Brij Bhushan Chabra And ORS v. Commissioner And ORS
! "#
! "#
! "#
! "#
$ %&'!& "& ($ ") $ %&'!& "& ($ ") $ %&'!& "& ($ ") $ %&'!& "& ($ ")
$!
$!
$!
$!
* $!'! * $!'! * $!'! * $!'! ++ !! "
$,&
- ") $!
++ !! "
$,&
- ") $!
++ !! "
$,&
- ") $!
++ !! "
$,&
- ") $!
/# /# /# /# 01/2/2 01/2/2 01/2/2 01/2/2 3 &
$ .$
$! 4 4.
$!+ 446
!
%')7+ 3 (
$$ .$
$!$" 93 &
%')7+ !&'4)( .$
) " 7 $ # /$ % ") $ 42 "7&,):
$
$! /$ %"
!&& )6 4,, $5 /$2"
,):
$$ 9 ;;;
+%
2 "7&,<$ +%
2 "7&,<$ +%
2 "7&,<$ +%
2 "7&,<$ & "!
6$
"&
" )'") $$
"!
'
" ") $='
!& "7 $) $)
)
<""
>'$ ? 3.
!!
)(5$ $)
) @ <""
>'$ ?93.
!!
)(5$
" !&$ , .
$ & ! (
" $) ) (
) " " ..4
" ) (5 $ 9 '")
"! ")@ $5 '(4 $ + !
")1
<:
" ") :
$53 , A@," '"
""?
4 4
")!'(4
"7& $) $ "&
'.&
4) (5 ( & '$ ! ( 46 44
$ ")
++ !! "
$,&
- : ! ",&
-
$"
) '"!
4 $
$!!
&
+ 446 6 &)$ 6 .$
"6 &4 ( 5 + - .$
" $ 9 $ ? "! )
+
$ ") ")'
.
$! ! 4
! $ "
$"
6 $4 !
$"
) '"!
4 $$ 9& !!'(+
)
&'7&
"" 4 +$ 4 4
+
$ $ 7& ,('
" , "5!' &$ .$
" !+ ) , 9!& 44 "! ) " 6 &4 6 ")
! (4 ,+ 5-
.
! & 4!(
". "
)'
(5 4
$"
) '"!
$ .
$!
" .'$!'
$) $ )
) !!
)(5 ?$) "
" & & !'$ , !'+ B 4 !& 4$
)5(
") .!
")
4!.
5 "7B
C?.
$+"
& ".'$!'
$) $)
) ,6& & !$ .$)'
!'") $#?
D
+ " $ 9 "
$ +!
5" ") "
$!
5!B 4 !6 & " $ ) E6
-! $+ )
9$)$ , 6 $)!& !4 ( 4 5 9$) ,
4 "7 6& &, !
5 !& 44 !
) & +'"
!)
$+ "
).$: ! "
"! ) $ "7
.$.
5
)
B@E C?.
$+"
& " 5
$ AAF & !
5+ !& 44" ( "!
$'
!)
$+ " "7
!!'
$!0
+ "
"'
"
.!!
!! "$
+
! & 56 44(
45 "! ) ) " 6$
"& !
!& 44 " ( !'(%
'
+
+)
"
'$ + 5 + - "
..4
" )(5 ! &
$!.
5B
C? $5+"
& $+
) 5 $+ +'"
+ (:
)%'$"
9 ( &
$) 4"7 6 & 9E
G ":
6
$ ) !'(+ !! "!, .$
" ! ) !+ !!
) ! 6 &)$ 6" 6 & 4 ( 5
+ - .$
" !6 & "
+"
& $+ ) 5 & 9 !) $
"! ) .$
" ")6& 4 ) "7!,& !& 44" (
4'
) (5 $) $ & ! '$ ") !& 44
-
) ! " " 6 & 4 6 & +'"
6& &&
") .!
)(5
$!!& 44( )%'!
(4
6 $)! +'"
+ '"))'
"!
+ "
6 &4 6 (
,
(
,
(
,
(
,
</23 </23 </23 </23 - " &