High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11822/2016dismissed

Union Of India And ORS v. Central Administrative Tribunal & ANR

2016-06-03Ms. Justice Navita Singh,Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri9 pages

! "#$

%# &'(% ) ()* &'(% ) (

!

#

$#% !

&

)* + ,- ./ '() &

#

*&+ ,

-% ,*.

,&

/

, !

,,

01 10 21(3 '

4) 5* , %

5#,

'

7

5#,8)"

5*

&!%#,*

& 9 2 5

!#, &!

!

!#% !

&

!

&!%#,*

#5

5*

*&"

, " ! &*"

!#%#,

&& &%

9 2

5

'2) 5

& &

&!

%*5 % '0)

!

/

.

,& && 2: 1: (::0 + "%

%

&& #78)10 1: 211; + (<* 8#5,

!

#, &

, "

7 * 8 7# 8 '4) 9 2"!

=

2: 14 21((,,

&,,"=

! "# !

$ !! % $!

"# $#

$!

& '

!(!

)!#

* $ $ (( "# (

#

$ !

& !(!

'

(!# * $ + !

"# ," !% #

$

(!#

$#

(

!

-./0.0.0 .0

!

/1234 % ,

) ';) 9 2 >#

#,*!

!#% "

% + "

#5%

,* "

&

># *&& "

!! 9 2

># *

1( 13 21(2

%

,* * % !#!

% 9,,

&7

&# *87,!?&

# *8&7#5 !% & %,*

8" '3)

># * && 5

! % % 5* 9 2

&&

& ,

"# #5 &

%

#

!

,&0=4#5

,

% !

& ,

& "

& #

#

& & &

9 2!

!,,*

& ,

"

!

"

%

% !

5#

& ,&

" # #

#

,&0=4#5

,

"% ?

5#

% &

# #

#!

% ?

'<)

* #

% & !%#,*

&% 9 2

(0 (1 21(2"

!

,,

5 &

5#,"

#

"

*#

=!

7># #%& *8 '@)

/

!

,,

5#,8 5#

*#

2: 14 21(0

% * & !%#,*

! + ,,

5#

5#,

%

* & , , ':)

&,,"

!%% % 5*

#

&

=!#%=

& + ,

-. 1< 14 21(4

,& 9 2 >#

= ((

!!# # !!

$

"

"

(

" (

!#( !

#

6

#

( !!# $

7 (

!# " $

&8

8 8 '

!: );<3=>/34 % ,

)

'(1)

,

,!

%% ,

#

#

5, *A

$ (

B '(()

#

*& ,,* %

,5

,

& ="

!%%

5*

C

, % '(2) 9 2

# !

,,

5 &

5#,

&

,*&

5#, %# ,,"

,, !

& !%#,*

& 9 2 &%

5#,

&

#5

# 5 &,,"= *!!# "

! $ ! (

(

!# "

(

( ((! " "

"

! #

(

(( "

$!!

7 (

!# '

%

(

$

(

"!# ((!

$ !

& '

!(!

)!#

? * & !(!

'

(!#?* $+ !$ $

$!!"

"#

((!

(

(

!# $!

$

(#$ !

$

((!

"

( $ "

$# "#"

!

% 64 % ,

) '(0) .

, !# , &

! 5, ,

#

!

& % !

5#,!#, !

#

* #!

#!

#

,!%

5#, % = "

&#, " &# "

* !

'(4) #

# & 5#,"#, ,* ?

*#

#5

># #%&# 5*C ,#

"

D!,#

%

%

&# "

&!

!

!#% !

&! '(;)

"

,

>#

&!

># #%&# ""

#

!

&# =

, 6#

#

&&

#, 5

##,* #, 5

&& !?!!

%#

,& !!,#

&5 C!

&

,

* !!

& # ,

" "#, #

"

"

D!,#

&# =

, & &#

" #

# & !

& ,

!

"#, 5

%%# &%!

'(3) !

" "

#

# #

,

+

# E 5#, "

!

"

&# ,

"! %,,*#5

"

!!,# * %

* &

#

5*

*#

*

#

* !?

!!

&

+

# E 5#,

"#,

,* %#,

&

*E

#

!

,

%*

,& D!

, !

# "

!

#

& '

% ,

) '(<)

D# $%"

&' () "+ , +- ./0122 # #

,

,

!

"

&# ,

"

+

# 5#, !

&

!

!

5*

C *#

* E ,

#

*"

& # #, #!

!

#&& &% ,,

,

* %

, !

#,

#,

*

"#, !?

!!

&

# E 5#,

!

& !

&# 5*

C *#

*

#

&!

#!

* & % !#!

!#!

& #

>#

*&

>#

,

# * &*

># 5 %

5,

"? '(@) "3 $ 124 21

,, " && "

% " !

& %

, "

*!

+ " "

# & !%#,*

&% +

&% !#!

>#

+85, # # &#

&!%#,*

!?

!!

#

! 5

, 5

!%% #

># !* !%%

,,

&!%#,*

"#5

"

, " ! & * "

# !#%#,

&& '(:) '"5 & %%"

0 67 "

8 * 124 2 2

># && , "

" "?

, ?&!

5,*

,"

"

&#,,*#?

*#

*& % , &%

># %,*

!

, %

5#,5#

" %

&

& "

+

# ,*

!

&

,

,

* & % , &% "

*&

% !#!

+85, # #

&

+

#

5#,

&

,

*!% ,*,*"

&# 5 #

#,*

& !

5

=

/ 3 6 , % ! (3 $++ -0 : , % !

$ " ) 0 124 1

41 '21) +

5 >#

&,""

&

! &,,"

D!

"

5#,

,*

#5

# &% !%#,*

& " ! "

!#%#,

&& .

*&

= )

!% !

& ,

!

5* 9 2"

% &!

5#

& , & "

# # &

"

% &

& %F

)

, & &%

% & 5

& % % ,* E + ,, -!

*

9 ' )E+ ,, +

,

9 "C

6

& %

5

& "

5

5 ,

F

) , & !

,

"

" %

,* !#

% ?

"

,*

,

?

F )

! % % 5* 9 2!?",

#% %*%# % ?

5

& # * 5#

7 % !#!

8 & #!

"

"#, " % * & , & %,*%

!%#,*

&%

&# " 5*C *#

* !?

!!

&# F ' )

># *&& "* D

9 2

5 & * 79

& C

8

* #

* !#, !

9 2 " * & !%%

% #

% !#!

F )

5 & * &#

& @ %, * !# %

&!%#,*

&% # ,*

&!

5

9 2F

)

5#,

,* 5

"#, #5

& *

!% ,, &

=#

"

"

,, =!

># #%& *

5#," *%#!

,#!

##

"

& *

#

5#

# ,#!

!

"5*

#

'2() -

& =

!

&

5*

5#, % # '22) % ,)0-1 * /

$ ! % ,4 - /