =-:,11  -,(1)*)> (+=/,+ ) :(1, 0,(-*)> *1 -,B.*-,+9 /0,) /0, /*<, =,-*+ 1=,:**,+ *1 ,G/,)+,+ 48 ()/0,-  +(81 -()8 .-/0,- -,(1)(4?,/*<, / :<=?,/, /0,,G,-:*1,(1/0, :*-:.<1/():,1<(8;(--()/*)-+,-/+.??()+:<=?,/,3.1/*:,  */0/0,1,+*-,:/*)19/0,1,=,/*/*)11/()++*1=1,+ 6 0/:=*,1/0*1-+,-4,=?(:,+)/0,-,:-+/0,-:)),:/,+ *?,1 

 (,-  , , 8 ()9'    !:5