Sushma Garg v. State Of Punjab And Others









 

 
 


 !
"#
$!%&'&"(
)
*
++



 

 

 



 )
 ,-

+
 .

.
.





 

!"


#
$
%
 
!"








&  
' 
 


.
. /
+


#

 

'

"'
(()


&

* 

  
"
 
+,-.(-(+

/+(
#0

# 
"'


1
' '2





 
3/" '
 
& 

 & 
 


1
 
& 2

(

"




5

! 

 
  

4
&!'
'
6
& 
 


1
  2
!



''


-+



 


 
& 
!
'"
"
 
+,-((-(+

'!


 


 
 





    

 
  
 
 
  


 






  


   



 








 


  



  

 
 !"



   


 
#$%
 
#$%




  

$& 



  


   
 
  
 

'

 



 

 

 



  
 

 



 

%
 
 


 
  
 





  


 !"
  
   ()

    

  

!  

" ""

           !#   $  % !  "  $

! &

'  !   

(

   !  !

( !

 $  ) * !

 !     +  $       *  

 $ "   ( *( 

$   ( !"

  ( $ "

$( $""$(

!(

$( " " ( 



( $

  ( 

$   "!

$

,-  

* 
 













+
,



'

-.
,



 

  /

.

$  

!/ * 

 



  






 

,

 
 

 ,

0
1  





 ''/

/ * 


 0 


 


  








1



 

 (

/!
2
   ()

$%

 
34
5  

  3
 

 , //

$%
2
 
 ,
  

 ,

  '

    

   
 


 
 '



  
 
 
 


,



/

/
2
   




 


 


2 0 ,
  6




,
 

  , /

/#





 

!
,


 /

#/  





  
 




,

 

  
  
 

-





  

$& 



  


   
  
  
 


'

 

  

 

 


  
 

 



 

%
 
 


 

  
 




  


 !"/

+/ 7 ,
  





 





  

 , 


'


,


 '





5



/

./ 8


  
 
  






  9 



 


 ,


 


9,


,

  

 
 -/    $ !$$/0
7 ,


 



 



 '



9
   

 
  ,

:


2
 
22


1/

;/
$      1

$   !  

()
 


 '







  




</


$  ()






 0


 


 
  
 



(

$!%



 
 








 


  



  =

$%

 '




 =

$#%  



 
 

 
,

    =

$+%
  

 


 

  
> 






> 




 ,


 






,

> 

 =

$.% 
 


  
> 

 
  


9,

 ,


  

 
 /



 
 


 


  



'




,




  

 
 !"
 
 



  

$& 



  


   
  
  


'

 

  

 

 


  
 

 



 

%
 
  /
2




,
 



 

 9



/

 /'

/




 
//
!"/ #/ !

.(

 
  


   




 ?)
$
*

,%


 
 0  
 

  





 /
 ,
 

 
   
 ' 



 
    ,


 

' 






 /

 
   ,

> 





  
:




@



 A
,
7


 
'"
"

 


#
'





"0



  
' 

'


#
#

1
' '2
!
  
"8 " 
 
+,-.(-(+
 /+(


'!





 
 

 /

9>5B7474*
5:
C4D8

234 11
( 56&2267

6&431136 $54C7
5*7*254
*
84E%
  8 & 4 22 69: 31 &
 ;< 1 3:2 6 1 =&
 44<36( 6 6&43
62&63
3666

4466 6(2&=<623: 6&43 (>?@ 63  , "  !

! 6 ,86"8
, 3") !

+/
F/
F/
./



> G?



,
>  71  


 
 2
 '

H
1


 I

D ' 
8'
,,
!""!
2
;-




 (
* 
71  



9

1  
 
0 '
 
0 






//
8 

'


  


  

8 

'


  !/
E 



  
,

1  
 0 /A
 C

'


 
C   



  /
-

!!
F/
F/
:"

#

;
< 

"'



 
 


 
 
& 

!
0

& 

"
= '"



 


" 
"

 


"
  

 !

'




 


 
& 

"
& 

'
(-(-


1
'

(-(-2

'
5

!
 

> "'2
 


" ?
@!0


(-
0 2
A"

" 
 
'

#
'"
 
"

*

 




*
B

'''
' '0

(-
0 



 !
A"

+.
0 

-;


:  "
0" 

-(
0 

-)

A"

 
"
& 

4
 
 

#'
"'




' '
!

 
+,-.(-(+
'


 

:2'
 
&
'


.0!'01"
(2345&
2$!
6'+
0&77/


.
8
#

 

!
 

,


9

1  
 




1


  




9

1  
  0 
 
0 

0 
 





,







0  

0 



:#!

!

 




'



"






 
 
& 

!
0

'

(-(-

#"


!
 

A"



"*

"

 "
* '"




!

'




 

' '0

>




! 

 2
"


 

1  
0 
    
  
0 

,


9

 /AC
#"



"



" 

B

 
 


'

'
 
 

:2'
 
&

.490'0
6'+
.  !
"#
01'0 1
($
(" 0!1/
*
.4::
;

.4:1!<!
"41
'!'
;;
 
!
 
A"




"*

* '"




!

'
A"




 

' '0
" 

7



!
' 

"'


'
'


 

!
>"


&
 

&D /;(-(/ (-+E
'

"'
1$4 !
(' & 4 !
"#
!$&%3
$4% &"(
($

!'!1%0/
0($&210
6'+
41=&($!1
.&(20
($
" 0!1'

#"

 

 
 
# 
'


7
# 


 
"

"








'

"$

A"

" 0


 '
 
 $
0




0 
(-+F
#

#
!

 




"
& 


# 

' '


 

 A"

'
"
 
  

 
+,-.(-(+
 

 
 '0


" !


'

(-(-


 


'


 
A"

(-
0 





"*

 
"

 '
* '"





 



0 
(-+F
#'

$
" 



< 0
 
"
& 

 '
& 
 
!
'
 
-)-F(-+F


0




 
9  

&"

G
''
+(-F(-+F


0

0
# 





"0





'


 

 


 


"
0
 







" 
"

 



 !

 
"


)
H


 
' 
 
"'
#'



5

'0
""

''0
 
 

# 

' '




 !

*
A"



& 
"
"
(-+F


1
"

(-+F2

#''


'

(-(-

!

 
 

 
6
 
 !
'
#


 
'

4
"
 
"









*
# 



'

(-(-

4
 
 

# 

! '
0

 

!#C




"



'' 


 

/ 

< '0
 
 


''
0

# 




'!


!

"

 # 
 '0
"
E
: 
' 
"'


 



"
.
"
,5


"

(-+F
!
 
&

! 
0
$
'




* '"




 



" 
"




*

#"

"



A, .

$  ( $,(   2 !   !""   6 ""

  ,0
* 



> 


,
,

 


9

 



0 



  


   
    
 

'

 

  


 
 



  
 

F
7
 

!
!

& ! 
 
'

(-(-

'
5

 

 , .

$    

"    2 !   ! ""  6 ""

  ,B$!%





0


 

  
 


 

 

D'

E'

 =
$%






0


 



 








,
,


'


)
$%

1  




,


 

 







 ,
 

0


  

 
 



  (
 




 ,
 






 =

$%

 

'


 

 '

J


 ,
 





 ,
 '

 ,


 '



'



1  



,
,







 






 




 
  
 

,
 
 ' 
 '  '


 ',



 (

$#%







  
  
 





 /A

+-

 
 
'"
"
""

''0
!

* '"


"

'
5



 

3&2&9&3& 7
1& !1&+

>



"" ''0




! 
 
0


" '





#'

"

"0


 




  ''







++





"


"'

 
 

'''

' '0

(-
0 2
A"


:2'
 
&

 
 
 
'
 
A"




"*

* '"



!

'




 

' '0

7


'

0

 
 

 2
"


 


'



"!0



'
5(


 ''


* '

 

 
'




'
 
,-
0 





> "'2
 

" ?
@!0C





'0
"C


 '
A"


'
 
(-
0 

& 
 
"



"'

 
A"

'"


)



#"

"

'



 
3

"'& &"(
0!3$
12(&> &"(
<!
($
$$1!''

!1&"$
(

"( 0'

+
:  "
0" 

!


""
+.
I 
;

(
:  "

0" 

B 

3
&


  :  "
 0
(
I 
++


5
<"

B 

B>
"

7

: '

J'"  +
I 
F

,

 

& 

 & 
$'
(
I 
)

;

 
 
% '0


 
4?

+
I 
-

)
"
 0
7  &'
> # 


+-
I 
-

E


B
> 
"



;
I 
-

.

 
"
& 

 & 
(
I 
)




'
5(

"

 


 0

#"
"



 

'




* 

A"C
 




 
"'0

7

#

A"



 



"




* 


 
'

&"'0

" '

> "'

:  "
"

 0
>:




0 
(-+(C

0

"



 

"



"
 

# 
 ! 
A"

(-
0 


 



7



!
""'
"
"






 

:2'
 
&

($&(
&13&(!'
- $+

" 0!1'
6'+
.+
":3?1&'0((/


.4:1!<!
"41
'!'
;

'!


 


 
 

 ./

 

0 


1  
  




,

0 '
1  
 

  

,
0 





  
0 

F//A

B

'
 
0



"" '

"

 

"
+(
B
A
"
 
0

 

0
# 




 

 
6


 !


'


 

''




'$
 '
'"


''


 
 



! 
'

# 
""

''0

 

0


# 
" '



"



 
#'

' '


"

"0

B

 
 

"


0

'

#


+5
7
!#


!
"

&




0




#



 

0
 

*++


 
.
.

 


D
 $
8
 
I

3
D
 '
I
3