M/S Grewal Stone Crusher v. State Of Punjab & ORS






   
  





 



 !" #
 $ !


!%&

" 
#
'(


     

 

  
    


 
  
 
) %
*"+

,-
"
 
,%-
*"+
,-

"
( 

 
,"


.  +
,
, +
!%&
"
 
!
)!/
$"+
,, +
!%&
000

"" ( 


(( 
/1
&
 


"
%!*/2


.
&



"
( 

2
34
5
""
"
%!*/
"!
&
( 

"
*2

000


 
 ,



"
!



   

( 1


6!"
"
/
+


7,8!


9+
-
""
"
( 
 

"
11
/!*



  + +:



!

!!" ;
8-

/ / 
7* -9<



5
7,8!


=9+


= 5 5
7,8!


:9+
" &1
"

/!

!*"

&




 


-!<


"



 5
7,8!


 9+
-
""
"
((
(


&1
"

*
"
( (
1

/
&1
  *+
>! 

// +
!%&
7 (
 9

 
?
"
 


&

 
/





 !"*
@
!

-*
)" 
)/
7* 9+
."
*+
 
'(* 
,
//

!
&1
"
(( /

"A
*

!!" ;
/*
&1
"

 !"*
@



 !
)" 
)/
7* 9
!

*
"
!


 !

-1(
&1
"
//+


!
"
"






 !" +
)" 
)/* +
"
!
!!" ;
/*

/
/ 
7* -9
, *1+

( +


+
"
6!


!&/
&1
"
//

"
*
B

 +
"
6!1+
"
,*
,!" 1+
-
+




7,8!


'59+
 
"
(

((



( 

"


( !

&A

!

" 

C - +
"

"
(
(( & 
"
*
!" 

"
1
!/ (1&%

"


."  +

 /
 "
!%&

 

'!+
D

7
" +
E"
D

'!F9+

/
+


7,8!


9+


!
&1
"
*
B

 +
-
""
( 



(1
11
/!*


 + +:


&1
D"

G!+


H!+

"
( 

(
"
11
"
"
( 
/+
"
*
B

 +
-


  
7,8!


'

9+

? /
EF+
6!
"
 +
'(* +


"

/!



 


-!
,

!+
,
 +


>>
!/
&
." +
*

5
(
 9+
!
 
( 
+


5
7,8!


=9+

= 5 5
7,8!


:9


"


(

  + +:



"
 !

1
H!+

"
/ "+
(
(



((
& 
"
  *+
>! 

// +
!%&
7 (
 9+
*
"
/

6!
1
"

!*"

&


C - +
"
,((
,!" 1+
-


5

5
7,8!


 9+
/
"
((
&*
&


&1
/
."

 

&1
"
(
-

D
 5
& 
"
!

+

-


D = 5
7,8!


9+
"
-
H"


"
/
."
/ 
/

"
,((
,!"


/ 
H!+

"
,((
,!" 1+


 

"
/

!

"
/ 

+
!
"
"
"

/
"
79

"!
1
( /."A

/
"
- /+
-



 5
7,8!


 9+
"
((

/
."

" +


&-+
(

& 
"
!


I 

!

"
(
!&/
"

"
/
&

"
( *

&1
"
(+

"
/!
"

!*"

&
+

"
( 



7,8!


' 9+
&!

(1
"  
- "

"
( 

"
( 

"
"
( *

1
*+

"
-



/
"
 !
"
I
'-!
,
." +
"
!&/
"
"
( *


 1
 
-

!

 !
& "

 

"
( (

!


%!
1+
& 
"
( /
!


/+
*
"
(

(
11

!

!!" ;
/*+


/+

 /

'!
 

"
D

'!+


(  6!
? +
 /

-
(
&1
"
,*
,!" 1+
1


/!
"
(!

( 

"-
&

 
*
,
((

"+
 

!
!&/
"


* 
+




7,8!


'59+

? /
E'F

!

"
(






!

6!
(( !

((

( !
"
6!

& 
"
/
!
&
( 
" 
C - +
"

"

((
& 
"
,*
,!" 1
 "
1

(
." +
"
,*
,!" 
"
&!


"
/!
 11
"

!

/
"
( 
C
+
"
"



7,8!


9+





/

-*
!
'!
 
79

"
D

'!

"-
" 
 
!

"
( 

( !
"

>
8

"
!
"
 

!

 +

!
&
((



'!
 
79

7 9

"
D

'!+
""

"!

 !"#$ %$ #&'()%#$ *+%,+ +(- ,#'. %$)# +%- "#--.--%#$ )+. --.--%$/ !)+#&%)0 %- -()%- %.1 )+() ($0 ".&-#$ +(- &(%-.1 *%)+#!) ($0 2(* !2 (!)+#&%)0 ($0 '%$#& '%$.&(2 &#' ($0 2($1 ($1 +(- $#) "(%1 )+. &#0(2)0 1!. )+.&.%$ )# )+. #3.&$'.$) )+. --.--%$/ !)+#&%)0-+(22*%)+%$)+&..0.(&-( ).&)+..4"%&0# )+.


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

&#3%1.1)+())+.--.--%$/!)+#&%)0'(0%$ &.-".,)# ($0"(&)%,!2(&(--.--..($1 #&&.(-#$-)#5. &.,#&1.1 %$ *&%)%$/ .4).$) )+. 1(). #  -!,+ "(0'.$) #& (22#* )+. "(0'.$) #  &#0(2)0 ($1 "&%,. %  ($0 50 %$-)(22'.$)-$#).4,..1%$/ #!&9 ,
& 
1

!& !
79

7 9

'!
 


&1
" 
"


( 

!

"-
+
"!
1


!
!" 1+
1
/
/ +
"
,*
,!" "
 -
!(
"
( 



? /
E'F




*

&
(( !1

&*
" +
( 


"
/!
 11
"

!
,+

 /

"
/
+
""
"

&
(

? /
EBF+
-


? /
E F+
"

"


(
"
11

"
- /
 !

1
&1

( 
+
&!


"
5
1

/
"


 -

!"

,(( 1+

"
/

"+

 
"
,*
,!" 1
!

+




7,8!


'59+

? /
E'F+

"
( +
-
""
"




((

(!
"

 
4-
 +


!/


//
"
(


"

(

"

+

 /

'!
 
79+
"
,*
,!" 



(



/
."!+
"
" 
&!

* 
6!
"
 

!

 /
<
"" "
!/+


7,8!


9+




/+

 /

'!
 
79

"
D

'!


? +



"
!/
7,8!


9

/( -+
"
/

&*

!
"  

#&' ..&!2. :; 8 .'($1#)%,.  #  <&.*(2)#$.&!-+.&  %22($/&($%-)) !"(/(&  ====  
$ ,#$)%$!()%#$ #  #)%,. # >?@ %--!.1 )# 0#! 50 ./%-).&.1 "#-) #$ )+. 1().1 @>?:@?>> 0#! (&. +.&.50 %$ #&' )+() )#)(2 "&#1!,)%#$ #  '%$#&'%$.&(2&(3.21!&%$/)+.0.(&@?>?;>>+(- 5..$ %$(2201.).&'%$.1() AB ?)#$$.-# &(3.2 ($1 (,,#&1%$/20 &#0(2%)0 ('#!$)%$/ )#

- >:>:A??<;

- #!&)..$ (,- #&)..$ )+#!-($1 .%/+) +!$1&.1 #$20 ($1 "&%,. #  - 
 #$20 %- "(0(52.500#!  #! (&. +.&.50 1%&.,).1 )# "(0 )+. -!' # 

->:>:A??<;

-

#!&)..$ (,-

#&)..$ )+#!-($1.%/+)+!$1&.1#$20(-1.)(%2.15.2#*%$)# )+. $.(&.-) &.(-!&0 #$ #& 5. #&. )+. B)+ 1(0 #  !$.@?>>($1)#"&#1!,.5. #&.)+. $1.&-%/$.1( ,#"0 #  )+. &.2.3($) &.(-!&0 +(22($ (- "&##  # 

=
"(0'.$) $#) 2().& )+($ >?)+ 1(0 #  !$. @?>> (%2%$/ *+%,+ )+. -(%1 ('#!$) #  ->:>:A??<;

- #!&)..$(,- #&)..$)+#!-($1.%/+)+!$1&.1 #$20 *%22 5. &.,#3.&(52. &#' 0#! (- ($ (&&.(& #  2($1&.3.$!.  
   > '#!$) #  &#0(2)0 "(0(52. !"..- >:>:A??<; @ .1!,)%#$ ('#!$) (2&.(10"(%1 - 
 C .) ('#!$) "(0(52. &!"..- >:>:A??<; .(2# )+.--.--%$/!)+#&%)0 #8C 1().1?

?

@?>>

2(,.(/(& 1<; %$%$/ %,.& .")# 
$1!-)&%.- (/(&9 48
+
"
!/



&-


/
+
!

? /
E F+
!
'!
 
7 9


 +
"


? /
E F

!
(
/

"
/!


11
." +

+
&1
1
 "

/*+
&
 !



/+
""
!
"
!
"

&
(

? /
EBF
?!

" +

" 
"
"
/

!
(!

!



 /

"
/!
 11+
"





 + +:



" +
"
  
&1
"
((
!" 1
 -
"
"

/+

 /

'!
 
79+
 
&1
"
*
B

 

-&

"

."
& -
"
"-
&
/+

(*


"
((
&A+

"
* 

"!
.&. %) %- ".&)%$.$) )# '.$)%#$ +.&. )+() &./(&1%$/ &#0(2)0 (--.--.1 (5#!) !$(!)+#&%D.1 '%$%$/ %$ #&' 6 !$1.& !$7(5'%$#&%$.&(2#$,.--%#$ !2.>B8:

:
)+.&.%-$#"(".&(3(%2(52.%$)+. %2.&./(&1%$/"(--%$/ )+.(--.--'.$)#&1.&50)+.%$%$/ %,.&9 ."
,*
,!" 1
/1
"-
(


 /+
&!
"
( *


"

 
!
/*

/
"

."
!" 




8
"
!(&1

 
(( ( 
/!

+
&!
!
+


"
"
!+

 /
"
+

+

? /
E F+

&



/
."
&*
+
"
1

"
-&
!
"
!
&


-

<
"


 /
8


(


,

"
&
"  +

!

? /
E F+


7,8!


9+


"

!
&1
"



"
/!
11+
(

* 

>
"
(!

"
(+

 
"
&!
/
"
/

"
,*
,!" 1
7 (
59


"
( *


"

(

(( ( 


/

'!
 
79

"
D

'!


 +

"
&



!

6!
(( !1

( (

"
( *

8( 

 
? +
"
/

&*
/

"
,*
,!" 1+

 




8/
"
!+


"
!
"-
&
"

/ 
 "*
"
!

-1

( +



7,8!


' 9+

"
( 
 ! 1+


"
"
( 





((

,8!


'
"
"


/

D
, *1+
"
/



7,8!


9+



5
7,8!


=9+


= 5 5
7,8!


:9+


"



 5
7,8!


 9+
 
&1
"
((
!" 1+
 


."
/

/

"
*
B

 +
( /
 >! +
,
* +
"
7 (
59+

( 
" "

 
"
 
."
(
"
(( & 
"
*
B



 "
1+




,

" 
"
!

((

"

"
"
&
8
&1
"
,*
,!" 1
C - +

"
A

"
!


  - 1
--

"
( 
+
"
,!" 1
"
(

(( ( 

(-1
"
"


/"

/
1
."
(

(

 *1

( S.J. VAZIFDAR ) ( ARUN PALLI ) ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE JUDGE 02.05.2016 Rajan