← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19162/2012dismissed

Kulwinder Kaur And ANR v. Suptd. Canal Officer And ORS

2016-03-28Mr. Justice S.C. Datta22 pages





    

 !

"# "

$ %"&"# % "







   

 

  

 

 

!





   "



 $ % ! "

% "

# $

 



   

 

  

 

 

!





   "



  !

$ %

'% "!

% $

 



   

 

  

 

 

!





   "





&

(  )*(  + (+ *$* ' 

"



 



( )*  



 + ( , + &*

 "



  , + -' 

+ (  *



  +  . , 

/ 1 2 $



 

( +

2

2# + * %1

2 $



34 

    *$  ( 

        *

   ' 356&&7&&-7& &7&

8784 &7- $ *



 

2 *$ ( 

   

*   

 *)

(( + (   (( 9  



 

 $$



   2     $ *





2  &&6:&&;

   < 

    





    



87;&7&2 =

; 

*)



3

 

 

1 



)



    





 *

(

 '8784&7-    



&67-&7-2 =

5 

*)



3

 

 



*)



9  

 *

 

>

 

-

 

 



 '56&&7& 

)



$      



 



3?



 



 *



3&.$ 

=    0 

(".375-7".34??77



   

(  ".34??77  *   $  

 @. * % %

 @ +@ @ *

 @# ("

'

 @1  '

1 ( '

 

* 





 

 



3&

( 

 *

   A

%  B 

*.$

 = (

( 

 

     0 

(".375-7* =

".

34??77        2 =

      

=   

 0  ".34??77 *





5&&7782 =

&



3&

=    0  ".34??77 2   ( 

(

 



*



3

(





3&.$ 

$



47;&775 2 =

-  





  =  

 (  

(   



3&.$ 

$



-775&7752 =

5  $

(



=    0 

(".375-7

4

".34??772   (





*



  3

 

   

 

    

(

 $

 

 747?&7  2 =

 ?   

 

 $

     

 

 ( )  

 



  

 ' 37686&&;6;&-884 &7

5

-;6 &7&



 $

(( + ( 

&87-&7&2 =

 6

*)( 

 

(





3

 

  



 + )

*)

 

$  *

 

$  

 &7 -72

3 

< 

.

 2 8;-  *

$)C 2 C  )<  

 



*) 



3     

( 

(





*)  

$

(



87;&7&2 =

;

     

 -775&775  2 =

 5   

 *)



3&.$ 



*) (  =   0 

(".375-7".34??-7 *



D

    < $ 



 

 



 >

  

$ ( )  

    

 -72 2 (



  )

 $  

 -72 2  *

(



?

>

  

 

 (





*)

 )  

+   

  

$  2 



&87-&7&2 =

6  



3

 

$ 



 &7 -72 2  )3   *

$

*)



3 





   $  



  ( 

)

 )



) = 

  

 (



 

  -72      2        *



    +    

 *

9

=    0      

   

 

 7?74&7 <  )

(

(  * =

*  

 >

  

 





* 

:( 



 

:(  (  

*)   #$

( 



  (  

   #$

( 

(

 $ (



 

=    0  

  



( 



 $  

 :@

 



9

 )     $   

(  



          $



 $ *

  



    ( ))

( 0 



=    0 

* + +

 0   

 

6



(   (47

 

*

9

=   0  <       

 



          

   !"#"$%!&!#' 

 



   $ ( )

    

  



 

    =

 = (

*) =  



 (  = (  :

2

 

 



   (*

   $ 

      *    



=   

 0   *



 >

   

 

  0   =

*

( 



  

(

 =$   ( )1 ( '

 @  '

 @# ("

'

 @ *

'

 @ + 

%

'

%

  2 =

"- *

(

>

   

 







 

(

 

    



 *+

      (    

  

 

 $

 



(

(   *

*

  ) 

  *

$ 



$

)

 

 

   (

((

  =   

(   $ *

(

 >

 



3-

4$ ( ) 

         

        

 

;

 

   



  3      

     







87;&7&2 =

; 

 $  



$ $



 

   



 =   (  $  

 -72 2 



$ * 

*  (



*   



 

@  

    *     <       

   

 



  (     )   !""#$*&' ) +( ,,- . 

          

   !"#%$#"&'-/        

 

!"#0&!#' 

 

     

 )   '-!!$*&! ) +( "! < $ $    

  $     

 

 



 < *  



 -2

& 2  

 

/ , * 1  23              4  5

  

     



  

   !  

!"# 

"$ $ 

  



 %       "  

  

8

  # 

"%  !  

 ! #   

   !       $     

!"  % 

 "                 !&! # !

! ! '(!

)  * " )%* " + " "  !

  ! 

  !              

  "    "  ! ! ) , "% -  "   

""! 

 "  

  !         

     "$   

  ) < $      

 

   *    = (  

* 

C

C

C

 C 

   C

C 

 *$   



  2 *   C

C 

 

  

   



     

      ! 

!"#

"$ $

5



   

    %       "  

  

  #

"%  !  

 ! #

!  $ 

!

"  % 

"       !&! 

 

   

 ;7 2  =

  

  

C 

 C 

  

  

   

  -&    

  

        

   

  



  

 

 -& 2



 $

)

  

 2

( )*

(  

   #$

(  $

  2

 

) 

( 

    



  ( 



( 

 1



(

  $  

 -& 2 



 

 !

 

(

(  

 

          #$

(    2  

  

  

 -& 2 

 )*  

 $ ) 

  (  

   #$

(  

C C  *

  2   

 @* 



 (

 

*)



:   

        

     

    <  

(

 C C *  

 

 -* 2

7

  =

  C  @ 

)



 

C 

C(  

   

*)

 #$

( C

      

   * *

  

 - 2 <

  @ )

 @ 

 )

( )* 

 

 (  

*)  #$

(   

$

 2 



  *

 

*) .$

     6 1$

  *



/ )   "

   !       .



!!+  + +" +    

  !        "  

"     " 

/          !    "   !  





  "+"  

!  )++0 + ! 

)    "       

   

   !" "   

  )    

  !   



   "   !

   !%

"  !  "%   !"   )* " 



             $    "      ! ) !

                    

 !    $  !   !  % !

 1    

        )  "

 



! % ! 1   +

 "$  

   

    

    "

  )+!  " +  

  +" 



 

  %.



! % ! 1)

! ! 

  $  "$ 

  

          

             ) ! ! !  !            1(%         )    

  

  !  2  3) .  &       1

 

7

   8 !9,0 !"#/  ,- )!"#/:!"#9& ;$,'4!!! "

$  )  *     !    "%    !  

 "   5)6) 7,(%89 9!   %: !/ 3 ;

<)*     6  ; 0!! !          "  "  ! !

)* "  

&

"):

   6  ; 0!!     ! 

 " !  )*

!6  ; 0!! "!!  

 ; 0!! )*   

        ,(!

 );  !2 3)   

    ,()2 3)

" 

"! "



.

! !

 !

   ! ")"

     "! ! 

 !"" ! ! .



   !  

 !  "   "

    

         !   %     !     1(% 

  )       "  !    

2 3) !"   

 ! "     

      !        "        !      ! 

!"! "    

 ! %  !     1(% )  *     .

  "       !  .



 ! :  (       )!"## , !!

!:

3)  9  !9 3) 2   

 

 ! %  ! 1(% "   +

+ ! 

   !

-

% "      !    ! 

!") " ! 

& 8 = 

  !! "



          "            !   

 !  "    )  /   

    

$ 2  3)             !    " )  *  "  " 

! !     !"  

 )  !

  !" "!

"   

  !"    !  )*.

! 

3)  . 

        

        !"#%  &  '-/   3)  "

: ! ; 

  1(% !  "   %

  ! % " " % ,"

 !     "    % 

! "

!

  !      !    )*  3

     "   

   !      

       !  "    "   "  !!

  8  

     !)*  3

!  

&  8 =        !    "   "  

4

  ! 1(  ! )>) 

$  "  !

)- 3 9  

  



 &7 

 -72  ) 



 < 

 

    

 



  *  



 &7

-72

& 2  



/ ,() 

!"  "% )% /   6  ; 0!! ! 

!"!     

 



  

   "%  

   ! !

"% "     !  ! !

 " 





   !$.







6  ; 0!! 

 " "    





  

"% ) /

!!   

!  "             "%    !  

" !  ! 

     ;  0!!                            !    ! "% )

 

  

"%

?

   !  !

"%      

    

!! !

"%       6        ; 0!!  )

 

   !!

! !

"%    ) ,-<1      %>"            

      !

6  ; 0!! 

"  !

 !   !

 !

?%  

    ! "% % ! "% # %

!  "%  #  ! "% #



!  ! ! !"% 

 #  "   !    !"!"%

) ,  @          %     

   !

 ! "% % !

6

"%     !  

!%

!

 " !!    $  !     ) 

     

)  *

 

 *)  

.$ 1

   ,-.*/)0-1234

  *

 

/ A)! ,(  

     !!

)  *      !       !!  ))?%    6  ; 0!! ! 

!"!  # , 6  ; 0!!  "   ? 

 



   "   

 

 " # 1*6  ; 0!! 

    ! ! " .

" " " 

           6  ; 0!! # B ! !

 6  ; 0!! $.

 

!     !

  7 " "      

 

        

"  ))  " ) C)* 

!! ,(

;

"

"

! "  

    ! 

!" "                 " )*  

!$ !""  



! !     )   .  

          1

 

 7



 =11  >  ) 

 <         !"#/  &  /"9   "  

 

:

3)  ,( 

 " !

    "            6   ;  0!!             

      !   )*  3

!

  

  "   !    %

  "  !

    

  ) 

       )!"#9  ," "



9 3)   " 

!D!   !!  

$   1(% ! !"  



    1(%:1(%6)*  

$

"!2   ! 

     ! !  !  "



  "! 



D"

):

3) 



  "  

8

      !"#9 99/<   

 ! ! "

  ) ! 6  ; 0!!    ,(  !!   +!+)"

!

"  3

="  

 9=  ,(!    "6  ; 0!!             !!  )"

   3

"  6  ; 0!! !       ,( 

      

 +   "  ! )+/     "!"  

  

 !     !        !              ,(  !    )  /      !

"  

! 

 3

.

)/

 



  ,(  

 

D! )- 2



    

 

 &7

  )   ( 

 ) 

  *  $ )

( = 

   

     

 ( @  

 

           

=   

5

 

 -72$  ( 



  

  ( 

  ( 

 

   

  -72        

 

    

  =  

 (  )

  

  (  ) = 

    

(C

 C

  

  

 -72

=

 C )

( 

    



) 



=   = * (  < $

) (    

 

 

 -  2   (  

  

 



(

  

  





(  *

( 

 

)( 



  *

  =

 C     )

  

 -72  

      



=

 C

 C      (

*

  

 

 

   (  < 



)   

                

   

(     

    

  

=

 C )

( 

C     



)



(  

 *  ) 





  

( 

 

 

)( 

  

  

) 

 $ *

$

*)   

 

 



(  

 *  ) 

&7

( 

 <

*   =   



*( 

* *)

(   ( 



 -72

 2 2

   

 

 

  

( C

C



 ) 



 * =

*

(

2 

 -72 2  ) 



 

 &7 2  3  <  = (   

=      (   

 2 (

) (  *  

=

$  1 ( '

' =   



  ".34??77  @. *  % %

 @ +@ @ *

 @# ("

 '

 @1  '

1 ( '

* *





   (   

     (     *

  

) 

(

 

 

)

 (

 

 -71



 

 (



9

*

9

=   (  *

  * 



  *)

$

 ( =(($  < 

 

( 

 

   

   

9

*  





  

) $ = (



 



 



 0

$



 

 

  



@ 

2 =

;*)

    

&



*  

  =   



=  

 =  * =  * 

<  *

  =   ( 



  . *

)  ".  375-7       B    

 





 * 

   



  

(  . *

) 

   . *

)  *   

  

 . *

) =





  * 

  





* *



*)  ( 1 

  *

   0   =

   * 66;77  

 *  

  

 



  (   =

  *

4??77 





 

(

  (

 * * 

 =

 (   

     =     *  -8;  0 

    

=     *  &7--  @(   "



  3 

 

 

 

(

$  *  



( 

 (   (



 

< $ (     

87;&7&2 =

; 

*)



3

 

  

 



=    0 

( ".375-7".34??-7 *

)





9

*

9

  

(

&&

 &67-&7-  2 =

 5    '  38784&7- 

9  

 *

) 



  <  $    *$               

(

 3

 

 !

"# 0 256+788/9/3

$

@(

  -.7